Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First successful (sort of) Pencil

Posts

First successful (sort of) Pencil

#1

First successful (sort of) Pencil

david weaver

John(NM) sent me a fantastic piece of incense cedar that I'll be able to make hundreds of pencils from (if I manage to master it, then I'll never make that many, I'm sure).

And I've learned a couple of things:

I think it'll take about ten minutes to make a pencil (without any fancy stuff on the barrel and without a ferrule) and do it neatly once I'm good at it.

1) When you hand resaw and plane incense cedar, you will think that someone is sharpening 100,000 pencils on your bench all at the same time. After 40 years of smelling a faint specific smell when sharpening a pencil, my brain isn't used to smelling that smell - but many times stronger - without seeing a pencil.

2) the slot in the pencil case needs to be slightly undersized and the case compressed around the lead. If there are voids, the case will break around the lead. If the voids are filled with glue, it'll just make the pencil slow to sharpen and hard on pencil sharpeners

3) if you try to plane the facets on the pencil freehand, you will lose track and they will be strange looking - like this one

4) pencils are faceted with 6 sides, so 120 degrees (6-2)*180/6? 12, meaning you have to plane 30 degree facets really easily - that's fiddly. The uncut pair of facets is where the seam is. I tried it freehand - not so great. Then with a board that I set up to hold the pencil, but you'd need two, one to hold an unfinished square pencil, and another to hold the pencil after the opposite side has been faceted. I can't see a reason that the barrel can't be faceted like a stop sign instead, and the next several will be done like that.

5) the grain can't be too straight. you cut the slot on both sides (two separate boards) and glue them together with the lead in the middle. White glue makes the wood a little bit damp and if it's not straight, when it's cut from its mother boards, it bows.

Making the leads, too, will be an interesting challege, but the 2mm drafting leads are a nice size, and the staedtler leads are good quality (I have container of them from the first go-around when derek told us about clutch pencils) and about 40 cents each (not a huge deal). They don't feel like a palomino black wing pearl when writing, but they're good quality, and for the very stingy, chinese leads are available.

I'll take a picture of the slotting tool at some point, but it's just a glorified scratcher much like a tonguing plane in style but with a scratcher only in the slot.


(the color of the wood makes it very hard to see the facets - I put cashew lacquer on this pencil after this picture was taken. Cashew is a shiny lacquer that's very aromatic (probably unhealthy) and it leaves a brilliant thick shiny finish and levels well. I have some left from sealing sharpening stones. It's a good lacquer for pencils but extremely greasy will only come off of your hands with naptha. Way too thick to dip finish a pencil, it's more like oily peanut butter.)

Other than the cost of the wood, I haven't had to spend anything to make the pencils, which is another nice bonus. It seems far more interesting than turning pens (not that I do that regularly, but I've done it a couple of times).

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#2

Or, there are circular pencils

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Cylindrical pencils aren't as common, but I do own some, and they're fine in the hand.

Another interesting journey you've put yourself on, David.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#3

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

AlanWS

I wonder how varying the size of the hexagonal shape would feel. I usually prefer larger handles for things, but I'm not sure about pencils, since that size and shape is so familiar.

I wonder if it might work to make a sheet of several pencils, and then cut them apart with a 60 degree V-groove plane (halfway through from each side) to form the hexagons.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#4

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

Steve Voigt

Excellent project.

What's your fixture for planing the facets?

For planing the bed and breast angles on skew planes (rabbets/dados/fillisters), I use dedicated shooting boards. See below. I push the point of the wedge into the fence and adjust the angle freehand; I imagine the same technique would work nicely for pencils. Maybe you're already doing this, in which case, carry on!


Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#5

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

david weaver

The sheet method you mention appears to be the way commercial pencils are made. Slabs are grooved, filled, glued and then cut apart and run through a shaper and a pencil comes out of the other side.

As far as size goes, I also prefer something slightly larger than typical, and my shop sharpener will accommodate, but most hand sharpeners and one-size electric sharpeners won't (unless they have a second hole which is usually much larger).

I'll eventually start making some other sizes, but the scratch tool that I made to cut the groove is set up fixed width (slightly oversize). the scratch tool is made from scrap and I can make another one in half an hour or so, so it's not a huge deal to make other ones. I was thinking that something larger than 2mm leads would be better, but they seem to be ideal for HB hardness, etc. I've noticed that some of the larger leads are around (3mm in some places) for 2b and 4b hardness - which would make for a nice dark-marking shop pencil.

It's fun, and something worth trying. I've never seen incense cedar for sale anywhere, and the use of the word incense on google or ebay brings up the smelly stuff instead of the aromatic wood.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#6

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil *LINK*

William Duffield

If you had read this essay beforehand, you might never have started.


I, Pencil

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#7

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

david weaver

So far, it's just a groove in a board so that I can plane the facets by hand.

I realize that's not going to suit a larger audience (the thrill for me is trying to do things mostly freehand with little setup - part of the laziness that limits how crisp my hand planes will be. that very mild thrill of trying to get better at something all the time so that I don't lose interest ...that ultimately limits my work to being decent but not better. I think a dedicated fixture could make a really fantastic pencil, but I'm not smart enough to learn it right away.)

I'm thinking for now that octagonal in a 90 degree groove should allow me to plane strokes that will make the pencil almost even but not perfect. That's in line with what I like to do, I guess - from a distance, I want it to look like nothing unusual, but to the most anal retentive close-viewer, something should look a little off compared to a machine pencil.

This may rise to the level of being video worthy without stooping to some of the efforts that I saw on youtube where people want to build a multi-hundred dollar device that actually takes the skill out of building the pencil.

sizing the barrel to square after glue up with a backsaw and a plane upside down in the vise is really pleasing. trying to facet the barrel then from that point freehand.....not so much!! It may be pretty easy to do it freehand with an octagonal barrel, though - I haven't tried yet, nor have I made a perfectly straight barrel after sizing - my two boards have slight grain variation and the water in the glue puts them in a fight.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#8

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

david weaver

I think he will not like me by the end, except for the "no barriers"!

I intend to hoard as many steps as a I can, and share whatever I learn for no gain!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#9

Re: Or, there are circular pencils

david weaver

Yes on the cylindrical pencils. What started this a couple of years ago was the realization that I'm getting old enough and with enough work-related responsibilities that I needed to start writing a whole lot more out so that I'd be forced to focus on it.

I thought an interesting thing to do would be to go out to ebay and buy a "lot" of old pencils, so I did that. I think the pencils that I got are 30-60 years old, and many of them are round. Wondering what made good writing pencils vs. not led me to the blackwing and now my daughter is getting into art and drawing.

Anyway, long story short, the barrels in square form, I decided to make with the lead relieved from the end a little bit as the scratched groove is best in the middle of the board (not important why - just based on the design of my scratching tool), so stuffing the square barrel on a lathe and turning the corners off is possible - the center is already there. It's the look of the facets on the blackwings that I like - someone made the facets, softened them a little bit and deliberately chose a lacquer that feels really nice, just as they deliberately waxed the graphite after baking to make it feel smoother when writing.

But I will turn some, too, and make some with square house made leads (and round ones if I'm lucky) before this runs its course.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#10

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

Dave Tardiff

Are you aware of this book?

The Pencil: A History of Design and Circumstance by Henry Petroski (448 pages of information)

Pretty comprehensive, as I recall, from the last time I read it. Might have some lessons-learned tips?

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#11

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

David Weaver

No, not aware of it, but it looks like it's worth finding. All I know of pencil history is that there was a shortage of graphite at one point.

I guessed at pencils having square leads in the past only because it would make s patty of graphite easier to make and cut. I'm going to track that book down. Thanks!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#12

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

John in NM

I love it! Incense cedar is really fun to work, smells fantastic.

Next you need to stipple one of them! Better grip you see :>>

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#13

Pencil Two - Octagonal

david weaver

The octagonal idea is far better for hand tools, but it's easy to overcut facets.

The cashew lacquer reminds me of varnish. If you ever brush varnish on something and there's a bit of dust or dirt, the varnish sort of aggregates around it and makes it look huge.

I had a little bit of dust around when I was putting the lacquer on this one and it just spread all over it.

strangely enough, it seems like the best way to apply the lacquer is with the fingertip, and I'm sure it's not good to touch it. I'm not keen to give up on cashew lacquer for something more common yet as the cashew lacquer has a lovely smell, it's really durable, and it's flexible. But the smell adds to the experience.

Still much room for improvement.


Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#14

Re: Pencil Two - Octagonal

John in NM

You got me curious about cashew lacquer..... that got into urushi lacquer and then to the Toxicodenron trees.... good heavens!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#15

Re: Pencil Two - Octagonal

John in NM

Pencils are looking good too!

Maybe wipe on the lacquer with a rubber glove? Or try a tack cloth and a foam brush... Sometimes the finger is the way to do it though.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#16

Re: Pencil Two - Octagonal

david weaver

Yes on the clean up, and it may be necessary to have more than one clean coat of it (not a big deal), but due to its stickiness, it's completely unforgiving of any dirt on fingers, pretty much anywhere. A couple of particles that get on in one spot end up spread all over the place.

I don't know much about the origin of cashew lacquer other than that it's expensive over here, urushi is apparently toxic, and the cashew (which worked great for sealing stones) is like molasses and has a very pleasant (and probably not healthful) smell. if I can get it on clean and level, it should be nice to use, and the aroma each time it's sharpened is nice. It smells almost like root beer or soda-themed candy.

I'll send a couple through the mail once I manage to get the finish to lay on them nicely. Varnish is also an option, but that'll require UV light.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#17

times change - urushi

david weaver

Urushi is now available on ebay. I'd make comments about it being horribly expensive (it's $35 for 100g), but it's about the same price as cashew, mostly due to international shipping, I'm sure.

...but the only feedback on it is a one star review from someone who apparently got sick from using and and developed a rash to go with it.

(a little further reading suggests that the oil in urushi lacquer is a much more highly concentrated version of the trace amount of the same substance in poison ivy. That's interesting for one reason - i don't have any reaction to poison ivy and can pull it or string trim it, or whatever else, without any reaction. Not willing to see if that's true for a much more concentrated form, though).

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#18

urushi is related to poison oak and others *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...a one star review from someone who apparently got sick from using and and developed a rash to go with it."

Urushiol, the compound that forms the urushi (lacquer), is the very compound that makes poison oak, ivy, sumac, and other allergenic plants something to avoid. No wonder the user developed a rash from using it, if s/he did not treat it as a hazardous compound.

It's too bad; I remember reading a Foine Wooddorking article on it years ago that included a reference to a wooden bowl that had been exposed to poor conditions and rotted away, leaving behind an intact shell of urushi lacquer. Apparently impressively good stuff, but I've managed to get to age 71 without becoming sensitized to the compound, and have no desire to start now.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urushiol

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#19

Re: urushi is related to poison oak and others

david weaver

Thanks for that link - my edit and your post crossed paths in space, but I saw pretty much the same thing.

Reviews on amazon show a string of very impressed customers along with 1 star reviews from people getting a reaction.

I'm also not sensitized to any of the poison ivy, oak, etc, plants and can pull them by hand or string trim them without issue, but I'm not looking to get sensitized to the stuff, either.

It appears things have flip flopped with the cashew (no problem - 80 grams of it is probably enough for a hundred pencils) lacquer, it's now not available in the US in any color I'd want, though someone is selling a 500 gram container of dark green (that would look nice) for $225.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#20

Re: times change - urushi

Rum

Note that the polymerizing part of traditional cashew lacquer is also urushiol. This is why you can't buy entirely raw cashews, they can have enough of the annoying stuff to cause some people to react, but with heat and moisture it cures out. The bottom of the cashew apple where the nut is is basically a little sack of urushoil resin (a smidge less pure than the urushi plant but much moreso than say poison ivy).

It's also in Mango sap FYI, some people will break out horribly from handling them, moreso if they're green.

I have no idea how the lacquer you have is made/treated so it might be treated to remove the reactivity.. I believe some types are/were not but ?most? are I believe at least air curing (assuming sufficiently thinned coats perhaps?). But I might exercise some caution to ensure that it is adequately cured before handing it off to the less fortunate or indeed shaking their hands after you've been finger painting it on :) You might also appreciate that sensitivity can be acquired, so enjoy your lack of suffering while it endures :)

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#21

Re: times change - urushi

Jonathan Elliott

I grew up in South Florida with a mango tree in the backyard and used to climb it all the time with no problems and literally made myself sick a few times eating fresh mangoes :)

When I moved to Des Moines I got exposed to point ivy for the first time and reacted every year in the spring.

Now I'm in Hawaii and react similarly to mangoes :( Good to know about urushi and it's similarity. Not fun to have a sensitivity.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#22

Re: times change - urushi

rum

We had a friend who was super sensitive to it and made the mistake of picking a whole bunch of mango's into her shirt! She was very very unhappy for a couple weeks, that's how I learned it was the same thing.

I didn't have any problem, but after putting up about 300lbs into the freezer for mangoritas (yum!) LOML started getting a bit of an arm rash.. so it appears that she was getting sensitized.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#23

Sensitization

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sensitization to an allergen can happen at any time, even after years of being immune. I think you're finally safe from the prospect when you die.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#24

Re: Sensitization

David Weaver

I remember getting very mild poison ivy as a kid, just little bumps on my hands.

I did (mild) when I was very young, but it - for lack of a better term - just went away after around age 10 and I haven't gotten it since.

I understand that it's like anything else and you can get sensitized to it, but there's little of it around here, so if I do get sensitized, I guess it'll have to be a surprise with the cashew lacquer!! (no clue what's actually in the cashew lacquer, but maybe the pleasant smell is urushiol).

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#25

Re: one more - shellac french polish

David Weaver

https://imgur.com/gallery/w9DOM0n

Each one gets a little better. Still a bit rough on the facets because the pencils always have a little bit of bow, but certainly good enough to write with.

Yesterday's pencil is a quick cheap french polish shellac, then oil added to continue to add more instead of waiting for each layer to harden.

The lacquer is ugly and sticky and catches all of the dirt, but it smells nicer and I'm sure it's far more durable once cured.