Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

Posts

OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#1

OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

david weaver

Through the last several weeks, something I saw locally (a wonderful Holland branded old vise with huge capacity) sparked my interest in getting a bigger metal vise than the unmarked columbian 4" vise that I have. I don't need complicated metalworking tools, but it's nice to have a decent vise with soft jaws to hacksaw and drill steel and sharpen saws (with auxiliary boards).

I looked around, found everything like the Holland vise to be expensive unless you really luck into it or buy something small (not interested), and most of Wilton's larger vises appear to have gone into the same foreign and overpriced territory as powermatic (my opinion).

I went to youtube to find reviews on vises and was somewhat surprised to see a low-cost chinese dewalt vise about double the physical size and capacity of mine faring well in abuse tests - stuff well beyond what I'd ever do.

https://youtu.be/VcbTopj5u7A?t=1m36s

Surprisingly, giving up little to nothing in the torture tests to more expensive vises.

Still waffled about it hoping to find an older vise cheap local, but no luck and eventually ran across the vise shown in the video for $92 shipped, bought it, still expecting that it might not be that great.

But i have to say after it arrived in-hand, it's leaps and bounds better than my old columbian (not sure if it'll last forever like that), it's about 40 pounds, works smoothly, is well finished, and now I can put the columbian on a board and move it around the shop.

Not really that worthy of a topic on here, but one of the rare cases where you buy something expecting it to be mediocre given its origin, wring your hands about being too cheap to spring for the "known good" version or a vintage version of the same for 5 times the cost, and ultimately end up with something far better than you expected.

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#2

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

TomD

Funny about the test using a replacement coupling for their gang bar. The one chinese vise I ordered was a repro Emmert. The T handle coupling arrived smashed to pieces. The rest looks pretty solid but, after that, I never bothered to install it.

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#3

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

david weaver

I have seen the harbor freight vises they're showing in person, and for the price, I suppose they're not bad, but they are rough as a cob. The cast 55 anvil is practically famous - it's good as a surface as long as you don't use it as an anvil.

I generally buy old to avoid guessing which foreign stuff is junk with a brand on it and which is reasonably well made, but bigger vises are just way too popular for me to do that - I was surprised by how much they bring, but I guess it makes sense. it's the age of the white collar hands-on hobbyist and there's too many potential buyers for a bench vise. toolmaker wannabes, blacksmith wannabes, mechanic wannabes, etc. Many of the old ones are welded, too, from someone abusing them. The old ones have unmatched style, though.

http://www.benchvisejaws.com/millscott-13-jaws-1480-lbs/

(not that that one is typical).

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#4

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

Joe shelton

I wish that you were not quite so derisive of us white-collar wannabes. ;)

I'm no Frank Klaus, and will never be, but he told me once that the difference between my work and that of a master was only the time I took to complete a piece.

To this point, I've only rarely spent enough time.

I read a lot of your stuff, and learn from you. But I can't help bristling some from time to time at your remarks about those of us who are not yet makers. And I don't intend this as heart-felt complaining; just a mild comment.

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#5

Tangential to your OT

Steve Voigt

Dave, that looks like a decent vise.

Your story reminds me of a related rabbit hole I went down this summer. I stopped in at Homestead Antiques in Millersburg OH this summer. They have an enormous supply of old tools, though a lot of them are not in great shape. But it's worth a trip--great little town, and the owner of Homestead is very knowledgeable and fun to talk to.

I got to talking with him about vises, and he showed me several Wil-Burt Versa Vises he had. I think he was selling them for $120-150, which is about what a decent one will cost you on Ebay. The vise swivels and locks when you tighten it--it's pretty slick. But even better was the swivel base adapter he had, which gives you another axis.

I did some research when I got home and found that an Ohio company makes the vises according to Wil-Burts original prints, using a mix of domestic and imported parts, for considerably less than the vintage ones go for. They also sell the swivel base adapter.

I never shelled out for the item but this thread is making me think about it again…a few more months of hemming and hawing and I might be ready! :D

http://www.willburtversavise.com/

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#6

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

Steve Voigt

I'm really struggling to figure out what you took offense at in Dave's post. He was just pointing out that there are a lot of hobbyists saturating the market, which seems a pretty neutral, fact-based observation to me. I suppose one could take offense at the term "wannabe," or maybe just dialing back the sensitivity meter would be easier.

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#7

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

Joe shelton

OK, I'll dial it back. No offense taken, none intended.

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#8

Re: I'm one of those guys...

David Weaver

I'm a white collar worker and not really a "maker" by any serious sense.

I like to make things, but lack the time or drive to do it fast like a real maker, and most of the time, the diligence to really perfect anything.

So, my basement is full of things that other wannabes like me would like to have, and I only gripe when I can't get what I want because other people seem to want the same thing. Or worse, when I want something, but some other type of hobby wants it a lot worse!!!

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#9

PM coming your way

Jim Matthews

I'll drop a line through your website

Re: OT: a pleasant surprise in a metal vise

#10

Re: Tangential to your OT

David Weaver

the thought did cross my mind to buy one of those instead (or in addition to), for the simple fact that most machinist vises aren't that great for a draw filer (no real clearance) and those are about the best.

I still may buy one of those yet. It's a good suggestion, though. When I draw file something like a knife blade (instead of belting it), it's always a challenge and I usually end up filing much of the blade with some spring in the metal (not really that pleasant).