Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Low Tech Pencil Fascination

Posts

Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#1

Low Tech Pencil Fascination

david weaver

A couple of years ago, Derek wrote an article about pencils in the workshop. I bought a lead holder at the time, but due to my carelessness, it's just not for me in the shop - plus the sharpeners seem to require too much care for my use.

Shortly after that, I noticed that my kids (who love to go into the shop) often take pencils and draw on everything. That isn't a big deal to me - some of my videos show strange drawings on my bench legs in pencil, pen and marker - they're welcome to do that as long as they stop when I ask them to stop. So, pencils everywhere - I got the cheapest pencils I could find that still had a wood case (sidetrack - there may be a few people here around age 40 who remember going to school and getting one princess HB pencil per month, and in the early 80s, the inexpensive pencils had poor graphite mixes in them, and also had some kind of glued together wood case - the pencils flexed, they were uncomfortable to hold, crappy to sharpenn....just bad to use).

Anyway, the penalty to be paid these days for the cheap pencils is slightly hard lead that's also very fragile. The kids' bad habit isn't so much using the pencils on things I don't want them to (I'm not that kind of "precious" person with "precious" things), but the issue is that they will use a pencil in some part of the shop, set up a workspace for themselves, and a year later when I get to the bottom of a lumber pile, i find pencils all over the place under and behind it.

At work as i'm aging, I start to write more of what I'm doing, and at some point, I got the bright idea to look up what pencils are the nicest to write with.

Well, that's about as debatable as which sharpening stone and which plane blade orientation, etc, but the japan-made blackwings received favorable talk about everything except price. Tons of others (tombow, mitsubhisi 8950, hi-uni, etc...also get good press, and some can be inexpensive if you're willing to get them directly from japan).

I found trying a couple of the blackwing types that there is a 4B hardness pencil, their softest - black colored case - that is superb in the shop. There's wax in the graphite in the pencil, it's not hercules strong, but still is very resistant to lead breakage. The graphite never breaks up into the case while sharpening, and it leaves a very dark mark.

Anyone else ever fooled with pencils made for drawing or writing, etc in the shop? With the blackwings, I'm in love. Price, not so much (a little more than $2 a pencil), but writing at work with the 602 (HB/#2 hardness roughly) or pearl (probably 2B) is just wonderful and it encourages me to keep my summary thoughts on paper - slowing me down and allowing me to examine what i'm thinking. The black pencil, I don't favor quite so much, but in the shop, it is just wonderful.

The only rule I have now with pencils in the shop is that the blackwings are off limits for the kids. I wish there was a cheaper way to get them, but it looks like the company that controls the brand is very careful to market them and make them unavailable elsewhere.

The other side topic that goes along with this is what pencil sharpener? The always fantastic David Barnett suggested a small two-size kum sharpener, and at the time, I also bought 24 of those. You could buy one for $7, or you could have 24 of them for $20 at the time. Same as the blackwings, a chance to get a bunch and dispense them to people at work. They are a fabulous sharpner, and for round case pencils with round erasers, there's a quick thrill of putting a new pencil in a cordless drill and making one long smooth continuous shaving out of the waste in about a fifth of the time that it takes for a boston ranger to sharpen a pencil.

I'm considering (after the guitars, chess pieces and some other things) attempting some pencil making if I can find leads that match the blackwing quality. Until then, I've also got tombow and mitsubishi (one set from 8H to 8B for my daughter, who is starting to take an interest in drawing) pencils on the way to see if some of them are close to the blackwings in terms of lead composition.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#2

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

Oskar

agree, a good black pencil up on the B-side of the scale is very nice. But for sharpening, this is a job for the pocket knife. I would never turn to something else, since putting a point on a pencil is such a satisfying knife task

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#3

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

david weaver

I've sharpened the blackwings (and others) with planes and knives, but I must admit to being too cheap to sharpen the blackwings with anything other than a proper sharpener.

The satisfaction of a manual sharpener like the kum (that's actually sharp and makes continuous ribbons of cedar) is still pretty good. Far better than hand crank or electric pencil sharpeners.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#4

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

Jim Matthews

http://www.artisanalpencilsharpening.com/

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#5

Zebra DelGuard

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Look up Zebra DelGuard 0.5mm Lead Mechanical Pencil.

This has the potential be a game changer. The lead does not break, and the mechanical pencil itself resists breakage. Plus the lead is thin enough never to need sharpening.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#6

Sharpening....

John in NM

I've been known to use a sharp chisel, bevel down.

But I also really like the Boston Champion sharpener. I've long had one that was left over from the map drafting room of my dad's closed mineral exploration biz from 1985 or so.

Great sharpeners, work with any reasonably sized pencil, always center the point, and nothing like the lousy ones you recall from school days. Also, spare parts readily available on ebay.

Now if I could just keep my wife from putting tooth dents in all the nice shop pencils as she works on a project! :D (yeah, I have a box of blackwings too... don't dare bring them out for fear they will suffer the abuse that the Ticonderogas currently bear solo)

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#7

Pentel P205

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I like the long narrow point of the Pentel P205 drafting pencils. I found some HB "leads" that leave darker marks on wood.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#8

Re: Zebra DelGuard

david weaver

Thanks, Derek - I'll give those a try, too. Probably something I can get in person at the local staples (which isn't true of the blackwings).

If their lead breaks less, I wonder if it's waxed and less gritty like the blackwing lead, and the other primo pencils (hi-uni, tombow, mitsu 8950, etc)

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#9

what's next....

david weaver

...professional tooth brush trimming? :b

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#10

An adult chewer!!

david weaver

I am a nail biter, terrible habit. When I was a kid, I would chew up everything like a nervous horse does with its stall. Pencils, including the metal ferrule, were not exempt.

I lost my taste for them at some point, but not due to the germophobes ("if you keep putting things in your mouth, you'll catch germs off them and get sick!!").

The lacquer is pretty hard and smooth on the blackwings - I'd keep them hidden, too.

This is all going to end with me making pencils - it's unavoidable.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#11

When you build your own pencils

Chuck Nickerson

please document the process for us.

My woodworking club already thinks I'm crazy because I import some pigments from Venice, Italy for custom finishes and touch-up work.

If I follow along on the pencil-build it will complete my legend.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#12

Re: When you build your own pencils

david weaver

Will do - the key will be getting good lead.

I think a small simple fixed fence plane will allow for cutting (or scratching) the slot for the lead accurately.

I'm sure there are gadgets made somewhere (bridge city style) to make pencils, but I'm not looking for something like that - it'll add better to your legend if you do it and make it out to be an organic process that started with your nuttiness and required nothing from outside of your shop bubble.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#13

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

Jeremy Osner

What's the best way to cut a mortise to hold a pencil? I built a calipers recently and just drilled a hole with the smallest bit that cut a hole the pencil would fit in (I think it was 1/4"), with a screw to hold the pencil in place. I wonder if I could use a smaller bit and then cut edges into the hole to make it hexagonal, if I could give the pencil a tighter fit/better support.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#14

At the risk of feeding the beast...

John in NM

I have some incense cedar left over from building windows... That is the wood for pencils, as far as I know.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#15

Re: At the risk of feeding the beast...

david weaver

That's exactly what's in all of the higher end pencils.

I'm not a pencil sniffer, but I noticed that a lot of the reviews involved the smell while sharpening. Some to the point that a good-working pencil with limited smell was not all that it could or should be.

As I'm getting older, my sense of smell is on the decline, I'm aware that there is a smell associated with sharpening a pencil, but it's never been that strong to me.

I'll take that incense cedar off of your hand for any reasonable price that you'd like to ask for it.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#16

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

david weaver

filing one side of that circle into a triangle is probably your best bet for a positive fit (I'm assuming this is in a marking gauge or something that needs to hold the pencil).

The triangular beam marking gauges all work better and will continue to even with wear if movement of the beam is a big issue. A pencil should be the same - you only need two sides to contact and a fixture to push the pencil against them.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#17

Re: Thanks -- makes sense


Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#18

Re: At the risk of feeding the beast...

John in NM

Let me dig out what I've got and get back to you next week.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#19

I think I sent a picture....

John in NM

New phone, not sure what I'm doing yet :D

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#20

Lead

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My son suggests that, rather than getting your own graphite and clay, making a suitable oven, experimenting with the graphite/clay mix, and so on, you search out the best mechanical pencil leads. Kind of cheating, of course...missing out on all that experimentation (will adding horse dung improve the lead? What if I make the leads hexagonal?).

Me, I'll find my quality pencils at the estate sales and call it good. Presently sitting on probably a lifetime supply of Ticonderogas and other good brands. I don't necessarily need the Maybach of pencils; just pencils on which the leads won't snap when I go to use them.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#21

Re: Zebra DelGuard

Wiley Horne

Derek,

Thanks for recommendation. I received mine yesterday from Amazon. The 0.5mm ones. It really is a different animal from the run of the mill mechanical pencils, where I have to go 0.7mm to avoid constant lead breakage. Cost me $18.85 for 3 pencils, plus $4.79 for extra lead. Lead is standard HB#2.

Both the pencil and the lead are Made in Japan.

Good recommendation.

Wiley

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#22

Re: Zebra DelGuard

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, the 0.5mm Zebra DelGuard mechanical pencils have nearly replaced clutch pencils. I keep a couple of 2mm Caran d'Ache Fixpencil for marking rough sawn boards, but all the fine marking is with a ZD.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#23

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

Don Stephan

Going to hugely embarrass self, but are the Blackwing and others mentioned are wooden pencils or mechanical ones? For writing on paper .5mm Pentel 205 has been my favorite for decades, but for writing on wood I use a box of wooden pencils purchased at a local big box office supply store. After a hand crank pencil sharpener like I grew up with in the 50's and 60's would not symmetrically remove the wood, I bought an electric pencil sharpener to get a symmetric sharpening. Same result, makes me wonder if the lead is not centered in the wood. Is it my bad luck with 2 different styles of new sharpener? Are wooden pencils that poorly made today? Or something else? Whittling away extra wood on one side is frustrating.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#24

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

David Weaver

Yes on the blackwing pencils being wood. They're just pencils, but with nice wood, nice smooth waxed lead, nice lacquer and a good fit.

For lack of a better way to put it, they're just a pencil that functions well and feels good, too.

The range of quality is so broad that you can get barely tolerable to blackwing. If you get off center lead on two sharpeners, the lead is probably just off center.

Re: Low Tech Pencil Fascination

#25

Re: Lead

David Weaver

I hadn't even considered trying to make the leads, as I'd get stuck in that for months and never really figure out how to make them accurately, even if I could make them into a nice texture.

I have some 2 mm staedtler (Sp?) leads, and was planning to take a trip to staples and michaels (I live over the hillside from both) to see what they have.

If they can satisfy, and I can find an assortment in a standard size, then I can make one small fixed fence plane to make a bunch of pencils until the disorder runs its course.

But i looked up leads after you mentioned them, and it doesn't look like it may be that unreasonable to try making them down the road. Graphite, clay, wax, bake.

They will need to be square if I make them, though.

Thanks for the heads up.