Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Anyone do a full french polish?

Posts

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#26

Re: Query

Rum

I have had the same dream, almost black.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#27

Re: Query

david weaver

it won't soak in that deep, so recovery could involve getting rid of it (but scraping a completed piece may not be an option).

Even on older guitars, I find that the cured oil on the fingerboards doesn't go that deep and it can be scraped off. Those don't have sap - the heart pretty much goes uniformly dark, but the sap remains light.

The difference on guitars is the various browns and reds aren't considered desirable in a rosewood or gabon ebony fingerboard (except madagascar rosewood or macassar ebony). The former are generally oiled or stained or both.

Much easier to remove scraping than sanding, as I guess the oily sanded swarf just spreads its wealth and the whole process is a bit gummy.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#28

Guitar makers

david weaver

who dream of one of their ebony fingerboards going out with a huge skunk stripe down the middle would like to switch dreams!!

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#29

Re: Guitar makers

Rum

Hah, some of them have gone the other direction entirely. Last time I was down at my cousins he had several pallets of fret boards cut out of pistachio wood (which is not quite as hard as ebony.. but close and similar weight) which is incredibly figured. Definitely a different style.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#30

Re: Guitar makers

david weaver

Yeah, I've seen some of the one off makers (and some of the semi customs) using really strange patterned wood that can make the pattern of the guitar hard to see.

The advent of CNC brings a lot of people into the hobby. Local guy here showed me a picture of his first guitar. It was more precise than anything I could've made by hand (at least in certain ways), but the design was suspicious!! All stuff glued together and a zebrawood fingerboard, and none of it stained to make color more uniform. Heavily sanded and rounded over, too, but there are some guitars where at least the larger elements are really rounded over (peghead is always crisp, though).

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#31

Re: reading the excerpt in nichoson

Robert Hazelwood

I've actually had good results from putting on a coat of BLO, letting it soak in, wiping excess off, then immediately padding shellac. There is enough oil left to lubricate the pad; it serves the same function as paraffin oil in the common french polish routines. A couple minutes of padding leave a nice shiny but super thin finish. The oil keeps the pad from getting sticky so you can build a nice finish in one session. Without oil it seems to take at least a couple of sessions to build up to the semi-gloss look I normally go for.

Of course you can do the same thing by just adding some paraffin oil to the pad, but if I'm going to apply BLO anyway to darken the wood then this consolidates steps. The BLO does not seem to cause any problems under the finish that I have noticed.

For smaller parts this has to be one of the fastest finishes in terms of elapsed time, though there is more elbow grease involved. And, finishing prior to assembly is mandatory. I mainly like the fact that I can do the whole finish routine without using any sandpaper.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#32

trial piece

david weaver

one pore filling phase, one build phase.

I filled the pores with spray shellac, but of course not sprayed. It's the only mixed shellac that I had handy, so I sprayed it into the "rubber" and used it like that.

The build phase is garnet shellac. It could use one more for completion, but I think it generally looks good and I'm surprise how well build coats work to fill pores that may be, for example, 90% filled after the pore filling phase. Unlike building a thick spray finish where orange peel and unfilled pores seems to stay as an anomaly, subsequent work with the rubber evens out the finish instead.

https://imgur.com/gallery/uhjovb9

It'll be buffed hard with oil and a more dry rubber at the end of this to bring the gloss up further.

The pore filling phase with this one did use 4F pumice, but the surface brightness is good, anyway. I will polish fill the other side of this (no pumice to sand and plug pores) to see how much longer it takes given the nicholson test not mentioning any abrasive to fill pores.

I like the garnet on this mahogany. My first test pieces were with the blonde shellac in the can sprayed into the rubber used for all phases, but the color is a bit light and orangey looking for my taste (even though the shellac doesn't have any orange in it, just the natural color of the wood with blonde shellac).

this color with garnet is closer to the traditional mahogany "natural" finish on guitars, which is probably done with a toned lacquer.

Two things are probably not discernible from these pictures:

* the pores in the wood are really large (khaya, quartered, sometimes the pores are really deep compared to the bigleaf mahogany billets that I have

* the amount of actual finish on the board is exceptionally small, and the finish is pretty good thus far with little more needed to be completely uniform. The dullish looking spots are some kind of anomaly from the interpretation of reflection, they're not actually dull (as you can tell looking across the finish in the other pictures).

Chatoyance is good with sort of a holographic effect when you move the wood around.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#33

Actually doing this process..

david weaver

...is *very* enjoyable, by the way. I think anyone who enjoys hand planing would probably be the type of person who really enjoys the feel of french polishing. total time on this test piece, pore filling and build to this point is probably around 15 minutes. It's not fast, but it's not exactly prohibitive for a hobby woodworker.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#34

Re: reading the excerpt in nichoson

david weaver

Robert, thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts. It makes sense as you've mentioned it - if the oil doesn't affect the bond between coats, I guess it really shouldn't have much of an effect on a coat being applied on the wood.

And now that you've mentioned it, there have been several times out of frustration or on test pieces that I've laid BLO on something (to see how it would affect the figure) and sprayed over it with blonde shellac without letting the BLO dry, and the finish has dried hard with good adhesion and hardness. In that case, it was fine just sprayed on, not padded on. No visual issues, either.

I forgot about that.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#35

Re: CA filler

AlanWS

"Celluloid instead of plastic"? Are you looking to replicate a particular period, or is there a particular property of celluloid you want? Why Celluloid rather than a different plastic?

I would not compare Celluloid to mahogany, as it does not have outstanding properties among plastics the way mahogany does among types of wood. (Unless the property you want is burning. It does that better.)

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#36

Re: CA filler

David Weaver

I like the look of tortoise celluloid and ivoroid much better than the abs plastic bindings. It looks less cheap.