Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Anyone do a full french polish?

Posts

Anyone do a full french polish?

#1

Anyone do a full french polish?

David Weaver

On a piece of furniture? By that, I mean the traditional process starting with pumice and ending burnishing the final finish with a pad, shellac and oil?

I've never considered it with a guitar, but the mahogany bodies that I have for the next four guitars would benefit from the process. I'm guessing if I want to spray lacquer, I can do the pore filling with pumice and dewaxed shellac.

I did the process on a couple of test pieces this weekend (shellac and pumice with shellac finish, no lacquer on top) and it works dandy and has an interesting hand-done look because of the thinness of the finish (it doesn't look faceted and perfectly level like a built finish that's leveled after a large build).

I wouldn't ever sell a guitar with only shellac on it, but I'm not selling anything that I make so it'll be plenty durable for me.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#2

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

David Bassett

Alf Sharp does on reproductions he makes.

I heard him speak at WIA 2016 about his short cut method, (I forget what he called it,) but he starts with the traditional pumice or rotten stone in the first steps to pore fill and start the build and finishes with the traditional padded shellac for the last few coats to refine the finish. But for the (many) intermediate coats, which build the finish, he suggested equivalent results by spraying light coats. IIRC- he figures one light spray is worth about 5 padded layers, so about five spray layers replaces the 25 or so intermediate padded layers which traditionally would have been used.

Oh, since you're making guitars, Kenny Hill uses shellac on (at least some) of his classical guitars:

http://www.hillguitar.com/website/news/tech_notes/french_polish.html

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#3

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

david weaver

Thanks, David - I thought about that, too (building the shellac another way as an alternative, especially if leveling/sanding and polishing are going to happen). The value to me (I don't like epoxy or CA pore filling) probably in every case will be using the process to at least fill pores - I just haven't done it before. It works a treat, it's tolerant of a dirty shop and really enjoyable.

I generally pass my thoughts by George Wilson if I'm already talking to him, and asked him the same (about french polishing). Of course, he's done a bunch of it, but he's also made a bunch of guitars and mentioned the same thing as the hill maker did - george made a few nylon string guitars and french polished them so that they wouldn't lose timbre to a thick finish.

On steel string guitars, though, he'd gone to pore filling with epoxy before retiring just because customers say they want a thin finish, but they really want a finish built up and leveled perfectly, and for a maker to tell them that it's thin. He didn't say that specifically, but that's what I gather.

I haven't looked up historical references, but I'm guessing that this process, sans oil (skipping the burnishing step at the end and some of the build) would also be great to fill pores before a true varnish, because it doesn't penetrate like an oil would, and the varnish could be laid on thin on top of it and would fully cure.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#4

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

Robert Hazelwood

Not really furniture, but a few years ago I attempted it on a set of 5 boxes I made for Christmas gifts. I had a lot of trouble with the pore-filling on the soft maple boxes. I never could get the pores filled and gave up on the idea, and just finished with padded shellac and then rubbed back the sheen with 4F pumice, which made the unfilled pores not stand out. I'd never even thought of soft maple as having much in the way of pores, but the stuff I was using (may have actually been birch that got mixed in with the soft maple bin) had decent sized pores that were like little round pinholes all over the surface when the finish was super glossy.

I also had some trouble with the darker shellac flakes. They are not forgiving of sloppy technique- if you overload the pad with polish and make a heavy spot it will be noticeably darker. Also if you put too much alcohol on the pad you can create a light spot. After creating the spots I was not successful in trying to blend then together, ended up having to strip and start over. I think the major mistake was just trying to use too much shellac, but in any event the blonde shellac is much more forgiving.

But aside from the pore filling and garnet misadventures I really enjoyed the process. The hard maple boxes did not need pore filling and they came out well.

These were the only items I have tried to take to a full solid gloss, but since then I use padded shellac on most everything. Usually I am going for a very thin coating with a satin finish, and it does this very well. Like you noticed with the guitar, it seems to have more life than a thicker film coating, even a very well done one.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#5

Do you have contact with

Wiley Horne

Konrad Sauer? He has done a lot of French polishing of rosewood, particularly of plane totes and buns. Email me if you’d like a go-between for introduction, etc.

Wiley

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#6

P.S.—His result has a

Wiley Horne

Close to the wood look. You don’t think there’s a build-up looking at it.

Wiley

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#7

Re: Do you have contact with

david weaver

Thanks, Wiley - I'd forgotten about Konrad doing the french polish with planes. I don't want to bug him or anything, just looking for tips (in this case, as they would apply to guitars). I've seen a few, and george mentioned that he always had better luck with pore filling and building finish using a slow hand on the pad.

I saw a second tip from another guitar maker who mentioned that circular strokes are necessary for good pore filing because strokes in the direction of the grain will push and pull pumice out of the pores and leave them unfilled.

I think now I just need to give it a few more iterations, as I noticed on the first two that what feels like finished pore filling usually needs a look across the surface and some attention to any areas where you can still see the pores, then a rest period is helpful (to ensure that additional drying doesn't result in some pore relief, and then once pores look good after a period of a few hours of drying, then the whole thing is ready for building.

Some of the guitar makers' commentary provided here helped with other questions (like what about areas that meet in a corner, etc - on an electric guitar, I have no real issues - I can just take all of the hardware off and do the job and then put it back on when done) and "does it look perfect", to which the answer was no, that's something provided by modern thick build finishes and a little less perfect looking than that is the standard. Sometimes I have bad taste. I like the look of the two french polish surfaces that I've done better than the look of a finish built heavily and then sanded and buffed back (leaving a still thick result to avoid getting stung by burn through when buffing). I also like the look of hand varnished guitars, but I know for sure the market generally sees hand rubbed finishes as flawed. I'm not the market.

These days, the larger manufacturers don't use people to build the finish, anyway. The spray process is automated and only the sanding and buffing uses people (in the case of martin, most of the buffing is done with a robot now, too).

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#8

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

david weaver

Thanks for the warning about garnet, as I was thinking about using it to darken mahogany (but not before using it on more test scraps).

Soft maple is a strange wood when you look at it closely and compare it to hard maple or other seemingly pore free woods. It's (soft) got little pores and a fibrous texture.

I wouldn't be surprised to find that early coats of some french polish involved a glaze in darker woods to ensure that the surface was much darker than the shellac (hiding any thin areas).

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#9

quick way from here to there

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Here is how someone that needs to make a living making furniture does it. (he has in impressive pedigree in Period Furniture)

Fill pores with filler. There is no doubt it would have been used in 1720 had it been invented. Spray to build a finish layer of shellac. Sand smooth if needed. "French Polish" the result.

For formal pieces I fill the tops, not the sides and drawers. I fill with filler, stain, seal, build top coats by spraying, grind glass smooth, buff back to desired luster.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#10

Re: quick way from here to there

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you want a quick way to finish a piece of furniture, you might look into what workers actually did in 1720. There are people who have actually studied 18th century finishing; it certainly sounds like you are not one of them.

And just because one professional in Tennessee uses a certain finishing regimen, it does not mean that we all use those same techniques.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#11

Yes..

david weaver

..the economy of doing the finish that way was decided long ago. Somewhere in the 1920s, I think, Martin guitars switched from varnish to lacquer.

I'm going for a different look than that, but also skill building for acoustic guitars where the different look will equate to a different sound.

It's an enjoyable process, too, and there's no economic motive, so I don't have to speed things up. It's also tolerant of an environment that isn't dust free, so I don't have to clean much up.

(I actually built up, leveled and rubbed out the very first piece of furniture I ever sprayed. It's in my bedroom as a book case, so it's stayed in perfect shape - no kid traffic, etc. But I don't want to make industrial-looking or sounding guitars, and even the guitars that martin makes for $3,000 leave a lot to be desired).

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#12

Re: quick way from here to there

david weaver

Warren - any thoughts? I've used oil under wax, shellac under wax. All of them are quick.

I've also done what bill mentions, but I don't like the look of that - especially on guitars. It's lifeless looking, and on acoustic guitars (just as violin makers obsessed), soaking finish in or building it too thick changes the timbre a lot.

The cheapest guitar finish these days is a straight off of the gun toned lacquer - sprayed only in a few coats and then left as is. Gibson makes a series of guitars called "faded" that are made that way - really cheap, but their customers aren't smart enough to deal with a finish that would require maintenance, and it's just my opinion, but business changes have seemingly reduced the skill level of the labor there by a lot, so the method they're using fits well.

I've made four test boards with the french polish process so far. It's extremely enjoyable, and I'm not chasing the sun as I did with the last two guitars I made out of "house varnish" with no cobalt salt driers in it (I can't find anything good at all health wise about japan drier, but I have marching orders from george on how to add it to a pine/dammar varnish if I want to. )

I'm assuming a quick finish in the 1700s may have also been varnish brushed to wood, thinly, with no leveling?

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#13

I don't understand your initial question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You began with a query about French Polish. As I know of it the result is a respectably built up finish over a pore filled surface, glass smooth and lusterous. I took a class with someone that apprenticed with Emmet, did a stint at Colonial Williamsburg, worked in a Period shop in Charleston, etc. This was the result we were striving for and the result I have see on other work. It was, and is, the finish to put on formal furniture. In this later post it sounds like this is not the look you are after.

To specifically answer your question, I don't use it. I can get the same look and durability with rubbed lacquer over pore filled wood, vastly quicker.

In certain parts of the country if you buy a mineral block for your cattle it will be fortified with cobalt. Animals don't do well without some. Where I live it is selenium. Wickedly poisonous stuff, but without any nerves and reproduction doesn't work. (I saw the result with a sheep herd before I supplemented) Apparently what isn't taught in chemistry is that it is the dose that is toxic, not the chemical. At some level no chemical is toxic and all chemicals are toxic at some dose. Deaths occur from water and salt....look it up.

Modern driers are formulated with cobalt to aid the oxidation of the drying oils. No more than a few parts per million are needed in the varnish formulation. Anyone fearing cobalt from this source is surrounded by a multitude of other cobalt containing products that they can be fearful of, some polyester for example.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#14

CA filler

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Cyanoacrylate is not a stable material after it cures. It will degrade more or less quickly depending on how much moisture it is exposed to. It might be years or a few decades but eventually the CA used to glue or fill will catastrophically fail. Keep this fact in mind when using it for some application it was not designed to be used for.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#15

Re: I don't understand your initial question

david weaver

I had assumed at one point that there wasn't really any difference between a french polish and a sprayed finish pore filled, built and leveled back.

I've done the latter already, I wouldn't say many times (and will probably continue to with furniture that I don't want to refinish or maintain the surface on).

In this case, I wanted to pore fill mahogany, and was considering the various pore filling options (tinting, clear pore filler, water based fillers) and figured I'd give at least the pore filling part a shot because it doesn't involve follow-up sanding.

it turns out in watching demonstrations that achieving a buffed-looking bright finish that is extremely thin is much easier than it is with lacquer (burn through while buffing guitars is what prevents them from being as thin as really particular buyers might like), and my assumption that it would look like a mirror was incorrect - it has a different look. The mirror brightness is there if you burnish, but every tiny undulation on the surface shows up because there isn't significant surface finish to "gloss over" that look (my very first case has 15 coats of WB lacquer on it and it literally looked faceted when I was done).

In short, I came looking for one thing (just the pore filling that is guaranteed to be the same color as the wood and done relatively easily by hand), and found several other things that I appreciate much more (the thinness of the finish, and the look for a guitar. It gives a more lively look to a guitar that can easy become an expanse of thick finish buffed to textbook perfection - a look I don't really like).

It's possible to do this with WB finish that has a bit of an open time before complete cure - those finishes harden enough to level and rub out in less than a day - I've done that - but I'm looking to do the actual process.

I've done four test pieces now. It's a very intuitive process, it yields a bright surface with an exceedingly small amount of shellac (which is a side benefit on an acoustic instrument) and it's pleasant to do - thus far in four test pieces, at least. It's not a replacement for modern spray finishing (I happily sprayed all of my kitchen cabinets after brushing a shellac sealer on them - just to get them done).

I also don't have a huge buffing wheel (which is the standard for guitars) and don't want one, as the finish look isn't something that I'm really going for. I think the buffing process for an entire guitar is only about an hour, done with skill. anyone sitting down to do that by hand might think they could match it for about five minutes until they realized that done by hand, it's a day. The industry has got this worked out because they count pennies, and while an hour sounds quick, I think the entire process of a fender american standard guitar has about 7 man hours in it. They pioneered using automotive paints on guitars and giving people colors like a car dealer would (sounds gimmicky now, but it was a big deal when they did it) and used small pore woods with body filler on them before the paint.

So, the differences vs. a built finish are what i'm looking for here, and each test piece has been a little easier and more intuitive than I expected, and very pleasant to do.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#16

Re: CA filler

david weaver

If the CA is pinned under finish on the guitar, it should get water slowly. There are sort of eras in guitar finishing - the original 50s guitars made with nitro can have various quirks. Some of them didn't have enough plasticizers in them and have cracked over time (which people really like). Some of them have yellowed (all?). Fender, to my knowledge, was using polyurethane type finishes as far back as the 1960s, but since there were no internet forums to tell people that was a terrible thing, nobody seemed to mind (they still do that).

Now there are several decades of water based guitars being made concurrently with polyurethane and nitro finished guitars, and a tiny amount of other options (french polish on nosebleed guitars, and a few brushed varnish, etc, or oil only). Some of those guitars will never age, and some will have finish failures, but very little of what's out there in older guitars doesn't have some kind of issue with finishes.

I'd guess because of the cost and ease of build with lacquer and WB acrylics, most of the CA type guitars are sealed on the top side and will get most of their moisture through the wood on the inside only (on an electric, that's almost none. Over time on an acoustic, it's probably considerable.

it's maybe a close of this thread at this point, but I thought there may be some helpful tips in applying or using the french polish, but have already talked to george and seen a couple of videos that mentioned things like "fill pores working across them rather than with the grain". The results that I've gotten thus far are probably only going to be improved by more iteration (but they are surprisingly good already for how often people say things like "that's a hard way to finish"). Brushing varnish in a shop with dust, or outdoor exposure is relatively difficult, but for reasons that I don't care for (it's not a skill issue brushing it on - that's easy - even making a true varnish turned out to be easy).

There is a little bit of a sense with me (too) that i'm not going to use CA on a guitar simply because it sounds cheesy to me. I'm using celluloid binding instead of plastic (plastic has become the standard now because it's easier to work with and a lot cheaper, and can just glue it to the guitar with any number of things, and then scrape it more easily). That's snobbery, I guess, but so is using mahogany.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#17

Re: quick way from here to there

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you look at 300 year old Stradivari and a 2019 Martin guitar, one looks like a million bucks and the other looks like a piece of plastic. Or maybe fine formica. I think you want to stay away from the lacquer look.

In 1986, George Frank wrote an article for Fine Woodworking on French polishing. It was the method that he learned in 1922 in his native Budapest. He claimed he had the one true "French method", and that all others (which he seemed not too familiar with) were not traditional. This method was adopted by writers who became instant experts, and it has gotten to the point that even David Weaver calls it "the traditional process".

I think one of the things you might want to avoid with the pumice is the abraded look, which is alright if you are sanding the wood anyway, but a little cloudy if you are not sanding. You might look into polish filling, which would give a more lively look. You might also look into historic finishing of violins lutes guitars et cetera, for ideas. There is a resurgence of interest in these methods for obvious reasons.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#18

Can you point me towards a reference?

Chuck Nickerson

Book, video, class; and will do.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#19

Re: quick way from here to there

david weaver

Thanks, warren, that's exactly the discussion i'm looking for. You're right, I used the term traditional method, but looking to avoid deviation from french polishing.

This might be a case where I would be well served reading older literature, even though i don't often do it, as everything post-Hasluck seems to ignore the discussion of liveliness, etc.

My electric guitars are sanded (not always all of them, just around the edges and the neck - it's nice to not sand the faces of the guitar body or the front and back of the peghead). I'd like to build some later guitars without sanding, not because it's historically accurate for anything that originated in this century, but because it's more interesting looking.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#20

shot in the dark

Wiley Horne

David,

Re: pore-filling guaranteed not to change the wood......what would happen if you filled the pores with the actual wood? For example, wet sand using a very fine or ultrafine paper and a thin cut of shellac.

Wiley

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#21

Re: shot in the dark

david weaver

nothing in particular, and that is a possible method (though I haven't tried it yet). The reason the french polish method that (I think) konrad uses works well for the pore filling is that the shellac involved in the process is a sparing amount.

It keeps the surface of the wood from getting gummy or sticky, and is just enough to color the pumice and mix wood in and set it in place. I think the more dry the pore fill mixture, the less shrinkage there will be as it cures.

The first two test pieces I tried, I filled the pores, and then came back a couple of hours later without doing it again. They still looked great, but the pores weren't as completely filled as I'd hoped and they showed here or there (but 98% better than doing nothing). the reason that the pumice is used in such a fine grade, I'm guessing, is because the pore filling process is done in circles or across the grain in some cases, and a very fine abrasive won't leave evidence.

Long story short, a wet sand of shellac might be possible, but the more wet the surface, the more it will need to be two steps. It's also possible that a cake of filler might work - one made of dust and shellac, and would be interesting to try.

My first painted guitar was done over plaster of paris. I thought the paint was going to be opaque (it was automotive paint). It turned out to be translucent !!!!!!

But good fortune and a heavy application tinted the plaster of paris the same color as the paint and it more or less disappeared.

There's just all kinds of fun to be had here. That test guitar was kit parts from teh far east. I gave it to my son (who is 6) .the purpose wasn't really to have a finished guitar, but to fiddle with a cheap kit and try some finishing things (the kits are far cheaper than I can get actually wood to make guitars). I found it yesterday standing on end against the wall...peghead on the floor, but that's OK. The unexpected translucent paint worked so well that I will use it on purpose next time - with the plaster of paris again.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#22

Re: shot in the dark

Rum

If you're looking to use sanding dust you can get finer dust off of a piece of the same wood sanding the end grain. IMHO that's a better sanding dust based filler than side grain which can be stringy.

I've actually just lightly cut back the shellac with sandpaper as well and integrated that as a pore filler. I think that works better on things with pretty shallow pores otherwise it seems maybe to fine or something.. idk.. I've had problems with little valleys doing that anyway.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#23

reading the excerpt in nichoson

david weaver

practical cabinetmaker, or whatever the proper title is for the volume:

As Warren suggested, but didn't refer to this - the "traditional" method may not be quite so narrow as the 4F pumice and shellac.

No mention of abrasive is made, and the shellac referenced (probably due to refinement at the time) involved two resins to lighten it. I think those resins could be left out now as they do soften the finish.

The rubber is used the same as it would be with pumice, just with no pumice, and nicholson does make the comment more or less, light finish for light wood, darker finish can be used for darker wood (presumably due to colors).

Nicholson also suggests spirit varnish (alcohol based resin finish, an antiquated term now in many places other than restoration and musical instruments, and maybe with some artists....maybe it's not that antiquated) without lac resin to be painted on details that can't be rubbed out with the rubber.

(I must admit that in the section just prior, he also mentions scraping and sanding as part of surface preparation!!!)

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#24

Re: reading the excerpt in nichoson

david weaver

"he" may be "they", I don't know the background of the nicholson text, but at some point in the literature, it mentions a coat of oil on the piece before starting as a suggestion from some sources and then uses the term "we", paraphrased "we don't believe this to be a good suggestion" (neither do I).

I'm not inclined to try the pumice-free version without having at least good honduran mahogany with smaller pores (not all of it has that). The two quartered african pieces I've used in guitars recently have extremely deep prominent pores.

Re: Anyone do a full french polish?

#25

Query

Wiley Horne

What does a coat of oil do to rosewood? I recall having rosewood go dark and featureless, and unrecoverable. Maybe I dreamed that.

Wiley