Re: I don't understand your initial question
david weaver
I had assumed at one point that there wasn't really any difference between a french polish and a sprayed finish pore filled, built and leveled back.
I've done the latter already, I wouldn't say many times (and will probably continue to with furniture that I don't want to refinish or maintain the surface on).
In this case, I wanted to pore fill mahogany, and was considering the various pore filling options (tinting, clear pore filler, water based fillers) and figured I'd give at least the pore filling part a shot because it doesn't involve follow-up sanding.
it turns out in watching demonstrations that achieving a buffed-looking bright finish that is extremely thin is much easier than it is with lacquer (burn through while buffing guitars is what prevents them from being as thin as really particular buyers might like), and my assumption that it would look like a mirror was incorrect - it has a different look. The mirror brightness is there if you burnish, but every tiny undulation on the surface shows up because there isn't significant surface finish to "gloss over" that look (my very first case has 15 coats of WB lacquer on it and it literally looked faceted when I was done).
In short, I came looking for one thing (just the pore filling that is guaranteed to be the same color as the wood and done relatively easily by hand), and found several other things that I appreciate much more (the thinness of the finish, and the look for a guitar. It gives a more lively look to a guitar that can easy become an expanse of thick finish buffed to textbook perfection - a look I don't really like).
It's possible to do this with WB finish that has a bit of an open time before complete cure - those finishes harden enough to level and rub out in less than a day - I've done that - but I'm looking to do the actual process.
I've done four test pieces now. It's a very intuitive process, it yields a bright surface with an exceedingly small amount of shellac (which is a side benefit on an acoustic instrument) and it's pleasant to do - thus far in four test pieces, at least. It's not a replacement for modern spray finishing (I happily sprayed all of my kitchen cabinets after brushing a shellac sealer on them - just to get them done).
I also don't have a huge buffing wheel (which is the standard for guitars) and don't want one, as the finish look isn't something that I'm really going for. I think the buffing process for an entire guitar is only about an hour, done with skill. anyone sitting down to do that by hand might think they could match it for about five minutes until they realized that done by hand, it's a day. The industry has got this worked out because they count pennies, and while an hour sounds quick, I think the entire process of a fender american standard guitar has about 7 man hours in it. They pioneered using automotive paints on guitars and giving people colors like a car dealer would (sounds gimmicky now, but it was a big deal when they did it) and used small pore woods with body filler on them before the paint.
So, the differences vs. a built finish are what i'm looking for here, and each test piece has been a little easier and more intuitive than I expected, and very pleasant to do.