Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

School me on polishing

Posts

Re: School me on polishing

#26

Thank you all...

Jonathan Elliott

I was hoping to communicate exactly what Wiley said and showed with the Norton abrasives. Bill's answer (that he uses 0-1u) actually surprised me so I'm glad I asked the question. I had always assumed that when 1u diamond was referred to that it was the average as Norton and Ted Pella list (0-2u). I don't desire to drag anyone down into a rabbit hole that has long been excavated as far as anyone wants to go, but I'm glad to have a better understanding of what's being discussed now.

I appreciate the practical points you bring up David. Personal experience is the greatest teacher. I agree with what Steve Voigt has said in the past (at least about the chip breaker) for someone just starting out it's nice to have a started point based on other's experience and then go from there.

For context, I am new to the hand tool world, having worked in machine only shops but look forward to diving into hand tools in my own shop so I'm absorbing with interest before I actually start experiencing and discovering what works for me. I wanted to have a clearer understanding of what was being discussed and this has helped a lot. I appreciate everyone's feedback based on their experiences, it's really interesting to me.

Re: School me on polishing

#27

Of course

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The means of preparing diamond abrasive determines there will be ranges. It is how large they are and how the range is described with a single number that can be unclear, to unknown. The more sophisticated suppliers provide both a range and a single descriptive value. Others don't.

Re: School me on polishing

#28

Re: Thank you all...

david weaver

Ahh, that clears it up. There are things you'll need to be very precise about, and things that you won't need to be that precise about.

For diamonds, unless you are going to order an array, I'd say (and this is more careless than some might be) find a domestic supply and order a couple of sizes rather than ordering one.

You may at some point exhaust your supply and want to re-order something. I've used diamonds relatively little, except for flattening irons on a kanaban before I found a better method to do it. Even with that, I've never exhausted any sample that I've purchased, and i don't know if I would have even if i'd used them more.

I can only say that I've ordered vials from a supplier on ebay in 0.1 micron to 5 microns (the latter only due to recent testing - before that, I just has 0.1, 0.25, 0.5 and 1). The vial marked 1 is what I used for testing, and even if it does range from 0-2 (I really don't know), it still looks as fine or finer under the scope than the 1 micron dense-composition artificial sharpening stones.

I'm not going to say how much I've spent over the years on various stones and other things to play with as the whole sharpening thing is a fascination, but it's probably more than 4 figures. The medium and those details have never been that important, every single method has worked, including materials that are supposedly obsolete or useless (like silica based japanese medium and medium coarse stones).

Far more important will be mastering a method that is quick to use and that is successful each attempt.

If you're hand tool woodworking, most things are about putting biases in your favor. I have a mechanical engineering buddy who also has a machine shop background and he struggled with the idea that there are only a few critical things that have to fit and the rest can be biased. He finally gave up on using hand tools. He's the one I mentioned who got a 30k shapton stone, because he just couldn't see how it wouldn't improve his woodworking given the quality (and it's a quality piece of gear).

Bills 1 micron may be finer than my 1 micron as far as diamonds go, but it doesn't matter. The details about what I'm doing when I sharpen matter a lot. Some things are precise (completing the job at the edge of the iron), and some are not (I don't grind with the rest set, I guess at the grind angle because it's not my final angle, and I don't check the final angle of work, either - it's by feel. The setup and the biases allow sharpening to be quick and precise where it needs to be but not where it's not needed).

If you can treat woodworking as a new thing and only transfer over talents from machining when they are applicable, you'll be much further along than comparing and assuming that something important in one is important in another.

Re: School me on polishing

#29

correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The dry powder I use occasionally is labeled 0-2 micron. The paste I use more often, for its convenience, is labeled 0-1. I have been calling it to, myself, "1". I don't know how standardized the reduction of size range to a single number is now, or was in the past. I have some other material that is labeled with a mesh size, 14000. Obviously there is no such thing as a screen capable of sieving 14000 so who knows what range is in this stuff.

The process of separating particle size ranges and recovery of diamonds after separation will be costly. One might expect that "cheap " sources might suffer broader ranges than claimed.

I suspect the particle range is more critical in polishing surfaces for appearance, gems for example, than our use for removing metal from a bevel.

Re: School me on polishing

#30

Re: Thank you all...

Bill White

David, your practical approach to the subject is much appreciated. I like the idea of "whatever works for you".

Re: School me on polishing

#31

Shaving lifters

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It may well be that us "shaving lifters" are refining edges beyond what is essential. To that end I am going to experiment with the routine of grind, "3" micron on cast iron and strop on abrasive charged leather, eliminating the "fine" fixed diamond step I have employed.

I suffer edges worn well beyond what David tolerates. Presuming I don't mend my ways my challenge is being rid of the dead dull edge which will require more metal removal than some/most of you deal with. 15 micron on cast iron does the trick blazing fast. It is approximately the equivalent of the fine fixed diamond plate. But I don't know what to follow it with that could conveniently stay on the bench and not require a water bath.

Re: School me on polishing

#32

Re: Shaving lifters

Wiley Horne

“But I don't know what to follow it with that could conveniently stay on the bench and not require a water bath.“

The DMT 8000 fixed diamond would work great for alloy steel after the 15u grind. It punches above its grit rating, and you would ‘t need a middle stone. I use mine on all alloy now (XHP, PMV11, 3V, A2, M2), with the 8000 used as the primary stone, and followed by natural waterstones to refine the diamond cuts, and a few licks on a green strop. Just spray it with any lubricant to keep the diamonds from getting torn out—I use water, but anything would work.

8”, D8EE, $72 from Amazon. No financial interest, etc.

Wiley

Re: School me on polishing

#33

not three steps beyond

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In principal I can go from 15 micron loose to 1 micron and done, but there is carry over and the 1 micron plate gets contaminated. It takes just a tiny bit of metal removal to refine 15 micron loose to diamond to useable. Experimenting with diamond paste is cheap, 10-15 a size. Experimenting with stones for final polish is not cheap, so I have no done it.

Re: School me on polishing

#34

Think Burnish

Charlie belden

Abbrassives remove material by scratching it away. The finer the scratches the smoother and more reflective the surface.

Burnishing, on the other hand, doesn’t scratch or remove material, but compresses the high points of the scratches closer to the bottom of the scratches, making the resulting surface smoother and more reflective/ shinier.

I burnish small turnings with paper coffee filter paper. And if you apply enough pressure at higher speeds you can scorthch / shade the wood.