Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

School me on polishing

Posts

School me on polishing

#1

School me on polishing

david weaver

I'm no expert in it, and maybe nobody here is.

I read the 1850 version of Holtzapffel III this morning, which has a section about 100 pages long on whetstones, grinding wheels and polishes. There is some talk about use of them, but it's summary.

What I noticed at the time is that it seems like the ideal polish in the old days was something around the same hardness as the item being polished (final polish, not the cut polish before it). iron *oxide* isn't the substance being recommended for razors, but rather iron itself.

Lots of lead oxides, etc, in that document, but I'm sure that's out of style these days!

The polishing section also mentions health consequences of some of the professionals, suggesting that men who polish fork tines tend to live into their late 20s or 30 before developing pulmonary issues and going downhill quickly.

The only application of chrome ox that I've ever seen (aside from the recent adoption) is that it is suggested for stainless steel. I'm going to assume that the old tripolis recommended elsewhere may have struggled on the chromium in stainless, thus a chromium oxide particle shows up in a compound.

There is obviously no mention of chrome ox as a polishing media in the 1850 version (that section of text is publicly available on google books and is an interesting read for the bored. I read it long ago as it relates to razors, but it was probably a mistake because razors weren't really mature yet at the time and were more like knives ground slightly hollow. I've had early to mid 1800s razors, and safe to say, they're nothing really special because the grind of a fine razor contributes a lot to the use and the ability to really target the edge.

So, taking a tangent back from this tangent, is anyone into polishing things, and if so, is there some theory that you don't just want to go with fine, but instead or also, that you want to match the media to the medium.

Bill mentioned that diamond is replacing a lot of things, and to the extent that older school guidance may have relied on something other than particle size, if diamonds in tiny bits do it cheaper, then that will be the standard. There's a whole world of kind-of parallels in polishing, making teeth, making lenses, etc, that piggy backs on some of the things that we swipe for woodworking.

And if you read the first book and you see the entry where there is a discussion of turkish oilstones, and their superiority, and that there is a light and a dark type.

...

...

..

I have one of each. Curiosity is a real problem. Those weren't particularly easy to find for a reasonable price. (And they're not a hone slate like the text says, they're novaculite, just friable).

The fact that the washita is exalted in the revised text is something I can identify with. While the turkish stones are really interesting, I like our oilstones better.

Re: School me on polishing

#2

One other interesting thing that I missed...

david weaver

..when I was originally reading to glean other info -

- turnings of instrument parts made of very hard woods was done at least at the time, finished entirely with an abrasive process.

That's of mild interest because I'm slowly getting around to turning chess pieces, and if I do well, then I think very lightly finished pieces would be divine if the wood itself could be brought to a polish with the pores sealed to prevent cracking.

I have used metal polish on rosewood before, and i think Derek did the same. It does something interesting to the surface smoothing and darkening it, but depending on the polish, it can leave an undesirable oil based stink. So, I'm pondering smashing together some of my beeswax/mineral oil mix with alumina.

Re: School me on polishing

#4

Re: School me on polishing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A few notes on old terminology.

A whetstone can be coarse or fine, oil stone or water stone.

A hone slate and a whet slate are fine stones; in an 1885 dictionary a whetslate is an oil stone or novaculite, also called whetstone slate.

Hone, slate, and oil stone usually denote a fine stone.

A roofing slate can be used to sharpen, but that is not usually what is meant by "honing slate".

Re: School me on polishing

#5

Thanks for that link..and poor memory!.

david weaver

I mentioned below that I thought that the 1894 edition of the edited turning ... volume III had favorable comments about the washita, but now after reading it, I recall that it says the opposite.

There's glowing language for the translucent arkansas stone, and then a kind of funny comment that washita is available, paraphrased - it looks like a second rate arkansas stone of some type, but it's not, it's 'inferior in every respect'.

That's worth a bit of a chuckle as it's present in the UK in droves (the UK ebay site is the easiest place to find them) and in US catalogs, they were about twice the price of soft ark.

The charnley is listed as a hone slate in this one, and I may have misread earlier (the turkish oilstone is said to *not* be a hone slate in this, and it's definitely not a hone slate). Not sure about the charnley and idwall, but I have had two of the former and have two of the latter. I don't think they're slate.

Re: School me on polishing

#6

Re: School me on polishing

david weaver

Thanks, warren. The other peculiar thing in the new IIIrd edition (new- 1894 new) is the discussion of the german razor stone. It's described as occurring at its best where it meets blue slate, and often being mined and cut with a blue slate backer.

That sounds more like a belgian hone (coticule), but maybe things change.

I've seen a lot of escher stones, but have never seen one that's a natural combination like a coticule.

The author of the book seems to prefer fineness and uniformity given that it's clear that he doesn't care for the washita.

Re: School me on polishing

#7

Re: School me on polishing

Rum

Question: how much does grit shape actually matter?

Basis:

I've read that sharper valleys (such as those given by some? types of diamonds) have more rapid failure modes (further justification for post-diamond stropping?).

I've also read some comments about one reason the belgian coticule's were desirable was due to the garnets having a rather round/soft cutting profile (even though they are rather large in modern terms in the 5-15 micron range) thus yielding a "smoother" surface on the resulting edge (desirable on razors).

How much this matters with some of the extremely fine stuff we can get now is debatable - hence asking the question :)

Re: School me on polishing

#8

Answer from my experience

david weaver

...it doesn't really matter much (if the abrasive can be fine enough or the medium applying it forgiving enough), and I think the evidence is in the widely used polishes.

When I look at something like Zam, or other specialized polishes for soft metals that are "gentle and don't scratch", they are still in some cases 85% alumina (and that includes stearic acid or something else as a base - makes me think they're in a soap bar). They're different colors, but the SDS for the wax sticks pretty much looks 90%+ the same.

The market of professional users probably will find that the all alumina types cut faster than the older various types of oxides, and are perhaps more consistent (are they cheaper? i don't know...some of the buffing sticks sold by rio grande are $5 a pound).

I can only assume that, especially with something like that where time can be counted easily, the market has decided that alumina in different sizes is generally the best for polishing metal.

And I'm resisting the urge to try one of everything cheap, as I've got about 10 pounds of wax sticks already.

I already see very little functional difference in sharpness from 1 micron diamonds down to chrome ox. Steve Elliot mentioned that finer and finer does have some additional edge retention, but in terms of work product and surface brightness, 1 micron is about where I stop seeing new things. A buddy and I tested this years ago - he had the hots for the shapton 30K stone, and I already had the 15k pro. From the king to the shapton 15k, I could see a difference. From there to the 30K, I couldn't. Expensive way to find out.

Re: School me on polishing

#9

Re: Answer from my experience

Jonathan Elliott

Since we're talking extremely fine stuff and the differences in grading, I have a question. When 1 micron diamond is referred to isn't it correct that it contains 0-2 micron diamonds and 0.5 micron contains 0-1 micron diamond? So when anyone is referring to "not seeing much difference below 1 micron diamond" is it correct that that's really 0-2 micron? Does that equally compare to the 1.2u Shapton or say a 1u film sheet that only has 1u particles.

Splitting hairs here of course but just curious. It seems like with really fine stuff how tightly it's graded matters more and 2u would be quite a bit different than 1u at this level.

Re: School me on polishing

#10

Re: Answer from my experience

david weaver

I couldn't tell you exactly how big the variation is because the only way I can see what each compound is doing is through the microscope using the media on a hard surface to create the scratches.

If grading gets really loose, I can see evidence from it. If one compound is graded at 0.5 micron and it's relatively tight, it will look different from one that says it's 0.5 average and has particles as large as 1 1/2.

I think the alumina in the finer sharpening stones available (shapton, sigma power) as far as grit size goes looks to me to be very uniform. Graded diamond powder that is intentionally closely graded looks to be very uniform. The buffing sticks (aside from the specialty expensive ones for shaving customers) appear to be somewhat less closely graded. If the literature with the sticks doesn't say exactly what they are, then I have trouble telling other than the scratch pattern. The SDS usually says the percentage of alumina, but nothing about size.

Still speculating, but I think the honing films are very closely graded like the higher grade sharpening stones.

Re: School me on polishing

#11

Re: Answer from my experience

Rum

I know there is some difference in diamond shape (beyond the mono/polycrystalline

classification) but am not sure if anyone really grades for that (or indeed if they can). I also don't know if different monocrystalline shapes have meaningfully different cut patterns.

There is also an arguably meaningful variance in alumina shapes (and hardness) - i.e http://www.metallographic.com/Brochures/Alumina.pdf

So I'm not -yet- convinced that you can tell usefully the abrasive classification of that entirely from the SDS (whether we care in our case, and how much is another question). I mean I love SDS's but there's always the risk of believing you understand a product from them when you don't because there's some non-obvious subclassifications of the material that aren't reflected in it.

I suspect that for all practical purposes you're 99% correct though (barring perhaps some specialized use cases). This is mostly just curiosity on my part as I'm pretty happy with my sharpening regime so unless something is worlds different the cost of changing isn't usually worth it. OTOH I also have large piles of rocks that need polishing work.. so perhaps less academic there and maybe some opportunity to buy some other grades mediums to play with.. just because.. :)

Re: School me on polishing

#12

Are you buying from China?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know where you got your information from but it is not accurate if one considers quality sources of diamond abrasives. Some of this stuff is used in critical applications, like grinding the gyros of ICBM's. Even grinding facets on a $100,000 diamond could be considered critical. Tightly graded abrasives are available for these applications, but probably not on Ebay.

Spend the money and one can obtain ever tighter size specifications. Buy a syringe of paste from China and it will unknown what range particles are present, or their concentration. Personally I buy from reputable lapidary supplies. I would buy from where the gyro polishes buy but the government won't tell me.

In the case of the small alumina it is made by a process that makes tight particle size ranges. It is not made and then sorted.

Re: School me on polishing

#13

Re: Are you buying from China?

Jonathan Elliott

I was hoping you would response Bill, since I know you have an incredible experience base with diamond pastes. Any place that I have found that will actually list the nominal particle range lists the same range, which is double the labeled size.

My question was based on this, wanting to know if when you, and others, refer to 1u diamond you are referring to the labeled size (perhaps a range of 1-2u) or the 0.5u labeled diamond with a range of 0.5-1u. I think I know the answer, I was just curious.

I have no doubt the stuff from ebay is not nearly as well graded as from lapidary suppliers, but it seems a nominal range of double the labeled size is standard practice rather than just poor grading. This supplier sells 5g for $43 and lists the grading range I am referring to. I'm not claiming authority on this it's just what I've been able to find and have very limited experience so I wanted to ask.

https://www.tedpella.com/Material-Sciences_html/Diamond_Polishing_Compounds_and_Paste.htm

Re: School me on polishing

#14

Re: Are you buying from China?

David Weaver

The scratch pattern from the one micron diamond powder that I used for the iron test is no larger in Groove size than the sigma 13k. If anything, it's closer to a visual complete polish under the scope and the subjective sharpness is at least as high. Off of wood, the level of polish was definitely finer than a 13k sigma power.

It is us origin.

Re: School me on polishing

#15

check Norton abrasives

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

Here is Norton’s line of diamond paste. Scroll toward the bottom, and you’ll see the micron ranges around the nominal mesh size.

https://www.nortonabrasives.com/sga-common/files/document/Catalog%20-%20Norton%20Abrasive%20Product%20Solutions%20for%20the%20Full%20Line%20Stock%20Industrial%20Market%20-%207362%20-%202017%20Safety.pdf

I have no doubt you’re right—that if one is willing to pay for precision, one can get it. However, reputable suppliers such as Norton are supplying product generally as described by Jonathan—you don’t have to go overseas.

Wiley

Re: School me on polishing

#16

what was substrate?

Wiley Horne

David,

Was that 1u on a wood lap?

Wiley

Re: School me on polishing

#17

Re: what was substrate?

David Weaver

Similar scratch size on cast, but much finer on wood vs the sp 13k. That's visually under the scope, of course. I didn't set up any specific tests for sharpness.

Re: School me on polishing

#18

Re: check Norton abrasives

David Weaver

Slight difference, though. Jonathan is describing a system where the label describes the minimum size, but Norton appears to be showing the median or mean, which is probably what we'd expect.

Re: School me on polishing

#19

How diamond abrasive is graded/sized

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Historically, and for the places that reveal how the product is sized that I know about(limited) what follows is how it is done and the product results. (There are other possibilities but I do not know if they are used for diamond sizing. )

Suspend stuff in a liquid and the rate that a particle settles depends on its size, all other variables held constant (in this case we are talking about just diamonds and some viscous liquid, historically olive oil).

Grind up some diamonds. Suspend in liquid and allow to settle. After XX amount of time decant liquid with suspended diamonds from what has settled. (Often the first that settles is reground). Allow the liquid with suspended diamonds to settle YY time. After YY time decant liquid with suspended diamonds and recover what has settled to be sold as some size range. Repeat this settling- decant many times to generate many ever smaller size ranges.

It follows that the more settle-decant steps are included the more narrow the size range of each product recovered. And, in the end there is a size fraction that does not settle in the time allowed that will be "0-ZZ" size range. The larger number in this range depends on how long the manufacturer allowed the preceding settling to occur.

The more steps are included, the more narrow the product range and the higher the manufacturing cost. Pay more, get a more narrow range. Someone selling a 0-2 micron range chose to quit the separation at 2 micron. Someone else could sell a 0-1 micron range by doing a preceding 2 micron decant step.

It should be added that the amount of the actual particle sizes in the range will be biased to the larger sizes. Something labeled 2 micron with a range of 1-3 will not be the weight average 1 micron. This value will be greater than 1 micron.

Re: School me on polishing

#20

answers?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I may have gotten lost/confused in your questions. Did the how diamonds are sized discussion answer them? Presumably the discussion explains why any product has a range of size and how a company can/will sell 0-2, 0-1, 0-0.5 etc. .

It should be added that the amount of the actual particle sizes in the range will be biased to the larger sizes. Something labeled 2 micron with a range of 1-3 will not be the weight average 1 micron. This value will be greater than 1 micron.

The "1 micron" I use is 0-1 micron. In fact the particles will mostly be near 1 micron. I am going to experiment with tightly graded 3 micron to see if I can skip the "fine" fixed diamond plate step.

Re: School me on polishing

#21

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When 1 micron diamond is referred to isn't it correct that it contains 0-2 micron diamonds

Yes, no , maybe. I do not know how consistent manufacturers labeling is. If a 2 micron fraction is recovered and the remains sold I can not predict how it would be labeled. So, you bring up an important point I missed. Knowing the range is more informative than the single number "average". The average reported is misleading, see discussion under the other "answers" heading.

It seems like with really fine stuff how tightly it's graded matters more and 2u would be quite a bit different than 1u at this level. Different yes. Quite a bit different? I don't know. A chisel ground with each possibility may be equivalent. I don't know.

Re: School me on polishing

#22

From a practical standpoint...

david weaver

...sometimes resolution is lost not in manufacture, but from the seller.

while we get focused on numbers (this brand's 0.5 micron vs. another brand's 0.5 micron), it's probably more practically useful just to try a few different things and understand that if you buy one of the $1 per syringe diamond sets on ebay, you might get lucky, you might get something mislabeled, or it may be low concentration.

When norton identifies 0.5 micron paste as 0-1 micron diamonds, personally, I see that as being pretty good and not at all dishonest. If someone is looking for absolute maximum particle size, then they'll need to pay to get that accuracy and maybe do some research, but a good practical test that is *Awfully* easy is just to get a one inch chisel, a piece of maple or a plane sole (unconditioned cast is -not news to you bill, but for others - a notoriously bad test bed, though, because the cast or mill marks can actually abrade steel and raise a wire edge) and work an edge up on one's normal media and then go to testing things.

It takes extremely little time to do something that gives a definitive feel and visual result in a light paring of softwood.

I would love to believe that I can create an edge in natural stones that betters all pastes and powders, but it isn't so. I can tell that just by the paring test, but also by the shaving test. Absolute sharpness isn't always the thing, so before one gets worked up about that, it's also a matter of getting what you want. On a razor, I want something that severs hair without any tactile notification of it, but that doesn't cut any skin propped up at the back of the pore of the hair being severed. I did my shift with blinding sharp razors, it satisfied curiosity, and now I have a couple of natural stones and a good linen and a good shell strop.

With paring chisels, geometry is at least as important as sharpness once you get to a point. not overcutting a facet on planes is also important. I like an oilstone edge for paring. The washita comes up just a tiny bit short, depending on which one I'm using and which chisel, but going to a tiny compound edge makes for a huge variation in cut resistance from a very thin cut to one that's more thick where wedging is causing the resistance instead of severing. it's easier to *not* overcut with an edge like I sent steve on a chisel even though there are several notches above that in sharpness.

Long story short, try some stuff, find what you like in use. The powder that I have labeled as #1 is at least as fine on cast as the sigma power #13000 stone, and that stone under the microscope is two orders of magnitude finer than a king 8000, and noticeably finer than a shapton 15k pro stone or 16k glasstone. The diamonds are more convenient to use than a soft waterstone, too.

The microscope makes for a lot less indecision about this stuff if you can't tell in use, but there's no real need for it if you can't tell in use.

Re: School me on polishing

#23

Care to recommend a reputable lapidary supplier?


Re: School me on polishing

#25

Re: check Norton abrasives

Wiley Horne

Don’t think either of us wants to go any further down the rabbit hole, however, both Ted Pella and Norton specify ranges, and I’ll leave it there.

I agree with your ‘practical suggestion’ below!

Wiley