Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Kanna blade sharpening issues

Posts

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#26

Re: The fine ones aren't too bad...

david weaver

I think the sharpening is either not done properly or it's incomplete.

I still have two of the shapton stones. I can't say that i use them because I just like the way washita and suita (could write a song about them) feel, and if necessary, stepping up to finer with another natural feels nicer than going to synthetic stones.

But I have to admit that with the 1 micron diamonds, when I did this last test and moved the diamonds from cast substrate to wood and spent the time actually making sure there were no defects on the edge, the diamonds did as well or better, and the shaving reflected a more uniform edge. That wears off pretty quickly.

The real trick with diamonds would be to put them into a substrate that's as gentle on the edge as an arkansas stone. For practical non-finish work, I didn't find the small flaws that the cast introduces (any contaminants that settle on the surface take a tiny nick out, understandably so) to amount to much trouble, they generally actually wore off of the steel.

Point being, if you had the shapton stones and liked the way they feel, you would have no problem getting a good stable edge out of them. Even most razors tolerate them well at 16-18 degrees. The problem at those events is that the people involved don't know how to assess whether or not their sharpening method is good because they're not you and they're not finish planing. If you come up with any shortcoming, you will address it immediately because it will bring your work to a halt.

I'm fairly sure 1 micron diamonds last longer on all of the blades that I sharpen, but I am so comfortable with the washita that I have (a little finer than the typical) that I know I can get a uniform edge with it every time, and I know contaminants are very easy to get off of it if they ever get on it. I don't know what level of coarseness diamonds become detrimental to a finished edge typically, but I'm sure it could be found. I've had many irons that tolerate a 10 micron diamond then polished by a finish stone of finish diamonds, but some that just won't.

When I find a defect on an iron and look under a microscope, there is usually some other evidence with it - like unrefined scratches that terminate into the defect (deep scratch yields to the edge next to the scratch also failing). When I did this test and forced myself to get a photo perfect edge, the bad behavior disappeared.

I do think carbon steel is the best at weathering small things in wood that cause defects, but the beech didn't result in many of them on any of the irons that I tested.

There is also a level of touch and control with natural stones that, in my opinion, is lost when abrasives are judged by speed. We can bias the edge finishing toward the edge of the iron a little bit with a natural stone, finish the edge and do very little changing of geometry. The race toward fast fine stones results in more work at the next sharpening, in my opinion.

At any rate, I have confidence that it would take you, at your skill level, less than a week to achieve perfection with shapton stones. It would be culture shock and first, and there's no real reason to do it, and they still aren't (in my opinion) any good for gouges, etc, so there's no practical reason for a shift. If anyone else is using shaptons and pondering a move to other stones to address quality issues, I'd imagine they have about a 2 in 100 chance of the issue being the stones, with the rest being technique or bad steel.

I have probably sold about a dozen bad razors. Unlike most sellers, I list them as bad and tell why. I expect a good razor to take an edge off of anything remotely close to ideal, and then keep it on linen and leather, and improve on both. When a razor only works by adding a layer of tape or two layers on the spine, I consider it supbar and the only option is to sell it at a huge discount (half or a quarter of the price). Almost every single time, I get "ha ha" messages from the buyers "jokes on you, i got it to sharpen fine". I'm guessing that I'm at a fraction of your level as far as sensibilities go, but the typical user of anything (knives, razors, tools, etc) is at a level way below because they don't think this kind of thing is interesting. Those buyers who think they've pulled one over on me will find limitations that I honestly disclosed, but I don't expect they'll ever admit it.

I could go on at length with sharpening things and why I think it's lie nielsen and their use of guides, etc, but I already get a lot of negative feedback and I like LN as a company. The things that they don't know well enough are a product of their audience, and maybe some internal advice.

(even the issues with cast are solvable - break the plate in, diligently wipe the surface of the plate off every time you're in the shop, even if it was covered - just to avoid the issues, and finish with a light touch. Stones are a lot more forgiving for that, and diamond on wood - which wastes diamonds - helps to alleviate some of the extreme sensitivity to contaminants. The tiny ones that make super tiny lines just get pushed into the wood instead of remaining on the surface taking tiny bites of the edge each time the iron rolls past them. )

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#27

Update 3 - the well-tempered blade

Winston

As I mentioned in another post, I tempered the blade in my oven at 340 F for about an hour. I put it in a cast iron pan and put a baking sheet on the rack above (to block any radiant heat), and used an IR thermometer to take temperature readings of the pan. I had set the oven to 360 degrees, but the temperature of the pan stabilized at 340, which I thought was a good temperature. I put the blade on the pan and let it sit in there for an hour or so. I took occasional temperature readings, which were all within a 5 degrees of 340. When I took it out of the oven, it had a faint golden hue.

So far, it seems like this has worked out as well as I could possibly have hoped.

I sharpened the blade on the Norton 1000, Shapton 5000, Shapton 12000 sequence, and this time it went without a hitch. It was just like sharpening any other blade. There were no chips from the 1000 stone to work out at the finer grits, so I only had to spend a around a minute on each of the finer stones.

People here seemed to like the previous pictures, so here are some of the sharpening sequence. I took a photo after each grit.


The post-12000 photo reveals that I could have spent more time on it, and there may have been some larger grit contamination. But I also think it looks more scratched than it really was due to the angle of the light. In any case, the resulting wood surface was once again glassy smooth, with no tracks.

This made me think, was all the stuff that happened before just in my head? Fortunately, I have the pictures to confirm that yes, it really was that bad before. If you look at the photos from my Update 2, you can see how much worse it was, and how long it took to improve the edge.

I decided to really press my luck and try using the Trend diamond 1000 plate before the 5000 and 12000 stones. Here's the result:


There were some edge defects that are clearly visible the post-5000 and -12000 photos, but only in one small region of the blade. (There are also some paper towel fibers in the post-12000 picture, which should be ignored.) The edge defects look small, but based on my previous experience, I think they would have left noticeable tracks in wood, especially if they crumbled and resulted in even larger defects.

I'm actually kind of glad that there was still a little chipping in this sharpening sequence, because it confirms that the phenomenon was and is real. Even though I have the chipped-blade pictures from before re-tempering the blade, it's still a little hard for me to believe that it really happened and was that bad. The fact that it still chips a little bit with the diamonds tells me that yes, the chipping is/was real, and also that I didn't overdo the tempering of the blade.

David said that he thought there was a 25% chance that the issue would be solvable. I think I may have lucked out. I haven't used the blade enough to get a good sense of how the edge will hold up, but in my limited testing so far, it seems good -- and, as I understand it, the mild tempering that I did should still result in hard steel (around 63 Rc according to David).

Thanks all for your ideas and feedback about how to deal with this blade!

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#28

Re: Update 3 - the well-tempered blade

Oskar

very nice. Congrats on a seemingly successful tempering! Hope the blade holds up for more use!

Great pics as well!

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#29

How old is your diamond plate

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a breaking in period for these plates where they start out exceptionally aggressive and eventually settle in to the grit they are suppose to be.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#30

Re: Update 3 - the well-tempered blade

David Weaver

That's about as good of an outcome as you can hope for. I don't know if I've seen anything that cool take tempering colors, but if 340/350 on your thermometer corresponds to 390/400 due to issues bill mentioned with laser thermometers, it's still going to be good.

I don't think there's a lot of virtue in a 65 hardness first japanese plane. A few points softer (suppose it's still 61/62) and it'll be easier to sharpen and not lose that much edge life (maybe 20 percent). IF it loses a little edge life, is twice as easy to sharpen and doesn't chip, you'll be far ahead. It'll still make an ultra bright finish and you don't have to resort to back bevels now.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#31

Re: How old is your diamond plate

Winston

There is a breaking in period for these plates where they start out exceptionally aggressive and eventually settle in to the grit they are suppose to be.

I've had this one for several months. It's actually the second one I've had. The first one was not quite flat -- with a good straightedge on it, I was able to fit a .05 mm (.002 inch) feeler gauge between the straightedge and plate. When I contacted Trend about it, they had me send it in and they sent back a new one.

It's definitely much less aggressive than it was in the beginning.