Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Kanna blade sharpening issues

Posts

Kanna blade sharpening issues

#1

Kanna blade sharpening issues

Winston

I recently acquired a Japanese plane, and I've been having some trouble getting the blade really sharp. This is my first kanna, and it's not a fancy one -- it's an Senkichi with a laminated blade.

The first thing I did with the blade was to flatten the back. This took a long time because the corners had a bit of lift to them. After tuning up the dai and making my first shavings, I noticed I wasn't getting anything near a smooth surface. When I took a look at the blade's edge with a 30x loupe, I could see that it was chipped and ragged.

The blade came with a 25-degree bevel angle, so I worked on increasing it to 30 degrees. (The bedding angle of the dai is 40 degrees.) After going through many rounds sharpening and making shavings, I found that even with the 30 degree bevel, I had a really hard time avoiding a chipped edge and plane tracks. Maybe one out of four sharpenings I was able to get a pristine, track-free surface, but when I did, it was beautiful. It's been frustrating because I've been able to get great results, just not consistently. (In my testing, in the best case, I've been able to get about full-width shavings from a pine 2x4 that are approximately .0008 inches thick, and not-quite-full-width shavings that are .0005 inch. My micrometer only has markings for .001 inch, so those values are estimates. Not that I'm trying to get ultra-fine shavings normally, but this is a way for me to test whether I'm doing a good job sharpening the blade.)

The sequence of stones I've been using for sharpening is: 1000-grit Trend diamond plate, 5000-grit Shapton pro, then 12000-grit Shapton pro. I usually only work the bevel side until the finest stone; my last step is to work the back, and I usually don't go back and forth between the sides. I've been using an Eclipse-style honing guide (don't judge me!) because I've been working on increasing the bevel angle from 25 to 30 degrees, and I don't yet have a large enough 30-degree bevel to do it freehand.

In my most recent time sharpening, I realized that I've been having a hard time raising a burr on this blade with the 1000-grit diamond plate. When I took a look at the back of the blade through the loupe after the 1000-grit plate, I saw that the edge was chipped and there was no burr (or at least not one that I could see or feel).

My theory is that the steel is much harder than the blades I'm accustomed to, and the fixed diamonds end up fracturing the steel. Is this something that anyone else has experienced with Japanese blades?

I then switched to a 1000-grit Norton waterstone, and with that stone I was able to raise a burr. My theory is that the loose grit rolling around can't fracture the steel the same way that the fixed diamonds do. Then I moved on to 5000-grit Shapton. After working the bevel side for a while, I could see and feel that the burr on the back was much smaller. However, there was also a tiny dip on the back just before the burr. (This is sort of like there was a back bevel.)

After working the bevel side on to the 12000-grit Shapton, the burr was pretty much gone, but the dip/"back bevel" was still there. Now, I've always worked the back of this blade flat -- I've never tried to add any sort of back bevel on it, and I flatten my stones often. With this mini back bevel, when I work the back of the blade on the flat stone, it doesn't quite reach the cutting edge, which prevents it from getting really, really sharp.

At first I thought that maybe the blade just had a slight convexity at the edge, and that honing the bevel a bit more would make the "back bevel" go away. But no matter how much I work the bevel side, the "back bevel" is always there.

Does anyone know if the "back bevel" has something to do with the steel in this blade? Or is it something else? I'm not sure, but I think I may have seen this on other blades, but it seems more pronounced with this blade. With the Eclipse guide, the blade only moves back and forth. Is it possible that on the forward stroke, the slurry in front of the edge is abrading the steel, causing the "back bevel"?

If anyone can help enlighten me about why these things are happening and how to deal with them, I'd appreciate it.

Here's a picture of the blade after the 1000-grit Norton and 5000-grit Shapton. There's still a small burr, but the angle of the reflection indicates that there's also a back bevel.


img

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#2

Update

Winston

After using the plane for a bit, I started getting some tracks, so I sharpened it again. I sharpened it three more times, and no matter what I did, I could not prevent the edge from chipping in the process. Two of the times I used the Eclipse-style honing guide and the other time I freehanded it, since the 30-degree bevel is big enough now to do reference off of it.

Does this mean that the steel is over-hardened?

Here's a close-up picture after I sharpened it to 12000 and then planed about 3 feet of pine. This time it left horrible tracks. It's possible that this time when I sharpened it, I moved through the grits more quickly than I should have, but even so, I've never had another blade that behaved like this one.


img

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#3

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can't help with the sharpening issue. You have remarkable pictures. How are you making them?

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#4

Re: Update

david weaver

I'd use the term hard tempered, but the same behavior isn't always due to hard tempering. Sometimes it's just due to a blade not being that great (and it's not always price related, either).

I think early on in learning a plane's behavior, even though it's not purist stuff, you're better off with a primary at 25 and then a secondary at 29 or 30 or so. Then, if the edge doesn't hold up, add a couple of degrees of *tiny* back bevel since you're not really afforded any greater angle on the bevel side due to clearance.

If the first stroke has chipping and lines, then there's a chipping during sharpening issue (either due to routine or something on a stone that's marking up the edge - the latter can be ruled out of you're sharpening something else on the stone at the same time without issue). If the chipping occurs during planing but not right away and continues to do so at 30 degrees total and above, it's probably just the quality of the iron.

Sharpening full bevel while you're figuring out the personality of the iron is fairly difficult. Freehanding japanese planes, I do all of my sharpening full bevel, but bias the final stone work only to be working the edge (rolling pressure up toward the edge a little bit).

If I was already at 29 or so, I may add a degree or two, you're limiting clearance a little bit but it would be easier at this point. I wouldn't use a japanese plane with 32 or so degrees of bevel angle on a regular basis, though - it will be out of clearance very quickly and never really have the strong pull in to the cut.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#5

Re: Update

Winston

For this particular blade, I have sometimes been able to get a clean edge, and when I have, it's lasted for a surprisingly long time without defects. This is subjective -- I don't have any numbers for it, but it seemed like I was getting a very smooth surface for about as long as the best of my other blades. The problem is that I can't seem to get that edge consistently.

This blade behaves so differently from all the other plane blades that I have (which include A2, O1, PM-V11, Tsunesaburo blue steel, and stock Stanley) and I just can't figure out how to make it happy. With the most recent sharpening of this blade, I probably didn't spend enough time on the finer stones, and the result was disastrous chipping, which you could see in the previous photo. When I sharpen other blades with this same progression (1000 diamond, 5000 Shapton, 12000 Shapton), even I don't spend enough time on the finer stones, the blade still cuts fine without big defects. I just don't get quite as nice a surface as I otherwise would.

Thanks for the advice about the bevel angle. Since I'm working and reworking this blade anyway, I might move the main bevel angle to be a couple of degrees shallower.

I'm thinking of tempering the blade in my oven. I've never done it before but it seems like I don't have much to lose at this point.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#6

Re: Update

david weaver

I have had chisels before that are hard tempered and hold up fine as long as the coarse work isn't done with an aggressive stone. That's sort of a double conundrum with a chisel like that because if there is damage, an aggressive stone is the only thing that will cut it quickly, and a mild stone is the only thing that won't lead to a crumbling edge.

The japanese refer to the very hard tempered tools as "not suitable for beginners" for obvious reasons. When they get too far out of balance, I consider them not really suitable for anyone.

I'd resort to a secondary bevel to allow use of a more easy going routine or more time on the finish stone with that before tempering it. Tempering may fix it if it's a pure hardness issue, but it may not if it's not. For actually getting work done, irons and chisels with that temperament are difficult to live with and will have you walking on egshells.

In the long term, i'd back it off to a 25 degree flat primary (I recognize it will take you eons to get it back to that by hand) and a 30 degree secondary. if the failure occurs just at the very edge and continues to do so, the tiniest of microbevels will let you experiment to push the failure further up the bevel (in the hope that rather than that, it just won't occur) without having to do much more work.

I think this concept is valuable (being able to manipulate where the failure occurs if an edge isn't behaving well), but probably underused in woodworking. Sometimes, if the temperament is easily solved, the result can be a hard and long wearing iron that's easy to refresh if it doesn't take damage.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#7

Re: Question

Winston

Thanks Bill. The first photo, of the edge reflection, I just took with my iPhone. For the second picture, the close-up of the edge, I used a Sony A7III and a 90mm macro lens at maximum magnification. And of course, good light!

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#8

Re: Update

Wiley Horne

Hi Winston,

The only suggestion I have is to never use that 1000 fixed diamond on the bevel of Japanese steel. Even on the back, I would suggest only working sideways, not straight ahead.

Wish I could help solve this, it’s perplexing. Best wishes,

Wiley

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#9

Re: Update

Winston

The good thing about going to a lower bevel angle is that most of the material to remove is the soft iron. I'll probably use 120 grit sandpaper for that.

Once I get to the cutting edge, I'm going to try using the Norton 1000 only, instead of the diamond plate. Then I'll also make sure to spend more time on the 5000 and 12000 stones.

If I'm not able to consistently get a good edge with that, I'll try tempering the blade in my oven.

When I got this plane, I didn't set out to learn about how various steels and sharpening media interact, but here I am.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#10

Re: Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Getting the magnification is trivial. Getting lighting that shows resolution of shiny surfaces is not trivial. Again impressive PICS

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#11

Any other media available

Jim Matthews

I'm curious what sort of results might arise from other sharpening media?

Do you have oil stones, or waterstones on hand?

It's my 'SWAG' that tool steel formulations arose in conjunction with contemporary sharpening approaches. This is what makes Japanese blades so expensive:

waterstones are necessary for best results.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#12

Re: Any other media available

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I very much agree. If you want to get the most from a fine Japanese tool, use the media that was used when the tool was developed, not some harsh modern abrasive that was not developed with fine tools in mind.

Likewise, if you want to get the most out of traditional European tools, use oil stones for finishing. That is the what was used for centuries while these tools were being developed.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#13

Update 2 - sharpening only on waterstones

Winston

I sharpened it again, this time using the Norton 1000, Shapton 5000, and Shapton 12000.

I spent several minutes on the Norton 1000 using relatively light pressure and honed away much of the edge chipping, but some of it persisted. After close to 5 minutes on the stone, it didn't look like the chipping was getting any better, so I can only guess that some of the chipping was caused by the stone.

Then I spent about 18 minutes on the Shapton 5000 trying to get rid of all the chips from the previous stage. Finally, I did about 5 minutes on the 12000 stone.

This is much, much more time than I would like to spend sharpening a blade, but it seemed to be necessary to work out the edge chips.

The mysterious back bevel was there again, and larger than before. My theory is that the back and forth motion (from using the honing guide) causes the slurry in front of the leading edge to wear away the metal, and since I spent so much time on the stones, it resulted in more material removed.

Finally, I stropped it 5 times on each side with light pressure on a bare leather strop.

After all that work, I was able to take very fine shavings, and a lot of them. (Incidentally, I was planing against the grain and didn't even realize it because I was getting a good surface. It was only after I tried taking a deeper cut and got tearout that I realized my error.) The edge has held up well, although planing straight-grained pine is admittedly easy work. In one of the photos below, you'll see one of the thin shavings I took. It has a split running down its length, which was caused by an edge defect -- one that I missed and was there even after all that work! On the wood, I could see and feel the raised track left by the defect. Looking back at the photos, I can see there's a tiny chip toward the left side of the blade that remained at the end.

So the performance of the blade after all that work is good (in my limited testing), other than the chip that remained. Hopefully I'll figure out a way to sharpen it more efficiently -- spending almost 30 minutes on a single blade is just not realistic. I also still have to see how it behaves under more difficult conditions, like if it hits a knot. If it's chippy and remains difficult to sharpen, I may attempt to re-temper the blade.

Here are pictures of the blade edge as I sharpened it:


The mysterious back bevel:


A fine shaving, with a split caused by the edge defect:


Finally, here's a picture from the prior sharpening (using the diamond 1000), where the edge was badly chipped. I wasn't exaggerating when I said there were horrible tracks:


Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#14

no knots...

david weaver

judging by the shaving, the edge is in very good shape. See how it holds up, and keep it away from knots.

While it's nice to see how a blade performs, if it's temperamental, you could be punished with more long sharpening sessions.

if it shows a little bit of chippiness but starts well and gradually develops it, a slight back bevel is still a good option.

Once it's in good shape like that, it's much easier to keep in good shape and you may wish to sharpen often to keep it like that.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#15

Re: Update 2 - sharpening only on waterstones

Wiley Horne

Hi Winston,

You’re ready to work! Thanks for sharing, the photos of sharpening progression are great.

Wiley

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#16

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

TomD

I have a gagilion stones, though 1/10th of a gagilion compared to David, though I am not sure that is a handicap. My go to stones are pretty similar to what I started with, two 800 kings; a 1500 something, maybe a lobster; the two king finishing stones. You can get far finer shavings than there is any purpose to, using that combo. You can read the writing, in the mirror surface of the wood, in an overhead lightbulb.

The blade I use the most, and the only one I have worn out 2 dais with and reduced the length to any degree, cost me 13.50 Canadian around 1980. That was cheap then. It's a great blade.

I would say the back of your blade is not that smooth, but nothing to explain the results you are getting. With my earliest blades, I did the whole SC grit on iron drill. Pretty miserable. But you do get a very flat and extremely polished surface. Some say it is too polished. I always prefer to finish the prep with a scratch pattern perp to the blade. Just makes sense to me, but then again, it would not explain the trouble you are having.

One of the few justification for using Japanese blades overall, is they mesh so well with the right Japanese stones. I don't particularly like using diamond on them. Though I will admit that back when I bought most of my diamond stones the swarf may have been harder than the bond on the stones, and certainly the mud from stones was harder. I never hear people complain about that these days, so presumably it is a non-issue.

If it were my blade, and I have never had a crumbly Japanese blade, but if I did. I would probably (short of returning it, never a good option up here) dry grind it to get back from the potentially brittleness of the edge. I dip blades in water, and grind till the water evaporates, and repeat. You will never burn an edge if you follow that routine. The water is not to cool the edge, but to reveal when you hit nearly 200 F. Way below the tempering level. I never dry grind Japanese chisels in normal use, but stuff happens like the time workmen came to remove the oil tank, and used an Ouchi chisel like a cold chisel. That took a lot of repair. Prior to that I had taken nicks out with the 600 carbo stone, but even back then I didn't have the patience to repair that level of damage by hand.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#17

No Disadvantage...

david weaver

If you have a couple of reliable stones, then having enough to make up for shortcomings in chisels, razors, planes, etc, just leads to using a plane that's probably better set aside.

I see this on the razor forums all the time - spending a lot of time trying to figure out how to prevent edge failure on a razor that's expensive but marginal. It's better just to find a good razor. Good ones seem to get sharp off of everything and don't take much extra care.

Same with good plane irons, though we don't know yet whether or not the failure was just due to harsh diamond treatment (if it was, then it's not necessarily a bad iron).

I've done the heavy work on setting up a new iron with diamonds before and had them settle in pretty quickly. I never kept any of the chippy tools and used them any significant amount, so I don't have a story of redemption where a chippy blade became something great.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#18

Re: Update 2 - sharpening only on waterstones

Jim Matthews

That's a finer shaving than I can manage.

If you can easily adjust the blade (for depth) without disassembly, you're good.

Kudos

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#19

Edge chipping, again.

Winston

That's probably the finest shaving I've ever gotten. :)

Unfortunately, when I sharpened it again with 1000-5000-12000 waterstones to get rid of the small nick in the blade, I ended up with an edge that no longer left a glassy-smooth surface. There were some small tracks in the wood, and when I took a close look at the blade, I saw that there were tiny chips in it again. It's really confounding to sharpen a blade only to end up with a worse edge!

I spent probably 5 minutes on the 5000 stone, which, judging by the photos, is crucial for getting rid of chipping from the previous stone. And it looks like that wasn't long enough.

I'm not patient enough to have to spend that much time sharpening this blade, and it's not a fancy one (I spent less than $50 for the plane), so I decided to try tempering it in the oven.

I put it on a cast iron pan in the oven and it got up to 340 F, as measured by an IR thermometer, and I left it in there for about an hour. This is totally new to me so hopefully I'm doing it right. When I have time I'll sharpen the blade again and test it out. Other than the sharpening issue, I'm really enjoying using the plane, so I hope I'll be able to find a way to sharpen it efficiently.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#20

Re: Edge chipping, again.

david weaver

340 should do it. If you go up to temperatures much higher, it may improve behavior, but it'll be as soft as western tools (that's really not that big of a problem, especially if behavior improves).

Putting it in the oven is all you have to do. Half hour should do, hour is probably even better on a thick iron.

I have never kept a plane with that kind of behavior, but I do have an iron that is so hard that I've never fully prepared it. Vintage type, and it should get the same treatment.

My experience with other tools is that bad behavior at high hardness often leads to still less than perfect behavior at lower hardness.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#21

Re: Edge chipping, again.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think I would try a different kind of sharpening stone, or at least finishing stone. These Shapton stones are rather harsh. I have trouble imagining a serious woodworker using them.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#22

Re: Edge chipping, again.

Winston

Thanks, it's good to hear that what I did should be OK. I'll see how it behaves, and if I still have trouble with it, I may try baking it again at a higher temperature. What would be a good next temperature to try? 25 degrees more, 50, or something else?

You've referred to temperamental blades and ones with bad behavior. Do you know what causes a piece of steel to be that way?

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#23

The fine ones aren't too bad...

david weaver

I never noticed any edge life lost if the finish stone was used properly. They are strong cutting, but the particle size in the finer stones are very small and nothing detrimental ever occurred with any of the tools I used with them (including japanese tools).

When japanese irons tend toward 64-66 hardness and are truly at that level, they can be trouble even for good natural stones.

It's relatively common now in japan to work all the way through synthetic stones and then make a lateral move to a natural stone or two (some of the sharpening procedures are arduous).

the first stones in most kits in japan are carborundum, and the damage to a temperamental blade usually occurs there and is brought out by later stones. The 1k shapton is about as harsh (similar fineness) as a king 800, just a harder binder.

It's possible to sharpen razors on the 12/15k shapton stones without issue, too, but they do expose temperamental razors. The solution there is often the same - increase angle slightly (with tape on the spine). I ditch the razor in that case or sell it as temperamental, but there are plenty of people doing that with good effect.

My experience in testing irons on this go-around leads me to believe that 1 micron abrasive edges or smaller (even if they are diamond) will outlast natural stones, that most of the edge defects using them are due to the substrate. I still like natural stones and will continue to finish irons with the washita (for the XHP) and if carbon steel, with another finer natural stone, but I can't claim that I saw any issue with 1 micron diamonds.

Long story short, I recognize what's happening with winston's iron - I'd give him about a 25% chance of the issue being solvable with stones or reduced hardness or both.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#24

Re: Edge chipping, again.

david weaver

I wouldn't go much above the 340. If it's white 2 or yellow steel (the two most likely in a blade in the lower price ranges), it'll probably be 63 hardness at 340.

Hitachi's tempering charts for white 2 show 217C equating to an ideal (if all other work was done as well as possible) hardness of 60 Rc. that's 32+(9/5)*217 = about 423 degrees F.

I'd not go further than that, and 60 is even a push because it's simple steel and will dull quickly at the sharpness levels you're looking at (as in, sharpness that would be OK in a western tool on harder wood isn't going to be enough for you, so you're operating in a narrower range).

375 and then to back beveling slightly is where I would go next if 340 doesn't work (375 in an oven will definitely result in some spots of the oven being 400 degrees).

The back bevel doesn't need to be large, it just needs to be larger than the length that the chipout is occurring.

In my opinion, if 375 doesn't solve the issue, the issue was present either in the parent steel or in the handling of the steel between manufacture and final temper. As in, nothing you can do about it.

I've tried various things over the years, hammering crappy chisels into knives to see if the hammering would help, and if it does, it's not enough to make them "good".

Tempering information is here:

http://www.hitachi-metals.co.jp/pdf/cat/hy-b10-d.pdf

Page five, item #2 in the table is white 2. Item 5 is yellow 2. I can't read japanese other than a few kanji that show up on stones, but specification of the alloys makes it easy to recognize white 1 and yellow 1.

The next steel down with a 2 beside it is blue 2. Not sure what the stainless steels are as we don't see them in tools. They could be VG10 or something like that - i'm sure they're intended for knives and kitchen equipment.

Re: Kanna blade sharpening issues

#25

Re: The fine ones aren't too bad...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have seen a lot of different planes at hand tool events sharpened with 16000 Shapton stones. All produced less than stellar surfaces. Perhaps there was something not proper about the way the stones were used.

Years ago someone on this forum advocated a test for sharpness. Bill Tindall said his tools failed the test, but it likely did not matter because that level of sharpness would be gone in ten feet (other times he has mentioned four feet). He dared others to prove him wrong.

I tried this and using the test, it seemed that my iron was sharper at 48 feet than his was at zero feet. That if I planed a set of drawer fronts just prior to finishing the whole operation would be done with sharper iron than he could produce.

It is hard to measure the degree that skill plays into this stuff. Whether diamonds

or water stones or oil stones, a skillful worker will get more out of his stones.