Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

Posts

Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#1

Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

david weaver

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/md/read/id/469361/sbj/the-veritas-shooting-plane-reviewed/

Can you believe....6 years. Almost 6 years to the date since derek released this review. Look at the nugget of a comment in the review - twice as long as A2, and then I'm not quite able to interpret the comment about O1.

It was easier to pass over this fact at the time because the testing was done on end grain and the plane itself was a distraction (and having bought one while making shootenstein, it was a dandy plane).

I can hardly believe the V11 irons have been out 6 years and it's taken this long for someone to plane a few tens of thousands of feet and really get the detailed dope on it.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#2

ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On the basis of David's research I concluded that the 2X longer edge life for the kind of work I do with a plane is worth the exchange cost. Hock 0-1 blades will be appearing soon on the after market.

I don't understand marketing, but I find it fascinating to watch. Unlike the knife makers, LV chose to make the metal a secret. Why the difference? Then they chose to make claims based on testing that seemed remote from normal use of a plane. Why didn't they plane wood? And the claims didn't make sense- longer edge life but sharpens easily. How can that be?

I think I must be some 3 sigma tail of customer. Marketing usually misses the mark with me. When I had relevant edge life data and an explanation of the edge life-sharpening quandary then I became a customer. Too bad but a sliver of the potential market will ever see these data.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#3

Re: ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

David Weaver

I made two more of XHP the last two days. Now all of the metal planes that I use except for infills (which I don't use often) have XHP irons. OF course, the cost making the XHP irons is almost the same as having LV's irons.

I've got one more to make for a plane that I don't use often (an older Record 8) and then I'll still have enough stock to make nine more irons.

One of the reasons that I never got many of the irons was because I didn't know what they were. Also, made the mistake of relying on what I thought was occurring for edge life, but that was stunted by comparing performance in end grain as well as two unlike planes.

It's not as easy to make irons out of XHP as O1, but it's not that bad now with a few under my belt. They do stay flatter, even in an oil quench. Which is good, because flattening the back of one is a little greasy feeling.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#4

Re: ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

Wiley Horne

I ordered a couple weeks ago, and will do more if they make an infill-ready iron.

I think David’s initial skepticism (maybe even bias :) ) is what made his results so convincing.

Wiley

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#5

Re: ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I ordered a couple weeks ago, and will do more if they make an infill-ready iron.

I think David’s initial skepticism (maybe even bias :) ) is what made his results so convincing.

Wiley

And my involvement with Lee Valley is understandably why there was some disbelieve when I posted my assessment results several years ago (and have continued to repeat them in the years since). It is good to have a second opinion (especially when it bears out one's own! :D ).

Keep in mind that the blades from Veritas are also prepared in a manner which David's efforts simply cannot replicate: they have backs which are flat, flat, flat. Only wipe the backs with your finest stone. Veritas prepare them to 4000 grit (their minimal estimate).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#6

What made David's results so convicing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most important, the data set was internally and externally consistent. The data didn't disagree with results from related experiments done by LV, Kees and Derek. And the data from David's various experiments didn't disagree with one another. Recall the kerfuffle a while back when I criticized the hardness research published by someone I don't remember. It was internally and externally inconsistent, a red flag for unreliable results.

The data was collected with a relevant experiment, with a well planed experimental design, whose details were revealed.....FINALLY. David planed wood used to make furniture under conditions commonly used to plane wood, with important variables randomized. The problem I have with Derek's results from most of what he does is the question of whether results on wood whose properties are unfamiliar to me will translate to the hardwoods 99+% of the world uses for furniture. I don't work wood that is abrasive and/or exceptionally hard. Tools and techniques for such wood may not be relevant to what I do.

We now have an explanation for the seemingly contradictory claim of sharpens easily, yet has long edge life. These are know properties of particle steel.

Icing on the cake is David's credibility. It is normal to begin experiments with a hypothesis. The sign of a credible researcher is the quick adaptation of the hypothesis to the data.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#7

Re: ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

david weaver

I throw the warp in for free!

Actually, I bias mine toward the flat side so that they'll be a little tiny bit hollow in their length (it only takes precutting a partial bevel to do that) and then flatten the backs reasonably well before sending them out. There's about 5 minutes of flattening work in XHP.

LV's system is trick, though. V11's abrasion resistance would make it a bugger for beginners if it wasn't flat.

The bigger gain for me isn't in flattening, but in the quality of the ground stock from carpenter. It's as good as anything I've ever seen, and the good stability of the steel makes it easy to work with.

Hand made irons will never be confused for machine made and flattened irons, though, but the price is good ($0 with free shipping promotion).

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#8

Re: What made David's results so convicing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I tried one of David's experiments with a 1915 plane iron. I did the cherry end grain experiment, even going so far as to use the same width board a David (a lot of wear occurs at the very beginning of the stroke). I did 801 feet before losing interest, more than David did for either iron. This kind of work is not only boring, but is hard on the body, which is something we try to be sensitive to so we can work the next day also. It is more efficient to sharpen more often. Results beyond the point where we would sharpen are not very significant.

I tried to duplicate Derek's chisel experiments some years ago. My 19th century chisels out performed all of his selections by a lot, even in jarrah. (A note about jarrah: Derek told us on this forum that we could not plane jarrah with a Stanley plane. Jarrah was so hyped up on this forum that even people who never saw jarrah were telling me I could not plane jarrah. In fact it is trivial.)

Finally, I have to say that there is something odd about a guy who spends months making a corner cupboard and cannot find a minute and a half to sharpen a plane iron. Something not quite rational there.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#9

Two times...

david weaver

While it is the case that nothing about these irons will really change someones' productivity over any other iron, especially when you compare things that do really contribute to productivity (good technique using a plane, not doing work that doesn't need to be done, learning to sharpen well and quickly), it is definitely the case that they do both of the following:

* work at the same level of sharpness, or higher, with less planing resistance even than carbon steel

* whatever carbon steel does for sharpness or surface brightness, these will do it twice as long, but also with better brightness for the same period of use

The grinding is more difficult with them. That's the only downside that I can see, but for those of us who power grind, it's not really an issue. They also have low sensitivity to being ground over temperature vs. carbon steels or anything else that's not high speed steel (if they get 400 degrees over-temper in grinding, which should never happen in the first place, they will still be as hard as a typical carbon steel iron).

Testing to failure in a certain mode isn't intended to suggest to someone else that they should plane to failure, it just takes out the subjectivity of certain things (for example, brent beach would plane until he got a certain wear bevel, measure the length and make a few comments. But it didn't really tell someone reading whether or not the irons were on even footing at the stopping points).

Planing end grain to see where the irons would fail was miserable. Even through that, the sharpness and planing resistance from XHP/V11 was lower. It is the first demonstrably better smoothing plane steel that I've seen (when compared to water hardening and oil hardening older steels).

As far as chisels go, I'm not looking for anything in the world of chisels, so I'm not going to be exposed to V11 and XHP is available to me in .094" or .094". Like the Model T in black. If anything betters japanese white steel chisels in hammering, I'd be surprised, but chisels are so fast to sharpen that it doesn't really matter.

I wasn't expecting to replace any of my irons, either, but the reduction in physical effort is something I couldn't really ignore after doing the testing. Cost to replace irons in planes isn't negligible, though, and i probably wouldn't have done it if I wasn't making my own irons (which is more for self indulgence and satisfaction of curiosity in making tools). I'd figure my cost without time after accounting for files and gas is probably $35-$40 an iron - less than I typically pay for a ward parallel iron but more than anything else. Point being, i don't think anyone is going to come along and make them for less than LV does when you can get free shipping on them.

The fact that they do everything so far (barring a comment I made last week about needing to confirm that the uniformity of the edge competes with carbon steel except for the fact that the surface brightness increase from XHP makes it harder to hide pretty much anything) as well or better than carbon steel and for twice as long, if it's a user's principle to plane to a certain level of dullness that is not many feet vs. a full loss of clearance, it's still twice as long. My cycle time with them now is the same as carbon steel, too. Stropping isn't necessary with alternating back and forth strokes on the finishing stone. Initial concern about the toughness of the wire edge is mitigated with experience in finding an easy way that it comes off uniformly.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#10

If it becomes available in .125 or .140

david weaver

It will replace a couple of my infill plane irons. the spec sheet for XHP says it's available from .103 to .250 or something of that sort in sheets as big as 12 inches wide and 48 long.

6x36 is big enough to make 10 irons of any size for any stanley planes, more if some of the irons are less than 2 inches, of course. It also leaves a center piece for me to make a knife, but the cost is $340 with tax, so it's not insignificant from the point of view of someone like me who will buy stock, make a few irons and then set the stock aside.

Personally (and this is just a thing of mine), irons will get surface rust here and there in my shop, unless they're kept over in my dry and heated and cooled basement. I'd rather save the Ward irons for future users (there will always be a demand for them since they were stock on norris and spiers planes) and put them somewhere that they won't rust.

So, if stock shows up on SB steel's page and is ground and finished like the .094" finished material, but .125-.140, I will buy it and make a few irons, and maybe take the opportunity to make the aesthetics a little bit more interesting. I never remember anything, but i'm afraid if I send them a request right now, they may have the stock on hand, but at a price that I don't feel like paying at the moment. Knife blank resellers buy the stock, and cut it into smaller blanks (and then mark it up accordingly), but the thicker stock is in blanks too narrow to make infill irons - and generally out of stock, too.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#12

Re: ordered Lee Valley PM V11 blades today

Wiley Horne

Hello Derek,

You have documented a body of work for the ages, with such point by point photos and commentary as to leave no doubt as to what was done and the objectivity of your findings. I should not have overlooked all this when making my comment about David’s freeform approach. Bill T’s post gives a fleshed-out summary of the bigger picture.

You mentioned Lee Valley’s quality control, particularly the flatness. I thought I would add my personal impressions to this fact....what’s it like to open the mail and find a PMV11 iron inside?

You have in your hand a rugged and purpose-built protective container which is an exact fit to the iron sealed inside. It’s not generic—there has to be a different sized container for each different width of iron. Here’s mine:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48705977301/in/dateposted-public/

The photo shows a very interesting technical paper packed with the blade (along with a moisture-absorbing chip). This paper explains the blade’s smoothness, flatness, and it’s matte-gray finish.

LV defines a smoothness specification, and the iron is lapped smooth to 5 millionths of an inch, such that no further polishing (to make it bright)makes sense. The iron is flat to 5-ten-thousandths (5 ‘tenths’). You can make out the matte-gray finish here:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48677512666/in/album-72157710681177492/

Only the final 1/8” of blade is polished. It comes out of the container working sharp. Nevertheless, I wanted to have the pleasure of hollow-grinding and honing this remarkable iron.

Overall, everything about this Made in Canada iron bespeaks quality and attention to every detail, from its packaging, to the technical note packed with it which explains the smoothness, flatness, and finish; right down to the moisture absorbing treated wood square inside the container. My impression is that the price is more than fair, for what Rob and company have put into this product.

Wiley.......noting that today is the last free-shipping day in this cycle

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#13

Amen on all points and a rant

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They know how to make stuff that moves woodworking out of the dark ages to make us better woodworkers. Now if they would just put some efforts toward making a screw driver suitable for driving brass hinge and latch sized screws under practical conditions.

It would have a round handle that could be turned with one hand while the other supported what was being hinged or latched. It would have a tight fit parallel sided blade sized for hinge, catch and lock screws- 3, 4, 6. It would not need construction and ergonomics capable of sheering #8 steel screws, only enough to drive brass screws. In fact the shaft could be designed to shear before a brass screw shank ;) .

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#14

This would seem..

david weaver

..to be something relatively easy to make out of drill rod. What am I missing? Buy drill rod, file to desired shape, heat, quench, temper, roll a burr on the blade if helpful for grip, and install a handle?

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#15

Couldn't resist...

david weaver

I sent the wholesaler for XHP a customer service email to see if they had any ground stock floating around in unlisted places.

If I can get a hold of some, I'll just pay the price and do like I've done with the stanley irons - make a few.

I doubt I'll have any luck, but refusing to ask in the first place is a good way to make sure I have no luck.

If I can get some, I'll be browsing old headstones (no kidding, old headstones often have great simple designs that look nice on the top of a plane iron) to see if the infill irons can be a little bit more stylish than the round top stanley irons.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#16

Re: wood-database-how do I use it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Check my memory....David planed for hundreds of feet of end grain on a wood whose properties are to be found in typical "furniture" wood. You planed a few 10's of passes on a 6" board to failure.

1. I am skeptical I could look in the wood data base predict this difference.

2. If my recollection of this comparison is about correct, these two species are in a different woodworking universe. I am therefore skeptical that testing on one will have any predictive information on the other. The data is no more relevant than LV testing MDF.

Maybe you test these unknown to the western world species because they are relevant to woodworkers in your area. The US exports hardwood lumber throughout the world. It will be easier for most to interpret results of testing techniques and tools if testing is done on stuff most people use.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#17

Re: wood-database-how do I use it

david weaver

Wood database can sometimes have cut and pasted comments across a lot of woods.

I'm sure Jarrah isn't something one would want to work up by hand, but the commentary makes it sound like it's not as abusive as some other similar hardness woods like some of the hickories or locust. Locust is very variable (I've seen turners use it, but i've never seen anyone working it by hand. One of my mothers' friends tried to give me some logs that had been saved to turn, but they were nasty nasty stuff.

Beech and hard maple are also close to each other on there but not similar when hand tooling, even with wood that doesn't have damaging stuff in it. Beech planes longer and the shaving has a different quality (less friction, more pillowy, whereas the maple is very smooth and strong - seemingly a lot of friction).

It just struck me as a not much time power tool user that maple was one of the woods that always seemed to have trouble burning if you didn't clear your head and get it through the power tools quickly, too. you can really feel that with the hand tools if you're planing something else.

Worth trying with it in terms of tensile strength and smoothness is getting a bunch of shavings, stretching them out and trying to tear them. Compare the same thing to a similar weight of shavings from oak or beech. They are extremely strong.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#18

the part I am missing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

heat, quench, temper



I made some from drill rod but never got them heat treated.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#19

Re: the part I am missing

david weaver

That will allow good shaft stiffness (for good feel) and tempering the end of the screwdriver to hold a good sharp burr so that the screwdriver stays in place easier.

I'm assuming these are slotted screws.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#20

consider gunsmith screwdrivers

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

Here’s a no-regret buy for you—gunsmith screwdrivers. Maybe you already have them, unless you’re going after those deer with bow and arrow. They don’t even have to be a perfect fit to get a bite. Buy the solution—don' make it, is my opinion.

The other thing about actual brass screws (as opposed to yellow-plated steel ones). And this comes from the unimpeachable source of Wm. Duffield.... I know you know this, but perhaps for someone else: always pilot full length with a steel screw of the same size, and then wax the brass screw, and let it follow the path made by the steel screw.

Wiley

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#21

Re: the part I am missing

William Duffield

I can't help you with the shear strength problem, but if you use drill blanks instead of drill rod, they come already hardened. The ones I use are M2 HSS, so they are stainless, and you can grind them to shape with whatever wheel you have laying around gathering dust. I used to get them from Enco, but when they acquired MSC, they liked their prices better, and turned off the Enco name.

https://www.mscdirect.com/browse/Holemaking/Drilling-Drill-Bits/Drill-Blanks-Sets?navid=12106172

They carry them in 64ths, metric, letter and number sizes, made in USA and imported, individual blanks and sets, but none of that is important for your application.

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#22

SB Steel?

William Duffield

I'm confused. I asked Google to tell me a little more about SB Steel. On the first page of search results, I got the following URLs:

sb-specialty-metals.com

sbisteel.com

sbsteel.ch

sbsteelsmtlab.com

sbmetal.com

and companies selling steel watches, angle brackets, and truck beds. :D

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#23

Re: SB Steel?

David Weaver

Top one. After googling around for a while, it's the only place that has XHP in quantity. Anyone else who has a basket that's out of stock appears to be getting the steel in sheets from there and cutting it or possibly having it cut.

http://sb-specialty-metals.com/shop/

I could be wrong, but I've made two small orders from them and they came fast and in perfect shape.

Not cheap, though!!

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#24

Funny Anecdote

William Duffield

A few years ago, I was sitting with Warren in the DeWitt Wallace museum's cafeteria, discussing distantly related subjects. Out of the blue I asked him, "Where did you get your jarrah?" The third guy at the table snickered and said, "I smuggled it our of Perth in my backpack." There's a pretty good chance it has similar properties to Derek's jarrah. :D

Re: Blast from the Past for XHP/V11

#25

Re: consider gunsmith screwdrivers

William Duffield

"unimpeachable"???

I assure you, I make at least as many mistakes as anyone else. It was not an original idea, but it is not as well known a trick as it should be. I heard it first many years ago, but have forgotten who I heard it from, otherwise I would give him credit. I did mention it to one of our suppliers of brass screws, and I think he took took the idea back to his management so they could start to include one matching steel screw in each box of brass screws they sold. An important detail is that the thread pitch of the steel screw must be the same as the brass screws. And it helps to wax the steel screw too. So, why use brass screws with brass hinges? It's not just aesthetics or tradition. Dissimilar metals can promote corrosion, especially if in a damp environment. While we are on the subject of damp, don't use soap instead of wax. Soap is hygroscopic (which means it can absorb even more water that what is built into it).