Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Thank you David!

Posts

Re: Thank you David!

#26

"seed grade" knives and tools

david weaver

Somewhere between when I was a kid and now, apparently farming has turned into an occupation where people need to have expensive tools on the equipment they're using.

We still have a farm (my parents have partial ownership with some of their siblings). When I was a kid, most of the tools on machines were seed grade tools. That is, they worked OK to get you out of a pinch, and you didn't cry that much when they unintentionally got planted in a field.

I no longer hunt, but i had a foreign made seed grade skinner by remington that was pretty nice. Maybe I remember if fondly more because it was the right shape than because it was nice steel.

Re: Thank you David!

#27

Re: Knife owners

Oskar

Warren, your reply might be a good definition of 95% of all "bushcrafters"

Re: Thank you David!

#28

Re: Well, me for starters

Oskar

Stainless is of course a requirement that does not show up in joinery. Its clear that hunters and many other knife users prefers stainless.

My point was that about surface quality. I´m no hunter, but I guess skinning is a good example. Is it critical that the edge remain free of defects when skinning? is "sharp, but leaving tracks in the wood surface" correspondingly a stop criterion when skinning?

Re: Thank you David!

#29

Re: Finding the right knife information-slicing te

Oskar

ha, of course there is the knife equivalent of a D. Weaver as well :) Slicing X miles of sisal instead of Y thousand feet of beech heartwood.

Thanks for clearing that, it's more about finding the guy in the knife world doing the tests, than the corresponding knife task or knife user. Assuming sisal slicing is a less common activity than wood planing (in rel. miles counted). Which might be mighty false, I don´t know.

Re: Thank you David!

#30

Re: Well, me for starters

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is it critical that the edge remain free of defects when skinning?

Of course not. Nor is wood surface quality beyond tear-out free of any importance to me either, nor anyone else I personally know that makes stuff and uses planes. They all finish sand prior to applying finish.

Personally I don't finish sand until just prior to finishing. I can't carry a complex piece of furniture along with accumulating scuffs, smudges, discovering defects like a gum pocket in cherry, dents, etc. that have to be removed or fixed before finishing. In the case at hand I must have gotten a film of glue on a finger for I found a shiny spot while finish sanding and scrutinizing the surface while doing so. It was sanded away. It could have been scraped but my sanding leaves a better surface.

I can't preserve the surfaces David creates nor can I take advantage of them with the protective finishes I use. I look forward to following your next build and you can show us how it's done.

Re: Thank you David!

#31

Ergonomics trump the metal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When the pointy end of a too pointy blade punctures an intestine while opening the body cavity the advantages of good ergonomics becomes apparent. While gutting a trout on the other hand, pointy is desirable.

I don't know any farmers that carry expensive knives. Maybe "gentlemen farmers" do but we don't have them here.

Re: Thank you David!

#32

You jest and miss the mark

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I field dress squirrels which involves breaking the leg bones over the knife edge. The blade metal that survives 100% more rope cutting is going to survive 100% (+/-) squirrel legs. Rope is easier to come by and it is always in season. So rope is tested and a knowledgeable knife buyer can predict squirrel leg performance from rope performance. I don't enjoy sharpening knives any more than plane blades. Less of it is better for me. Your results may differ.

Re: Thank you David!

#33

Re: Well, me for starters

Oskar

ok, for me it was not obvious, as I said, I´m no hunter. For me, surface quality of the plane is interesting, since I don´t sand. It seems we are kind of opposite in this respect. You sand, and use building finishes. I don´t sand (except for knife handles, and tools without flat surfaces, like spokeshaves), and mostly use oil or wax as a finish.

The problem of keeping finished parts clean and free of gunk, glue, smear and the like we share!

I guess I prefer a finished piece with an overall planed look, even if there is the occasional spot of tearout, or defect, rather than a blemish free piece with a sanded look. I always aim for only cut surfaces since I don´t like sanding but I´m by no means a master. You make very fine work, thank you for sharing it here. I hope to post my next project here as well.

Re: Thank you David!

#34

Re: Finding the right knife information-slicing te

david weaver

strangely enough, I only found that guy after seeing XRF results of XHP and then doing the first part of this test, and thinking that something must've been wrong with my sharpening of 3V because the cut resistance was greater than XHP, plus XHP was showing seemingly more wear under the scope and then outlasted.

What's the importance of that? Nothing other than planing about 10,000 feet up to that point and worrying that subsequent tests would show something different. Two or three iterations with wildy differing results would sure throw a wrench in concluding anything.

I had written off most of the knife testing world after seeing one buschcrafter (misspelling intentional) after another talk about what they "need" and then seeing them sharpen knives for half an hour in something that looked like a robot. Then, you have the guys bending knives in vises, other guys trying to cut metal with knives, etc, and it just seems to have nothing to do with planing.

And in googling XHP, that video came up. I would never have guessed XHP would cut more sisal than S30V or S35V, but between that and cliff stamp videos, it's pretty clear that getting past all of the noise and finding the few guys who would do something like cut 500 feet of cardboard, cut several hundred cuts through old carpet, or cut sisal....those guys are testing the same thing we are more or less. I felt lots better about my results.

Some of the folks on here who always have a negative reaction to LV didn't. It still felt very odd at the time to have an iron slip through material with less resistance - it just makes you think that you must've sharpened one really well, and you start questioning all kinds of stuff. This may just be a one-off experience, one of the few times we got a high technology steel that wasn't made to be used in industrial stamping dies, and that doesn't have carbides made to rub against metal at high speed. It's just lucky, and it's easier to get your data and then go back and find the few people who were testing something similar - but the confirmation is nice.

I'm "that guy" planing for duration for a second time in 10 years. The first time I did it, I compared a small number of A2 irons. I hope to never do the test again, but after finding this missed gem of an iron steel for potentially a long time, and then missing the mark looking at it in two metal planes, I went through all of the other steels. I don't see any other missed potential marks. Elmax and 204P look like potential good plane iron steels, but they're probably more expensive, and I don't think their schedules allowed shade tree iron making like XHP does.

Long story short, everything seems to line up with this one. I wouldn't be surprised if this is the one and only.

The fanatics of the finest white steel aren't going to like it that much, either, but I have planed with white steel planes, and they are wonderful. But the life of the edge is probably similar to good O1.

If some knife guy shows another steel that slices 2 times as much sisal as XHP yet again without being temperamental, I will probably wake up again.

(I was on to the slicing before this, I guess, because of cliff stamp -not because he ever measured XHP, but because he would get something like S30V, and then go find an inexpensive 440C knife or something similar and find out what kind of changes in geometry would yield the same result. I believe he said something along the lines of S30V being fine for duration, but 12c27 or some other lowly steel cut the same number of feet of carpet if the total angle was 2.5 degrees less than that of the S30V knife..I see that kind of stuff as interesting. And he made the same point - for all of the torture tests all of the knife loonies like to go through, most of us slice things with our knives.)

Re: Thank you David!

#35

Nor in my area...though...

david weaver

...there may be some "superfarmers" around, most of the renters we've had in the last 25 years are regular guys or hobby farmers (current tenant has a couple of businesses and would like to hold the land until he retires in a few years so that he can farm it himself....so he rents it, and for now pays someone else to do custom work on it).

Further south where there's more open land, youtube feeds me videos of guys who work 10,000-15,000 acres. They play golf sometimes, and other times drive $100K pickups and wear safety vests while everyone else around them is doing the work, and they have service trucks that look like they belong on an oil pipeline. They say things like "if I had craftsman tools in the service truck, my guys would bust their knuckles all the time".

My grandfather is 23 years dead. He wouldn't have been able to tolerate seeing those guys talk.

Re: Thank you David!

#36

Re: You jest and miss the mark

david weaver

>>I don't enjoy sharpening knives any more than plane blades. Less of it is better for me. <<

I think this could be changed. It can be turned into something wonderful unless a knife is made so that it can't be sharpened well. Lots of the more modern offerings are made in such a way that it seems they're intentionally difficult to sharpen, but no relief behind edges or bits on the tang/shoulder that are literally in the way if you lay a knife on a stone.

There's one other wonderful thing - gray deburring wheel and a hard buff with a pretty stiff compound in it (cheap 5 micron al ox stick that mcmaster carries for $10 per kilogram is great).

As much of a "purist" as i am, if the main bevel of a knife is thin, you can do awfully well with something like that. Perhaps returning to the stone every 10 sharpenings.

Re: Thank you David!

#37

Re: Thank you David!

Steve Elliott

For a number of years I haven’t posted much on issues related to plane blades because I don’t have much to add to what others are saying. Recent discussions have caused me to look back at my own initial interest in the subject and the value this forum has had for me. About twenty years ago I wanted to find a better plane to use at my job in a custom woodworking shop. I’d found planes to be better tools for certain tasks and thought the ones I had weren’t working optimally. Eventually I had well-used older plane bodies that needed better blades, meaning ones that were the right width and thickness with the slot in the right place and plenty of life left. I looked into making blades myself and did some controlled testing of manufactured blades to decide what kind of alloy to use. With help from Bill Tindall I settled on CPM-3V and had the heat treating done by Paul Bos. The blades were just what I wanted and have served me well. At the time PM-V11 blades had not been introduced.

The next area of interest for me was cap irons, and in 2005 I became aware of the work of Kato and Kawai. That was a result of forum discussions and the internet friends I met there and it got me started on using the cap iron effectively myself, another major advance in my technique.

These days I’m pleased that I can buy blades I like and with David Weaver’s recent work I know I could make custom blades in odd sizes if needed to.

As I near retirement I’m looking at what I’ll do when I don’t spend my time in a commercial shop outfitted with power tools. Hand tools will become more important to me for a lot of tasks and what I’ve learned and will learn on this forum will be invaluable.

This post isn’t meant to be about me but rather about how much I appreciate what this forum and its members have done for my woodworking. Our discussions aren’t for everyone but they are very valuable to some of us.

Re: Thank you David!

#39

Re: Thank you David!

david weaver

Steve - your work and contributions have been pioneering, and I've borrowed so much from them (reviewing results, checking experience against them, etc) that I probably wouldn't remember all of the times that I've either referenced your page directly ("what bevel angle does an A2 iron stop displaying chippy behavior") or used the results indirectly (viewing the edge of the 3V irons on beach's page, where they fared very well).

The difference between your information and the sometimes seemingly random choices of steel in ultra high end planes is that quite often, those choices don't yield a dominant (in game theory terms) result. In your case with 3V given what was available at the time, the results was very close to dominant, but you were actually able to prove it, too, in data and pictures.

I wouldn't be surprised to find that 3V made a chisel as good or better than V11, but I'll probably never know that. the V11/XHP is just a notch further along in the development of the steelmakers and it's even closer to dominant than 3V in a plane iron. Who knows what tomorrow brings? Whatever it may be, I think you have a whole lot to do with why we'd even see something like V11 in a woodworking plane in the first place. Especially on the heels of an era when most of what was put in planes was demonstrably worse than older efforts.

Re: Thank you David!

#40

Re: Well, me for starters

TomD

Well one guy who might fit the bill is Ed Fowler who is a very well known knife maker, and author of the Knife Talk Column and the books of the same name. Wyoming resident, hunter, maybe guide, and worked in a slaughterhouse, and as a result could get a lot of practice with his knives (don't they have machines for this kind of work?).

He seems to be in the whole ABS slot which puts a premium on a variety of features, that might not meet your "scientific" preferences. They all use HC steel, and resharpenability is as important to him as edge holding because you don't get to quit on the line when the blade goes dull. That may also be the case with really large animals. Though really big animals tend to get processed by staff. His preferred steel was ball bearing steel forged out. He had his opinions. What set him apart, aside from his craft, was the line experience.

Knives are a lot like planes in that it is hard to find a real world heroic situation today that justifies all the hype. Though that doesn't account for drag racing either.

Re: Thank you David!

#41

For a long time...

david weaver

...the 52100 type knives dominated the abuse contests. Until recently, I didn't see anything that really was worth the step up from simpler steels.

Super blue, etc, I tried all of those, all the way up to M2 and YXR7 - they all work OK.

This is the first steel I've seen in a knife that would outperform carbon steel in a butcher setting. But is it really necessary? how much time does a butcher spend sharpening vs. cutting? I'd guesstimate not much. Geometry is probably more important than sharpness, but both together is great. Would it matter if a butcher had to sharpen 2/3rds or 1/2 as much if sharpening was marginally harder? Probably not.

Butchers of that era got to see large chromium carbide stainless steels that wouldn't deliver. then, the trend became high vanadium steels that had a "toothy" edge after a little bit of use, and won't take an edge well at lower angles, going as far as breaking off on a strop. Who wants that? Not me.

I don't think V11 would make a good razor (even O1 doesn't), I think it still has enough strength to the wire edge to be problematic if drawn on a strop. Instead of releasing, it would always have a small foil. But on planes, and probably in slicing knives (test data is already available), it's just plain better. Better isn't always necessary, and an all natural stone regimen won't tolerate V11/XHP.

The two things that torture woodworkers (big vanadium carbides and big chromium carbides) are solved, though, by getting rid of most of the vanadium and making the chromium carbides tiny and not doing things that allow them to get big (namely, keeping stainless or high chromium steel between 900-1400F).

I do think people who demand easiest sharpening or who have a regimen set up and who are unwilling to experiment with faster sharpening before the fine parts won't tolerate XHP or V11. It's slower with grinding and coarse work. If a butcher had a pair of natural stones that they liked, they wouldn't be able to deal with it, either. It grades my washita a little finer, which is a benefit with it for fineness and a detriment for speed. I'm using the washita to finish it, though, so the speed doesn't matter.