Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Thank you David!

Posts

Thank you David!

#1

Thank you David!

Wiley Horne

Hi All,

I had the good fortune yesterday afternoon, of receiving a smallish package from David Weaver. To backtrack, a few days ago I got an email from David, who was then neck deep in his projects, asking if I had a No.4. I admitted to it, and he then said he was sending a package.

Well the package came. And upon opening it, I found this,

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48678849848/in/album-72157710681177492/

One of his hard-fought XHP irons attached to an LN cap iron!

Well. This professionally finished blade set did not bear out David’s “aw shucks, I jess drilled and sawed and took a file to it and then hit it with a bigger hammer” description of his fabrication methods! This thing is beautiful and finished to a fare-thee-well. Metal has a nice tone, almost a patina.

He sent it ready to work, and I was interested in the cap iron setting—took a mental image of it. It was about what you or I would do if we said to ourselves, I’m gonna set this thing real close, but not disappearingly close.

One thing I found aesthetically nice was the rounded top—said he did it by eye. I put the blade set in an LN4,

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157710681177492

David had said there was about 200 feet on it, but it felt fresh and really smooth in the birch stick.

I had the instant feeling that this is the last iron this LN4 is ever going to see. It’s perfect. So the excellent LV PM V11 that was in it is going into a Bedrock 605 Type 6 (meep) that is on its way from that auction site.

Thank you David, and thanks to others for reading this far.

Wiley

Re: Thank you David!

#2

Re: Thank you David!

david weaver

Thanks for posting pictures of it in its native environment, Wiley. Released to the wild!

Pretty close description of the construction methods, but the slot hopefully matches the LN wheel on the lateral adjuster. It had probably a spare thousandth on mine, and making an iron for someone else to use forced me not to fall asleep and just make it sloppy like the ones that I have.

Deburring wheel is a handy thing - if the iron is already flat, it makes it look like it was finished more finely than it is. Heat treat is pretty much "dummy on floor with can of oil" method, followed by angry wife "what is the smell in the oven?"

(soy oil!)

I see aesthetic improvements possible, but there won't be too many of these irons because the idea for the iron came from someone else's work and it really doesn't belong to me. So, there will be no DW brand irons, though I could still drop one out of the forge onto me somehow, and make a brand on me.

I have enough material to make about ten of these irons. Then the fun will have worn off. Half a dozen or so will find other places to go. Many of the readers on

Woodcentral don't know of your generosity and encouragement to others in following curiosities at the same time, but all who read know of your positive impact on here. I couldn't think of a better place for the first of the small group to land.

Re: Thank you David!

#3

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

if you wiggle it around in the light can you see any wear bevel after 200'?

Indeed the metal looks handsome. All it lacks is an elegant imprint proclaiming "Weaver Blade Smith"

Re: Thank you David!

#4

Re: question

david weaver

I don't remember it showing much at a couple of hundred feet. One of the reasons I was misled on the "it's going 4000 feet!" thread is that this one isn't honed on diamond and neither was the first mule (that did the 4k feet), so I think the wear bevel wasn't quite as visible.

It's just starting to show wear under the microscope, but I sent that to wiley with some wear on because with probably 200-300 feet of wear on it, off of the washita, the iron seems to actually get better for a period as the initial edge comes off. It makes an astoundingly bright surface given that the washita is fine, but it doesn't give me a particularly bright surface with carbon steel.

I wish Larry was still around to come up with all kinds of talk about burnishing to explain it!!

What I did not expect to find with all of this stuff is what I did find - that the XHP and V11 irons feel sharper with the same abrasive that I would use on carbon steel, and then a step further, easing their hardness a little bit doesn't seem to do too much to their durability, but they become sweethearts to sharpen.

Re: Thank you David!

#5

Update

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

This evening I decided to regrind and resharpen David’s XHP iron. Taking it out of the plane, I noticed it was still sharp from David’s Ouachita. I had put another 100 feet on it in birch, and it still very nearly passed the newsprint test—only stuttered a couple times as it slid into the paper’s edge. I was surprised, and am sure it still had a few hundred real good feet left in it.

Grinding on Tormek with 10” CBN wheel. I ground to a heavy burr at 25 degrees. It was not an easy grind, very much like CPM 3V. In fact, for comparable metal removal, it took a little longer, but then the wheel is settling in now, so I would call it comparable to 3V. I thought ‘uh oh’, this thing is going to be a bear to sharpen on natural stones—my goal was to avoid diamond.

But it went well, on 3 Japanese stones, shown here:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48680196638/in/album-72157710681177492/

First a tomae (far side in photo), then a karasu (middle), and then my best finish stone, which the iron is laying against. The iron got tremendously sharp on these stones, and you could tell after the first one that it would. It had a heavy burr going into the honing, but gave it up easily on the tomae. ‘

Close-up on the finish stone:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48680196233/in/album-72157710681177492/

I gave a a few licks on a chromium green leather strop and did the NYT test:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48680706602/in/album-72157710681177492/

I don’t think it even saw the paper. This is really amazing blade steel, if you use a grinder. Because it hones to a true edge on natural stones. You don’t have to go to diamond, as with 3V or the M’s or any high speed steel.

The full set of,photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157710681177492/with/48680706602/

Wiley

Re: Thank you David!

#6

Same experience

David Weaver

That's pretty much the same experience that I have with it. The grinding is slower, but it will sharpening sweetly on pretty much anything after that. The wire edge comes off neatly, and stones that slurry like those are even better to inhibit wire edges.

Re: Thank you David!

#7

Well done David ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... and thanks you for pointing out Wiley's generosity. I am one of many whom have benefitted. In my case, several years ago he sent me a cutting gauge by Kinshiro. For those who are unaware, Kinshiro was the doyen of makers. These gauges are no longer available. The steel and design is simply the best. And I know this because of Wiley's generosity. Thank you again Wiley.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Thank you David!

#8

Compare and contrast

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If we make the assumption that the blade you received from David differs from PMV11 only in the heat treat and the heat treat differs only in the final hardness will you compare you experience sharpening the two? I realize David has reported the difference, in terms I largely don't understand, but science demands confirmation of results.

I bake in a kitchen oven, with about the same indulgence in details as you all planing. In my experience there is nothing uniform either spatial or temporal about any place in any oven I have baked in. And if the oven is electric, radiant heating becomes significant which in turn means IR absorption/reflection of the metal becomes significant. (dark bread pans bake faster than shiny) While I regard the heat treat schedules provided by manufacturers reliable I am skeptical we can predict the hardness of David's blade from his heat treat information. Interpreting results for this blade requires its hardness to be tested. The both of you live within a short drive of many places that could test it.

Re: Thank you David!

#9

Familiarity with the oven

david weaver

I can get to within 10-15 degrees in the oven. How do I know? I have to put the irons in a particular spot in the oven, and then check them periodically with a non-contact thermometer. If I were to start moving irons around in the oven and not putting them in the same spot on the same setting, I would have errors that were more like 50 degrees plus.

Where I can gauge hardness is with stones, reasonably well. Perhaps less well with V11. I think I can still easily guess within two points. I'd say the iron that i sent wiley is probably 60-61 hardness. it would be interesting to have an iron like that tested, but I don't think it's important. The detail where the easing is important is in making an iron that's hard to finish sharpen on a certain stone suddenly finishable in that zone without too much loss in longevity.

Washita is right around 62 hardness, as is about 85% of the abrasive in a japanese natural stone (they do generally have about 15-18% natural aluminum oxide from volcanic ash, and can be stronger cutting than novaculite because of it - but that's a density much lower than synthetic stones. The grit in a good natural stone is relatively uniform - actually very uniform - but even if the alumina particles are uniform, the rest of the stone may not be.)

Back to the hardness - small changes in the above-60 hardness area make for big changes with how the final honing behavior is on a stone.

I hollow grind shallow and then freehand a secondary bevel on an iron, never working that much material. Someone who wanted to freehand a single solid bevel on the iron that I sent wiley would still find it challenging.

I sometimes forget that I've gamed my honing method to be doing very little with the finish stone so that I don't have to remove errors from it on the next sharpening, and so that I'm not dependent on "fast" finishing stones. Wiley's discussion of the grinding still being a little slow rings true - it's also true on a high speed grinder. Grinding is probably half the rate of carbon steel and with far less spark, so there's less to observe other than feel.

(my oven is also convection, so a particular spot tends to stay in a narrow range, even though the entire oven doesn't. I just need to know the setting and the spot and not deviate. I've done that in the past).

Years ago, George Wilson was coaching up some beer leaguers on SMC and telling them to get a reliable toaster oven to do this instead, OR, to get a decent oven thermometer and run their oven first without anything in it and put the thermometer at a given spot and observe. That's what I did initially.

There is a bigger variable for me, though. By color, I suspect I can't reach the top of the range for V11 before quenching. trying to attain it and keeping the metal at high heat in the open atmosphere to chase another 25-50 degrees is, I think, a bad thing. Am I getting 1850 or 1900 at a very bright orange? I don't know. By color charts, it's not 2000. that's a minus for my hardening in terms of initial hardness, but some patience still finds a 350 degree temper too hard for my taste. Probably at least as hard as the LN iron. 400-415 is slightly softer than LV's iron. 1 point or two? I don't know, but it's not 4.

Hardening in oil as opposed to in moving air or plate hardening is a plus 1 for hardness more or less, and not cryo tempering is a minus 1.

Add that all together, and if LV is hardening with air or plate hardening, I'm up plus 1 for the oil. If they're cryo tempering, plus one for LV and were back at zero, and if they're quenching from the top of the heat range instead of mid or bottom, they're up another. They may be able to attain an extra point.

I don't know if wiley will compare to the two, but I suspect my iron will be slightly sweeter to hone on his japanese stones than the LV. It's not going to feel hard, and it's not going to feel soft. It won't blacken the swarf as fast as carbon steel.

I fiddled with this a little bit because I just don't want to give up the natural stones. It's not essential that you do with a V11 iron, but drop them back a point or two and sharpening goes from tolerable to pleasurable.

Re: Thank you David!

#10

For reference...

david weaver

http://sb-specialty-metals.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CTS-XHP-NF.pdf

This document and others kind of clued me in that this stuff could be suboptimally heat treated with very little expense. At this point, I'd go so far to say that it's easier to quench consistently than O1. Not because it's that easy to get above 1850F, but because despite all of the procedure and warnings, it behaves just fine in unheated oil, even if you quench it all the way down to touchable. If you do several in a row and the oil heats, no big deal.

50 degrees F per minute at least to achieve hardening. We're achieving probably something like 1600-1700F in a matter of 15 seconds. Lots of wiggle room.

Also an indication of why once you get it up to a certain temperature and harden a piece that you're working with, forget about any easy quick ways to anneal it again. It can harden at extremely slow rates.

All of the other stuff about triple tempering, etc, I blew that out of the water because we kind of learned with the testing here that we're probably not challenging any reasonably tough steels, and toughness seems to be pretty good.

The high carbon amount may also be aiding in allowing open atmosphere heat treatment. Who knows? Seeing all of those things and learning stuff through the test didn't make all of that important to me, but convinced me that it was worth a try. It boils down to "heat it up to bright orange or dull yellow if you can, as fast as you can - don't leave it there, quench it in oil, don't worry about cracking or too much of the other instruction and temper it single temper for at least a half hour in the oven without overheating it.

What if you accidentally undertemper it? You'll know. It'll be too hard? What if you accidentally temper it to 450F instead of 400F? It'll be just a tiny bit soft ?1/2 to 1 point on the C scale? very forgiving.

Interestingly enough, I went to look at the annealing and hardening and tempering instructions for O1, because I suspected that "getting the best out of it" would also be very complicated. It is. Getting it "really good for woodworking", however, is not. Fortunately.

Stainless wrap turned out to be a waste for me. I think it's applicable for someone with a good furnace who is going to be using a non-vacuum atmosphere but keeping the metal at high heat for a long time. The best I could figure, it keeps me from heating the iron quickly and I can't see the color (which is really important when you're relying on color to determine when to quench).

Re: Thank you David!

#11

Re: Oven tempering

Steve Voigt

I bake in a kitchen oven, with about the same indulgence in details as you all planing. In my experience there is nothing uniform either spatial or temporal about any place in any oven I have baked in. And if the oven is electric, radiant heating becomes significant which in turn means IR absorption/reflection of the metal becomes significant. (dark bread pans bake faster than shiny).

I agree with all this, Bill. If you put a piece of bare steel on the rack and heat it to say 400°, you are likely to get a rainbow: gold, brown, purple, even blue if you're unlucky.

Here's how to temper accurately in an oven. You'll enjoy this if you're a baker.

First, get an insulated cookie sheet. It has to be insulated, not just any sheet. Cuz duh, it insulates. Put it on the top rack.

Second, put a heavy cast iron pan (or two) on the bottom rack. This'll act as a heat sink.

Third, always preheat the oven before you put your steel in. Good practice when baking too, right?

Last, you'll need to calibrate the oven thermometer, since it obviously may not be correct. You can use an external, accurate thermometer, but it's not necessary--trial and error will work fine. Start at 300° and work your way up. Make sure you use a piece of clean, bare steel (preferably O1 or other HC steel) when calibrating. At around 375, you should see a light straw. 400 is a nice gold color, and so on.

It's important to judge color out of the oven. Put the steel on a white plate or sheet of paper (after it's cool, lol). It's really hard to read color accurately in the oven or on a dark or metallic background like the cookie sheet.

I just read Dave's description of how he tempers. He's obviously got a process that works for him (using a specific spot in the oven) but it may not be replicable. Probably can't do batches, either. I sometimes do a dozen irons at a time, and they all come out the same gold color (or they would if I abraded them all before tempering; the process is so dependable that I no longer do that--I just throw them in the oven after HT, and clean them up afterwards).

Re: Thank you David!

#12

what is your temperature measuring device

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If it is an IR "thermometer" the reading has to be corrected for the emissivity of the object being measured. The correction is the temperature, in Kelvin, times the 4th root of the emmisivity ratio of what the thermometer is calibrated for and that of the metal. The error at tempering temperature will be -20to40 degrees K, or the actual temperature of the metal is 20 to 40 degrees hotter than what you are measuring. (making a guess as to what exactly the surface of the metal looks like during this part of heat treat. )

Re: Thank you David!

#13

Re: Oven tempering

david weaver

I can do two or three irons at a time, depending on their size. it wouldn't work for large batches, but the average person tempering a few irons would be served to reduce the risk of messing a bunch up and do only a couple at a time.

I used to temper everything for an hour, but have also noticed no difference in plane irons doing that vs. tempering for a shorter period of time and checking with a non-contact thermometer.

I haven't seen a variation greater than 15 degrees with my magic spot in the oven (e.g., if I set convection at 375, any iron on the top rack will always be between 400 and 415 degrees F) with the non-contact thermometer, but success in my oven definitely does not mean that someone else will experience the same.

Probably a well-invested half hour for someone wishing to do this stuff to turn their oven on, then put one of the $8 oven thermometers in the oven where they want to temper and observe both the temperature of that thermometer as well as how much the thermometer fluctuates over a half hour (then watch longer if something alarming occurs).

When I temper, every single time, I use a non-contact thermometer mid-process and then again when turning the oven off. If a thermostat goes bad on an oven, it's not like an alarm will go off (that I'm aware of).

Re: Thank you David!

#14

Re: what is your temperature measuring device

david weaver

two, but only one measures the iron itself. The first is a hanging $6 taylor thermometer. The second is an inexpensive IR thermometer, which as you're mentioning, I am assuming is a data point, but not certainly within the 15 degree range I observe with it.

The third, and most important, is the tempering color of the iron when I'm done. it should only be the very faintest straw at 400 degrees, close to nothing. I get the iron down to touchable temperature (with gloves) between harden and temper so that I can deburr the face of the iron (so that I can see it).

And, of course, the last tester of hardness is the washita.

It'd be interesting to see how close I could get three pieces of iron in hardness using my quenching and tempering process, but not interesting enough for me to find someone with a hardness tester.

The XHP iron is a bit of a cheat, though, because if I miss by 50 degrees (which would show up solidly in tempering colors, but I haven't seen it), i'm introducing additional softness of about 0.5-1 on the C scale. It is extremely forgiving. If I am pushing for hardness on an O1 iron as I did on my plane iron in this test, as well as the chisel I sent steve, I start around 360 degrees targeted and then go up by 20-25 degrees if the stone and use say "too hard".

I use a slightly modified sharpening process (in that the last stone is a slow stone and I use it in such a way that I'm pushing the failure point further into the bevel), so I can tolerate slightly higher hardness without defect vs someone sharpening with a guide or right on a hollow. If i start talking about that in detail, I'm going to have to go on coast to coast am radio.

I sent steve that chisel that I made a month or two ago, though, and sure enough, he found it a little bit hard tempered.

The same method makes japanese chisels work like a champ.

Re: Thank you David!

#15

Reground the PMV11 iron

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill and all,

I’m curious too. So I just put the LV iron through the same grinding/honing as David’s XHP iron. The LV iron was lowered from 30 degrees (where I previously had ground to) to 25 degrees. Took me 6 minutes. Yesterday, I took David’s iron to 24 degrees from whatever he sent it at—33? That took 11-12 minutes. There are some complications: David’s iron was starting from very little hollow, whereas the LV iron already had a full hollow from my previous grinding. The LV iron mic’s at 0.103” thick; the median on David’s iron was 0.985-0.99” thick. Overall, I removed considerably more metal from David’s iron.

All in all, it seemed to me that the LV iron ground the same to slightly faster, mg for mg. I do not think David’s iron is softer than the PMV11.

I then honed the LV iron on the same three Japanese stones as shown before. The two irons honed at the same rate to the same end sharpness (very sharp), and slid through the NYT with the same ease.

Conclusion: I don’t find David’s iron to be softer (or harder) than the LV. Best bet: as an anecdotal, weakly controlled, shade-tree estimate, I go for the null hypothesis—they’re about the same. Which is high praise. I really like both irons. A lot.

Wiley

Re: Thank you David!

#16

I could have a memory error

david weaver

....from comparing the hardness of that iron to the hardness of the mule after the first (insufficient temper). That one and the one I have now (which I tested by heating longer and higher, seeing potential negative effects in the middle of the face from doing that - so I won't offer to send it to Bill for hardness testing because it could give some odd readings) got to a very faint straw temper, which should lead to a hardness around 60-61, but it's possible that since the washita is working a tiny part of the iron that it could be a little harder (due to the fast cooling in oil).

It's almost worth having made it and sent it just to hear other opinions about it...

..and the memory error could be confusing what the mule felt like at hard temper vs. the V11 iron.

I recall also that bill requested a head to head with both irons, but that's potentially 8,000 feet of planing. I'm out of reliable waste-able wood. The target in this case was less to see if I could equal the V11 iron and more to see if I could make something reasonably close enough so that I can do what I like to do - experiment and improve skills while yielding something permanently usable.

Given the laziness of the process, credit goes to carpenter for making a supremely wonderful steel. The first that I have seen that is a genuine improvement over my favorites in general planing, one that I cannot argue against reasonably.

Re: Thank you David!

#17

Re: Reground the PMV11 iron

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You do good experiments and write lucid technical reports ;)

A lot can be concluded from these results.

Re: Thank you David!

#18

I like it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First, you have created a uniform space. Finally, just as potters do with a melting point measuring test piece, you determine the temperature of this space. Best, would be in the end confirmation by hardness measuring as any heat treat company will do.

It takes 15 seconds to determine Rockwell hardness. When I worked near a machine shop they would test anything I brought them for free because it was so little effort to do so (possibly an occasional basket of fruit from my orchard could have helped, but they did more than this favor)

BTW, the insulated cookie sheets were a must in the radiant electric oven. I shielded this radiant heat from everything I baked. Less so an issue in gas oven, but one still gets heating of something like a chunk of metal by radiation from the oven walls.

Re: Thank you David!

#19

Lee Valley

Wiley Horne

David and all,

I never gave much thought to trying a PMv11 iron, until you performed your testing. I liked all my irons, including the old W1 in the LN4.

But your testing—showing that PMV11 outdistanced everything else, which was surprising to me, and was smoother in the cut, and yet sharpened on natural stones—changed everything. The sharpening was the clincher. That’s why I ordered a 2” PMV11 for the LN4.

Your testing PMV11 against this XHP steel—and I think we must respect Rob Lee and not presume an equivalence—but your testing did nothing but reaffirm the superior performance of both these steels.

As I say, I never gave a thought to retrofitting with PMV11, but I believe in data, and the data changes my mind. I would encourage anyone and everyone to consider PMV11 for their compatible planes. And I’d love to see LV make a line of slotted irons in the 0.14-0.18” thickness range for infills and LN’s longer planes—I would be an immediate buyer.

Thanking Lee Valley for their R&D and risk-taking to bring this steel to market!

Wiley

Re: Thank you David!

#20

Planing equation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

David's results + Lee Valley free shipping = I too have ordered blades for my go to planes.

I never found the Lee Valley data credible. It was easy to dismiss, and I did even for the messily $15 premium on a blade. How could a steel sharpen easily yet wear longer? And the testing was done on MDF!

Now if you go to the knife Forums where CTS-XHP is known and discussed you find data that shows exceptional edge life and an explanation for easy sharpening in the discussion of particle steel properties. Read up on CTS-XHP and you don't find the results you all are finding with David's blades surprising at all, or Lee Valley's.

I don't usually, but I watched some of Forged in Fire last night. Everyone told what the steel was in the blades they made. Why? Because the knife community knows that if the knife is made from XXY it will have such and such properties. The steel name predicts performance of the blade in manufacturing and use. Ditto for the show that followed where contestants whacked on things. One person's blade was made from PD1 a metal I investigated for chisels. I could predict how it would perform on some of the tests (it's boggling tough at high hardness and vanadium content means it won't dull easily) If I make any more tools it will be from PD1.

For some of our woodworkers woodworking is a life style and that style is rooted in a previous century. Until most of us are getting excited about new technology there won't be much of it in our market place.

Re: Thank you David!

#21

Re: Planing equation

Oskar

Who are these knife people pushing the limits of steels and edges. There has been numerous references to the knife community and their knowledge and thoughtful use of steel.

What are the knife equivalent of a joiner or cabinetmaker?

My perception of the knife community (only mine, and as such with my prejudice) is that there is more talk than action (could probably be said about any community, including ours), and few people actually using their custom knifes to their limits. Collectors like to talk about the things they collect, and the more space steel, mammut bone handles, filipine pearl inlays etc. there are, the more they can talk about.

Planing thousands of feet, with the additional condition of creating an excellent surface is a task which I can´t see the equivalent of in the knife world. Please educate me on the knife users that would actually note the difference between HC steel and e.g XHP in use where it matters.

Re: Thank you David!

#22

Knife owners

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A lot of these knife enthusiasts prepare for the time they dropped off on an uninhabited island. They want a knife that can go years without sharpening while being constantly bathed in salt water. They want a knife that can open up hundreds of cardboard boxes for the next time they get lost in the Amazon rainforest.

Re: Thank you David!

#23

Finding the right knife information-slicing tests

david weaver

For years, a decade I guess, I ignored a lot of what the knife community has to say because only a subset of them is really looking for what we're looking for, and many of the rest will buy things that don't make any sense for a usable knife.

A lot of the competitions for knives are pretty much abuse, as is much of the testing that people do (like trying to cut into the lip of a steel drum, etc). Couple that with the fact that i've read several times on forums that the knives that win the abuse competitions (powder metal high alloy) often find their way to some kind of structural failure in a couple of years when the older knives (52100, etc, can't win the competitions but didn't have those failures).

But, what I found looking a little harder is that there is a subset of users who will test knives cutting used carpet, cardboard and sisal and record the results, and their results are pretty much right in line with what we'll find planing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2WU-vUpfXc

(this guy found the XHP to slice rope about 40% longer than S35VN in the two samples he tested)

A lot of the exotic knife steels exhibit things we wouldn't want in woodworking tools (small edge failures, releasing clumps right at the edge and then staying like that, refusing to be sharpened on anything except diamond).

I scoured the carpenter and crucible steel listings to see if there's anything like a super XHP, and there is - CTS 204HP or something like that, and there's something called Elmax that's also favored, but none of them have the same combination of sharpenability and wear resistance. There are tougher steels, but toughness and wear resistance at the same time usually comes with lots of vanadium, and that is a little unfavorable to me.

Re: Thank you David!

#24

Well, me for starters

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Please educate me on the knife users that would actually note the difference between HC steel and e.g XHP in use where it matters



A great many deer and lambs have hung from this spreader. Years ago their hide came off and they were quartered with a Ruana custom made carbon steel knife. While this traditional knife readily took a razor edge with traditional sharpening media this edge didn't like bone. To cut around the "ankles and wrists" I would use a second knife so as to keep the Ruana razor sharp for the task of actual skinning. The Ruana got sharpened after every animal for it was dull at the end.

My hunting is rooted in 1825 technology. My hunting is a life style; skinning isn't. Hides now come off with a custom made CPM 3V skinner. Were I buying today it would be XHP. This knife will skin several critters before it needs sharpening which as a practical matter means it stays razor sharp for one session. My field gutting knife is 440C with a fluorescent green handle that shows up in dead leaves. It's stainless steel I find useful. The kitchen knives are custom 440C Rc60. I sharpen on stone not with a steel so I like a harder knife. My farm knives are cheap 440. I loose them often so I won't pay more than $15 for them at Smoky Mt Knife works.

I'm delighted the knife market offers all these choices to meet my needs and desires.

Re: Thank you David!

#25

Other side comment...

david weaver

...from oskar's question, the difference between XHP and something like a wonderful skinning knife made with 1095 is probably limited to the fact that XHP is stainless so you can be careless, relatively speaking.

Bill's noted that the skinner manages to take abrasive wear and always seems relatively dull when done, but unless someone is skinning 3 deer a day, that's not really a game changing thing (it's obviously not essential for wood, either, but it does seem to be the first option that's generally better than carbon steel without some compromise).