Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Surface quality from the plane question

Posts

Surface quality from the plane question

#1

Surface quality from the plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Throughout the planing discussions are statements of planed surface appearance, sometimes described in subtle detail, and being the goal of planing successfully.

The recent discussions have been coincident with building a corner cupboard. And they have got me to thinking about planing and how it fits into my building stuff. Planed cherry is lustrous and pretty, but I don't know how to use this fact. As I apply the last coat of varnish to the project I am left concluding that surface appearance from the plane is irrelevant to me, so long as there isn't tear-out.

But this conclusion got me further thinking where is the surface from the plane significant? It must be to some, because it keeps coming up. Is it irrelevant to me because of what I build, or how I build it or how I finish it or all of the above? Or, because I am missing something I should have known about when building a corner cupboard?

Looking at my finished product I don't see where the surfaces David describes would make any difference in how it looks compared to what I did, or how one could achieve, and preserve, these surfaces on a corner cupboard as it was being made. Optically I am looking at varnish luster with color underneath. So where does it make a difference?

Taking the case of building this corner cupboard, is there any opportunity to benefit from the refined surfaces being described?

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#2

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

david weaver

I think most people would see the liveliness that I like as "blotch". Not sure how else to explain it. When you plane, the agreeable grain is dense, and the grain that runs out into the surface a little bit will soak in more finish.

without planing two pieces and placing them side by side, I couldn't tell you whether or not you'd ever see the difference through shellac.

I know I mentioned it on here before, but a planed or scraped and burnished surface will absorb less shellac and takes less time for me to move on from. If I am building finish on a guitar, like on the spruce telecaster I showed on here, I don't level finishes or sand out standing grain until there is enough such that I won't reach into the wood itself with abrasive. Actually, I think I did that guitar with varnish only, can't recall, but cherry telecaster types (I've made two)..

..ok diversion there, one of them was hand scraped on purpose

Never mind!!

I also think that if you're not chasing a certain look, then why change the method to try to achieve it? If sanding gives you what you want, then why do anything other than sand? There's a learning curve with everything. do you want to go through it? That curve pops up going forward on things like cabinet frames and door frames - you will mark a door panel or something at some point if you're learning to plane.

The value equation is simple for me. I like planed surfaces. Sometimes they probably don't look any different. I like planing. I don't like sanding. I'd rather plane and correct any issues with light scraper and burnishing than notice sanding swirls on a spot after finishing is complete.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#3

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

Joe shelton

I'm glad to hear that I'm not alone in liking the way cherry looks. (When it's blotched.)

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#4

blotching

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is blotching from poor surface preparation and that from irregularities in the grain. Why everyone values these irregularities in maple and lays a pejorative name like blotching on them when it is cherry, I don't understand.

On the corner cupboard I did use a wash coat to control stain absorption but it was because one board was exceptionally porous in place and crotch figure demands it. But for most cherry I don't try to hide it. For example:


note: the pulls are what they are because this chest was made for a young child. Some day they will be replaced with something more elegant. The cherry color is accurate. It is low elevation TN cherry and that is the color it ages to. The top drawer fronts came from a log in the wood pile. When I split it it looked promising.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#5

Re: blotching

david weaver

I kind of like the pulls, but love the blotching.

The pulls are simple and they're not polished brass or brushed nickel, nor are they wonky looking awkward arts+Crafts movement stuff like you'd find in some of the strip district shops around here with "custom woodworkers" making cutting boards and other such things.

When I can find cherry that's close to quartered, I'm on it. I don't often get it, especially if the stock comes from a circle mill of one of my local suppliers. It's always got varying density between the early and late wood and some type of curl. Even weak is more interesting than nothing, and it looks good sanded or planed.

Curly maple is often doted over as a "difficult" wood, but it's pretty easy to plane. Curly cherry that's on the lower density side and very dry can be a lot more of a challenge to finish straight off of the plane. You can't scrape it too hard, either, or it crumbles.

When i first started woodworking, i sanded cherry all the time. It would cause me to have a mild asthma attack and could leave me with ill effects for a couple of days. Thankfully, planing it for years seems to have lessened the sensitivity.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#6

My sad tale of quartered cherry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Years ago there was a veneer mill in Knoxville. I could buy the "backer boards" for next to nothing. They would be about 5/4 and perfectly quartered center slice of the log. Could not sell it in cherry. Nobody wanted that figure in cherry. Thousands of bdft of it was burned. Today the cants are mounted different and the backer boards are not useful for anything I have thought of-too thin.

They veneered white pine. Never could figure out how they sliced through knots so smoothly. The logs are steamed to soften them but I doubt the knots softened. (Hence, all the walnut veneer you buy is "steamed walnut") These backer boards were about 8/4 and we sold a lot of it.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#7

The nasty side effect of efficiency

david weaver

I like to watch an old sawyer named "Mike McCoy" on youtube. He's got a circle mill that's not even remotely close to new - it looks like it's probably a 50 year old frick mill.

But I finally see, watching him, the drive to get the most board feet out of a log, and the continuous flipping until every flat sawn face is out of the logs, never a quartered or rift piece to be found anywhere.

I wouldn't be surprised with veneer logs if each iteration of machinery was pushed further and further to maximize the amount of the log used in veneer, advertised as such (the economic proposition is easy to make), and all that's left as trimmings for people to pick up is stuff that my dad would've said "makes too much ash to burn".

I would love to work with nothing but quartered cherry. It planes easily, has fantastic personality and to my eye, wonderful color without any stain (not to most eyes - and my wife calls the figure "marks. Why does it have all of the dirty marks on it? Can't they be cleaned off?"

Of course, most of the efficiencies were found long ago. I grew up close to waynesboro, pa. There were a lot of old frick mills in the hills around Gettysburg where local sawyers were running, and there were still some when I was a little kid (but more rusting mills with U-farmall power units by that time - just sitting waiting for a buyer). By the time I was in college, I worked at a cabinet factory (pure production, didn't have any resemblance to woodworking). Our weekly scrap and rework cost was about $800 total on 3350 cabinets, and every monday, we'd get the spiel "we've got to keep working to get the scrap and rework down, $800 is too high". Fill in the number. If it was $900, it was too high. If it was $550 one week "it's getting better, but still too high".

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#8

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Back in the 1980s I took a cherry table to a craft show where I was demonstrating the pole lathe. A woman came around and looked over the table; her husband was a very fine cabinetmaker. She said "that's a beautiful piece of cherry." This table top had nice color, but very little figure, just a few dimples. So I wondered if she really thought this plain piece of cherry was beautiful, or if that is just what she said when she had nothing else to say. I was still thinking about the remark the next day.

A few years later I had this same table on display (easy to carry) and here is this woman again saying the cherry was beautiful. Then I realized what it was. She had probably never seen a no sand piece of furniture before.

The planed surface has a depth, clarity, and a liveliness that sanding deadens. It takes some skill. I would not recommend finish planing with an iron that has planed 3000 feet. It is a lot easier to sharpen the iron than to go through the sanding, sanding sealer rigamarole.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#9

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

Oskar

I leave my projects with surfaces right off the plane, and I don´t use building finishes. Rather boiled linseed oil, wax, light shellack coats (not building a polish) or some combination of these three. It usually results in surfaces one can see and feel that they are planed, which I enjoy.

Maybe not relevant for you, and your nice inlayed cupboard which might require a more sophisticated finish.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#10

Re: The nasty side effect of efficiency

Brian Holcombe

I started buying from Horizon because of that reason, they always saw through and through, aligned with the outside of the log. Much better materiel is the result and now I’m terribly spoiled. I’m making a table from QS walnut, 9-10” wide boards.

Bill, plane finish is top for efficiency and I think it makes a better product. I make finished parts that require no additional work and absorb less finish. Time savings is highly valuable especially when it produces a better product.

Re: Surface quality from the plane question

#11

Re: The nasty side effect of efficiency

david weaver

With the quality of their beech stock when they were sawing, I will probably buy from them in the future if I want to make something out of cherry that's actually nice.

I was listening to the guy with a circle mill on youtube who saws pine, and he mentioned that most of the band mills now are computerized, so the "efficiency" in sawing will only go up. Meaning what I can find is less and less like what I want when I go to a commercial supply place.

I think the same will be true for most people.

I do have a local guy here who can always come up with #1 cherry inexpensively, and he's a little below market on FAS, but I'm sure if I get him to saw a nice log through and through, it won't be much off what horizon charges, and I can't browse a gaggle of pictures first.