Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Honing oil

Posts

Honing oil

#1

Honing oil

Jeremy Osner

Hi All --

I had a hand tool woodworking hobby 15 or so years ago. One of the things that caused me to stop (or well, taper off) is, I was never any good at sharpening tools.

I'm picking my tools back up these days and I realize I need to get better at the sharpening... I'm practicing, getting a little better. One thing I'm wondering about is honing oil. I have a little squeeze bottle that I bought somewhere ages back, it will run out soon. Is there anything I can get at a local hardware store that will serve the purpose or do I need to go to the internet and order more?

Stones I am using are Norton India Medium and Norton Arkansas Translucent.

Re: Honing oil

#2

Re: Honing oil

Jeremy Osner

Looks like the cheapest source for it on the internet may be sharpeningsupplies.com...

Re: Honing oil

#3

Re: Honing oil

david weaver

Food supply - edible light mineral oil for the coarser stones (through india for me, and medium ark stones), and WD 40 for the fine stones.

The honing oils are overpriced light mineral oil. Generally, norton charges about the same for a pint as a commercial kitchen supply place will charge for a gallon.

odor free baby oil is next best (it's usually a medium weight mineral oil).

If you don't want to use something thin like Wd40 on a fine stone, you can wipe off most of the honing/mineral oil and leave a very thin film. Since the surface is oil, any accumulated blackness will come off easily with the introduction of another drop of oil.

The IM313 is a wonderful device if you ever manage to come across one used (it's an oil bath for larger stones). Not a necessity, but makes using the coarse stones a lot easier.

Re: Honing oil

#4

Re: Honing oil

Wiley Horne

How do you sharpen? Reason I ask: One of the very highest skills in all of woodworking is maintaining a flat bevel freehand. I stopped trying. If you don’t want to try to perfect this skill, you can make life enjoyable by hollow grinding. Or jig the tool.

If you are jigging or hollow grinding, but it’s still not happening, switch to waterstones or ceramic stones. Many good brands.

Even better, when you visit John A., he can show you.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Honing oil

#5

Re: Honing oil

Jeremy Osner

Thanks! Mineral oil is cheap and easy to find.

Re: Honing oil

#6

Need sharpening advice.....as a 10K planer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

David doesn't run 10K's, he planes them.

Re: Honing oil

#7

Re: Honing oil

Jeremy Osner

I haven't gotten to the point of re-grinding bevels yet... All my edge tools have the bevels they came with from the factory.

Last night I sharpened four carving gouges that I had been using with the edge they came with from the factory (!) and I can at least say that each of them is a lot sharper now than it was before I sharpened it. So while I may not be doing a perfect job yet I am getting somewhere... Also re-sharpened a thumb plane blade. Tonight I am going to do some chisels and my block plane.

I watched Maurice Fraser's video and found it useful.

Re: Honing oil

#8

Good for you!!


Re: Honing oil

#9

Never thought of it that way..

david weaver

but I'd guess a hand tool woodworker who was doing a lot of work (not me), would probably do that much each week.

In the recent spate of test planing, I did plane more feet than a 10k.

Re: Honing oil

#10

Re: Honing oil

John Aniano in Central NJ

Jeremy,

If you do make out to my shop, I can go over how I sharpen carving tools. Some can be a PITA, but the straight and bevel chisels, as well as 95% of the gouges are pretty easy. Short sweep gouges (the end of the tool is curved) can present problems too. The V-tools can be tricky as are the "macaroni" tools since they have multiple bevels that meet at angles. Just takes time to do.

I use my Tormek for the majority of the shaping, then go to diamond stones to round the bevels and get the edges nearly correct, then switch to Arkansas stones for the final steps. Then strop and test cross-grain cutting to see if the cut is nice and burnished. If not, figure out why and correct the problem. Easy, right?

To answer your honing oil question, I use odorless lamp oil. It is thinner than a heavier bodied oil like mineral oil, but it have it in a squeeze bottle on my bench all the time (I use it for "wet" sanding) so I grab it.

I've never used roller or similar sharpening jigs, but use whatever you need and are comfortable with to get the job done.

John

Re: Honing oil

#11

Re: Honing oil

Jim Matthews

I use 3in1.

"A little dab 'l do ya."

Re: Honing oil

#12

Re: Honing oil

Joe shelton

Well, that raises a question - what is lamp oil?

Is it a different grade of kerosene?

Re: Honing oil

#13

Re: Honing oil

David Bassett

A quick web search suggests: Yes.

One site says Lamp Oil is in the same family as Kerosene, but is more purified to eliminate the odor and burn cleaner. Further, it says it doesn't burn as bright as kerosene.

Re: Honing oil

#14

Thanks, David


Re: Honing oil

#15

Re: Honing oil

Pat Riley

I used 3 in 1 for 30 years.

In the last few years I have changed to Light Mineral Oil - only because it is much less expensive.

You can get a gallon ( I was teaching some classes on free hand sharpening, so I needed a bunch - and am still using it) at a vet supply place for between $15 and $20 dollars. Should last several lifetimes.

https://www.valleyvet.com/ct_detail.html?pgguid=30e078e9-7b6a-11d5-a192-00b0d0204ae5&sfb=1&itemguid=3269d80c-7b6a-11d5-a192-00b0d0204ae5&utm_content=11738&ccd=IFF003&CAWELAID=120295250000087149&CATARGETID=120295250000178974&cadevice=c&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIpeyviJef5AIVlLfsCh3l3wCZEAQYASABEgLdy_D_BwE

https://www.tractorsupply.com/tsc/product/ideal-animal-health-mineral-oil-light

Re: Honing oil

#16

Re: Honing oil

Pat Riley

If you are starting all over, switch to diamond stones. Initial cost is higher, but you only need water and they are awesome.

Re: Honing oil

#17

If your shop is damp

Jim Matthews

My shop (below grade, Coastal Massachusetts) is damp year round.

While my new hybrid hot water heater helps (it's a glorified air conditioner), water is to be avoided around my tools.

If rust is a concern, light oil lubricants work fine on diamond stones, too.

Re: Honing oil

#18

Re: Honing oil

William Duffield

20 weight non-detergent motor oil.

Re: Honing oil

#19

Re: Honing oil

AlanWS

Lots of oils work, but the best I've used is trombone slide oil. It does not smell, and is a nice low viscosity. Other than the smell, kerosene and WD-40 are fine.

Re: Honing oil

#20

Re: slide oil

David Weaver

Slide oils are usually mineral oil or paraffin oil, sometimes things like stearic acid or palmitic acid with oils if they're not mineral or paraffin oil based (strange combination of acids - looks like a recipe for a soap base).

The benefit to paraffin oil is that you can put it in your trains and make them smoke (supposing they have a smoke system) :\

Re: Honing oil

#21

Trombone slides

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The trombone world has grown more sophisticated/complex since I played. We all used cold cream, wiped on, then nearly wiped off. Worked fine.