Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Experimenting with XHP

Posts

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#26

Re: growth rate?

David Weaver

Orientation with beech and cherry also affects hand sawing, as I'd imagine Warren and Brian would confirm noticing

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#27

Pitiful

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Earlier today you wrote, "However, I remain skeptical about the difference in dulling of heartwood vs sapwood". I gave tulip poplar as an example of a timber with different working characteristics between heartwood and sapwood.

You wrote five paragraphs to say that you had never noticed the difference between sap and heart in poplar. When we work with hand tools we notice this kind of thing.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#28

Heart thrown away.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When we say that the heart is thrown away, we are generally talking about the wood near the center of the tree that has rings with small radius, higher proportion of knots, juvenile wood, etc. Not that all the heartwood is thrown away.

On a large log, the wood that is three to five inches from the center is the "heart". The higher quality portion of the log could still be mostly heartwood.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#29

Re: Tree to tree differences

Larry Barrett

I have been reading these threads with interest but have not not had much to contribute. I use oak a lot in chairmaking (white, red, black, chestnut) and after riving out billets, most work is with a drawknife/spokeshave (so some similarity to planing wood) . In the initial stages, the wood contains a lot of moisture and the main idea is to remove the sapwood as quickly as possible. With wet wood it is usually very easy to work on the ray planes and not much harder to work on the growth ring plane in the heartwood. But regardless of the species, the most tenacious wood by far is the sapwood, and in particular the sapwood that is in the growth ring right at the juncture with the heartwood.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#30

Re: Heart thrown away.

david weaver

In the case of the planemakers, the text was clear that "a thin layer" or some other such test of the sort was used for the planes and the rest discarded.

Whether or not someone would use the salvage heart at the center for something else wasn't clear.

If we're building something out of beech now, I don't think there's a great reason to do that. It must've been the luxury of having large numbers of old growth trees whereas finding beech stands now is fairly difficult in a lot of places.

There is a stand near me on township land that has many trees in the 20-48" center main stem diameter, but many are laid over going to waste since it lasts almost no time before spalting. That's irrelevant to this, though - my main issue is that I actually liked the feel of the heart better, it feels more durable, and learned about this use of the sap only much later. Stands at home and here are filled with mostly red oak, maybe some novelty softwood trees and a mix of cherry/maple/hickory. Plus, horizon lumber is my wood supplier for 16/4 beech and nearly all of their supply is mixed sap and heart.

I had never seen a large stand of beech trees before seeing them on township land here (they're on a steep hillside). Given that this is Pennsylvania and that the state was stripped of trees to a great extent, I doubt that those beech trees are the kind mentioned in texts as dominating mature forests established for hundreds or thousands of years.

I would like to see an explanation as to why the text said most of the tree was discarded, whether it was stability, ease of working or what. I've never seen anything further and haven't looked further. I'll see if I can locate the reference (I take sentiment from things I've read, but am not good at remembering names or texts that things come from).

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#31

Tree centers, "the heart"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When commercially sawing a log except beech ( which is only sawn for RR ties which require the center/heart in the tie) the heart/center of the tree is "boxed. That is, boards are sawed on the 4 sides of the center until about a 4 x 4 or 4 x 5 remains. This center, or "boxed heart" is sold mainly for the large timbered parts of pallets. This juvenile wood is prone to cracking when it is dried and it is not good for much other than these pallet parts.

Beech is common here. It sprouts in shade and idles in shade awaiting some good tree to fall over or be cut upon which it springs to life and shades everything under it. After a couple of logging cycles it can become a dominant species. I regard it a forest weed. I have whacked dozens in our timberlands to free up space for a useful tree. Come visit and I will show you dozens I still need to whack. You can take home all you want.

Beech was common in the Adirondacks where the family hunted deer. It think it is common everywhere in the east. Want is uncommon is anyone motivated to harvest it other than for firewood.

BTW, do you know that the beech you are getting has or had not been steamed? It is easier to dry after steaming and less prone to splitting.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#32

I stand corrected

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I did notice a difference planing this heartwood with the bullet in it. Son in law loves the bullet in his chest of drawers.



However, when dovetailing these drawers I did not



And, when planing this drawer side I did not. Other's results may differ.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#33

Steaming...

david weaver

I understand the issue of the heart itself as it's normally described - the core of the tree used for its vertical strength (though not stable) in 4x4 posts, and prized in some japanese chisels to have centering in the handle.

I don't have a clue where my reading was, but this was a different discussion, as there would've been no reason to mention it if only the core of the tree was discarded. The sentiment was that makers had a preference for the sap layer around the outside of the tree used bark out. There must've been a reason to mention it, but it's probably lost.

If it was in whelan's book, I had that in PDF but was being a good citizen when it went back to reprint and discarded mine. I very well may have bought that book, too, which would've made it dumb to delete the PDF, but I don't remember.

The other planemaking books that I have are WPINCA, etc, and about the NY planemaking industry. I don't think it was in those, because I haven't read them in a really long time.

As far as steaming, horizon did steam some of the beech, and others they may not have. I would guess mine is probably steamed. The real issue for them is that the drying process is so slow with 16/4 that they ruined some trying to speed it up and decided at this point that it's not worth their trouble, so the last wood I got from them was european, probably from eastern europe (it's available cheaply by the cubic meter for anyone willing to get it at a terminal. $200 or something per cubic meter from eastern europe).

Using euro beech just isn't something I want to do much of. Not because there's anything wrong with it, just because I don't like the way it looks and we're making planes in the united states. I have been informed of all kinds of idiocy on my youtube page, though, such as "beech isn't a good enough wood for planes, it's only used for cheap planes in europe. Cherry is used for the better planes" (this is based on the lignum soled planes as somehow being definitive), as well as "american beech is much softer than european beech and not nearly as good for planes".

You cannot convince people who haven't actually done what they're asserting, and it's a waste of time to try.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#34

Re: I stand corrected

david weaver

I haven't noticed a difference in poplar, but it's so variable - some is like styrofoam.

Dark heart beech vs sap side, yes.

Cherry heart vs. sap, definitely.

Much of the literature floating around from the last century or so seems to be aimed at structural use, and I doubt the difference between heart and sap for many of the woods matter too much in a 2x4. I'm sure beech sap is relatively strong compared to poplar heart, and so forth.

Why planemakers would've used a small amount of sap and discarded (or let rot) a large amount of heart is probably more related to the cost of processing wood that wasn't absolutely wanted vs. wood that wasn't. I don't know enough about mill history to know when the cost of the lumber became a bigger factor than the cost of the processing.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#35

Re: Tree to tree differences

David Weaver

Thanks, Larry - you say they're similar in the ray plane and the ring plane when wet. Does it change at all when dry?

I don't know if it's universally true, but one of the things that I think makes cherry and beech easier to plane perpendicular to the rays is that the early wood tears some. If it tears a lot, then it takes a fine set to get a decent surface.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#36

That's fine work

Jim Matthews

My wife sex,

"You can tell a lot about a Man from his drawers."

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#37

Re: Tree to tree differences

John Schtroumpf

The heartwood and sapwood feels/works different on these pieces of poplar:


Re: Experimenting with XHP

#38

The solution to the heat..

david weaver

(this is a solution for the dumb. Not for people who have proper machining setups).

I am in the middle of cutting out two more irons, not much time each night to do it and for me without machine tools, it's a lot of filing, anyway.

The heat issue with the iron is that it can heat at a spot and then air harden quickly (like where a cut is being made). I rough cut stuff like this with a portable bandsaw inserted into a vise (held by the handle). Cheapie HF saw, works great.

I can tell when the saw is cutting that if I don't move fast enough, the steel will harden ahead of the blade, but luckily, unlike the drill, I can power through it and get back on track.

The drilling solution is simple. If you have no mill, you drill a series of holes down the slot area ever so slightly further apart than the bit width and then hand file out the rest. It's not as bad as it sounds, but with XHP, the start to finish process may take 2 hours. More importantly, it doesn't use anything that I don't already have in the shop and it's cheap to do sans ruining bits on the first one.

$15 worth or round and flat files is probably enough to make 15 irons.

The bit heat is solved by marking the holes and drilling them a tiny bit at a time and moving from one to the next, within 5 minutes or so, all holes are drilled, no metal has hardened, and the mid dollar (but super high quality) norseman bits are still sharp.

I also put a couple of drops of water into the holes as they progress. When steam bursts out of the hole, I move on to the next one, dump out shavings, dribble water in and do it again.

Word to anyone who ever has an interest in doing something like this. your iron either needs to be in a holder or you need to be wearing a welding glove or something simple. If the bit grabs the iron, it'll come around and could probably cut you (I've never chanced this).

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#39

Re: The solution to the heat..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They make cutting fluids for this task. A quart is cheap from MSC or other places.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#40

Re: The solution to the heat..

david weaver

Yes, I think cutting fluids are good except I'm using the water as a cheat to indicate heat, and it's gone when I leave, so I don't have to clean it up.

Cutting fluids, etc, may prevent more of the heat in the first place and extend the life of the bit, but bit life isn't much of a problem as i can freehand sharpen the bits, and the big bits like 3/8" are very easy to freehand vs. the smaller ones.

oil based cutting fluids (i've never looked) or even water based, whatever they may be, probably come in all kinds of smoke points, but I did find out with Wd40 as a cheap substitute for one, once it's smoking, i'm pretty close to being in trouble with hardening on these irons.

Water is good in this case because the penalty for this stuff hardening (you can't remove the hardness by just bluing it to get to spring temper - it only loses a couple of points between 400 and 800F) is much greater than the time wasted drilling.

Not that I would mind having a mill and a constant trickle of fluid, but I'd hate to learn to use anything like that at this point.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#41

your life would be greatly simplified

Bruce, a MN Galoot

by a mill and a surface grinder :D

But you already knew that.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#42

Re: my great problem in life...

david weaver

is that my interest in making irons probably runs out after about 10 (other than necessity). Anything that I buy that works in higher volume but at great cost...

...well, I can never make the numbers that make it worthwhile.

Plus, i don't want to sell irons. I want to make them and keep them, or give one or two away here or there.

Getting a sheet, finding a mill and making all ten all at once and outsourcing the harder stuff to do by hand (heat treating, post heat treat surface grinding) would sure be less work, though.

(dirty secret, I kind of like filing steel to a mark, even though the general public considers such things as plane irons with hand done variation and lack of filth cleaned off after heat treat and tempering as crude. I'm crude!!).

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#43

Re: Tree to tree differences

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks, John. I was not prepared for the negative response i got previously.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#44

Re: Tree to tree differences

Larry Barrett

I don't do much chair work with kiln dried wood (except the rungs), but sometimes work with air dried wood (maybe 12%MC). This is always harder to work with than wood harvested from a recently opened log. But removing the sap wood with a drawknife is still the hardest task. And the toughest wood is always at the boundary with the heartwood. At least it seems this way because once you get into the heartwood the work is noticeably easier.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#45

Some of us value handwork

Jim Matthews

Many that straddle the eras of analog Bridgeport and CNC (I witnessed the swift demise of Cincinnati Milling Machine) value the subtle I fixations left by a skilled maker's hand. They're significant connections to those who came before us.

These are significant in their embodiment of patience, practice and products in the tangible World - lasting artifacts that our descendants will value.