Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Experimenting with XHP

Posts

Experimenting with XHP

#1

Experimenting with XHP

David Weaver

reading through smc posts, it looks like someone there, Patrick Chase, had an iron xrf-ed to find CTS-xhp as a likely candidate.

So, I read the heat treat sheet and it said something that I thought I could do by eye and kitchen oven. What i can't do is abide by the heat treat instructions because the stainless wrap impedes what I need to see.

So I just heated it very high by eye (shooting for dark yellow color before quenching in oil and broke a bunch of rules. It's not particularly pleasant to work by common tools like 01 is.

The cost of this stuff makes it not worth buying anything other than lvs finished irons, but I have a curiosity problem.

The surface yielded by this iron is much brighter on the same abrasive than o1, and the planing resistance is less.

The pile is beech sap, 3075 feet worth so far. I don't have more beech heart without ruining good wood.

I did damage two norseman has bits, though. A little bit of bit heat and the stuff hardens never to be annealed again by a home shop worker without threatening the fine carbides.

http://imgur.com/gallery/uLoKUJD

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#2

Re: Experimenting with XHP

David Weaver

Beech sap planes more easily than heart, by the way, thus the ridiculous number. Subjectively, I feel a fee hundred more feet in this iron, and then I will take a picture of the edge.

I'll need to make a second one to see if I just got lucky.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#3

Picture link probably wasn't obvious..

david weaver


3,075 feet worth of shavings


How do you spot a shop-made iron where the maker strugged? First part -shop made, rounded top edge. Struggle? Look at the later adjuster. It's off center because the slot isn't ideally made, but I have ideas to make the second one much neater. I have a serious distaste for irons where a square iron requires the lateral adjuster to be set way away from center. Once this iron started to air harden from over heating, it was downhill from there until I was cleaning the slot with a cutoff wheel in an angle grinder instead of filing it. Never a good sign.


A cherry edge - reflective, though the camera absolutely will not allow you to see reflections, I just tricked it a little into showing the top of the soda can reflecting on the edge. This is sharpened with a washita - this kind of shine is hard to get with carbon steel. I'm dumbfounded about why the iron leaves such a bright finish. Is it right at the limit of the washita? I don't know.

The biggest surprise so far has been 3,075 feet of shavings out of one sharpening without needing front hand pressure on the plane, albeit with very favorable wood (subjectively, the sap in this piece of beech feels more like cherry, but it accepts the iron edge at the beginning of the cut a little better (it's probably more dense).

I will finish this off tonight and see how many more feet it goes. At the outset, I was just hoping that it wouldn't make a worse house-made iron than O1.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#4

4046 feet and 920 grams planed

david weaver

a photo of the oil hardened xhp edge after it finally stopped cutting. Sharpened with a washita stone of all things, and no stropping.

This is not what we would've expected it to look like after breaking all of these rules hardening and tempering it.


Re: Experimenting with XHP

#5

Re: 4046 feet and 920 grams planed

Jonathan Elliott

Did you just stumble into a better steel than PMV11?? ;)

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#6

Re: 4046 feet and 920 grams planed

David Weaver

It feels the same, but I oil hardened it and I don't think anyone may be doing that.

It could also just be a much more favorable piece of beech, or maybe this iron will have a weakness that I haven't found yet.

The result and the edge picture not having the powdery look were unexpected. though.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#7

Controls and lessons from competition

Jim Matthews

"It could also just be a much more favorable piece of beech"

The Kezuroukai specifically selects lumber for the best possible outcome, to be used by all the participants.

I suspect you've got a good piece of steel AND a lovely stick of Beech.

****

To get uniform results, variable must be controlled.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#8

Re: Controls and lessons from competition

David Weaver

Absolutely. This needs both follow up head to head as well as repetition in making the iron to see if it's a fluke. I don't have enough sap left on this wood for a fair test with v11. The wear pattern on this iron is drastically different and the planed weight supports a difference, though. Subjectively, it's not much harder or softer.

Weight was added as a control to compare different boards, but it's not perfect. This is also why the original test was run in all heart.

It's drudgery to test something like this. Takes about a an hour to plane this distance and was the plane 200 times.

If someone has an iron lie Nielsen 4 and would like a bronze, I might like to switch.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#9

Who wants to come over to my garage...

david weaver

...and push two planes for potentially 7000 or 8000 feet of controlled planing?

Maybe a couple of repetitions.

Bring the wood, too.

I don't have enough left in this board for V11, but I do have enough left for the O1 iron and can get a same plane, same board, same sharpening method and shaving weight number.

Not my intention to see if I can make an iron that lasts with V11, it was my intention to see if I could make one that could come close. For the cost of making one, why? I guess ...well, why make wooden planes?

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#10

Perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I once worked for someone where I wrote lots of reports. It was insisted that each report begin with "The objective of this work/experiment/ whatever was .....". I chaffed at the tight boundary within which to write. But, I came to understand the requirement. Don't leave it up to the audience to decide what the objective is. They can make your work look like a failure when it isn't.

In the case at hand I am going to speculate that the objective was to see if David could make a functional blade from a steel highly regarded in the custom knife community. I think he has proven that he met the objective. No further claims have been made but we are all free to speculate. And as David has said, if you want to confirm your speculation do the work. It's not a requirement that David test other's speculation (though there is evidence he can be goaded into it ;) )

We all, including David, realize that variables in the wood will affect length of edge life. K&K showed that variation in grain angle+/- 10 degrees had a large effect, for example. Flat vs quartered likely has an effect. Early wood/late wood and species likely has a significant effect through density. Sapwood vs heartwood may have an effect (David and I are arguing about this factor). Hence, one blade can be quantitatively compared to another only by a careful test of the blades on the same stick of wood in an alternating shaving removal experiment. This procedure was done when David compared the various steels. In that experiment I think we have a reliable comparison of these steels.

The rest provided qualitative or semiquantitative trends of sharpening and steel properties that affect edge life. If one thinks a result could be useful use it and come to a conclusion. Some of what David has reported is so easy to implement that I will do it because the "cost" is small compared to the possible benefit.

Personally, David's work has and will change how I work. I plane in such short sessions, mostly fitting, that I never begin to get tired planing, nor do I feel dullness creeping up on me. I do get annoyed needing to sharpen unexpectedly, either because dullness crept up on me or the demands on the planing task changed. Halving these surprises will be a significant reduction in annoyance.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#11

for the record...

david weaver

...in our dispute about sapwood, I am the one saying that i think the results are overly rosy because sap beech is easier to plane than heartwood.

But I will also say I think there is a material difference between this iron and any of the other ones that I've planed with so far. when I was planing the last 1000 feet last night, I was giddy to see the edge picture at the end (late at night, I didn't take pictures of the edge progression to see what they'd look like - I expected that this iron may not be able to outlast the O1 iron because it wasn't that hard to sharpen), and hoping it would show something different.

I also knew and know there's a risk that I'll be labeled as a bullshitter by saying that I have an iron that planes 4000 feet.

I'm fairly confident that I could livestream a session planing if I know for sure that my phone would take an hour video without capping the video and shutting off (one of my older phones had an option to limit video size, and it burned me a couple of times in planemaking videos).

I am hoping this isn't just a fluke with this iron (did something migrate to the surface because it was heated open atmosphere and only quickly? Is it just in a spot of the iron and will the rest not wear this well? Will it wear off?).

Whatever the case is, this wood is not easier planing than cherry, and O1 on cherry, If I recall, planed 1000-1200 feet. This is worth following up on.

Worth enough that I have bought a sheet of this steel, ground. I may never use it, but won't hurt me to have it. The standard bar stock from the wholesaler is 2x36, which means I can't use it in my 7 and 8. Getting it in a wider quarter sheet (more or less) will allow me to make irons for my other planes.

it's not just that it planes longer than carbon steel, but it actually planes with less resistance, and as the picture shows, the edge wasn't really that fine from the start (i overestimated how fine the washita actually is) - like carbon steel, it "healed its edge" without forming defects around the grooves that get to the edge. I'll reserve going on about it too much longer until I can make a second iron that does the same thing. The "mule iron" here was very sloppily made, and I was considering what I'd do with the rest of this stick after I failed at making it neatly.

The real congratulations for this steel goes to carpenter. Apparently, the knife people aren't happy because this is a knife steel and the knife industry also isn't a big enough customer to get carpenter to make it in scads of sizes and keep it in stock everywhere.

I'm jumping pretty far ahead based on one iron, but if bar stock in thickness more like .125-.140 ground comes into stock, it will find its way into my infills, too.

There is a large part of me that I could probably live without, though, that still says "you're risking embarrassing yourself, you just got lucky with the first board, the next iron won't be like this, and you're one wood sample away with finding out what's defective with this iron". I had no expectations with this one other than hoping to better the O1 iron, though, so that embarrassment issue is pretty minimal.

As far as "real life planing" with contaminants, etc. I'm fairly sure a stray abrasive particle or bunch of dirt would ruin the edge on this iron just as fast as anything else. I don't have sterile conditions in this shop, and there are metal particles right in the bench top next to this because I use a portable bandsaw in the vise on the sharpening bench. I consider worrying about things like that too much (super clean shop) to get in the way of my imagination and sense of what's materially important, though.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#12

House 01 - 2224 feet, 475 grams

David Weaver

It looks like the secret wasn't in the iron, it was in the sapwood, which we didn't use in the other test. It's super friendly to hand planing.

Sort of a balloon popper!

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#13

Re: House 01 - 2224 feet, 475 grams

Wiley Horne

Wasn’t the ratio of HouseO1:PMV11 earlier about the same as HouseO1:XPS in this run? If so, the feet planed were just scaled up due to easier planing wood. Would also indicate your homebrew heat treat compares OK with commercial mehods.

Wiley

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#14

Re: House 01 - 2224 feet, 475 grams

David Weaver

That pretty much sums it up. In the ballpark ratio-wise. Earlier was 2 to 1, this is slightly less, but hard to tell either way.

Sap beech would be a bad choice for planing to failure testing, though!

The favorable wear pattern on the other picture may just be a matter of favorable wood. I'll remember to take more pictures of the edge here in the near future. As this test has wound down and now I'm interested in making a few irons of XHP, it'll just occur along side of getting back to building guitars, and scribbling together the report of the findings in the other numbered tests so that we can post them somewhere with the pictures.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#15

AND.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It demonstrates the reliability of David's work and conclusions while learning something about the importance of the test specimen. I am please with the consistency of all this data.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#16

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

was it just sap wood vs heart or was there a grain difference?

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#17

Re: AND.....

David Weaver

Everything that seems outlandish has something else that goes with it that brings it back to earth.

The article that you sent me about the "trash" that trees pack in their heartwood cells, I wonder if that's what the issue is here in terms of abrasion.

I still haven't snipped two pieces off of the same board to get sap vs. heart specific gravity, but I'll do that at some point.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#18

Re: question

David Weaver

level grain like test one. Some of these boards have darker heart. This one is all sap in the planing test, but the heart on the other side of the board isn't particularly dark. Not sure if the board is just less dense in general, but the O1 iron planed more mass of sap in this test than the V11 iron did of heart in the first test.

I can only speculate about whether or not it's the difference in heart vs. sap or board vs. board, or both. I think it's probably both.

The second board that I planed had upward sloping grain, but it was still heart (but lighter heart than the first board). That was the board that I used for the 3v vs. v11 vs. m4, and it also planed more favorably (but nothing like the sap in this test).

Separate side fact - the O1 iron is definitely harder than the XHP iron. Not by too much, but it's actually easier to roll up a burr on the XHP iron. I will have to do the next two at a lower temper temperature. I don't want it much harder, but a tiny bit might be worthwhile. I think 25 degrees F will gain about 1 C on the rockwell scale. I'd have to guess this one at 60/61 at most.

After subjecting the tested O1 iron to the washita again, I think it's probably at least 62.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#19

Tree to tree differences

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

K&K showed that dulling is proportional to wood density. Makes sense. More solid stuff in the way of the blade tip, and hence less air, more stuff to rub and dull.

I sawed a walnut a few years ago whose wood is as light and soft as pine. Growth rings are not unusual. It is just light. I have some white oak that is as mellow as poplar. As a demonstration I was able to easily drive a #4 finish nail into it. And I have white oak so dense that it bent hardened flooring nails. I'll bet there is a large difference in how these boards dull.

Details of growth will change the ratio of early wood to late wood. Given the cell structure is different the planing could be. And K&K saw a large difference in dulling affected by grain slope. Grain that promoted tear-out dulled less because the wood was splitting ahead of the blade tip and there was less rubbing. Grain the opposite direction would spring against the blade and cause more friction.

However, I remain skeptical about the difference in dulling of heartwood vs sapwood. I found nothing in the literature to suggest a difference in density for the same tree. The garbage the tree deposits is composed of organic chemicals that are not abrasive, unless corrosive abrasion is a factor, which seems unlikely for a stainless steel. But we are faced with a substantial difference between two boards that has some explanation. A curiosity, but not one that affects David's conclusions.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#20

Re: Tree to tree differences

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would say there is a correlation between hardness and dulling. We certainly notice some woods that are rougher on the edge than some others that are more dense. As an example, a wood that is stringy tends to beat up the edge.

Tulip poplar, Liriodendron tulipifera, is a good example of a wood that has very different working characteristics between heartwood and sapwood, both for planing and chiseling. Hand tool woodworkers have a strong preference here.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#21

Re: Tree to tree differences

david weaver

I would say, do the following: Next time you find beech, don't discard it, but cut it, look at the heartwood. If it's light or dark, save a few boards from it. Nothing fancy, just a few.

Do the same again until you find a tree that's opposite (where the heartwood is substantially lighter or darker than the first.

Kiln dry the wood, and then hand plane the two samples. In my estimation, the density won't be that different. None of my beech seems noticeably different, but so far, the darker the heart, the more resistant it seems to be planing.

I have tracked three here for sure:

* First beech test - board with very dark heart - shortest planing lengths and least weight. The board had sort of a dusty feel when planing. I didn't plane the sap, it's saved for moulding plane blanks.

* second beech test - board with heart that was lighter - longer planing lengths, and planed weights probably 50% higher than the first, same sharpening method

* sap planing here with the last two irons - sap only, board with lighter heart (similar in color to the second beech test board, but planing the sap side in this case). more feet and more weight planing.

I couldn't tell you exactly why that is, but it's noticeable. I think there are two things happening - 1, the wear is occurring faster than the density differences (proportionally) and the harder heart of the first board probably got to a point where the blade wouldn't enter the wood without help a lot earlier even at the same geometry.

Looking at the results here, the beech sap planes longer than cherry. I don't think cherry presents more wear, but I think it's got more spring and takes a slightly sharper iron to get the plane into.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#22

Poplar- a differing lumber

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We sold no wood more different tree to tree than poplar and it is not all to do with growth rings (rate of growth). With one exception, I never personally logged any poplar that was turned into wood I dried and used. So, this information is 2nd hand but from persons that ran saw mills. They spoke of "deep woods poplar" and "field poplar". When I bought logs for turning into secondary wood and drawer sides they would choose logs from trees they knew grew close among neighbors in the woods. The wood was soft and mellow to work. Field poplar, trees that grew in more open territory, was harder, denser, and more brittle texture. And there is "Cucumber" (a magnolia) which is graded in with poplar. It is substantially harder and miserable to work. None of this information is of much use to someone buying from the local lumber distributer where you get what you get with no knowledge of the provenance.

Then there is the "poplar from hell". I would love to engage someone knowledgeable in wood structure to discuss what about this wood results in its unique properties. It was a monster tree that grew near Greenville, SC. It grew at least its later life as a yard tree uncrowded by neighbors with a moderate growth rate. It was removed and I was given permission to saw pieces of it that I sawed and split and sawed some more into rift and quartered drawer side stock about 26" long. The remains were destined for firewood.

Poplar normally splits easily. The dried firewood sections from this tree would not split. In fact, drawer side trimmings, a mere 7/16" thick, only reluctantly split and the split surface has hundreds of torn fibers that connect to the adjacent split surface. It is not curly. It just has some fiber structure that ties the vertical grain together.

I can't be fussy about heartwood/sapwood in my use of poplar. I have at hand what I have, and it gets used. Drawer sides will often have some of each. Hence, I am often dovetailing and drawer fit planing boards with both. Personally, I never detected any difference. I use up sapwood in walnut and cherry as secondary wood. This secondary wood often has mixed heartwood and sapwood. Again, I never noticed a difference in working properties within a board. Not denying they exist, just that I don't detect them in what I do and maybe most won't either.

A board with mostly, or all heartwood, would have come from a large old tree, or one that grew slowly, which could lead to differences. A board with all sapwood could come from a rapid growth tree (field poplar). Given the sized logs I see on trucks now days it is likely the poplar at the local lumber source is all or mostly sapwood and came from relatively young, fast growth trees. Thirty years ago we would get poplar boards wider than 12" in our wholesale packs of lumber and they would have substantial heartwood. Now lumber this wide, even in poplar, is rare because the big trees are rare.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#23

Re: Poplar- a differing lumber

david weaver

Cherry sap is something you'll feel a difference in. It's the easiest to feel with a jack plane and a cambered iron in a bigger cut. It has a feel similar to soft maple or poplar in a jacking cut, and you can turn the board over and plane the other edge to feel the difference.

Beech sap only feels a little different - both heart and sap are smooth, but heart provides more planing resistance, especially if it's dark.

I read that article about heart and sap again this morning and noticed that the writer chose their words carefully "in beech with white heartwood". I'm guessing that trees differ from one to another just based on the fact that (to my eye), some have a nice pleasing very reddish/dark brown heart. But that part of the tree was forgone by planemakers until recently (not sure what larry and steve do, but I will build a half sap, half heart plane or an all heart plane without thinking too much about it. As the wood ages, the color difference disappears pretty quickly.

The heart was, as described in an old text, thrown away. It may have had something to do with plane weight, as i've had exactly one plane that I could identify as all heart (that I didn't make myself - there's about a pound or pound and a half difference in an all sap beech try plane vs. one that's all heart) - it was an old jointer from new england, 10 1/2 pounds (28 inches long). I ended up selling it to someone who might like a plane that heavy.

I also got a larger plane at the same time (same dimensions, except 1/4" wider iron). It was all sap like most, but especially light (I get the sense that sap beech can lose weight over time - is it volatiles leaving? I don't know. It was 7 1/2 pounds. Similar growth ring size between the two, but I no longer have them to compare. I got them from MJD tool auction before I learned my lesson.

The one other thing that i notice with beech (and I could be wrong, but I think this is correct) is that side checking of the wood when making planes happens more easily with heart. I wouldn't be surprised to find that the heart was discarded by makers due to both being more difficult to work and being more susceptible to checking during making or before sale (after sale would create a problem, too, I guess). Best way to slow down problems with that is to get a billet sized and get the plane made quickly, but I learned that while making planes in the winter, if the forecast called for near zero temperatures, I'd better wax the flat face of a billet in process or there was a fair chance I'd find a side check in it, even when the ends are sealed.

All that aside, the working properties of the different sticks so far have been, well, different. The dustiness of the shavings was greater on the darker heart, and the wood offered greater planing resistance. I don't know that these things could be noticed easily without hand planing, but when you're hand resawing and hand jacking plane billets, the differences lead to effort, and someone exceptionally lazy like me (or maybe just oversensitive, maybe that's what it is) will notice them fairly quickly.

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#24

growth rate?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Late wood is probably more dense even in woods not ring porous. Therefore, a faster growing tree could be more dense. What did the rings look like in these test specimens?

Re: Experimenting with XHP

#25

Re: growth rate?

David Weaver

All similar. Quartered orientation was dead on for the first board and less so for each subsequent one. As we discussed elsewhere, it's much easier to plane beech perpendicular to growth rings than parallel.