Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

V11 vs. O1 end grain

Posts

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#26

One problem with that...

david weaver

..I'm sure there is some case for a lower angle easing some of the wear in shooting if clearance allows.

However, bill has been troubling me over email (i don't mind) by stating there can be quality issues with irons at lower values because steve found them especially with A2 in long grain.

A2 cannot operate ideally in long grain at 30 degrees, so there is no reason to believe it would tolerate end grain well at all at 30 degrees.

In the case in my test, I'm not dealing with that, the planes cut well with the charlesworth sharpening method, and everything is locked down tight in a high quality plane with the cap iron set relatively close (which is near where it would be in daily use - I don't adjust a plane when I'm planing the end of a sawn panel to the mark, whatever it was set at for smoothing, it stays set at that).

What I didn't mention to bill (because this exchange went while I was having a pity party for myself over how much work it was to do the end grain test due to the actual duration) is that I leave an edge at 33 degrees by experience when freehand sharpening. I have one set that I do, so the idea of accommodating a couple of alloys and then having a bunch of other setups for steels that will tolerate something else - it's not an overall improvement for me. Bill is looking for something different in this test - he wants a blueprint for picking one iron and one process and finding the iron and the angle and the process that makes that one single setup last the longest in feet planed. I get it, but it's beyond the scope of what I"m looking at where I'd suggest most people use one setup, one set of sharpening gear and sharpen everything the same with few exceptions (my chisels are finished at a lower angle most of the time, and the shooting plane blade is sharpened close to its primary bevel because the bed is 40 degrees. I sharpen it little enough that I don't find it annoying. It's also got such a wide primary bevel that sharpening it on the bevel is something that a grandmother could walk into my shop and do without any prior experience (i still bias the final finish up slightly due to knowing that finish quality is paramount).

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#27

Re: Comment

david weaver

there is probably a reason for that. But, in cherry..

* the BU plane would need more wax more often

* veritcal alignment with the type is more problematic (which is a problem planing something in a vise), and

planing the ends of long panels in medium hardwoods over here is just less effort with the stanley due to those things. Not to mention, it requires no screwing around with a separate plane.

One more situation that makes me annoyed with the forum wisdom, because there was a time where the general advice was block plane or BU plane for end grain. Woe be to the person who would ever think about completing the amount of work that I did yesterday with a block plane. They'd have arthritis. On a board of this width, which is typical of a long drawer, a larger plane like a bu jack (Which was the recommendation for a while) is awkward. The #4 is superior. I don't have the luxury of a crosscut sled or anything of the sort to minimize use of the plane or take the equivalent of a few very slow controlled wood show type shavings.

The BU jack can work, but it's not as good, and the workpiece needs to be larger (putting more work back over to the shoot board) for it not to be awkward. On the ends of panels, the lower weight and smaller footprint of the #4 and its fine proficiency for planing end grain makes it better. I'd guess that if I was a historical reader, I'd find that most endgrain work was done in a vise with a full sized smoother, and only small precise or thin work was done with planes like strike blocks.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#28

David ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... all this is about as opposite to my experience as can be.

* the BU plane would need more wax more often

I use these planes as well. I have extensive experience with BU planes, and sticky is very far from the description I would use. In fact, I have described them as having a low centre of effort and that this facilitates less force being needed compared to BD planes (with the same cutting angle).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#29

Re: One problem with that...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A2 cannot operate ideally in long grain at 30 degrees, so there is no reason to believe it would tolerate end grain well at all at 30 degrees.

That does not accord with my experience, David. I have years and years of using A2 steel with 25 degree bevels in a LA Jack shooting end grain. I cannot recall when it chipped. More recently, I completed tests with the Veritas Shooting Plane with the same blades and angle, and it lasted and lasted.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#30

Re: One problem with that...

david weaver

Your definition of chipped and mine are far apart in particle size then. The trouble is, it's not just catastrophic chipping (that splits a shaving) that reduces edge life significantly, but very small chipping at an edge.

Brian has found the same thing that I have, and so has Steve Elliot. Steve has produced it in controlled testing, specifically pinpointing the angle where it ceases to occur.

As far as the lower center of effort discussion, it has never been a smaller amount of work or soreness for me physically with the BU planes. Discussing angles is good for diagrams, but I would leave anyone using BU planes in the dust for several reasons, and i'm not exactly a physical specimen. I tried that route, actually for a fairly long period and then off and on until I finally had no use for the planes. There was instantly clarity on why a lot of the older tools are the way they are once my shop session started to consist of 90% of the volume of work being done with hand tools and 10% with power tools vs. the other way around. Bu plane always ended up being more work and more soreness in actual use, and less apt and capable when it comes to the user manipulating them to adjust something (like biasing the vertical component in a plane). If the BU planes were less effort, I'd still be using them. I am exceptionally lazy once my curiosity is satisfied.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#32

Re: One problem with that...

David Weaver

I see the same formation of lines on end grain. But, in this test, none.

Bill sounds like he's going to experiment with some of my parameters and compare shooting to vise work at the same time. I hope he reports what he finds.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#33

BU

Wiley Horne

Derek,

You’re bringing to our attention the big advantage of BU planes in mitering, where the edge is subject to less unsupported shear than in the BD case. So much so that A2 does not chip in your testing. The result with A2 perhaps underlines the advantage of the BU geometry for mitering, based on the line of force and the greater support of the edge.

After all, the BU plane was developed in Britain and Germany back in the day, specifically for mitering.

Wiley

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#34

Re: BU

David Weaver

That's not Derek's only contribution to this, either. While we're not agreeing on day to day end grain planing, my shootenstein is better because of the advice that it would hold up fine at 40 degrees bevel down.

Bill asked last night if I would add a2 to this test if it didn't go long. But it did.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#35

varibles affecting this experiment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Planing end grain could be like chiseling dovetail waste. Pound on the chisel with a coarse cut and steel hardness and toughness will be tested. Or it could be like planing long grain where abrasion resistance is paramount and toughness and resistance to deflection are unimportant beyond a modest threshold.

Before David started I predicted the two steels would be similar on end grain because the greater abrasion resistance of V11 would be unimportant. I seemed to be right but likely for the wrong reasons. I'll bet the wear geometry on these blades is substantially difference from flat grain. Or simply, the blade is passing across much less material per foot on end grain. End grain is largely air space.

Where in the range of these challenges to edge life one finds one's self is going to depend on the wood and technique and a host of details. I can see now that my puny edge life likely stemmed from several important details that differed from David's experiment. The edge of my shooting plane blade looks like a dull chisel, not a dull plane blade. David has identified ways to improve.

I got suckered into buying a low angle block plane for end grain. I'm "dull" from using it after only a few feet.It sits unused if I can get something with a handle to work.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#36

I tried it.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I tried duplicating David's results. I am at 701 feet. I could keep going if someone thinks it is important to know if it can top 800 feet or not. This is not the way we usually plane.

I used a Stanley V logo iron (c. 1915) sharpened at 30 degrees, flat bevel. Might predate O1 steel. Stanley Handyman smoothing plane (1973). Prunus serotina.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#37

Re: I tried it.

david weaver

Thank you, Warren. Getting these results are part setup and part control of the plane. Thanks partially to your encouragement over time, I have learned to control a plane and get more out of it than I ever thought I could.

Like you say, things will continue (cut wise) if you're willing to abuse yourself. The O1 was still cutting when I stopped, but the force required was getting extremely high and putting me in pain. V11 was skipping at the beginning of the cut at that point, and that's not recoverable, but after that number of feet, who cares...i'd have sharpened half of the way through. Same for O1 - it cut the whole time with no damage, but 2 minutes of sharpening probably would've yielded a huge gain in lack of wear and tear on the user.

I was surprised by this result, but I've never tried to quantify it, and knew it would cause some static - static that would go away if other people just tried the same. I think as a result of this, more people who are not expert planers will be confident that they can put wood in a vise and plane the end to a mark. Their satisfaction in the shop will increase because of it.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#38

Re: varibles affecting this experiment

david weaver

I, too, bought the low angle block plane. An inexpensive one, as well as a LN 60 1/2 (the other was a stanley 60 1/2, vintage). They both worked OK. The LN lasted longer in work.

For all but the smallest work, they are absolutely the wrong tool for the job, fatiguing a user and possibly flat out having the wrong thing in the user's hand if the job is more than just cosmetic touch up on a tiny surface.

Both of mine are now long gone. I still have a stanley 18, but I couldn't tell you anything that I've done with it that I couldn't do with a one hand grab on a stanley 4. It has probably planed about 75 feet in five years, mostly because I think it's novel looking and once in a while, I look at it more closely to make sure it's not rusting while the bottom is hidden under it.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#39

Re: I tried it.

Wiley Horne

That adds a lot, Warren. Extends the results. I would suggest David include your comment and result verbatim in the appropriate portion of his report.

Wiley

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#40

Re: David ..

Brian Holcombe

Same experience as David, much prefer a #4 or Japanese plane for end grain.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#41

picture of what you are planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


You are planing mostly air. I guess we should not be surprised that the wear rate was less so long as deformation and chipping was avoided. Never-the-less I was surprised. Must avoid chipping and deformations.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#42

Re: picture of what you are planing

David Weaver

well, that makes me feel like I've accomplished less.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#43

Re: Comment

Kees

A few years ago I posted on smc about the exaggerated reverence to the shooting board nowadays. I got a lot of flak :D Then I searched in the many old books online about woordworking and found that the shootingboard was originally a device to help with mitering and being used in marquetry and such where they work with very thin and narrow stuff. Only late into the industrial revolution the shooting board seems to get more attention for bench work too.

Of course we knew all along that a handplane in the normal position is way more comfortable then laying it flat on its side...

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#45

Use of the shooting board

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a healthy lazy streak so I tend to do whatever I find efficient to get something made and in service Where I wind up, of course, depends on what I know, what I can successfully do and what I have to do it with. For me a plane is the best way to remove small increments of wood in a controlled fashion to achieve a perfect fit. This need appears often in building case furniture.

Over time as I became familiar with a shooting board and acquired a plane that worked well on one (LV shooting plane) I found I was using this device ever more. I now use this device so much in building case furniture that it stays in arms reach of the bench. Derek, who also builds case pieces, seems to have arrived at the same conclusion.

David has shown a way to plane end grain but I will find little application for it. I do understand that mounting something with end grain in a vise and planing to a line works well, but I rarely would encounter this need for what I do. I will however, as a result of his work, take more care to change my technique on the shooting board to prolong edge life.

My use of the shooting board falls into two situations- adjusting an end to some angle (90, 91, 45, etc) and trimming to length. I used to diddle with cross cut (power) sawing to get perfect square ends or adjust an angle to fit something not 90 degrees. I find it easier to get mostly square ends and ensure a fit by a quick "shoot" across the ends. As an example I now "shoot" the ends of drawer sides to ensure they are square and to "polish" the end to see scribe lines better.

A similar application involves miters. I find it difficult to get perfect sawed miters, or I am mitering to a case that is 89 1/2 degrees on some corner. Again, rather then diddle with the saw I just saw and shoot to get the angle right.

A combination application is installing cock beading where I am trimming to length and adjusting a miter rough sawed to length and angle.

Another application is fitting. I am frequently fitting some piece between two existing pieces. I like a fit tight enough that it stays in place before gluing or nailing. No better way for me than to saw approximately to length and shoot to fit.

An exception is fitting doors. These are done with the door mounted in the bench vise and my "go to" #5 Stanley.

Now that I know how to prolong edge life planing end grain I expect to use a shooting board even more. Without the handy ergonomics of the LV plane I doubt I would be shooting nearly as much.

Summary- I encounter lots of opportunities for end grain length and angle adjusting. The handy ergonomics of the LV plane and shooting board becomes, for me, the best way to meet the need.

Thank you again David for the information that will lessen my time spent sharpening.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#46

Yeah? Well you're still wrong!!!

david weaver

Just kidding!

Laziness led me away from the shooting board. The kind that means I only need to mark a board, put it in the vise, plane it, and if it's not critical, I don't even need to mark both sides.

No switching planes, no walking around. Just plane it. Some of my old woodies have their limitations in terms of wood hardness, but I'm not usually working with them on the end grain, AND I don't use most of the woods that are stringy or porous because they're not pretty and not nice to use with hand tools.

If I wasn't so cheap, I'd buy an XHP (thick) blank and taper the entire thing on the end of the belt sander and put a hollow in it and throw it in a try plane. But, the irons that I have in the try plane now are so dry feeling that they are far too satisfying to sharpen, and they probably still last for a straight half hour of planing before needing a resharpening.

In this end grain test, I would've appreciated blades that lasted half as long or less in end grain so that I could have an excuse to stop and sharpen.

i did buy one .094" since finding out the likely suspect and am curious to see how a shade tree person can quick the hardening and tempering (oil harden in a stainless sleeve and then temper in the oven twice without any of the strict scheduling. XHP's schedule gives a heating range of 150 degrees F, which is wide enough to judge temperature before quench just by eye. There really area a lot of attractive things about it other than the price and limited supply.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#47

It's interesting that what we're finding..

david weaver

....with this relatively brief study is a lot of things we weren't really looking for.

I doubt at the outset of this, you were looking to find a way to extend the edge life of your planes in end grain.

I wasn't looking to change my technique or even use V11 in the long term (that's still up in the air). I wanted to view a whole bunch of other things that I may still view (like pictures of failures around sharpening errors, the effect of dragging a plane in duration instead of lifting...actually, i may do that tonight while I still have a little bit more heart left in the beech test board. Anyway, the effect of setting a plane down with some vim a few times on a bench top (I still lay my planes on their sides. It'll never make a difference in duration, but I can imagine I could deflect a fresh edge).

At any rate, I'm super thankful that Phil was nice enough to provide me with a proper cast lap (with some heft, even) - something he didn't have to do. It's just dandy, and I will continue to use it. I will be working the backs of irons on it pretty much no matter what. The test last night with washita and 1 micron back honing confirms what I suspected - little sharpening effort, edge life as good as a black ark (I have two black ark stones that are as good as any arkansas stone in the world - I've been through probably 20 trans and black stones before getting them).

I also learned through you guys that my fascination with protecting edges has probably paid off at least in some cases (using shooting planes and planing end grain). Laziness prevents me from wanting to go back and sharpen those planes to remove quality issues, and quality issues often end up affecting longevity. Maybe not on average on the long run, but two or three failing edges in a row is enough to start throwing hammers across the shop.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#48

Re: Yeah? Well you're still wrong!!!

Kees

Wow, you're brave to try! I would be so anxious to do everything wrong and end up with a warped potato chip and a lot of money down the drain.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#49

That's what Research is all about`

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unanticipated discoveries that are a joy to find and often useful.

Re: V11 vs. O1 end grain

#50

Picture also shows why gluing end grain is weak

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When gluing end grain there is little wood to wood mating. It is mostly wood to air mating with a correspondingly weaker joint. Think gluing a bundle of soda straws end to end vs. edge to edge.