Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Recommendations for grinder/wheel

Posts

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#26

If you were working entirely by hand..

David Weaver

..you'd go through that pink wheel a lot faster. Trust me.

You can't really get a sense for the advantage of CBN without actually using it.

I had sort of a sick feeling when I ordered my wheel because I thought I was just being a pig and chancing getting a gimmick. Mine was $125. I had a pink wheel before that had lost a half inch of diameter per year. Starting with a 6" wheel, I just didn't really feel like dealing with that.

The pink wheel was a camel brand wheel, which probably isn't top of the line, but it wasn't junk, either.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#27

Re: Does anyone here have the

bridger berdel

I have that grinder with someone else's cbn wheel on it. It works fine, though the tool rests are a bit cheesy

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#28

Re: Well I missed it

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't want to miss an opportunity. What did I miss?

For $30 I added a wheel to a grinder I already owned that does what is needed . I have never burned an edge and none of the people I have taught to use it have burned an edge.

Bill, this is is what I wrote earlier:

"Heat and speed aside, an advantage of the CBN wheel is that it does not require any maintenance. The wheel does not change shape, does not need resurfacing, which means that set up does not alter".

Consider that you have set up the pink wheel to grind at 30 degrees (this is an option for many, myself for example) ...

The pink wheel will wear, require resurfacing, as well as and general maintenance. The 30 degree set up will change and need to be reset. Not a big deal, perhaps, but consider this ...

The CBN never needs any attention and the set up can remain permanently. For many years longer than a pink wheel.

Whether this interests you, or not important, it will be for others. For owners of a Tormek, such as Wiley, it is a huge advantage. For Dave (whom I turned onto this wheel - and knowing Dave, that is a big statement!) and I, the CBN on an 8" bench grinder was a game changer for sharpening.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#29

For those experiencing significant maintenace

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Derek, you have stated several times that you had to grind at 46 or some coarse grit to avoid burning. This fact puts your grinding in another universe from mine. I can now grind at 3600 rpm with my 120 grit wheel, even on a thin Stanley blade. I am unsure the variable(s) that is different. Probably wheel hardness. Maybe crown? Tool pressure? Technique? Hard wheels need frequent resurfacing and are prone to burn.

If your wheel maintenance was even worthy of mention you again are in a different universe. If someone is having noteworthy maintenance they aren't doing something optimally.

I lightly touch the 120 grit wheel with a diamond dresser rarely. Grit shed typically keeps the wheel cutting. At worse I see a hint of black accumulating on the top of the wheel crown. I expect I would grind for a year or more before a grind angle would change a degree. In any case it is unimportant. Before I turn the machine on I spin the wheel by hand to see that the scratches are in the center of the tool bevel. Adjustment is a whack on the tool rest with the plane or chisel blade, if necessary.

We don't know that your CBN wheel will last longer than my pink one. I'm doubtful it will. The one advantage of a CBN wheel that could be of significance is grit shed. My wheel sheds and needs to be located where loose grits flying about are not a problem. If I could not locate my grinder remote from where wood is worked I would be attracted to the CBN wheel.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#30

Re: Does anyone here have the

david weaver

Do they have detents on them like the cheaper ryobi, et al grinder with two piece aluminum rests?

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#31

Lifetime...

david weaver

from what I've seen so far, the CBN will last several multiples of a pink steel, and reduce the necessity of light touch that you mention.

the surface across mine (not crowned) is also perfectly flat, and that allows literally just setting a chisel right on the wheel, and leaving it in situ with light pressure, planing a perfect little hollow without any movement. That's an exceptionally lazy thing, and since it's not moving, it *does* require light pressure that working off of the edges of the wheel does not.

It's better. It's not necessary, but it's superior.

However, it would seem that the absence of grit would make it OK to have it located close to a work area. The metal filings that come off of the grinder and settle in its locale are significant and would still ruin the day for anyone planing.

I wouldn't advise someone who has an already workable setup buy one. I could probably just still be dressing my brown 46 degree wheel with the $10 T dresser that i had. It worked GREAT as long as you didn't let it glaze or get quick with pressure. I bought the one-way balancing gadget for that al-ox wheel, too, so that ruined a lot of the economy. Such perfection in balance isn't really necessary for grinding. My ryobi grinder was out of concentricity and balance at the same time, leading most of the grinding to be done on part of the wheel. Rotate it, and that part would change. It probably made it generate less heat.

While the finer pink wheels are OK, people who have used one of the white wheels made to finish turning tools will recognize that those can generate huge amounts of heat at 100 grit or 80 grit. The cheapest coarse wheel I have, one without a proper center bearing is either 36 or 46 grit. It came with the ryobi grinder and if it's dressed for two seconds each use, it also works fine.

So this isn't a suggestion that someone should buy or change what they have, just like the iron test will not be a suggestion to go buy V11 if someone already likes what they have, or even green chinese (or the black version) irons. I'm just as enamored with those as V11 because of the price. My mother somehow imparted that on me. I don't need them, I have no economic need to use only things like that, but I'm fascinated with them at the price.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#32

Re: Does anyone here have the

bridger berdel

Mine has a groove in one of the tool rests- the left one, iirc- and i think they have detents of a sort for up/down adjustment. It's a pretty crappy tool rest. I mostly don't use it.