Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Recommendations for grinder/wheel

Posts

Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#1

Recommendations for grinder/wheel

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

Am looking to set up another grinder. Looking for slow speed, though doesn’t have to be Tormek slow. Dry wheel but as cool as possible. At least 8” wheel. Small footprint—at least as small as Tormek. Does anything meet or approximate this spec.?

Much thanks, Wiley

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#2

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

david weaver

Any reasonable quality 8" grinder with a two piece rest.

CBN wheel, anything from 80-220 grit is perfect. You'll much appreciate the speed gain over the tormek and the lack of ever having to do anything to the wheel.

Something like 60% of the grinding heat is absorbed by the wheel, which doesn't glaze, and the overall effect is that grinding feels like about a quarter of the heat of a dressed al-ox wheel (the latter works well except it starts to glaze mid grind on difficult steel like 3V).

I got my wheel from woodturner's wonders several years ago for about $125. I think $150 is probably typical (mine was a sale item at the time). I use 80 grit and like it. It will break in some, but then continue cutting once it does.

Lots of intermediate quality 8" grinders for $150-$250 (dayton, palmgren). Anything made in taiwan instead of china is probably a good step toward the quality of a baldor grinder. I'd stay away from variable speed control grinders and buy single speed. The jet slow wheel grinders with variable speed probably would've lasted a lot better if they didn't put the goofy speed control in them to try to one-up tormek.

One other benefit to CBN - you get dust off of the wheel, metal only. There's no abrasive dust flying around. I don't do anything to capture mine, but instead house it in a corner near my drill press. All of the black settles there, and I've never had any issue with it moving it self the 6 feet or so to the end of my bench.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#3

Looks like...

david weaver

..my comments about finding a taiwanese grinder are out of date. Dayton and others are listed as made in china now. That's a shame.

Baldor grinders are nice, of course, but expensive and generally the guards do not work with the CBN wheels. I have the 6" cast baldor and have to leave the outer cover off, which normally wouldn't be a big deal except I have small children.

There are narrower CBN wheels that will work with baldor's cast guards, though. It's nice to have the guard, and the partial guard covers the left side of my wheel, and I stand on that side of the grinder while it's working so I'm not in the arc of unprotected wheel surface anywhere.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#4

Re: Looks like...

Wiley Horne

Hmmm ..... Do you think maybe they’re still made in Taiwan, but labelled China as a concession to Beijing. Anyway, I’ll buy China or Sweden, if someone has come up with a perfect combination. Love Balldor but is bigger than what I need.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#5

Re: Looks like...

david weaver

I'd guess they're made in China due to cost. There are still more expensive grinders marked taiwan, but they're in the same price range as a baldor.

I have no good suggestions.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#6

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

Philip Duffy

- -all good notes below/above but one word of caution: most steels will not give you a spark pattern "over the top" so you have to check on the progress of the grind. Yesterday, for the first time, an old tool gave off a spark pattern and I was greatly surprised. So, do not waste your steel when grinding! P.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#7

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

Wiley Horne

Thanks Phil. Generally, I grind when about half the hollow is gone. I grind to the edge on Tormek, and raise a good burr, to make sure all the old wear is gone from the back. As for checking, that’s a natural on Tormek, cause you'll look a couple times early to find out if it’s getting close yet :) .

On the new rig, I will also grind to a burr, but will definitely keep track. Thanks.

Big problem I see is whether there is anything other than a Tormek which has as small a footprint as a Tormek. I hate to think about buying a new Tormek but space is in short supply here.

Wlley

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#8

Does anyone here have the  *LINK*

Wiley Horne

Rikon grinder, 8”, half-speed, that Lee Valley offers? LV also offers CBN wheels to go with it.

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=76621&cat=1,43072,43080

Wiley


LV’s Rikon grinder with CBN wheels

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#9

Tool rest for CBN after a Tormek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, since you are familiar with and use the Tormek, add the BGM-100 kit to the 8” grinder you purchase. Basically you end up with a Tormek which is faster cutting and less messy.


You must be familiar with my review of CBN wheels I wrote a few years back. I have posted it many times. The relevance of doing so again is two-fold:

Firstly, there are wheels that benefit turners and thise that benefit flat woodworkers. The wheels for the latter are those without any corner radius.

Secondly, the use of a BNM-100 creates a straight and smooth grind, ala Tormek. You can really pick up the difference between an 80- and 180 grit wheel. Go for the 180 grit. I grind to the edge of the blade, and the 180 is often smooth enough to skip a 1000 stone for the first couple of honings (I hone frequently, so the wear bevel is minimised).

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/UltimateGrindingSharpeningSetUp.html

For reference, my grinder is an 8” half speed. Speed is still important as you can burn steel with CBN. Friction creates heat. The steel wheels are a big heat sink, and help. A light touch helps as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#10

Re: Does anyone here have the

E Phillip Smith

Years ago I had one of those or one of the Asian knock offs, but pretty sure mine was 3600 rpm. Grinder is respectable and will do a good job but it is not the equivalent of one of the vintage American industrial models. On mine the tool rest were stamped steel not very useful. Tool rest are the bane on most grinders, and these days I like to make my own. That said if you look at the link you posted the guy is grinding a lathe tool and if you look carefully he is using a One Way grinding jig. I have that jig and used it with this grinder, It is really good upgrade. The tool rest is easily adjustable, very smooth so tools slide easily.

Over the years I've had several grinders, and these days they are some of the most used tools in the shop. Any thing from sharpening tools, chisels, planes, lawn mower blades, to resizing things that don't fit. Previous grinders were 6" sears. Wheels too small, terrible tool rest. Rikon 8". Tool rest were poor, tried Lee Valley Aluminum tool rest but did not like. Metal did not slide easily. Upgraded to One Way tool rest and grinder worked well.

I have since upgraded to two 10" old school Black and Decker industrial grinders, one stays setup for fine tool work and the other is setup for rough grinding and with wire wheel for rust and paint removal. I also have a 7" Milwaukee, setup with very soft pink wheels for tool grinding. These are great grinders and you can but very good surface grinding wheels that fit these in any grit, hardness and porosity you want.

Phil's suggestions for grinder selection.

1. Decide what hollow grind you want. Practical choices are 7", 8" and 10". 7" and 8" surface grinding wheels are readily available in broad range of grit and hardness, with bore diameter that is easily bushed to grinder shaft. 10" surface grinder wheels are available also but they have a 3" bore and will require custom bushing and more importantly custom flange to fit grinder. I still need to make these for my grinder. I prefer 10" for a relatively shallow hollow grind BUT that is just personal preference based on NO data.

2. Speed. My choice is based on price, buy whatever is cheapest, which normally the high speed 3600 rpm for 7" and 8" grinders and 1800 rpm for 10" grinders. With the correct wheel and a light touch burning the steel is not a problem.

3. I used to use a 3/4" or 1" wide wheel. These days my preference for TOOLS is a 1/2" wide wheel CROWNED so that only the center of the wheel grinds. Currently using a 46 grit, Radiac ruby wheel with J hardness. It is much harder than I prefer but it is what's available until I get around to making spacers for the softer surface grinding wheels. 46 grit cuts fast without over heating the tool. I typically grind to 1/32" to 1?64" of tool edge so you never have coarse grinding marks to remove, and even when to do grind to the edge fixed diamond stone quickly removes grinding marks. There is great article by Bill Tindall on grinding wheel selection over in the articles section. Once I learned to grind free hand with a crowned wheel can't imagine going back to a square wheel, so can't imagine paying a premium for the CBN wheels.

For reference the Milwaukee grinder is 21 1/2" wide and about 12" deep. The 10" Black and Decker grinders are about 25" wide and 12 to 15" deep. My recollection is that the Rikon grinder is narrower but don't know by how much.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#11

read my article on wheels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The thing that turns the wheel is unimportant for things like chisels and plane blades. Given the proper wheel I can grind, and demonstrated many times, a Stanly blade on an grit 60 to 120 at 3600 rpm........so long as the wheel is pink and soft, no more than H grade. Pink is ideal for tool steels. Why does everyone sell white....?

Disclaimer- I used to need a slower speed for control, not burning. But with a light practiced touch I can grind anything on a soft crowned wheel. I typically use a 120 pink for sharpening, and 80 for major bevel reorganization.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#12

Re: read my article on wheels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, if you are content with your oink wheel, just carry on. However, a CBN wheel is in a different league. Heat and speed aside, an advantage of the CBN wheel is that it does not require any maintenance. The wheel does not change shape, does not need resurfacing, which means that set up does not alter. Would you return to your old steel after 3V?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#13

Incremental step

Wiley Horne

Thanks to all! The knowledge here, and willingness to share it, is just overwhelming. I learned from everyone, and each solution had some advantages.

The solution that I was thinking most about—as shown by Derek—was more money, and more space-consuming, than I wanted to spend right now for a second set-up. And especially for an all-new set-up to get used to.

So I ordered from Woodturners Wonders a 10” x 2” CBN wheel (200g) for the 12mm Tormek arbor, and will put that on my Tormek. I want to use the CBN wheel, even at less than optimum speed, to get used to it. It’ll be nice to get to a dry wheel anyway, and one that doesn’t have to be skinned a lot like the Si carbide black wheel I’m using now. So it'll be a ‘no regrets’ buy, whatever comes next.

Again, thanks to all,

Wiley

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#14

No advantage to me for CBN wheel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I looked to people, and suppliers, grinding tool steel in machine shops for guidance. The pink wheel for my grinder cost about $30. (Wheels for surface grinders are cheap from tool room supply houses) I have used it for about 10 years. I have a new back up but probably will never need it. I can crown it to my specifications which is why I can grind a Stanley blade at 3600 rpm, 120 grit.

If I was grinding a lot of lathe tools I would buy a "Ceramic" seeded gel abrasive wheel in a K hardness for about $60.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#16

Re: Incremental step

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, the 200 grit is a good choice. I consider the Tormek to be a grinder, not a sharpening system as some do. For this reason, I always used it at the coarsest setting - 220 grit - rather than the finer 1000 grit resurfacing.

I have friends who have the 200 grit wheel and have only good things to say.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#17

I used soft pink wheels for a while...

david weaver

..they're good. The CBN is better by a factor of two, though.

I would've continued to use the pink wheels if I had a 7" grinder and could find them cheaply. I found some camel 6" wheels at one point for $12 each, but they lose diameter quickly and I was looking at the prospect within a year of buying another one at $44 and got the CBN wheel for $125.

I think the CBN wheel will probably last as long as 10 pink wheels, maybe more. It's even less heat, it doesn't change shape at all, and there's no dust.

I'm slow to take up new modern abrasive gimmicks (But pretty easy to separate from my money with natural stones, I'll admit), but this is one that people should probably adopt.

If you can make bushings accurately, you can find them as cheap as $55 shipped from china on ebay, or you can buy accurately made sized "econo" wheels form people like Vince at WTW for about $99.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#18

Re: Incremental step

david weaver

I'll be interested in what you think about it. I had a tormek and got so frustrated with it after breaking a wheel that rusted the shaft that I took the whole thing and put it in a box and sent it to George Wilson. He said he'd like to try one, and I wanted to stop trying one, so that worked out well, and it was easier than trying to sell something heavy.

At any rate, I wouldn't be afraid of the $250 grinder you linked from LV. I haven't looked at grinders in a while, and just use the cast guard 6" version from baldor with cast iron rests (as phil said, sometimes the aluminum rests collect bits of metal or abrasive and then become less slick, something you can correct but shouldn't have to).

What I found with slow speed grinders is that there's a bunch for about $100-$150, but they're all 2-3 amps, vs the 5 amp regular speed versions. The reason for that is unwillingness to spend more money on copper for the slow speed version, I'm guessing. The one that LV is selling is low speed and somewhere around 5 amps. You don't need the extra amperage, but it's nice.

If you tire of using the wheel on the tormek, I'd chance the grinder LV sells (it's probably good) and leave one conventional wheel on it on the side you use less and put a CBN wheel on the other side. CBN is great, but I like having a conventional wheel to grind tools if you're making something that's not hardened - non-ferrous metals and unhardened steel are probably hard on CBN due to the grip they have on the abrasive on the wheel (I've seen recommendations to not use them).

The one benefit of the tormek that I can think of is that the wheel won't spin as fast, so the there probably won't be any significant airborne dust. The tormek set up properly is accurate, too. Derek's pimped out setup is probably the best of both worlds, especially if you can do something to capture most of the dust, as my solution (having the grinder in a spot where dust doesn't matter), maybe wouldn't suit everyone.

If I was buying again, I don't know if I'd spend the money on the baldor. It's superb, but the $38 grinder that I had before would probably still be working fine (if less smoothly, it wasn't vibration free for sure) and my tools would be just as sharp. I'd sit around and wait to find a deal on something like the grinder that LV is selling. it's not often that I've heard someone talk about anything on a grinder wearing out other than the wheels or having trouble with switches - even the foreign ones.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#19

Re: Incremental step

Wiley Horne

David,

I really liked the LV 8” halfspeed 1 HP, Rikon, with the steel CBN wheels they advertise. And I like and trust LV! Then add the Tormek MBN-100 tool rest that Derek showed. So the grinder, 2 wheels, and nice tool-rest, tax and shipping—I figure about $600 and using half again more footprint than Tormek. And I would be nervous about grinding to a primary burr as I do on Tormek—Tormek is relaxing. And I like the shallow hollow on Tormek, as Phil mentioned.

Tormek is slow. But. At 77, I’m sorta enjoying doing hobby things slow and relaxing. Other parts of life aren’t so relaxing. The CBN will be a step up over the black Si carbide wheel because (1) it’s dry, (2) it’s faster, (3) it doesn’t require me to dress it a lot to keep it cutting.

All of the help which is so freely given here is especially helpful because each and every suggestion has real merit, and therefore one is forced to think through and prioritize what you really want to change and what you want to keep.

Thanks to all!

Wiley

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#20

You're right about price...

david weaver

.. for about a year or maybe two years, I used an aluminum rest ryobi 6" grinder that I bought at home depot. The rests are the same type still seen on a lot of grinders where there's a diagonal groove on the left side - they're two pieces, but they had detents to help them lock down securely and the detents were like a tractor with too few gears - you can have any angle you want that's 2 degrees or so different from what you're actually looking for.

BUT, after clamping it down tight (it wandered quickly when powered up if not locked down), and using one of those $12 T-bar dressers on the really cheap wheels that came on it.....it worked fine.

There's much virtue in not throwing out the whole thing if you like the tormek, and as you say, less chance of grinding over the edge and less penalty if you do.

(the black wheel on the tormek drove me nuts. It and the grading stone graded each other, it loaded, and it would cut well after a diamond truing tool refresh, but then go back to some level of mediocrity. I tried all of the wheels after finding them on clearance and still preferred the original, though 3V probably still favors the black wheel, despite the grading issues. The ability to triple the speed would be nice with CBN, but wouldn't work very well with water on the regular wheels!).

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#21

Rikon Grinder sale (Re: Incremental step)

David Bassett

FWIW: Woodcraft has Rikon grinders on sale from 8/9 to 8/18. The "1HP" model is $213 during the sale. (The "1/2HP" model is $136. It was much more attractive back when it was regularly $99.)

I agree about trusting LV, but if you had a Woodcraft store you can get to you wouldn't have to deal with WC's shipping and have someone to deal with in person if you had troubles.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#22

Re: Rikon Grinder sale (Re: Incremental step)

david weaver

Looking at alibaba, the cost of chinese goods has gone up. I don't see any 8" grinders with white wheels, but the gray grinders with 300-350W motors and slow speed are about $25-$35 delivered for an order of 50.

10 years ago, they were about $10. Shipping costs from china on anything other than first class mail size makes ordering prohibitive, of course, and Rikon, et al, would have distribution costs, service costs and a desire to make some money, let alone the high cost setups like B&M woodcraft stores.

I'd be surprised if the more expensive of the two grinders actually cost woodcraft $50, though.

Personally, I wish more of the value of products was the actual cost of item plus transportation and less in advertising, coupons, subsidizing other peoples' returns (i rarely return anything), etc, but that's the way it is now.

If people were trustworthy enough to do a group buy now, you could get 20 or 50 of those grinders and fetch them and ship, but my experience with "Group buys" is that people who say they're interested in something have little chance of showing up, even if they commit to it, between the time they commit and the time something is deliverable.

there was a relatively well known post that john economaki made to his blog years ago when the 8" white wheel variable speed grinders became popular and were going for $100-$150, depending on the retailer and the sticker on the front. I think John gave a figure of about $7.50 per grinder delivered to port in the united states (presumably, it would've been his responsibility from there).

The white wheels at the time in the US were $20-$40 each, depending on generic or norton. The retailers must've loved those grinders - no wonder they pushed them so hard. As simple as grinders are, if they don't have trouble with the speed control components, most are probably still working. At 2.8 or 3 amps, they're anemic, but it's still plenty for sharpening and grinding things.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#23

Well I missed it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'm dense. I don't want to miss an opportunity. What did I miss?

For $30 I added a wheel to a grinder I already owned that does what is needed . I have never burned an edge and none of the people I have taught to use it have burned an edge.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#24

Think of this like..

david weaver

...the difference between good A2 or 3V vs. V11 in planing long grain in medium hardwood.

You never really needed the V11, but from what we can see, it's clearly better.

I happily ground tools with a coarse wheel, then a pink wheel, but then bought CBN expecting it to be cheaper in the end over a lifetime, and basically static. I don't know yet if it will be cheaper, but if I went through a $30 wheel every 2 years, probably it will.

I also heeded the warning of grading wheels early on and found that even a coarse wheel graded fairly often was very easy to grind with. I haven't had water at my grinder in years - I can't imagine that it does anything good when grinding an iron if the temperature is anything more than just a little bit, and for years, I've cooled the iron by dragging it across my palm. If the iron is too hot to be dragged across my palm to cool it, then I've done something wrong.

Re: Recommendations for grinder/wheel

#25

Better analogy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The difference between an oak and a pine 2 x 4 for a stud. Both strong enough. One more expensive.

For what I do I see no advantage. I have bought Radiac 7" surface grinder wheels for as little as $10 on sale at Travers. I have about 12 of them in various grits and hardness to test what was best for me. Conclusion: it doesn't matter about grit but hardness needs to be soft, about H. I can grind on anything and the "Fine" fixed diamond plate removes what ever the result is. Current list is about $25 on MSC.

A wheel every two years! I'm 10 years on my wheel and it has lost 1/2 inch of diameter. It's not like I haven't been doing woodworking the past 10 years. I rarely dress it. Little need to. 3600 rpm 120 grit Stanley thin blade. Need I say more about heat? Not an issue for me. Anyone burning blades either has too hard a wheel or improper technique.