Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wear Mechanisms of edges

Posts

Wear Mechanisms of edges

#1

Wear Mechanisms of edges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have spent some time this AM investigating what is know about tool wear in milling wood. Corrosive wear is a significant factor in machine cutting of wood. What I could not find (nobody would be interested) is whether it would be significant in hand planing. The important variable would be heat, which both accelerates chemical reactions and promotes volatilization of corrosive wood chemicals. Is the heat at the blade tip enough to promote chemical as well as mechanical abrasion?

Why ponder corrosive wear? The steels used in David's work range from highly susceptible to resistant. If searching for the "best" steel should corrosion resistance be considered? I would like to see S30V vs 3V comparison. They have similar abrasive resistance but S30 V is a stainless steel. If corrosion resistance is significant it should show up as a edge life difference in these steels.

What I found was no mention of adhesive abrasion for cutting wood. The physical properties of the materials involved does not predict this mechanism could be a factor. In adhesive wear hard stuff wears soft stuff.

Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

#2

Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges - corrosion

Rum

The other factor is time, in the light of time I think corrosion might possibly be more of an issue for weekend warriors like myself. Tentative hypothesis would be something along the lines of:

  • sharpen your tool
  • do [small project] which isn't enough to warrant resharpening
  • let sit for [time of duration of life events say O(2-4 weeks)]
  • corrosion sets in
  • subsequent usage is less than stellar.
  • possible repeat the previous 4 steps

    I'm thankfully in a super dry climate so background corrosion is relatively low so it hasn't been a huge problem for me, but I also try to clean/wax when done for the day (usually...) so that likely helps.

    This would be more than slightly more tedious to test than the current ongoing set :)

  • Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #3

    reduce time scale 100X

    Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

    Corrosive wear is the corrosion that occurs in the time scale of the planing stroke. Stroke, corrode, stroke- which removes the tiny amount of metal compromised by corrosion occurring since the last stroke. which leads to an insight...... there probably aren't enough planing stokes in David's experiments to remove significant material by a mechanism of corrosion followed by removal of this layer in the next stroke.

    edit: did some calculations and I am less sure corrosion isn't fast enough to contribute

    From Kato data the blade shortens at the rate of 0.1microns per meter planed or about 5 atomic layers. If the corrosion rate can penetrate faster than material is removed corrosion could be a factor for the abrasive rate will be enhanced by degraded corroded metal ahead of the abrasive wear. If it was Myth Busters I would call it plausible, but no where near confirmed.

    Proof's in the pudding. All things being equal does a corrosion resistant steel wear slower? Intriguing. If there was a significant market for hand plane blades as there is for router bits someone would have found out

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #4

    how many angels

    Joe shelton

    Can dance on a nanowire?

    How many demons can low-crawl through a nanotube?

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #5

    Re: reduce time scale 100X

    Kees

    We thought about this a few years ago and I did some tests with oak and beech. Our thoughts back then was that the tannines in oak would promote corrosive wear, while they both don't have very abrassive content. But I didn't see any difference when looking at the wear bevels between the two wood types.

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #6

    Re: how many angels

    david weaver

    The method that bill is talking about has actually been used elsewhere, too. I saw a hard edge set of lawnmower blades on youtube last year (don't ask, my interests are varied in just about anything that involves machines or blades).

    They are essentially a hard layer like this and as the steel above the layer wears, but the hard layer wears much more slowly. It looks like they work well for grass as long as there's no rocks (a strange thing to be looking at, but the idea caught my eye. I use a reel and quite like it just as it is).

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #7

    History

    Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

    In the dark ages "scholars" debated things like how many angles could sit on a pin, or some such. And then the Enlightenment of the Renaissance arrived. Scholars discovered that through scientific investigation things around them could be explained by universal principles. Most importantly by understanding phenomena predictions could be made about other phenomena. An arch in a door become a Cathedral and most agreed that things got better. Others didn't care but for others the quest to understand burns brightly. Some are entertained by striving to create a surface where each wood cell is perfectly cleaved. Others are entertained by understanding what it takes to cleave these cells with the possible goal of cleaving them better. Some won't care if there is a better way. Others could make a market from the information.

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #8

    Re: reduce time scale 100X

    david weaver

    Bill and I had talked about this a little bit, but I don't know anything about chemistry, so it was more simplistic from my view point. And one of the reasons I talked about heat.

    What I know from past experience is that if you live rural in the united states, you may still burn your trash. We did that when I was a kid - paper items and anything not noxious, we burned. Plastics and metals, we recycled. Every couple of years, we'd get a burn barrel. They rusted right away, and I never understood why (but I do, now, even though I don't understand exactly what's going on, I know the fire is causing the metal to oxidize).

    I met my father in law about 16 years ago. He had just bought a stainless steel cylinder to burn his trash in, and he's been using the same one now (he moved houses, his son is living in his old house burning his trash in the same cylinder).

    The point I'm getting to is whether or not there is enough heat at the edge of the iron, even if it's an atom or two thick and and 5 atom deep in iron length where the surface gets hot enough for this oxidation to occur, and it continuously leaves the iron in the middle of a cut.

    The addition of tannins may accelerate that or not, i don't know. I'm less concerned with that. Well, I'm not concerned with much of it at all - I'm satisfied to see the results and know that I could repeat them, the why is less of an issue to me because focusing too much on the why can lead people like me to suppose things rather than observe them, and supposing on partial understanding is how old wives tales are created.

    How would someone test my theory? (not that they need to). I guess have an extremely slow planing machine and just let it go for days and see if much slower planing speed creates a different result. I'm assuming that the steel used in V11 is stainless because it doesn't rust. I have a halfway underground shop that lets me observe the difference between relative humidity and absolute, and things will rust in it in the summer, no matter what. I've never had any rust on a V11 iron, even when the cap iron attached rusts (they always rust at a higher rate than the underlying iron, anyway, if they're uncoated - I guess soft steel rusts faster than hardened steel?). to this point, I don't think we've had a good stainless iron that we've been able to observe because nothing has gotten hard enough to make a good plane iron. The recommended upper range for 440C is 3 or 4 points short of where V11 is specified, and it needs to be cryo treated to work well at that, or be PM. Same with CPM 154 - it goes a little higher than 440C, but not into the range where V11 is.

    There's a gaggle of high vanadium stainless steels, but I can tell from the stones that this isn't high vanadium, and those steels have a terrible reputation for holding their initial edge and wearing with a fine edge. So, it is more or less the first time I've seen a steel of this type that's stainless (and from the stones, high chromium, as chromium doesn't stymie natural stones too badly - this iron wears two or three times as fast on the suita vs. what the 3V does, and the 3V is probably softer on the C scale), that's not full of hard sharpening or big particle vanadium (the latter doesn't need to be the case with PM), and that gets hard enough to work in the same range as harder O1 and A2.

    It sort of makes me want to go track down the 3rd generation PM steels that *are* higher vanadium and see if they will go further yet, but the reality is, they're expensive and I can't harden them in my shop, so I'm not going to do it. They will also likely make irons that pretty much only sharpen well on diamond, and LV and others can't market irons like that - they'd just get returned.

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #9

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    Alan S

    It might be interesting to try planing at high and low temperature, and check whether the wear was any different. High temperature should speed up any chemical processes.

    Planing outdoors vs indoors in the winter in a cold climate might do it, but you'd need to be careful about bringing a cold plane inside causing condensation, or heat causing sweat. Salt from sweat would likely make more difference to corrosion than other factors.

    I don't know whether the effect of temperature in this range would make a measurable difference to other properties of steel that affect wear.

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #11

    Re: reduce time scale 100X

    Kees

    We allready found out quite a while ago that PMV-11 really is a special type of PM 440C. I forgot the exact name, but it has about 17% chromium and very little vanadium. That makes it special because most of these PM die making steels are high in vanadium.

    So, no wonder you find it doesn't rust and that it sharpens reasonably well on normal stones.

    Re: Wear Mechanisms of edges

    #13

    Re: reduce time scale 100X

    Kees

    Bill reminded me, CTS-XHP from Carpenter steel is the most likely candidate.

    Composition:

    1.60 C, 0.50 Mn, 0.40 Si, 16.00 Cr, 0.35 Ni, 0.80 Mo, 0.45 V, Bal. Fe