Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Let's go bonkers about wire edges

Posts

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#26

a newbie question...

Jonathan Elliott

...who hasn't worked with the cap iron yet but through reading all this and re-reading Steve Elliott's page and Kees cap iron tests I'm curious how the "extra work on the back bevel" affects the seating of the cap iron.

If one has precisely mated the cap iron to a flat back and then puts a small back bevel on the blade to ensure all scratches are removed, wouldn't that cause potential jamming of thin shavings since there would be a small gap.

Kees shows 0.1mm cap iron setback as most effective in his tests, and I think David you've been using close to 0.2mm here? I know it varies depending on the exact situation but surely back bevels of even 2/3rds of a degree or 2.5 like Steve Elliott talks about using would reach further back than 0.1-0.2mm from the edge.

Just curious, thanks!

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#27

No problem..

david weaver

Back bevel in this case is just done with a half mm or so steel ruler at about 2 inches away. It does impart some angle onto the edge of the blade, but the relief on the cap iron should be greater than the angle and the back bevel itself not deep in the first place, so it shouldn't (and hasn't) affected function.

I don't like back bevels, but I also wanted to be able to get a photo perfect edge more easily on the wood with some irons that may not be dead perfect flat (e.g., the chinese HSS iron is very hard to flatten perfectly, but not difficult to get close).

Steeper angles that are close to or greater than the relief cut into the front edge of the cap iron would certainly cause problems by creating a gap or a weak pinch of the cap iron onto the edge.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#28

Re: a newbie question...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We don't use a standard setback for the cap iron; we use a range of settings dependent on the situation. I don't think I have ever needed a setting as close as .01 mm in 46 years of use.

I can see why David used the back bevel for these tests, but generally people who do a lot of hand planing don't use back bevels.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#29

Re: a newbie question...

Steve Elliott

David mentioned the two main issues: the underside of the cap iron is relieved a little more than the angle of the back bevel so shavings don't jam, and for a photo-perfect edge on a blade with a less-than-flat back, using a back bevel saves a lot of time and work.

I don't advocate for or against use of a back bevel and my own choice of 2-1/2 degrees is based on a honing jig I made when I was testing blades and needed very consistent angles and fairly quick honing of both sides of the blade. It's a much greater angle than I would recommend for general use.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#30

Thanks!

Jonathan Elliott

That makes sense, I remember seeing the relief angle talked about in instructions on how to set up a cap iron.

So if I understand correctly, the front edge of the cap iron that contacts the back of the iron, while not a knife edge per say, it is very narrow due to the relief angle and will seat along the back of the iron if the back bevel isn't too steep and the iron isn't bowed across it's width.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#31

Re: Thanks!

Steve Elliott

If the top edge of the cap iron is 45 degrees or more and the relief angle is 3 degrees there's still plenty of meat at the edge of the cap iron.

There's a video on YouTube by The English Woodworker called "Tuning Bench Planes--Preparing the Cap Iron" that shows how to add the relief angle, about three minutes from the start.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#32

Re: i vaguely recall years ago

Steve Voigt

there was a thread on SMC where someone asked who removed the wire edge after every step, and I was shocked to find that there were people who did that. I didn't even know it was an option that someone would take.

That may have been me, although I would not describe what I do as "taking the wire edge off with every step." But I definitely do flip the iron over and work the back after raising the burr on each stone.

I raise the initial burr on the coarse stone ("fine" India), then work the back on a medium stone (mystery stone that may be a Washita), raise another burr on the trans Ark, work the back on same stone, then finish with light stropping on charged MDF.

It seems to me that the choice of whether to do it this way, vs. working the bevel on a succession of stones and saving the back work for last, is largely a matter of ones' sharpening method. If you use a flat bevel technique, perhaps raising the iron on the last stone only, then you can be reasonably sure that each stone is adequately working the bevel. But if you are working a secondary bevel only, as I do, then it helps to be able to feel the burr after each step.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#33

Something more direct...

david weaver

..The method you use reminds me of what Larry does (which I only know due to someone linking a video of his sharpening process). IIRC, he worked the back of the iron on one of the less than finest stones to make sure he removed all of the back wear (something I want to check during this process of taking pictures - I doubt I remove all of it, but if the edge is reasonably fine and undamaged, it's not a huge deal on a carbon steel iron).

IIRC, at least one of the responses on SMC was more direct about removal or bending off of the wire edge at earlier steps -I don't remember exactly what it was except that it led me to think of "tearing off".

I check for the burr by finger, too, just don't remove it until later.

I've gotten lazier over the years and do sometimes use a middle stone on an iron that i didn't prepare completely. The chisel I sent you is much the same - it's just prepared enough to use. I'd continue to work the back a little each time if a non-flat part gets close to the edge.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#34

Larry...?

Jim Matthews

...Williams?

I viewed his video on replacement molding plane irons with fascination.

I think that interim step of pulling a wire edge was necessary on the unhardened steel before the final profiles were "set".

There was a great degree of fitting to be done before the final hone, and that included getting the bevel right for a given shape.

Some of the more complex shape have inecapable "traps" for shavings - Big Dogs like LE know when to stay out of the weeds.