Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Let's go bonkers about wire edges

Posts

Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#1

Let's go bonkers about wire edges

David Weaver

So, after the last disaster on maple, I've settled with testing 3V and V11 head to head on beech again. I could either use beech or cherry, and beech makes more sense right now as a potential asterisk.

I discovered what made the wire edge on the 3V on the bevel side (you guys familiar with wire edge manipulation that differs from just continuing honing will recognize that a wire edge on the bevel side is maybe slightly less obvious).

Wait for it...

.. it was created by vigorous ruler tricking with 1 micron diamonds. In my vim to really be sure I'd eliminated all scratches at the edge, i created a back side wire edge. Had I stopped with the bevel work, this wouldn't have occurred, but light work on the ruler trick would've left lines going all the way to the edge and they would've eventually shown up in the work if they didn't immediately.

Fast forward, I was just refurbishing the two subject blades after they took on more inclusion today, and Phil Smith sent me a wonderful cast blanchard ground plate. I decided to speed things up and try 1 micron diamonds on it. It's aggressive compared to the wood. Much faster cutting - not surprisingly. It can easily create the wire edge I'm talking about on the bevel side if you do the ruler trick and then do not tease back and forth on the edge.

Some won't believe that, so I took pictures of it.


See it?

Now, see what it looks like when you strop it off (all of this wire edge was created after all others was removed - this is purely 1 micron diamond wire edge, but made very aggressive by a cast plate with blanchard grinding marks on it (I love it, by the way).


I have an arsenal of freehand trickery to deal with this kind of stuff, but I can't use it for a test like this because it's not reproducible by other people.

I also have a keen eye for edges from sharpening a gaggle of razors. I can see this on the edge with a naked eye because the little direction changes only just reflect tiny amounts of light.

This edge will plane just fine - it would probably actually take a 5 ten thousandth shaving without issue and it shaves hair off no problem. But it won't make an absolutely uniform surface.

How much is the penalty in feet planed? I don't know.

The cast plate is helpful, though - it's decisive and i can do the initial final bevel with it and then switch over to the wood for the purposes of this test.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#2

Excellent detective work David

Wiley Horne

Does this explain your earlier finding that the alloy steels (only) made fine scratches on the work?

Wiley

P.S. In my experience, 1 micron diamond on a hard surface is really brash. It would tear up a hard Japanese iron or chisel for example. Because it’s diamond, and because it ain’t 1 micron at 1-2 std. deviations out. I only mention this because I think you avoid diamond in your normal everyday.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#3

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

Steve Elliott

Your experience is consistent with mine when it comes to removing the final bit of wire edge using 1 micron diamond on cast iron. Years ago when I was testing initial sharpness on different sharpening media I found that higher sharpness was achieved when the final honing was done with light strokes on alternate sides of the blade always using a forward stroke, never with the edge trailing. This was just for the final half dozen strokes or so, and the tiny amount of increased sharpness went way beyond what I felt I needed for any practical woodworking operation.

For the record, using 1/2 micron diamond gave better sharpness, as did 1/4 micron, but for me that level of honing was a waste of time for the kind of work I do. All my work goes to professional finishing shops which absolutely want and expect a uniformly sanded surface that will act as a uniform canvas for the stains and finishes they apply. I admire the level of surface quality that can be achieved by expert planing and I may want to go to that level after I retire and am working on projects for myself. For now 1 micron is a good compromise that gives good sharpness with reasonable speed.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#4

Re: Excellent detective work David

Steve Elliott

For Japanese chisels with their harder steel I prefer waterstones to diamond of any kind. For final honing I also like softer waterstones that develop a slurry. The feel of hard steel on a soft waterstone is much better than on diamond.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#5

Re: Excellent detective work David

David Weaver

I agree, Wiley. Very brash, and even tiny mill marks have some cutting ability to go along with it. I was hoping that it would still sharpen more cleanly, anyway, but have past experience raising a wire edge on a cheap Japanese parer eons ago with .5 micron diamonds on steel.

The focus on the steel plate with the ruler trick and any pressure at all is just too harsh, and would probably work better send the trick.

And 100% agree, bringing any high hardness good quality Japanese chisel to something like this is verboten. Chance of complete edge failure is way too high, and the jigane would suck up the diamonds.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#6

Re: Excellent detective work David

David Weaver

Japanese edges can crumble from something like this, too, and the diamonds get stuck in the higher. It's hard to see when they're tiny, but they embed in it.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#7

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

David Weaver

Yes on the alternating strokes. I did very light back and forth out of the guide on some of the irons, but on wood, couldn't do leading strokes. I guess I just missed some on the 3v for the first test. The guide makes this repeatable if someone wants to challenge my results, but it makes every nuance obnoxious to deal with.

Yes on the tiny diamonds. You can feel that even .5 micron diamonds are too harsh on a razor on a softer substrate unless it's practically follow. The sub micron sharpness is very transient, though, other than for its ability to set the edge up to wear smoothly without defects. I would venture to guess that 1 micron on wood is more gentle to the edge than .5 micron on metal, but I'm not out to prove that. The relatively large shaving thickness makes it so that The highest level of initial sharpness isn't quite as critical as long as the method doesn't promote uneven wear with the initial edge.

As far As razors go, we continue to see edge improvement all the way through .09 micron iron oxide. That's a decent option for vegans who wont buy a leather strop, but i prefer less keen and then stropped. Sharpening at that level allows a razor to cut the back sides of pores as the razor lifts the hair and severs it. A more appropriate level of sharpness cuts the hair but won't catch any propped up skin behind it. The result of the former is bad razorburn despite a comfortable shave.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#8

confused by wire edges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'm lost. I gather wire edges are a concern. If small, why are they a concern? What difference does it make if I break them off on a leather strop or by planing wood? In short order the abrasion of the wood is going to smooth out the edge and it will be what it will be at 50'(to pick a number) whether I removed it all or not- yes, no, confused.

Bottom line- I need some guidance for how much I should be worried about wire edge formation and removal.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#9

Re: confused by wire edges

David Weaver

It's an issue of equity for this test and quality for a surface gazer, but the small wire edges we're talking about really aren't that much of a bother for a shaving lifter.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#10

thank you

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

aren't that much of a bother for a shaving lifter.

Always pleased to find something I don't need to worry about. I do understand that at some level a wire edge will be detrimental.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#11

Re: thank you

David Weaver

I'm troubling over accuracy in this test, that's pretty much it. If I was doing this by hand, I'd do leading edge and tease the wire edge off without ever worrying about it. I don't think you'll find a wire edge on the blade I sent you, but I had the luxury of sharpening it freehand.

If it affects the test results 200 feet, that's a big deal. If it affects you 200 feet on a regular day planing something other than finish strokes, no big deal.

I have an easy test for wire edges. They're usually pointed one way or another and I'd guess most beginners and even experienced folks (who don't care about the small wire edges for good reason, or even a deflected edge after they're gone. The test is simply this - if you shave hair off of your arm, and then flip the blade over and shave with the other side, are both clean and easy? If the edge is stropped off and not deflected in the process, a blade will shave easy both sides.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#12

wire edge miscellany

Wiley Horne

David and all,

Many years ago, a fellow who had a good sharpening reputation suggested (not to me, I got it second-hand) the following: When you’re in a two-stone or three-stone sharpening regime don’t go to the back after the primary stone. Stay on the bevel until the final stone. Then go to the back. The idea is to thin the hinge on the wire edge before removing it. You avoid the possibility of bending it back and forth, or breaking off a heavy wire. Ideally it sloughs off on its own. And you don’t need primary stone scratches on a back that’s been polished many times over.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#13

Re: wire edge miscellany

David Weaver

100% agree with that. Actually, I've never used anything but a polish stone on an iron back unless there's some kind of damage, and I've never removed a wire edge until it's been thinned on the final stone.

It's tempting to grab it sometimes and move it around to see how strong it is, but I can't imagine that wouldn't damage the edge.

This test with the 1 micron diamonds stumped me on the 3V because I think I was vigorous enough with it that I created a significant wire edge, though it's possible that I never got the polish to the corner of the iron in the bevel side - it would've only come up just short if that was the case.

The damage from the pictures here were all done with 1 micron after the wire edge left, just from vigorous work on the cast. I really like the cast and used it today to set up my iron and a hock 01 iron, but I used it with more discretion, too.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#14

Re: wire edge miscellany

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, that is what I do. I move on to the medium stone when wire from the coarse stone (Shapton Pro 1000) is felt with finger tips. It is unnecessary to create a strong wire. In fact, it makes for more work later on. Consequently, I stop when the wire can just be felt along the entire edge.

Perhaps theoretically, successive stones should reduce this wire until there is almost nothing to remove. In practice, how one grinds and how one sharpens will affect what follows.

One of the factors influencing this is how straight the edge is working the coarse stone on a finely cambered edge. This will leave a stronger wire at the centre of the blade if one sharpens square and adds in the camber later. Alternatively, if one works the camber, keeping the wire even along the length, there is the risk of unwittingly increasing the camber.

If the bevel is hollow ground to the edge of the blade, as one might do on a Tormek system or a cool-grinding CBN wheel, the size of the wire will depend on the straightness of the grind, since the coarse stone must first straighten the edge. This is one of the reasons that I use the Tormek BG100 blade holder system on my bench grinder.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#15

Burr size is controlled by..

david weaver

..the level of wear present on the iron, and whether or not there is a nick.

If you're just removing wear and the iron was cutting evenly when you took it out of the plane, then the first small burr will not remove all of the wear, but you also don't need to create a giant burr, either.

The scope shows a fair amount of back work is needed on 1 micron diamonds to remove a complete dulling cycle when dulling is pushed all the way to lack of clearance or lack of ability of the plane to stay in the cut. The answer to this is two-fold. No back bevel, and a final step that's more coarse.

I'm sure there are lots of people who think that they've removed the entirety of wear from the back of their iron,but at the same time, their claim wouldn't hold water under the scrutiny of my scope. It probably took twice as much back bevel work as I thought it would to remove the wear scratches all the way to the edge.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#16

i vaguely recall years ago

david weaver

...there was a thread on SMC where someone asked who removed the wire edge after every step, and I was shocked to find that there were people who did that. I didn't even know it was an option that someone would take.

A foil has strength, and the thicker the attachment to the iron, the more you'd reasonably conclude taking it off would damage the edge left on the iron. There's no guarantee that you'd work deep enough to remove it in subsequent steps.

re: the comments about wire edge size. You do need to raise a large burr sometimes, but it's like anything else. You need to do it when you need to do it and you don't need to do it when you don't need to do it. Properly thinning the wire edge all the way to and through the finish stone still makes it just as thin at its connection of done right. if a fight needs to occur to bend or snap it off, then something bad will happen.

If there's a reason for persistence (carving tools, softer tools on oilstones, etc, teasing it the way steve described is the best idea. Alternating back and forth until it's too weak to hold on.

I think the back and forth is common for japanese tool sharpening, but doing anything about the wire edge isn't. An edge of plain steel at 65 hardness doesn't really respond to a strop at all, and there's usually not enough wire edge to need one. The japanese razors and other overhard western razors are less convenient to shave with because they don't work right with a linen and leather and need to be honed or stropped with abrasive fairly often. A good western razor in the mid hardness range (as well as the japanese western copies) can shave daily for a year without ever seeing a stone.

As far as the test here goes, the wire edge on the 3V was most likely caused by not teasing the foil off that came to the edge as a result of ruler tricking. It wouldn't have existed long if I honed freehand, but I don't think introducing my freehanding would've made for a good test unless i had a way to picture and measure the bevel side to prove the final angle and bevel size.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#17

sharpening with a hand lens

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...well.... with the aide of a hand lens. Those that sharpen early may not face the issue of burr formation preceding complete wear removal. By the time I am forced to sharpen the appearance of a burr greatly precedes the complete removal of the loss of clearance(bevel side wear). Sharpening and following results with a hand lens has taught me much about what is going on at the edge when sharpening.

And what David has taught about burr removal is important. I used to think it was easier than it is in fact, at least with tenacious 3V. Sharpening is not considered complete until the 10X inspection is passed.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#18

Re: sharpening with a hand lens

david weaver

3V definitely has a strong hold on the burr. V11 does, too, but I didn't compare the two directly, I just recreated the burr with V11 off of the 1 micron diamond, and noticed just out of curiosity touching it that it was firm and fairly strong.

I teased the burr off of a couple of the irons while sharpening, but missed it on the 3V, back and forth between a senseless concern for potentially lowering clearance a tiny amount by teasing the burr off lightly. If that throws the test results, then it just suggests that it really doesn't matter what irons we use. If 3V matches V11 on test two in the same wood (again stating that with beech, the testing is very smooth and the iron tends to run out of ability to stay in the cut pretty convincingly whereas in maple, it wasn't as easy to find that point consistently)...anyway, I'd guess from what i can tell that such a thing would be more a result of the wire edge than any other variability. We'll see. We're not talking about a big wire edge, but one that's there. If it was that big, the plane wouldn't have cut a 2 thousandth shaving as easily. It did seem less keen, but I couldn't tell if it was the plane or the iron. V11 seemed more keen and stayed bright longer than anything else polish-wise. I was surprised to feel (I hope this doesn't end up in marketing stuff somewhere) that the V11 felt sharper at every distance mark than both carbon steel irons. It's a very small thing, but noticeable. I expected that might be the case with A2, but not the blue steel iron or the O1. I think its wear profile is a little bit different and the O1 rounds a little bit more.

I can tell at this point on the cherry test that both O1 irons have a lot of depth to their edges (rounding) and shouldn't last too much longer, but I didn't see that on V11 and expected clearance issues to sneak up sooner than they did.

The both sides shaving on both ends of the iron is a good test for the wire edge, though. You can move it back and forth. I used to do that by making my last strokes on a shapton 15k on the back of an iron to ensure that the wire edge was pointing toward the bevel. Not until stropping did both sides of the bevel have the same sharpness.

More academic than anything else. It never caused a polish or sharpness issue and since in that case, it was very thin and not on a tougher iron, so it left either right away or as soon as wear progressed.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#19

Re: sharpening with a hand lens

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The burr will start forming when the wear on the back side is nearly eliminated. If there is considerable wear one can have a burr that can be felt with a finger, but will not flip over to the bevel side when the back is abraded. The flipping is an indication that wear has been eliminated.

With an oil stone, the burr will keep growing as you sharpen. You can have a strip of foil at the edge 1/8 inch wide or more if you have the patience and skill. It is helpful when doing demonstrations to have a burr large enough that observers can easily see what is going on.

With water stones or other loose grit sharpening, the grit in the slurry beats up the burr so a long burr cannot survive. This is a much different system.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#20

Exactly


Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#21

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

Charlie

Do a final polish/stropping with a half micron cerium oxide slurry.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#22

Does anyone actually do that?

david weaver

you use them for carving tools or something?

I will agree, those oxide pastes and pigments (the pure ones) won't leave much of anything on an edge, but I don't want to post a test like this recommending (or even showing) such a thing because beginners will take that and run with it. The formax stick that has al-ox in it gets a bad name, but the al-ox makes it usable as a final honing step. There was a long series of posts elsewhere about forgoing it to use chrome-ox paste from a razor vendor (as in, way overpriced), which is fine for razors, but too fine and slow for anything other than actual stropping (vs. strop honing).

This method (guides and ruler tricks) is already over my faffiness quotient by a pretty wide margin - it limits your ability to quickly do things you would do to prevent or remove wire edges.

I haven't used cerium oxide, but have used chrome ox III (pigment, not al-ox blended stick) and iron oxide on razors. CeOx is between the two for hardness. Both of the aforementioned are slow but very fine and don't threaten much rounding.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#23

Very useful!!


Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#24

Re: Does anyone actually do that?

Charlie

Yes.

If you're going to log on to the internet and use a credit card to buy a fine grit polishing compound (or stropping/honing compound if you want to call it that) why stop at some essentially arbitrary point short of what's available? It takes no longer to buy it, and it's delivered to your doorstep just like anything else.

Why do all the work you're doing and not polish with a sub-micron product? Historicity? Bias?

Using a half-micron product is no different than using a five micron product. If there were significant differences that would be one thing, but there aren't.

Re: Let's go bonkers about wire edges

#25

Method/Simplicity

david weaver

The oxides that you're talking about are somewhere on the order of a tenth as fast as 1 micron diamonds. 1 micron diamonds speed wise are more similar to an 8k king stone. On something like 3V or V11, they might be faster. And finer at the same time.

The objective of testing the irons isn't absolute sharpness, it's uniformity in preparation and comparison.

A simple method to sharpen in this case (repeatable if someone doesn't like my test results) is something like a 1000 grit diamond plate secondary bevel and tertiary bevel with 1 micron diamond. The oxides we're talking about are a step beyond that, and none of those that we've discussed will sharpen a vanadium carbide, nor will they establish a tertiary bevel properly or install a back bevel or remove full wear from one.

As far as outside of this, using them on a leather strop to strop vs. a bare leather strop, I certainly don't find fault with that. The 1 micron diamonds are used in place of a finish stone, though, not after one.