Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Posts

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#26

sorry I sugggested it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Don't want to tempt David to ruin a blade

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#27

Hypothesis rejected by data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are assuming that all the irons generate the same amount of heat. Any evidence for that?

work = calories = force times distance. In all cases the distance per stroke was the same. So the only variable is force. David did not mention any significant difference in force between blades.

Kato and Kawai measured the force to push blades made of various steels. The force was the same for each at an equivalent sharpness. The K&K data shows that force does not increase much as the blades dull.

I would expect stainless steels like so called "Pm v11" to give off less heat. I would expect less friction because the steel resists sharpening by abrasion. The K&K data does not support this assumption that abrasion resistance has any correlation to friction across a wood surface.

All that chromium makes the iron more slippery. I have no opinion on this claim. Do you have a citation to support it?

If you believe that heat degrades the blade edge that leads to using steel that is not affected by heat, M2 for example.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#28

Trouble reading

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You are having trouble reading what I wrote. I suggested the possibility that the two steels might have different friction in use. I did not make an "assumption" that this was the case. Nor did not make a "hypothesis". I was trained to be more careful than that.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#29

Re: Trouble reading

David Weaver

I'm sure the actual friction is different but not sure the heat is from friction of iron to wood, but rather the manipulation of the wood itself.

On the grinder, these irons all generate drastically different levels of hest. Carbon steel the lowest. The three most highly alloyed irons here don't even spark much.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#30

The second test with maple..

david weaver

...The first test with maple showed formation of small lines with the alloyed irons, and at the time, I wasn't sure if it was sharpening refinement or not.

The second test showed the same thing, except in this case, I am sure that the irons were cleanly sharpened with no notches. Both 3V and V11 developed small lines (visible, but can't be felt).

All bets were off with the mineral occlusions in the wood (or whatever you'd like to call them) - the lines created by those were not small.