Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Posts

Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#1

Side fact, temperature change from planing..

david weaver

..I recall Rob lee mentioning heat when he was talking about planing, and certainly when speeds increase or hardness does, that's probably a factor.

Where I gauged the center of the cut (putting my thumb on the webbing of the plane casting while fencing the cut with my fingers so that the stroke would be on the same part of the iron over and over), the shavings ran over the back of my thumb.

Plenty of warmth on the exiting shavings, but not that hot. I thought it would be interesting to measure the temperature change of the iron 1/8th inch from the edge, knowing that the point of cut is probably much greater, but the remaining iron near the cut will absorb the energy as it's allowed to.

The conclusion after 200 feet of moderate speed planing (probably 2 seconds per pass or so).

....6 degrees F. Enough to notice, but just not that much.

Plenty of other cooler areas anxious to absorb the heat from the cut, of course the shavings and the air around them (thus feeling the warmth passing over my thumb), the cap iron and the frog.

Always wondered that before, this is the first time I've gotten a measure. I expected not a great deal of change, but something a little more than that.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#2

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Brian Holcombe

I've turned an edge blue from planing.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#3

Tell us more, please!!!


Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#4

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What I do notice is this:

We all recall the heat that occurs when using a cabinet (card) scraper - the burned thumb experience? I suspect that high cutting angles are more likely to produce heat in plane blades.

I have observed for many years that a plane that always requires the back of the blade being cleaned is the HNT Gordon smoother (60 degree bed angle, used with a 1/4" thick and 2" wide O1 blade). What occurs is that the back of the blade becomes brown with a resinous coating. Where does this come from? Springback? What these blades in particular? Is this linked to the wood type?

The "resin" has to be scrubbed off before lapping the back of the blade. It will gum up media if this is not first done.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#5

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

David Weaver

Do tell.. :)

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#6

work=heat

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For those that remember their physics history , Thompson in the canon boring experiment and later Joule, demonstrated that work and heat are equivalent. The more work you put into planing, force times distance, the more heat will be generated. The heat generated by the friction of the shaving rubbing on the cap iron and blade will equal force times distance. This heat divided by the time to generate it will be the heat flux into the blade, and cap iron, if there is one. That's the easy part.

Heat flux out of the blade tip will be a complicated function of wood heat capacity, temperature rise of the shaving and mass of the shaving, plus a complicated function of the mass of the blade and cap iron and steel conductivity and heat capacity and a few other variables.

The temperature of the blade tip will be the temperature where the heat out equals heat in. Heat is generated by friction so this heat input is being generated all along the front and back of the blade that is rubbing on wood plus the shaving rubbing on the cap iron. This heat input is not concentrated at the tip. In fact the frictional forces at the tip may be substantially less than along the blade surfaces because of the splitting action at the tip.

Bottom line-

Scrapers get hot because the amount of shavings carrying heat away is puny, the work input is high and the mass of the metal is low compared to a plane blade.

Speculation- in normal planing I don't see the opportunity for a bade tip to reach a temperature where it will loose hardness. There is too much heat capacity of the metal and it is a good conductor to carry the heat away from the tip. Of greater interest is whether the blade will reach a temperature where corrosive wear becomes important, as it is in milling wood with a high speed router bit. If it does the chromium content of A2 and PMV11 could contribute to their edge life.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#7

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

David Weaver

Same thing with the muji plane that's 63 degrees pitch. I'm sure I've had some of that stuff on a cap iron at some point, I just don't remember when.

It's a little bit of a nuisance to get off.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#8

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This result says the shaving is getting hot enough to volatilize stuff from the wood which is condensing on the cooler bade.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#9

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Brian Holcombe

Using a highly rounded plane on a chair seat in hard wood. The small area contacting the wood just couldn't handle the pace of the work. Of course I had to hone past that and decided not to take such a course of action in the future.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#10

Re: work=heat

david weaver

What you describe is what went through my head (this is a decade old thought at this point, though), and the inability to tell what the actual temperature is on the wearing edge, because all we can see is the residual in the iron, which could be from shavings rubbing the edge away from the very tip, etc.

You can get bound up in your head (or I can), trying to guess at things that you can't measure, and it goes back to the same things as arguments about edge life...there's a whole range of conditions that have to be met just to talk about the same thing. Shaving thickness, iron thickness, iron type (steel), hardness, wood type, planing speed, ability of the wood to carry heat away....

While it's interesting to think about until it gets confusing, I've boiled down what I think the answer is - I don't think at most hand planing speeds it causes much of an issue or we'd be able to smell something. It could cause some (does steel wear faster at a higher temperature that's still sub tempering? Who knows).

I had a relative who had a D average in high school, but was a masterful tinkerer - he was obsessed with two things. "Work is heat" and "Noise is unnecessary wear" (applied when you know the noise isn't typical for something). I often think of him when I start puzzling over questions that have an economic answer (like, why can't we harvest some of the thermal inefficiency from electricity generation by heating mass and using the heat elsewhere later where it's needed?). these are strange things for a non-scientist to think about, but I've heard the amish lamenting the same thing when they talk about diesel engines and wasted thermal energy. Maybe it's a lineage thing (my descendants were PA dutch, just Lutheran types instead of Anabaptist).

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#11

More heat, pointless drivel - Bill..

david weaver

...the HSS iron that you will receive in the mail, i got sidetracked when I was polishing it because it's so rubbery that I didn't bother trying to polish the back with normal means. Any undulations on the back would've stifled me on cast or glass, so I gave it a basic flattening on paper, then diamond hone, and then using the wood that I've been using for this test - impregnated with 1 micron diamonds.

I don't usually use diamonds this way because it's wasteful, but i noticed that lubricating the surface of the board with WD40 greatly reduces both heat and the cutting ability of the diamonds (I'm guessing they're slipping all over the place and sinking into the board).

So, I let the surface of the board dry, and allowed the swarf and diamonds to form a cake on the surface, and that cake had some grip and cut much faster. This is a very lazy way of working around not having a cast plate, and for the purposes of this test, wanting to be able to rectify any contamination immediately by just replacing the board. But what shocked me was how hot the iron got when I was polishing the flat side.

I may have gotten enamored enough with it since I was freehanding that I cut the bevel a little steep, but you can solve that easily. Bringing the back up to a polish with that cake made a tremendous amount of heat, though - enough to burn the tips of my fingers on the iron. (before you fix the bevel if it's needed, drop it in a plane and take a couple of smoother shavings and look at the level of polish that it should leave on the wood - it's garish. You may work at that level all the time, but I usually sharpen with a washita, which makes it easier to get a good uniform surface because the level of polish isn't so absurdly high).

I hate to say it, but the diamond cake on wood, adding a drop of lubrication only when absolutely needed, is something I could live with on a daily basis. It prevents the diamonds from moving around and being pressed further into the wood, and economizes their use. Nothing sticks to it (contaminants) because it's dry, the flatness is determined by the prior abrasive, so the slight imperfections present in board flatness won't amount to any real issue, and even if there is a contaminant, the board is soft enough that it should just get forced into the board.

Talk about pointless wondering.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#12

The point about not smelling anything...

david weaver

..by the way. If Rob says the temper temperature is similar to carbon steel on V11, then all are in the same boat. Figure significant things start to happen if the edge gets above 350-400 degrees. One can bake maple and find out that it flat out stinks once it's been baked at that temperature to get the volatiles out (I have some torrefied wood for guitars, it looks wonderful, it's a bit harder than normal maple, but it smells like a house fire when you plane it - the whole board stinks from end to end, and planing it frees little particles to flat through the air and invade your sense of smell).

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#13

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Seems like a month ago, when hard maple was being considered for tests, that I mentioned that a dull iron can overheat in use and lose its temper. And that this happens more easily with hard maple than other woods. And I am not talking about mineral streaks here, I am talking about normal Acer saccharum.

The truth is that this stuff does not happen in the 1/8 of an inch or 1/100 of an inch from the edge; we are talking about a very small region. One does not need to be able to see blue or any other discoloration to know this is happening. We learn this by noticing how the iron acts, not by being able to see actual damage. If an iron suddenly acts as if it has been overheated and it then requires a number of sharpening cycles to regain its former quality, this evidence suggests overheating.

This is the kind of thing one would not notice without a great deal of experience.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#14

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Brian Holcombe

I noticed it on my chamfer planes. The chamfer plane has a brass wear strip which extends out to the sides of the plane, I've burned myself on this strip before during more intense working sessions and when I extract the blade there is no evidence visible on the blade (IE no blued sections) but there of course is evidence that work was conducted.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#15

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

Steve Voigt

A while back, Larry posted this clip on Instagram:

https://www.instagram.com/p/BLlVfZghNNS/

It's worth noting that the clip is actual speed. I presume it's so slow because they couldn't have gotten the images at regular speed. So, I'm sure the temperature increase would have been much more at a brisk planing speed.

In any case, it's cool to watch!

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#16

Agree...

david weaver

..which is why I said I knew I was chancing it based on your advice.

My wear pictures suggested I was getting away with it until the bark inclusion.

The real question at the edge for maple (to me) other than knowing it generates more heat, is does it go beyond that. It really doesn't matter, though - unless it appears to affect test results - I had less than stellar experience planing it years ago and put it aside then. Heat isn't its only bad habit and a little bit of planing from rough should send most people looking for something that is more hand tool friendly.

I made a couple of planes from it later, and figure it's got other bad habits. It doesn't pare nicely, it doesn't float neatly, and when mortising, it resists penetration by the chisel more than fruitwoods.

A friend of mine who uses only power tools loves it. It tablesaws crisply and sands nicely.

The strange alternate comparison of this with beech, though, is that beech appeared to work bits of metal loose from the powder iron away from the edge. The overall wear of those was less than carbon steel (A2 suffered the same fate at the edge after a while, but less neatly than the powder metals). Point being, that without the bark inclusion, the wear rate of these two woods appeared to be not that far apart, but probably for different reasons. I'd have preferred better predictability from the maple for a simple reason - i don't have a use for the wood, and would rather work through it doing these tests than working through what's essentially my plane handle stock.

I don't think heat was an issue in the maple in this test, though - it could certainly be in other planing. Especially smoothing a wide panel where the plane would get less of a rest than me taking a couple of steps backwards.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#17

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

david weaver

I wish he'd have kept the video on a little bit longer. I suspect his probe is picking up a reading from the wood, too, which while I'm planing is much warmer (as well as the air around it) than the iron was when I was done. There is a little bit of faffing time elapsing between planing and my measuring of the iron, though, when it was probably dumping heat into the plane (probably more correct to say the plane was absorbing heat). It would've been nice to see what the temperature reading would've been with the quick-cooling shavings not present (heating the surrounding air).

I've noticed irons being warmer after brisk planing before, though, but never enough to be painful. Just seemingly a dozen or two degrees warmer.

Not that any of the pondering is more important than the actual planing results (which is really what this testing was for - regardless of what the reason might be, what lasts longest given the test set. I would've assumed if heat was really much of an issue, the two high temper temp irons would've beaten the V11).

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#18

Bark inclusion

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The defect you had in the maple was not a bark inclusion. A bark inclusion would have been associated with irregular grain like scar tissue or callous wood, as the tree worked to heal over the bark and get back to normal wood.

Your defect was normal grain that was stained and was abusive to the edge. We call these defects mineral streaks in the trade. See Wenger, Panshin, Hoadley, et alia.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#19

smell

John in NM

I don't think you'd smell much even if things were getting hot enough to accelerate wear on the iron - after all, you don't smell wood burning when a scraper gets hot, and I don't think an iron is reaching that level for the reasons Bill mentioned.

I would be pretty surprised to see an iron get hot enough to worry about temper in planing. I wouldn't be surprised at all if the very edge of it got hot enough to affect the overall mechanisms of wear.

If you really want to know the temperature at the edge, you might be able to set up some kind of holder for a laser thermometer. They actually work quite well and usually have a peak hold feature. I think some of the better multimeters have temperature probes and a setting on the meter to display calibrated temperature - that would be easier to set up on a plane, but a more expensive system.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#20

Re: Bark inclusion

david weaver

I'll take that into account. I'm not inclined to define it in the summary that gets posted ultimately. My picture was taken after most of it was planed out, so the gritty looking part was mostly gone.

There are several other spots on the outside of the board that I'll get a picture of with a surface scope - I can't find my old hand held scope and am waiting for another one to be delivered, or we'd have seen a better picture.

For the purpose of the summary, it's not vital what it actually is other than that it damaged every edge and puts into perspective the conditions needed to actually attain the idealized results (in beech, none of the irons suffered any significant defects. I expected greater degradation of surface quality as wear accumulated on the more highly alloyed irons, but it didn't happen - they all just lost lustre as the irons wore. Only the O1 iron showed no evidence of any visible issues, though - well, the japanese iron did the same, but its lustre dulled almost immediately. It robbed itself of performance by giving up the chunks seen in the pictures, but they were too small to leave visible lines). Or to be more clear, until the O1 iron was spent, all of the other irons left surfaces with no defects. The point where they began to leave very minor defects that were very difficult to see was after 800 feet.

It may be their resistance to abrasives that causes people to sharpen them incompletely (but that still butts up against K&K's much harsher conditions where they did find everything other than carbon steel had some kind of surface quality failing).

This was the first time that i very deliberately extended the sharpening cycle and checked with a scope until all marks were removed from the entire edge of all of the irons (think 400 total strokes on three sharpening stones), and I'm not sure that I'm not just as guilty of this in the past. But I'm also sure I have zero interest in 400 strokes on a sharpening stone when a fraction of that on carbon steel will completely refresh an edge (where the defects seem less likely in the first place).

I think every mostly or all hand tools worker is still going to stick with carbon steel even though there's no chance that any carbon steel iron that I've ever seen will match the V11, chinese steel and 3V in longevity of lifting a shaving. The total in-context time spent on the carbon steel irons is probably still less, and subjectively, the predictability of the quality is a lot easier. Sharpen once, use, no finding defects that weren't removed. Dull, sharpen again. No sharpen, plane some, super bright finish with lines in the middle, resharpen, still a line in the middle, and after 10 minutes, finally get a period of finish quality performance.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#21

Re: smell

david weaver

I think the part that would heat is like some fraction of a thousandth, and because of the conductivity of the iron, after the instant when the heat occurred, it would quickly be absorbed by the surrounding metal. I'm not sure it can be accurately measured with anything a mere mortal can afford.

The outcome is a better predictor. If there was enough to burn even a tiny part of wood, I would think it would still be aromatic.

Last year, I was cutting a bead on cherry trim with a boxed moulding plane. The boxing was the entire bead profile (griffiths plane, not a cheapie), and every time you take a stroke with it, something about the cherry causes it to burn. It stinks almost immediately before there is any evidence of the burning on the plane (it doesn't show up on the wood). If you continue to plane, then gradually the smell gets much stronger and the surface of the boxing shows burn damage. This occurs at very routine planing speeds (even when you're being careful about the profile vs. just slamming the plane up and down the length of the wood).

To find when heat actually makes a difference at the edge, the easiest thing to do would be just to have a planing machine and use an HSS iron and a carbon steel iron and run tests incrementally increasing the speed. I'd assume that in most test scenarios, the speed would be beyond what we do, but perhaps in some (as warren suggests, maple) it may occur at lower speeds.

The problem (and what I'll have when I publish the longevity results with all of the conditions and materials, methods, etc) is that nobody likes a complicated result. If warren says maple causes iron temper problems sometimes, that's good enough for me. People want a blanket answer for everything (pine to leadwood), which is naive.

I expect the first thing I'll hear once I publish results is that someone else will lean on a plane, plane twice as many feet, link to my report in a blog and tell everyone I have no idea what i'm doing. That's OK - there are people more familiar with sharpening or planing or this or that than me, but not many.

(the planing machine outcome to generate material damage due to heat would be interesting, but I'd rather just have LV tell us where they found that to be an issue if they would be willing to. I'd not be surprised if the super surfacer could easily create heat problems the way it smashes through huge heavy cuts at high speed).

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#22

Re: Bark inclusion

david weaver

To be clear, I'm assuming you're probably right about the mineral streak, but given the granular appearance of stuff in the middle, i still want to get a picture of it. It's different looking than a lot of the more minor typical dark marks in maple. May just be more concentration of minerals than most.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#23

David's results show heat irrelevant

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Kato and Kawia's papers provide data to calculate the work, and hence heat, that is generated just by the blade (no sole component) and the wear photos show where this heat is deposited. Will do calculations later.

If heat was important in edge life 3V and M2 would stand out in wear resistance compared to the others. Both are tempered way above any temperature that could be generated (1000 degrees F for 3V) . If heat was destroying the hardness of LV11 (tempered similar to O-1 and A2) there blades would have fallen short of 3V and M2. O-1 and A2 did but for other reasons.

David's data set is a gold mine to tease conclusions from. Enough fundamental variables were investigated to make valid conclusions on the importance of these fundamental variables to edge life.

I hate to stimulate yet more work, but what has not been investigated is the effect of hardness. Problem is this variable would be difficult to separate from toughness for the two are highly correlated.

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#24

Effect of hardness

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill and all,

This could be tested using the Tsunesaburo iron, provided someone has a hardness test setup. The test would be destructive.

Test:

1. Check Rc right now (david thinks it’s really high)

2. Do a test run, with photos.

3. Put iron in oven at 400-425F for a while, and retest Rc (IIRC 220C is the upper end of tempering advised by Hitachi).

4. Make another test run, and compare.

Wiley

Re: Side fact, temperature change from planing..

#25

No

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You are assuming that all the irons generate the same amount of heat. Any evidence for that? I would expect stainless steels like so called "Pm v11" to give off less heat. I would expect less friction because the steel resists sharpening by abrasion. All that chromium makes the iron more slippery.