Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Why you can't make blanket statements..

Posts

Why you can't make blanket statements..

#1

Why you can't make blanket statements..

david weaver

...and a subtest to come. Before I do any more tests, I'm waiting for a hand held scope. I've lost the $11 one that I had, but intend to take a picture of the wear on the bevel side of these irons.

Leafing through the pictures, it's strange how different beech is on an edge vs. maple. I could actually feel it a little bit. Drier, more powdery feeling (no powder hanging around, but think waxed paper (maple) vs. the texture on a paper bag (not nearly that, but that kind of feel) on the beech shavings.

A comparison of the powder metal irons on both at 200 shavings (this was after the edge battering on maple, the smooth edge pictures are from the side opposite the bark inclusion).

V11 - maple - 800 feet:


V11 - beech - 800 feet:


3v maple - 800 feet:


3v beech - 800 feet:


The edges are clearly coming apart differently in the two woods. Now, it may be that they're not that much different, but that the grainy texture on beech is less prominent (below the visual wavelength). Whatever the case, I'm not open to much criticism about results unless someone wants to recreate them.

As far as what the follow up to this is, subjectively during the maple test, I felt like the pictures showed less wear on the 3V. I'm not interested in retesting all of the irons just to see if I can make the results match my expectations, but these two irons were head and shoulders above the rest in maple (LN A2 was falling apart much more quickly than it did in beech, the HSS was taking a little more beating - also, if it would do better, who cares. If I can't convey the value of a $10 iron that does as well as it does, showing it in other test isn't going to make the message come through).

So, the follow up is that once I get pictures of the edges as they are on the bevel side, and before I do any other tests, I'm going to complete the maple test with the top two irons. If V11 again fares better, then other than curiosities (like figuring out if the tsunesaburo irons desire to release blobs can be avoided) the tests (end grain, different bevel angles, different levels of final finish) will be done with the O1 iron and the V11 iron only. They're relatively far apart, and we'll see if that relative gap stays there with some changing variables.

The beech test results are reliable, but the level of care taken to ensure an edge cleaner than most people will ever use, with fewer visible flaws than most people will ever have in an edge they're using, it would be nice to confirm that such results stay consistent with more ordinary and faster sharpening routines.

Where's patrick chase when you need him? I could count on patrick to reply that all of his edges would hold up to the same scrutiny under a microscope, but as cheap as it is to check that, I can only say - take an iron that you're using, sharpen it quickly like you normally would, and then look at the entire length under a scope. You're not likely to find perfection from edge to edge, and nobody would put a back bevel on an iron as large as I did on these - but you need to if you really want perfection at the edge of a really hard iron. The back bevel itself becomes a pain (to me) because once it has some size, it isn't refreshed in ten strokes. If it doesn't have some size, then stray scratches will go through it to the edge, and those will turn into nicks and faults (I will take a picture of the progressive development of one of those faults in 3V vs. O1, too).

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#2

makes sense

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

curiosities will be done with the O1 iron and the V11 iron only.

It makes sense to shrink the candidates. You showed that there is no reason to go to the trouble to make an M2 or 3V blade when you can buy a better blade from LV, and that we should abandon A2 for woodworking tools. Given the practical choices are now O1 and PMV11, what people want to know is what is the best way to use these choices for how most people use planes.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#3

Even if...

david weaver

..things even up in the maple sample with 3V, it's tough, maybe they will, it's not commercially available and it's from my perception, a full rung up on the ladder in terms of sharpening difficulty because the material removal with diamonds is slower.

I think we'll be able to establish that of the available options for most things, V11 is a better choice. But, I'd also still say if someone loves LN products and the stanley plane type, it's not like A2 is bad, it just doesn't fare as well in the maple and beech tests.

I was pondering why LV even offers A2 anymore, and then thought about the fact that I was going to do this whole test with the 5 1/2 instead of the LN smoother, and one of the reasons that I didn't was because there was no online stock of V11 irons in 2 3/8" (I'm certainly not going to ask LV to track me down an iron - I hate it when people do performance reviews of "stuff" and they go directly to manufacturers and get samples of whatever they're going to test).

So far as to stick my neck out a little, LN's A2 is a little bit better than LVs. That's been my experience (not so much longevity as edge uniformity) and brent beach's pictures show the same thing. The only reason I can think of that LV still offers it is to give people something other than O1 to buy when the V11 is out of stock.

Since we've established the two end points (but I'd still use any iron in this study without issue day to day - I picked all of them because other than not using 3V before, I knew they were all good irons from use - how good was the question), I'd like to cut down on data gathering time and study other cutting conditions, other abrasives/sizes and other final bevels.

As you've suggested, there's all kinds of things people do - I don't believe many sharpen to the standard that we've performed so far, as I've bought a lot of used planes (not going to name the sellers) and I've never seen an iron close. I trust that if I got a plane from warren or brian or some other folks, I wouldn't be able to improve on what they do, but few people must actually sharpen to a spec like that or it's unlikely I wouldn't have seen it rifling through used premium planes.

At any rate, I hope nobody who already has well outfitted kit reads this study once it's done and decides they need to wholesale replace things they were already happy with. I'm not even doing that, and the feel during testing was pretty convincing. Dumping metal planes for wood for all of the rough and penultimate work, simplifying sharpening and figuring out how to use the cap iron to reduce labor was more effective than this. But that goes back to your mention of lifting shavings - I can tell someone who trims with a plane all I want to about carbon steel and washita stones and wooden planes, they're still going to ask what will make sharpening occur less frequently for them.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#4

(It's a matter of likelihood, of course)

david weaver

observing what happens with subsequent changes in variables. If the gap stays similar between V11 and O1, then it's far more unlikely that there's a need to view anything from the other steels for those tests (other people could do them if they like).

That won't satisfy critics who say they plane pine knots and leadwood all day, but too much attention is given to "difficult" woods when few people do much actual hand planing in them. The solution for those is still getting better - actually, faster - at sharpening, not buying more stuff (I tried the former first - the latter was more effective, even though we're marketed to believe that we're solving the problem if we buy something directly for it vs. figuring out how to get past it).

And - I love the chinese irons, but I flattened the one I'm going to send you. They are unbelievably abrasive resistant over a large area. You cannot even feel 80 grit fresh PSA paper doing anything with them, and I have a house made holder for the irons that makes them hot enough on that paper to melt the lacquer on the back of the iron. Someone using two fingers and a stone to try to flatten them would be SOL.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#5

Re: (It's a matter of likelihood, of course)

Steve Voigt

David, I've been thinking about how these results might vary in different species. Last week, I made some float handles in African Blackwood and Boxwood. With the blackwood, my normal O1 iron was badly dull after 50 or so shavings…on a five inch long blank. So that's less than 25 lineal feet. Caleb and Darryl (both of whom I hold in high regard) commented that they considered PMV11 mandatory in something like blackwood.

You're right that folks often make too much of "difficult" woods--no one in their right mind is going to be building cabinets out of blackwood, or lignum vitae. Euro/American handtools are best suited for the more moderate hardwoods (and softwoods) that have historically been used here, and it made sense to do your testing on medium hardness timber that represents what the majority of woodworkers are using these irons for. But I guess my point is that I agree we can't make blanket statements, and the results are likely to vary significantly by species.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#6

You can't make blanket statements..

roger lance

isn't that a blanket statement ???????

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#7

"Hardest" species

Jim Matthews

I wonder if there's more to workability in wood than Janka numbers.

Is there an abrasive inclusion in the lignin of species like Gabon Ebony, such as silica?

There's a reason Kezuroukai specifically select fine Alaskan Yellow Cedar for competitions - it yields gossamer shavings.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#8

Re: "Hardest" species

David Weaver

There is definitely more to workability than just janka, but it's a big part.

Beech and hard maple are very close together, and ash is probably close to them (white, green, whatever....).

Dimensioning hard maple from rough is the worst of that bunch by a bigger factor than any particular hardness. No clue what it is other than it is.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#9

Re: (It's a matter of likelihood, of course)

David Weaver

Making tools is definitely somewhere that people would work woods like that. I haven't used blackwood (too expensive, and probably on CITES listing, so not changing until they meet again and there's some at least limited relief).

Anyway, the thing that sent me down this rabbit hole years ago was getting some sparkly cocobolo turning blanks and cutting them apart to make plane handles. I couldn't thickness a single plane handle blank with an A2 iron, so I bought some of the chinese planes and that provided some relief (it still would've probably been easier to sharpen a few times, but i was going to get the "right tool).

So I scratched that itch (and used those planes to size cocobolo infill blanks), and was just getting into hand dimensioning and thinking "AWWW YEAAHH....I've got a plane iron that worked through about 4 or 5 times as much of the cocobolo without dulling and wait until that multiplier goes to cherry, soft maple and walnut!!"

And then it didn't.

I've been curious for a long time about what's what, but fast sharpening and a cap iron beat buying magic steel 10 to 1, so that was the end of that.

Still on the bender to make a couple of irons that wear reasonably well an have almost no wire edge tendency (despite the results of this testing).

But if I was making nothing but infill plane blanks, I might think of setting up with the HSS tooling again. I can understand why other people would, too.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#10

Re: You can't make blanket statements..

david weaver

It is. But it's the blanket statement negating all others!! :)

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#11

Re: (It's a matter of likelihood, of course)

Steve Voigt

Funny, cocobolo (purchased 20 years ago) is the only exotic I normally use (for strike buttons). I use it in such tiny quantities that issues of blade durability don't even come up. It's hard,but significantly less horrible on edges than the African blackwood. I really will be fine if I never use that stuff again!

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#12

Re: "Hardest" species

Rum

I remember a particularily miserable time trying to plane out a chunk of black locust I'd cut out of a friends tree that came down.

I'm not sure what it was as the wood wasn't really all THAT hard (wood DB claims 1700 which seems about right, hard but not anywhere near blackwood & friends) but about 3 plane strokes (old stanley O1 for the record) and there'd be big wear streaks in the blade, enough to leave visible ridges on the wood. No obvious inclusions so my theory is/was that there were silica streaks in the tree for some reason (apparently locust is known to do that). I eventually gave up on it and now the chunks sit on my lumber shelf slowly growing harder and mocking me.

Another chunk made a truely fantastic chopping block though.

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#13

Re: "Hardest" species

david weaver

I haven't planed much locust, just a little bit. It lasts for eons in the ground, and it makes the chainsaw spark (we burned a lot of it) sometimes.

If wood makes a chainsaw spark when you cut it, it's bad!!

Janka measures a dent if I remember correctly. There should be another measure that provides the hardest constituent part of wood, also , as it's not a complete measure for harshness on tools. It's a good start, but indian rosewood is supposedly much harder and so is gabon ebony, and they both plane wonderfully (gabon ebony doesn't have a lot of directional conviction, and fractures a lot, but it's pleasant to plane through).

I fell into the trap of thinking that my tool kit and irons should be set up to deal with those woods, even though I knew they'd only be a small percentage of what I work with in the long term. Understanding ideal weight for tools, etc, cooled my jets about making planes from rosewood, etc, too. Nobody wants a 28" rosewood jointer that's full height and width unless it's going to sit on a shelf "look at this plane...it's 17 pounds!! it'll go through anything!!" (including users).

Re: Why you can't make blanket statements..

#14

Re: "Hardest" species

Rum

Yeah it's taken a long time but I've slowly come around to the conclusion that its at least usually smarter to adjust the wood used to my tooling and capabilities than vice-versa. There is always the desire to try something new of course which sometimes leads one a ways down a blind alley 8)

I DO like some of the harder woods, like ebony (except the cracking problem) for small stuff with lots of detail work on then.. although in some cases its much easier to get as much detail into gentler woods like cherry.. that's not true in all cases though.

Definitely a case by case situation. I think if I need some trenails for a boat or something I'll be motivated to revisit the black locust :)