Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

My favorite durability claim so far...

Posts

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#26

Re: I'm not sure I would notice the difference....

Charlie

I'm going to get a PM-V11 iron for my jack if nothing else. Might get one for my jointer too, and then smoother. It these things will last two to three times as long as 01, and get just as sharp, it would be totally irrational to ever use anything else.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#27

Re: I'm not sure I would notice the difference....

David Weaver

How often do you take a jack and jointer shaving that's really thin? OR a whole bunch of them in a row?

Bill asked me earlier why I don't use irons like this for the coarser planes, and I mentioned to him that I really don't remember the last time I felt like the jointer or the jack plane needed something that lasted longer, but I sure hate irons that take a nick and then are hard to sharpen on either one.

I don't want to steer any newbies on here who think they're going to find purchasing recommendations in the conversations except to say that this test is for smoothing and I wouldn't assume that it's useful for jack planing or edge jointing boards that aren't already clean lumber.

I'll believe that you're going to buy any of these when you show a picture of all of them lined up in your planes. I don't think anyone who has been around for a while assumes that any of your comments are made in earnest.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#28

Re: I'm not sure I would notice the difference....

Charlie

With those kind of results it doesn't matter what thickness the shaving is. There should be a profound and obvious difference.

I take thin shavings with a jointer all the time. The best smoother you'll ever have is a No. 7 or 8.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#29

I've never adhered to that

David Weaver

Someone braver than me can test what these things do in white oak at a hundredth or so.

I suspect that there are factors in that kind of work that go beyond smoother shavings. Just assuming that one works to infer results for another is kind of foolish.

I've never found the big thrill with using a jointer as a smoother. It's more work and it tells you less about what it's doing through the handles.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#30

Re: I've never adhered to that

Charlie

I don't switch planes if the jointer is pulling up beautiful shavings and the surface looks good. No reason to.

A steel that outlasts another steel by a factor of 2.5 to 3.0, even if making smoother passes, still ought to be better in a jack and jointer. A factor of two to three is a lot of cushion for a little degradation in performance.

Don't be afraid of your own numbers. They're stark. But that what the data says.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#31

Re: I've never adhered to that

Charlie

s/b 'that's' Memphis rubbing off on me...

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#32

Just to stay accurate...

Jonathan Elliott

...with the actual data numbers. PMV11 lasted exactly 2 times as long as O1, in this particular test, under these particular circumstances and parameters, not 2.5 to 3 times.

No one is making claims to anything more. To predict that others will likely try to do that is probably true.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#33

Re: Just to stay accurate...

Charlie

True, but still enough for me to give it a try. I do need the added durability in a jack plane iron though. I wouldn't mind it cutting well for an hour or so (++) before needing to be refreshed.

I rarely remove measurable thickness with a smoothing plane -- a few very light passes only if used at all. I prefer to keep long planes on the wood as long as they're cutting well, and if they're working extremely well, often the case, then they're the last planes that I would use under theory if it ain't broke then don't fix it.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#34

Re: Just to stay accurate...

david weaver

This is an ideal steel for the smoothing you're talking about.

You're twice the man that I am if you could do jack work for an hour, sharpen and then continue on. I think I could do that once.

In the middle of this test, as this iron dusted my beloved shop made iron by a mile, I start to think "what I am doing making my own stuff?", but I cannot deny the sweetness of steels that work on the stones that I have the way I like.

I'm inclined to do a comparo test between O1 and an old ward blade. if the ward blade beats O1 by any significant amount, I'd be very surprised, but the older ward are water hardening steel and they are the sweetest thing in the world on oilstones.

You mentioned changing planes, maybe I responded to it already, but I made my own jack, and my metal jointer is a dandy I. Sorby jointer (which usually gets fairly little use in favor of faster working with the try plane - the metal plane gets used to finish edges/match joints and to work small things - occasionally if I'm working on something and the try plane isn't sharp, I'll use it out of laziness). The sorby jointer has one of the softest irons I've seen on a metal plane, but I will try everything these days. It would probably do horribly in this test, but drag it across a stone, it rolls up a wire edge, remove it and you're off again.

That is a draw for me to the shop. What would it last vs. the V11 - a third? I don't know. It's very uncommon for me to take 500 feet of shavings with it all at once. The inclusion that stopped the other test would damage it, too, but how long would it take to repair? three minutes, maybe.

I didn't set out to make this test something that would change my gear, though it's probably gone so far as convincing me to keep the V11 iron rather than sell it on ebay. I did think we'd be able to find 3V superior, and that V11 would be close to A2. In both runs (up to the point where the maple test stopped), I wasn't able to prove that. I suspect the record plane was a slight disadvantage for 3V. Was it 50 shavings? I don't know - it's not available on the open market as a commercial product, so it's not material to the test.

I'm over the moon with how the chinese iron performed, and I was actually using that one at the time of this test in a stanley smoother. There are some things about it that make it less ideal for a beginner, though (occasional voids in the steel, not flat when you get it and harder to flatten than A2 - the cap iron slides on the polished face of it - it's really slick and resistant to abrasives over a large flat surface).

If you're not sure about my thoughts that V11 would be brought back to earth, you can see the tirade I went on about LV's O1 not being as hard as I'd like, and wishing they would optimize those irons. Not that you need to. But, I was at the beach for the week and bored and supposing things before testing them. I just turned out not to be correct, and may have been a little bit out of line. When I ordered the V11 iron, it was on the heels of that, and I was a little bit concerned that my order might not get filled.

So, at least in the results of this test and based on the progress in the maple test, I was wrong. It happens.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#35

Re: Just to stay accurate...

Charlie

I wouldn't jack plane for a solid hour, but I wouldn't mind not sharpening at that first 30 minute break either.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#36

Re: Just to stay accurate...

Charlie

I have a Hock 01 iron in a Record 08 and it can really do just about anything. I have a standard Record iron for it that shaped with a pretty decent curvature that I use from time to time as well -- like a very large jack plane.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#37

Re: I have no idea...

david weaver

...what I'd do at that point if I wasn't sharpening. I'd hate to fully relax for two minutes. I have no idea how one would chart momentum and inertia in planing rough wood, but it's got to be worth something. Easy sharpening irons in rough planes just seem like the way to go. I can't prove that they "more closer" than the result of the smoother irons, but it just sort of feels like either they are, or it doesn't matter that they aren't.

Plus, your second half hour would be with the dulling half of an irons life. If you could manage to plane for a full hour without hitting anything that would nick off anything on the blade. That sounds uninviting. Rolling an easy burr up on an agreeable iron when you're tired....that doesn't sound uninviting.