Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

My favorite durability claim so far...

Posts

My favorite durability claim so far...

#1

My favorite durability claim so far...

david weaver

https://www.thewoodworks.com.au/shop/spares/spares/plane-blades-bench-3-to-8/blade-plane-bench-hss-tipped-detail

Looking for an academy saw works blade yesterday as I'm fairly sure the chinese blade is a good blade, but i don't know for sure that it meets is hardness spec and it may not give an accurate view of what M2 is capable of.

I never found a hobart or ASW blade, but I again found people trying to push a $100 kunz blade (that always pisses me off) and then this page - claim excerpted here.

"You can expect 20 to 40 times the interval between sharpenings when upgrading to High Speed Steel "

The listing goes on to explain the virtues of grinding hot and not worrying about it, but there's a reality to that - you'll burn your fingers on the iron. HSS irons don't spark much and they do seem to generate a lot more heat on the wheel (i'm using CBN, so it's not like I'm at the high end of the heat spectrum, either - I can still brown an edge on CBN if I feel like it, but I either have to set the iron down and something else or lay it on top of an oilstone for a little bit and let the stone soak some of the heat out of it)'

Then:

"The modified blade may require an upgrade of sharpening equipment - Japanese Waterstones are recommended."

(I'm guessing they sell waterstones, and probably not much loose diamond. I can sharpen HSS on oilstones now, as bill points out, not to its max potential, but the chinese iron in this test is something I sharpen regularly with oilstones. Something like soft waterstones would be a mistake with HSS irons)

Then, since the bit is small, they say this at the end:

"Remember that tool steel plane blades are only tip hardened and when they are worn down within about 10 to 12mm of the back iron slot the steel will not hold an edge."

Maybe that's true for new irons. I've got a lot of older irons that I've gotten in planes that were worn almost to the slot, and they still work fine.

LN told George that they weren't hardening the full length of their water hardening steel irons, but with their tendency to warp, it's easy to understand why they'd do that. I would expect that while the slots on a lot of new irons can be filed a little bit to fit a plane, I'd sure hope that they were hardened to the slot on the bit end.

20 to 40 times, though...wow.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#2

this post explains the previous question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was asked, what is the point of David's research? It can not be explained better than this advertising claim.

When completed, there will be two conclusions valuable to me, and one that will satisfy a nagging curiosity. One result is already revealed. That is, there are two, at least, categories of planers that have little in common either in practice or on these Forums- shaving lifters that could care less about surface appearance so long as the plane is reliably lifting shavings, and surface grazers who value appearance above all else.

1st the nagging curiosity. Does wear resistance, as measured and reported by steel manufacturers, predict edge life for lifters or grazers? This curiosity became nagging when LV claimed edge life way beyond what would be predicted from composition and abrasion resistance for the steels tested.

2nd abrasion resistant steel. Is it worth the trouble and expense to buy plane blades made of abrasion resistant steel? Two candidates will answer this question with reliable data-M2 which is abrasion resistant but not exceptionally tough yet to be found in everyone's power planer and jointer knives and many lathe tools, and 3V which is both abrasion resistant and exceptionally tough. David and Steve Elliot have dismissed they myth that these abrasion resistant steels can't be sharpened. So, should we be using them?

3rd What level of edge refinement is good enough. People sharpen to the extremes of edge refinement. It is relatively easy to do yet pricy if done with modern ceramic stone abrasives. At what point does edge refinement no longer yield a benefit in edge life? It may well be that most of us could remove a step from our sharpening procedures. In my case I might move from (1)grind, (2)fine fixed diamond, (3)1 micron loose diamond to simply (1)grind and (2) 5 micron loose. Sharpening time would decrease by 2 or three fold.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#3

Re: I think...

david weaver

that one is bad enough (20-40 times) that nobody will believe it. You know better than I do, I'm sure, that even once you nail down a composition (M2, for example), some samples may be tempered in a certain hardness range to preserve more toughness and still may not be ideal for planes or chisels.

I know the ASW blades that brent beach tested are harder than the chinese blade that I have. I'd have to have the chinese blades tested to find out how much, but even if they are at the bottom of their spec (60, and they very well may be), there's a huge chasm to a hand sharpener between 60 and 64 hardness and the results will show.

Subjectively, I felt like I didn't get the edge life i expected out of V11 but wouldn't be surprised if I was incorrect ultimately and it's better than I think (now with the benefit of seeing it last 600 shavings and cut smartly through all of it until it ran into what was probably a bark inclusion - only the plain steel blade left in the test took little damage).

It's worth charting wear, and since we have the scope available, coupling it with edge quality in a *good* testing regime that's had a lot of variables taken out. That can sprout further test ideas, as it has.

LV's claim may end up being right in wood, and the two plane types I used a significant amount may have been the cause for what I found.

it's also important to me if I say I don't think V11 lasts that much longer than anything else around, it's only responsible for me to actually do something rather than throwing shade from my recollection of actual use that wasn't identical. I owe that much in fairness to LV, not to make errant statements out of laziness.

I also wanted to test my ideas about how blade uniformity contributes toward extra longevity (because it seems to be what I gravitate toward in my constructive laziness). I kind of wonder if the second test with uniformity will start the same as the first. My house made iron chugged along OK and then abruptly ran out of clearance without any edge degrading. I want to see the same thing happen again to make sure I didn't make a sharpening error in setting the iron in the jig. I, perhaps misguided, was hoping it would last just on the heels of the LN iron - but it didn't. It probably won't the second time.

These are all nice things to know, and they're deliberately set up so that someone else can recreate the same results if they want to study another avenue. I could've been snotty and just taken some boards and planed them, released a number of shavings taken, made very opinionated statements about surfaces rather than objective, and sharpened freehand. There wouldn't be a springing off point.

I hope that I'm also about as close to unbiased as anyone would be with this stuff. I'm receiving nothing free (wiley did loan me a blade, but it's going back), have no relationships with anyone involved, and unless I have a severe change in job status, I won't be making and selling shop made irons.

This is intended to be free result generating and open source if someone wants to do linux style and test other things.

One curiosity to me, since the question of whether or not something can be sharpened was dead long ago - even carbide can be sharpened to an excruciating level. But knowing that I often sharpen something like HSS on a medium that it wasn't intended to be sharpened on, how much of a loss in performance will I get if I sharpen HSS on a washita and a strop, or 3V on the japanese stone that I sharpened it on first. What will the surface look like?

There will be a few charlies who get bent out of shape because i'm not building furniture, but I'm not going to be building much for a long time (thanks to guitars and tools) except under duress (threat from the spouse to go out and buy some cases she'd still like to have made).

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#4

Haters gonna hate...

Jim Matthews

Charlie can produce a portfolio of commission pieces, I'm sure.

Funny how the Big Dogs are the most gracious on these forums.

It's the Barking Bedroom slippers what make all the noise.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#5

Re: I think...

Charlie

I'm not bent out of shape at all. I think David's study will end up (perhaps already has) confirmed what I've said for years -- half the claims are mostly marketing puffery, you can't overcome basic physics of material truths, "improvements" are well at the margins, etc., etc. Indeed I've been banned from forums for stating this very thing in explicit, colorful, and less than diplomatic language.

I tried A2 when it came out, I tried PM-V11 when it came out. All I could ever manage for both of these was a huge yawn. They work fine, but nothing to get excited about. I actually like Hock O1, and I've used Japanese steel which seemed to me a lot like the Hock but maybe a little better. It was good stuff, lasted a little longer, but all of it when sharp produced a decent enough surface. I could probably manage a finer shaving the harder a steel seemed to be but I didn't feel faint and lightheaded over the 'discovery' of this. I don't find much of any of this to be transformative. I might if my job were to plane lumber all day. Thankfully it is not. I guess that after being taught basic sharpening skills and how to sweep the floor the next thing that young teenage apprentices were turned loose on was planing up the stock for the rest of the shop. So, there's that.

At this point, I'm only hoping that David will type all of this up into a neat report with photos, graphs, narratives, etc. and publish it to a PDF. I can't follow all the posts and have never particularly cared for WC's forum software, which makes projects like David has undertaken almost impossible to follow, at least for pea-brained guys with short attention spans like me.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#6

Re: I think...

David Weaver

from one pea brained short attention span guy to another, I will be organizing and condensing the results.

I think one thing you're saying is true - the results of all of these irons may differ, but they will probably be more condensed than the claims would lead one to believe.

They're unlikely to change what I use making things - you can sharpen an O1 iron almost without thinking on a washita and step it up a little with something if you want to. Recovering these things after the inclusion is a good lesson as to why that's so practical. It would've taken me minutes to recover and resharpen a stanley iron and remove the wire edge.

That said, I may have said it on here, or elsewhere. I get the sense that a lot of advice posts from people show that they're experiencing what the ad copy said they would. That could happen, but often it's just confirmation bias and it bugs me. From a less rosy standpoint, I think quite a few of the posts stating those results are completely subjective with no intention of judging whether or not the poster has ever actually experienced what they're talking about. That leads to bad advice, or maybe the first question that never was asked:

Is this about making things, or is this about having things that are nice to use? A test like this is really pleasant to run because it's idealized and there is a goal, but it is not remotely similar to planing boards to make floor trim or kitchen cabinet parts.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#7

Re: I think...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I mean this comment with the greatest respect....your post is exactly why David's work is important. As a shaving lifter watching from the side lines I see my M2 jointer and planer knives lasting months and my carbon steel plane edges lasting hours. And I wonder, am I missing something? And then I read posts such as this one, from someone I don't know anything about but who seems experienced, that says there is no significant benefit to be had. If true, my curiosity leads to why wouldn't M2 make a substantially better plane blade? You have my attention, but you haven't provided data to drive a decision.

We have lots of opinions from people that seem to have experience. What is lacking is data derived from well thought out and executed experiments. LV could have gotten believable data and chose not to, or got data and didn't publish. Why spend a small fortune building a planing machine and just test MDF? Maybe they would sell it to David.

I have a 3V plane blade that has set on the shelf for years. Your post will keep it there for a while. I bought a plane with a PMV11 blade because it only cost 15% more. I figured it could have a 15% benefit. I'll bet they would not sell any if the premium was even half the benefit claim. When David gets done the 3V blade will either stay on the shelf or get installed, but in either case a decision will be made based on good data.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#9

I just read...

John in NM

an article that was describing what is and has mostly always been wrong with nutritional studies, and the description of those studies struck me as very similar to a vastly more organized and pseudo-official version of what you see with tool reviews :D

It seems as though experienced people should all be able to come to a consensus, but many end up with vastly different opinions about things like plane blades for example. There are several possible explanations, but I don't think any one of them quite covers everything. I think reality is probably along the lines of people's modes of work just being too varied and complicated to extract anything definitive from anecdote. Useful yes, definitive no.

In that regard, I think David's efforts are useful, because in them he is trying to remove variation and make as direct a comparison as possible. However, everything is still open to interpretation or misinterpretation, as the question of M2 in machine blades should demonstrate.

I'm looking forward to the condensed version, because I'll admit I've not had the time or patience (summers are stressful at the current day job) to follow all of it, but I think I'm going to appreciate the final results.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#10

Re: I think...

Charlie

Looking forward to the results.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#11

Re: I think...

Charlie

I can't really physically last longer, continuously planing, than most stock cutters edges will last. I just hone when I take a break, this always seemed like the natural thing to do. It suits me. If somebody really did come up with a steel that stood material science on its head, that really would hold a quality edge several times longer than 01, but be just as easy to hone then I might be interested in that but I don't think such a thing exists now, and its existence may be physically impossible without some breakthrough worthy of a Nobel Prize--- marketing and advertising copy, and wishful thinking notwithstanding.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#12

Re: I think...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Charlie

There are plenty of steels that sharpen like O1 and hold an edge much longer.

These simply require that you do not expect to sharpen them with the same media you sharpen O1. For example, the Sigma stones I use hone PM-V11 with the same ease that O1 is sharpened by King stones.

David have already demonstrated that that PM-V11 outlasts O1. I have done this many time. As have others.

When it comes down to it, everything can be honed with diamonds. Longevity is not in doubt as long as the parts are not seen in isolation.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#13

Re: I think...

Brian Holcombe

I have some experience with PM V11 and did not feel that it sharpened like O1.

I do have hard wearing steels, frankly the appeal is a bit lost on me as the sheen required for my work wears off of those blades at just a slightly slower pace than white 1. I enjoy those blades for their quality buy longevity is not the utmost importance.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#14

Re: I think...

Charlie

You're selectively reading, or reading past my post(s). I don't doubt PM-V11 lasts a little longer, marginally longer than 01, but it apparently requires special honing media in order to do so. That said, I've honed it on oilstones and it seemed to get sharp. Oh well. It is not a breakthrough steel.

If David's results indicate that it lasts two or three times as long as good O1, I'd have to reproduce those results for myself before I'd believe it and I think others would too. Fifteen/twenty per cent longer -- I can buy that (with all the fluff it had better at least deliver that), but that's not enough to make me replace all my cutters and my honing kit too.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#15

Confucius ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... a noted metal worker in the Spring and Autumn period, when asked about abrasion-resistant steels, stated, "There is no free lunch".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#16

Robert Heinlein

Bruce, a MN Galoot

TANSTAAFL

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#17

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

TomD

Yeah 20-40 times seems steep for a wood tool. HSS bits for use in metal working machines are huge orders of magnitude more efficient in their intended use in machine tools, where the heat can be considerable in some operations, and when not using coolant. And the bits are sharpened by basically burning the steel away with friction. The combination of those two thoughts seems to indicate a perusal of non-wood literature.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#18

Re: Confucius ...

TomD

I would have to know more. It almost seems like a free lunch: You can sharpen to a razor type result right off the grinder, or with a tiny amount of honing. The stuff cuts like for ever, compared to wood, in fact it is hard to see how woodworking tools ever get dull after watching a shaper pare away metal for an extended period of time. The bits in use are superior in wear and equal in edge holding to what we get in woodworking, and they cost a few bucks from china. And if you are bored with that you can just use inserts, no sharpening required.

There was a lot of excitement here over a single piece of research on super surfacers. In the metal field specific research has been done on maybe thousands of different tool types for specific processes, so even the simple solutions from the 40s have been studied to death.

Yeah, I suppose he was saying something like you have harder to grind bits if they last longer, but it is hard to care all that much when you see how elementary and quick the grinding is. It is sophisticated also, but you can just eyeball it on the grinder with a simple rest. Of course if you are producing parts to a bid, that little extra time can be the difference between profit and no profit, so there probably is no free lunch in that sense.

But in the amateur shop when a few seconds a part don't mater, it certainly seems very efficient. And part of that is probably that there is a way to do everything, so you don't have to consider what that way might be, you just execute.

------------------------------------

A lot of the pros and cons on HSS come down to whether you are sharpening it efficiently. The bizarro part is that hand sharpeners sometimes tilt to HSS, or similar super steels, in order to get a better yield from their slow hand sharpening methods. It is called HSS because it does not loose it's temper when you work it aggressively. If you grind it with power, you will quickly get a long lasting razor sharp edge, but the skill and unpleasantness of that are not attractive to many.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#20

Re: Confucius ...

Charlie

No free lunches for sure, but plenty of overpriced/overhyped ones.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#21

Durability

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been using Cast Steel tools. Unlike some of these other steels, it was not designed for can openers or dies or machine shop tooling. It was not designed to fit into a marketing campaign.

Cast steel exceeds O-1 in the fineness of the edge, longevity in use and ease of sharpening. For a serious hand tool woodworker I think 0-1 is unacceptably tedious to sharpen. And the edge is not nearly so durable as cast steel.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#22

Re: Durability

Charlie

I have a Record "Crucible Cast Steel" iron in an 04. It's a good cutter, a little harder than Record's later offerings and it does take a nice edge, maybe marginally sharper and harder than new stuff. But just so. It may be that the Record iron isn't a good example of cast steel, but I've heard others say it is. That said, I do envy you guys. Y'all seem to have epiphanies on what appears to be a regular basis that have so far eluded me.

Fine Woodworking has restarted their forums and I just yesterday found myself reading an old thread (13 or so years old I think -cool that they retained old posts) dealing with A2 and the gushing was not to be believed, and from some fairly recognizable names. Dunno what to make of all of this or how to reconcile it. It is what it is I guess. Seems almost like the fashion industry to be honest -- nothing more gauche than being caught wearing last season's Prada.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#23

I don't agree with warren on this one..

David Weaver

..about the longevity of the cast steel irons vs. O1. I don't think the two are any different in longevity, though the fineness of the cast steel might be better.

I have one remaining hock iron and a bunch that I've made. I think the ones that I've made, tailored to the situation, are the best that I've used, and I can test mine against hocks at some point in the future and risk embarrassment by doing it (I'm not afraid of being wrong, I'd much rather be wrong than attached to intentionally misleading information).

I also have little issue with O1 except from the most ideal standpoint in sharpening, which is lack of wire edge retention. O1 has noticeably more than older tools, but it's insignificant relative to the very strong wire edge holding tendencies of HSS, 3V, A2 and V11.

The results of this test aren't going to change anything that I use. I use either vintage irons or my own make, or (I have two working #4 smoothers that I use on a regular basis - I don't use the LN smoother that I used in this test for more than a calibration when making infills - as in, can I make something that is as smooth in the cut, as flat and as solid feeling)...the other iron that I use in a stanley 4 opposite those that I've made is one of the green chinese HSS irons in this test. I am enamored with it because of how good it is for $7-$11, including shipping to your door.

Of all of the irons I've ever used, only a couple come to mind as being really significant underperformers:

* the irons that come with primus planes (despite their promises of long wear, they don't deliver)

* shepherd A2

The former was probably a gross overpromise, and the latter was just outright defective (and I"m not the only person who found the same performance - hard sharpening, big edge defects).

I also have had four of the record planes that you mention. The ones that say something like tungesten crucible cast steel or something of the sort. They are no better or finer than a typical stanley iron, but they did a good job advertising them and talking up the fineness of the steel with grain pictures.

I still have one in a cherry record #8 (Vintage, not one of the newer ones) that the English folks made me pay dearly to get.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#24

Re: I don't agree with warren on this one..

Charlie

As I've said all of the various epiphanies especially those with tool steel have so far eluded me. I see differences, but they never leave me saying 'wow, I can't believe this.' I'm probably not paying enough attention. A2 was supposed to give two three times the edge life of regular Stanley and Record, D2 even more, not even close for me and I was using waterstones and Scary Sharp at the time so it wasn't an "issue with my honing media." None of it ever translated for me. Don't know what to say. Others gushed about A2 then less than a year later were off it. I can't explain that. How could somebody be getting stunning performance and then just decide to dump it like it was a pair of shoes that had gone out of style?

I'd say publish your results as widely as you can and see what sort of feedback you get. We'll make note of all the head nodders and see if they stay the course. I suspect it'll be like the A2 and D2 days.

Re: My favorite durability claim so far...

#25

I'm not sure I would notice the difference....

David Weaver

..if I was dimensioning wood. For one, if you take a lot of small shavings, you're not going to get anywhere, and the small shaving bits are just at the end of use.

This is only a test of medium thickness smoother shavings. Years ago, I tested some A2 irons. They lasted longer on thin smoother shavings than I thought they would, and I noticed some things during testing that I would've mistaken previously:

1) when you're dimensioning, you'll get tired. When you get tired, you'll lean on your plane. When you lean on your plane, you'll get more tired and blame it on the plane and then sharpen. The sharpening break at that point is probably just as important to stop leaning on the plane as it is to sharpen

2) When I tested edges last time, I used not getting a shaving out of a plane at all as the bogey. It was a bad idea. Somewhere around 1100 feet, the LN plane that I had became a lot of work. This goes back to 1 - I planed all of those feet in a row instead of stopping every 200 feet to weigh shavings and take pictures like I did here. I'm sure I leaned on the plane, and I noticed that for quite a while in that test, each time I assumed the plane was getting dull, waxing the sole allowed me to continue on.

I could not plane 1600 feet in rhythm with one of these planes. I don't think anyone has the physical stamina to do it neatly. I would've sharpened earlier because something else would've taken me out.

One result that I cannot deny is that I had a LV custom plane for a short period of time early on. I no longer have it. I got to pre-test it. I also have my own planes (there is clear bias for me favoring my own planes. What I wanted to see was how many more beech plane bodies I could face, square and then clean up to final dimension after sawing the waste off of the last two sides. With a beech plane, I can *always* do that in a single sharpening without fighting.

I couldn't finish a single blank with the LV custom plane. It was precisely machined and made far more friction than my beech try plane (which has a great vintage hard-side-of-normal butcher iron), I waxed it but I could not comfortably get as big of a shaving out of it by .008" to .005". That's a big deal. I only measured it because I was curious, but I know from experience that I can push up to a hundredth on a try plane out of quartered cherry and about 70-80% of that on beech and ash. The proportions of the custom plane kept me from being able to match that, and the friction made me tired and then the iron needed resharpening. I was very disappointed.

The same thing caused me to sell my LN jointer - it just made too much friction. Sweet working planes if you're looking for a certain smoothness all over, but less work done.

I can only guess looking back that between having to take more shavings with the custom plane to do the same thing, and then pulling a thinner shaving (a plane that stops cutting at a thinner shaving will still pull a thicker shaving), it still tipped things in the balance of the wooden plane, easily. Plane design was more important than engineering specs for the blade.

If I weren't running this test, I would've mistaken a couple of bad strokes when I was tired for the need to resharpen, but that wasn't the issue with the comparison against my wooden plane. I tried a couple of times to continue planing. My post about that could be found here several different times. I was given that plane to comment on its function, and I felt it was kind of rude for me to say that in public, but I did, anyway. I also felt like the proportions of a stanley plane would've been better to just copy and work from, and I guess that was also rude.

I still think LV"s best plane would be a stanley copy if they were willing to make one. I've tried a lot of their wares. It doesn't suit me.

I see the results of this test, but what can I say? There are other factors and I'm not buying a bunch of irons. I like the break to sharpen, and I like irons that are on the easy side to resharpen if something is amiss. If the work before smoothing is done well, then smoothing is here and gone like a fart in the wind.

I still had a comparison of a LV plane and one of my wooden planes with an iron that certainly wouldn't win this test. I could do more work with the wooden plane. It would take a bigger shaving for the same level of effort, it had less friction and despite the lesser iron, it was better suited. I sized try plane bodies figuring I might be able to size two with the LV plane for one of mine (There's the break thing again - after I size a plane body with the try plane, I sharpen it), but the LV plane didn't finish the first one. As much better as the iron may have been, I couldn't take as big of a shaving with the plane and the superiority of the iron wasn't enough to overcome working differently.