I'm not sure I would notice the difference....
David Weaver
..if I was dimensioning wood. For one, if you take a lot of small shavings, you're not going to get anywhere, and the small shaving bits are just at the end of use.
This is only a test of medium thickness smoother shavings. Years ago, I tested some A2 irons. They lasted longer on thin smoother shavings than I thought they would, and I noticed some things during testing that I would've mistaken previously:
1) when you're dimensioning, you'll get tired. When you get tired, you'll lean on your plane. When you lean on your plane, you'll get more tired and blame it on the plane and then sharpen. The sharpening break at that point is probably just as important to stop leaning on the plane as it is to sharpen
2) When I tested edges last time, I used not getting a shaving out of a plane at all as the bogey. It was a bad idea. Somewhere around 1100 feet, the LN plane that I had became a lot of work. This goes back to 1 - I planed all of those feet in a row instead of stopping every 200 feet to weigh shavings and take pictures like I did here. I'm sure I leaned on the plane, and I noticed that for quite a while in that test, each time I assumed the plane was getting dull, waxing the sole allowed me to continue on.
I could not plane 1600 feet in rhythm with one of these planes. I don't think anyone has the physical stamina to do it neatly. I would've sharpened earlier because something else would've taken me out.
One result that I cannot deny is that I had a LV custom plane for a short period of time early on. I no longer have it. I got to pre-test it. I also have my own planes (there is clear bias for me favoring my own planes. What I wanted to see was how many more beech plane bodies I could face, square and then clean up to final dimension after sawing the waste off of the last two sides. With a beech plane, I can *always* do that in a single sharpening without fighting.
I couldn't finish a single blank with the LV custom plane. It was precisely machined and made far more friction than my beech try plane (which has a great vintage hard-side-of-normal butcher iron), I waxed it but I could not comfortably get as big of a shaving out of it by .008" to .005". That's a big deal. I only measured it because I was curious, but I know from experience that I can push up to a hundredth on a try plane out of quartered cherry and about 70-80% of that on beech and ash. The proportions of the custom plane kept me from being able to match that, and the friction made me tired and then the iron needed resharpening. I was very disappointed.
The same thing caused me to sell my LN jointer - it just made too much friction. Sweet working planes if you're looking for a certain smoothness all over, but less work done.
I can only guess looking back that between having to take more shavings with the custom plane to do the same thing, and then pulling a thinner shaving (a plane that stops cutting at a thinner shaving will still pull a thicker shaving), it still tipped things in the balance of the wooden plane, easily. Plane design was more important than engineering specs for the blade.
If I weren't running this test, I would've mistaken a couple of bad strokes when I was tired for the need to resharpen, but that wasn't the issue with the comparison against my wooden plane. I tried a couple of times to continue planing. My post about that could be found here several different times. I was given that plane to comment on its function, and I felt it was kind of rude for me to say that in public, but I did, anyway. I also felt like the proportions of a stanley plane would've been better to just copy and work from, and I guess that was also rude.
I still think LV"s best plane would be a stanley copy if they were willing to make one. I've tried a lot of their wares. It doesn't suit me.
I see the results of this test, but what can I say? There are other factors and I'm not buying a bunch of irons. I like the break to sharpen, and I like irons that are on the easy side to resharpen if something is amiss. If the work before smoothing is done well, then smoothing is here and gone like a fart in the wind.
I still had a comparison of a LV plane and one of my wooden planes with an iron that certainly wouldn't win this test. I could do more work with the wooden plane. It would take a bigger shaving for the same level of effort, it had less friction and despite the lesser iron, it was better suited. I sized try plane bodies figuring I might be able to size two with the LV plane for one of mine (There's the break thing again - after I size a plane body with the try plane, I sharpen it), but the LV plane didn't finish the first one. As much better as the iron may have been, I couldn't take as big of a shaving with the plane and the superiority of the iron wasn't enough to overcome working differently.