we'll need to restart in beech
david weaver
3v

v11

tsunesaburo

chinese hss

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
we'll need to restart in beech
david weaver
3v

v11

tsunesaburo

chinese hss

Re: we'll need to restart in beech
David Weaver
fending a complex migraine happening right now, so I might make more comments later.
The crux of the issue, though, is one dark pitch spot in hard maple and all of the plane irons that ran into it got destroyed by it. It's not metal, it's something wooden, but extremely hard. It's nondescript looking, but each iron went from working reasonably well to giving up right away.
Each picture is a section of the edge after 200 strokes (800 feet), and a picture of the typical destroyed section where the spot was on the location of the edge. The tsunesaburo iron tolerated it better than all of the others, but nothing came through without damage.
So, we'll start the test over after regrinding, resharpening and repolishing and use beech. A real letdown!!
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Not a "restart", David. You have compiled an amazing amount of information. Think of this as the next stage. It should go quicker, since you have a good idea what to expect, and simply need to document the similarities - rather than repeat all the analyses in writing, as before. It is the documentation and its organisation that I suspect is your bugbear. Easier when starting out and novel ... 
Regards from Perth
Derek
The culprit
David Weaver
This is the spot in the maple test board that caused the problem. What is it? Not sure, but it took about 3 tenths+ of width to get rid of all of it. The fortunate part of that is that it allowed four different irons to beat themselves up in it. There's tiny amount yet, which I could use to beat up the LN iron, but it's not worth the trouble at this point (that iron is already leaving a lower quality cut).

No need to restart.
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
front the size of what you photographed only a small portion of the blades are damaged. Forge on. Testing can continue on the undamaged parts. As a bonus you get to see how the damaged edge wears.
I have no idea what material would be in that defect that would be hard enough to damage either 3V or M2. You can machine metal with either.
question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
will you describe the details of the damage. Is it metal missing, metal deformed? The maple defect just looks like a pitch pocket which would just be resin unless it oozed and collected sand in a dust storm.
Re: The culprit
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I was referring to pockets like this in my post of 7/10. I have seen this lots of times. Sometimes I struggle through, sometimes I throw away the board.
My guess is that not many have made a piece of case furniture planing hard maple, Acer saccharum from rough lumber. As I mentioned last week when the tool is dull it seems to lose its temper and take a period of poor performance with multiple sharpenings before coming back to normal. It is helpful to sharpen much more than usual when doing rough planing.
Some way, some how, craftsmen of 300 years ago were able to figure this out (it is obvious) and used hard maple for turnings, not much for planed work.
Re: question
David Weaver
The simple reason that the test has to stop and restart is that the damaged part from powering through is a couple of tenths of the iron. if I shift far enough to the right on the plane, i'll be planing unused iron - it'll just be hard to quantify which iron did better.
Except for the tsunesaburo iron, the other three have probably 80% metal completely gone and another severely deflected (in the dark areas). The blunting is so severe that it feels like a wire edge on the iron and you can catch your fingernail on it. The bluntness stopped the iron from cutting and it covers a fairly large territory.
Tsunesaburo was exhibiting loss of clearance, or just starting to at 600 feet. For whatever reason, I could feel it hitting that pitch pocket but it didn't take nearly as much damage - maybe a tenth of what the other irons did, and I don't think it would be able to form a wire edge due to the hardness.
I would be lovely if the board was more uniform without that spot, but it gives me a chance now to correct the LN plane as I see the culprit preventing the thinner irons from bedding - it's the snugness of the adjuster in the cap iron. The taper is fat and steep on the adjuster, so the cap iron will not slide down on it to firmly sandwich the part of the iron on the bed appropriately.
I'm going to file a taper into the cap iron slot/hole so that it just does bed the thinnest iron tight to the frog. That'll create some backlash on the stock iron later, but I could care less about backlash.
it took about 20 shavings each for the three irons that took more damage to nearly stop cutting and for the shaving to be split into several pieces - it was just unworkable. Since the first iron got ruined and the test couldn't proceed, I figured I'd see if all of them took the same damage, and thankfully the pitch pocket was deep enough to accommodate.
No problem on retesting - the first 600 feet here were instructive, but they won't answer the question I'm hoping to answer and test #2 will require fewer comments on here since we've already talked it all out. I"ll just run it and post the pictures.
Re: The culprit
David Weaver
After literally planing 2400 feet and having this appear without any outward evidence that it was in the board, all I could think was "gosh, I have to do this again". I have a couple of other boards that look clear, and I have a boatload of cherry and a lot of beech.
Between those three, I"m not going to risk it on the maple again. I have planed maple before and never really noticed why it's so miserable, but I haven't made anything big with it, just noticed how it's similar hardness vs. beech and so much more miserable to plane. Now I have a very specific answer of why it is. If one wasn't looking so closely as this, they may not notice why an iron took damage, but the damage was swift and caused the edge of the iron to generate a large burr where it ran over that spot. Not on the first stroke, but over 15 or 20.
I've never had a similar issue in beech, nor cherry.
After seeing that the mark wasn't metal, I immediately thought "warren warned us about this".
This kind of thing is another reason that in a try and jack plane I like an iron less hard - to work damage like this out of an iron more quickly. And carbon steel in smoothers - it's easier to recover an edge from damage. The average person wouldn't get the four thousandths or so sharpened out of the bevel on the first try, at least not without obliterating the whole edge.
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
David Weaver
Yes on the commentary. Less and and more to the point on test two. I think I am going to publish the results of this also as an addendum, but this gave me a chance to figure out why the LN plane doesn't bed the iron if it's below a certain thickness, and I will now correct that and use a single plane for all of the irons except 3V.
It's not as novel now, but I have a system worked out to document weight and edge commentary in a spreadsheet, so it'll probably take half as long.
Sometimes you've got to do it twice to get what you're looking for!!
Little of the voluminous pondering that's taken place here will actually make it into the summary document, anyway, and wouldn't have even if the first test allowed planing to failure. In my attempt to be stingy with the woods I like and am familiar with, I chose one that I've only used previously to test plane irons. The same issue won't happen with beech or cherry. I could certainly accidentally drop an iron mid process with that, though, but I've worked out a good way to store the irons in my chisel cabinet staggered so that they have a low chance of taking a beating.
Re: The culprit
John Aniano in Central NJ
David,
Could it possibly be a piece of rust? An old staple or small nail that totally rusted in situ? No metal remaining, just iron oxide?
Can trees pull up enough iron in the water to actually create a pocket of rust? I've heard that some species can draw up silica. As particles or dissolved, I don't know. Maybe maple can do something similar.
Neat stuff!
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
Steve Voigt
Dave,
Ouch! Bummer. Stuff happens in real wood, right?
I think Derek's comments are spot on. I'd also urge you to take some time and write up what you've got so far before starting over. You've done more than enough planing here to draw some important conclusions.
Two other thoughts:
If you use beech, you might be at it for a long time…perhaps something more abrasive, like white oak?
To what extent are you documenting (either in pictures or in words) what the board looks like at the various stages of the test? For me, the most interesting part of this has been your observations on surface quality. If you do start again, I'd love to see more of it…
Re: The culprit
David Weaver
I'm drawing a blank on figuring out what it is, and planed most of it off with the fourth iron in the group....
... but we're in luck. on the bottom side of the board, there are several more exposed marks like that, so I'll get the handheld scope on them.
Whatever it is, it causes the iron to damage and get deflected (not in 1 stroke, but like 15 or 20), and it doesn't mark the plane sole like a staple would.
Maybe something like a bird peck that fills with dirt and then heals around it? Who knows. Hopefully the scope picture will give an idea of what it is.
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
David Weaver
Yes on the beech taking a while. I'll either use beech or cherry and take my lumps to get another set of pictures and a solid durability number. I know relative wear numbers up to what was probably close to failure for a2 and the tsunesaburo and will be able to make the observation of how many shavings before the first visible line shows up.
The conclusion is clear from the first round- quality in terms of uniformity is a space only occupied by carbon steel or close to carbon steel. We'll see if the second run shows the same.
The Japanese iron took the least damage from the wood flaw by far and will be the fastest ro refresh. 01 was saved from damage by not lasting to it and will be very easy to refresh.
Once again, Warren provides a piece of advice and it turns out to be accurate.
wood choice
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
K&K found strong correlation between wood density and wear rate.
Cherry is notorious for pitch pockets.
Oak is not isotropic. As planing proceeds the blade will be encountering varying amounts and orientations of spring/summer wood with huge differences in density.
I'd recommend sticking with maple. It is as uniform as any of our wood species get, and its dense for "rapid" wear.
Is it correct that the maple defect was at a growth ring?
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
Brian Holcombe
Beech is a nice choice and fairly common for furniture. I don’t like working with maple, it is hellish on the tools. I bought the best maple I’ve ever seen last year and even it was just brutal on my handtools and equipment. I always offer up ash for anyone who requests maple. Ash is a beautiful material in every respect.
you may be onto someting here
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Maybe something like a bird peck that fills with dirt and then heals around it?
Sap suckers enjoy pecking at maple, hickory and occasionally others. Its appearance is consistent with the result of a bird peck. If there are other spots like this one at the same growth ring, a bird peck it is. The sticky sap that oozes out could collect dust.
The fact that metal is gone from the blade tip, and in some photos it looks like deep scratches "downstream" of the divot, suggests some abrasive contaminant, not simply a hard spot.
The defect does no look like a iron stain.
Question for Derek
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
You have been working with maple the past few projects. Was this defect common in your work?
Branch bark ridge?
Jim Matthews
I wonder if this inclusion is common on smaller, younger trees.
I would suppose pre-industrial furniture makers used what they could get.
If you're nowhere near a port, or railyard - local lumber was used.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/solved-puzzle-bark-inclusions-trees-duncan-slater
Slater D, Bradley R S, Withers P J & Ennos A R (2014) The anatomy and grain pattern in forks of hazel (Corylus avellana L.) and other tree species; Trees: Structure and Function 28, 1437-1448.
another theory
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It could be a bark inclusion and bark can be wicked abrasive. A bark edge will peel the edge off my M2 planer or jointer knives in short order. See Skaggs post in main board for an extreme example of bark inclusions. When I have seen bark included in maple, and it is rare, the wood was figured like birds eyes or blisters.
That said, the picture looks more like a healed wound than bark. But maybe more evidence of bark has been planed away.
The end is near for ash
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
All the ash in our area died this spring. Once dead within weeks other insects invade the wood. I had an ash awaiting to be sawed and it became a pile of beetle chewings in 3 weeks. I talked to a logger at a logging contest Saturday and he confirms they are gone from his logging range so they are likely gone from the southern Appalachians. The beetle moved 100+ miles in 2 years from Knoxville through where I live. I suspect there aren't sound logs anywhere to be found or won't be in a year or two.
Re: Question for Derek
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Bill
No. I have not come across inclusions.
The Hard Maple I have worked (quite a lot now - a few tables , plus a whole kitchen in Curly Maple) is an interesting wood in comparison to Australian timbers, such as Jarrah, etc. Most has been planed easily without a hint of tearout. It leaves a beautiful finish as it is so tight grained. However, where there is a grain reversal, unless using a closed chipbreaker, the wood will tearout, and do so obviously. The tearout leaves jagged, deep edges, where tearout in Jarrah just appears rough or shallow.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: wood choice
david weaver
I'll show pictures of more. All of my maple (since I rarely use it) was from the same lot, so I have some fear of encountering others. It's relative uniformity in hardness whether it's flat or quartered (some woods plane much more differently depending on grain orientation at the edge) made it attractive for this. The wear and qualities of maple make it provide uniform results unless you hit a defect (and if you can avoid them, it's reliable for something like this), but it also if I recall will keep itself in a shaving longer into a wear cycle than something like pine or softer cherry.
I have a gaggle of 5/4 quartered beech boards. I don't know what I'm saving them for, but I can plane the heart side of them for this test and save the sap side to make moulding planes. When mike digity went out of business, he sold me all of those boards at $3.25 a board foot to use as drawer sides in my kitchen process (he also sold me nice cherry for cheap), and I didn't have the heart to waste them on drawers so I bought poplar elsewhere. Not that there's something spectacular about beech, but an 8" wide board dead quartersawn is begging not to be stuffed under a counter.
At any rate, the heart shows the uniformity and I have good consistent grain orientation, so it's a good option. I work mostly cherry, and encounter a lot of pitch, but nothing with the hardness of this one. It makes me think, as you mentioned, bark that either is abrasive by nature or that was healed into the tree after an inclusion with dirt. I know that atmospheric dust and dirt generally stops somewhere around silica, so it could include some of that. I'll look closer at the plane soles tonight to see if there is any evidence at all of damage. I have planed staples refurbishing my floors before and the damage from metal is much more immediate and much difference. This felt like a "thwwwppp" when you go over it, and it still planed off nicely for a couple of strokes until the damage mounted. Staples make a distinct click as they snap a nick out of a blade.
All of this hard maple came from the same load, though, and more of these inclusions are still there for us to ogle under a microscope (I'll do that, because I want to put an abbreviated version of this study in an appendix and note what happened and what the edge damage was like).
By the feel of the irons, we were just on the edge of some of them telling us where they'll stop. Derek has mentioned before that once I get stuck on something, I won't stop. I'm sure he has plenty of clinical information about why that is, but i find even dumb challenges satisfying to beat, so we will move on an make version 2 a better test than version 1. And correct the bedding issue with the LN plane, which takes one more minor variable out.
Re: Branch bark ridge?
david weaver
Bill and I were discussing this separately - I would guess by the way it looks that it's bark or bark plus dirt, but it's not quite as big as some bark inclusions are. it was in the neighborhood of 1/4-1/2 inch in depth. It started 10 strokes or so into the V11 iron in this test and finished just with the Tsunesaburo edge, which was the fourth iron, so somewhere in the neighborhood of .0025*200 shavings, less the difference in depth of wood cut vs. shaving width.
At any rate, I saw all kinds of potential defects that heal as hard spots, but without starting an old wives' tale, it looks like compacted bark particles. My hand scope will do a good mediocre job of getting a picture of a similar spot further into the board's width.
It allowed itself to be planed a couple of times with each plane before the damage mounted. The V11 was rolling along smoothly, planing really well for the level of wear and I figured that clearance would sneak up and stop it at some point. When the shaving split, my first thought was "a ha, it's finally starting to give up", then as the damage mounted - so much for that.
It's become a great curiosity of mine to find out of the V11, which doesn't appear to wear any slower - it's not really that hard feeling or abrasion resistant on the stones, manages by some luck of composition to plane well despite wear, and maybe not wear the same on the bottom side as the carbon steel iron (which had better edge uniformity and toughness at first, but stayed the same while the uniformity of the V11 iron seems to have stayed the same or improved).
I'm learning a lot that i really didn't need to know, but it's interesting, anyway. I guess i learned to heed warren's advice on hard maple. I'll cut it into garden stakes after that. I've only got about 40 board feet of it. this mark would've nicked a machine planer blade, and I gathered a bunch of nicks years ago when I used one more, planing maple. Almost makes you wonder when people talk about having defective blades, if they're the ones putting defects in them without knowing, as a table saw, router and sander probably wouldn't have given up much secret in this. I'm sure the mark sands fine if the plane still cuts it a few iterations.
Re: we'll need to restart in beech
david weaver
I really liked working ash for my bench - little of that was by hand in the early parts, but all of the finish planing and shoring up dimensions was done by hand, as well as the leveling of the bench top once the boards were laminated.
It's superior for a hand tooler to maple by a wide margin, but I've only got it in 8/4, so it would be too much for this test on an iron that is only 2" wide.
The retailers around here seem to have given up on it. I'm sure the logs come in as recent snags faster than they can do anything with them, but the retailers aren't going to do anyone favors so rather than sell something at a low price that might compete with other $5 a board foot woods, they either continue to offer it at the same price, or don't stock it.
A good uniform board that had little runout would've made a good piece of test material. But I've got plenty of the beech, and it should be much more reliable than the maple. Some of my maple boards are seemingly clear on the surface, and this board has some dark spots visible elsewhere. This one was completely obscured. It's a power tooler's wood in my view, which is why it has sat as long as it has. It's terrible to jack or try plane, even when it's working well - unreasonably resistive given its hardness level.