Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

1000g water stones

Posts

Re: 1000g water stones

#26

Re: 1000g water stones

Wiley Horne

Thanks Derek. I admire your compact system. My reason for the question is that I’m setting up a second sharpening station, as I laughingly call it. I began just now to write down my sequences, but it’s crazy varied according to exactly which iron or chisel and whether it wants regrinding, so I’ll spare you.

Long story short, I need a 1000g stone at this second location. At the primary location, I’m using an old Sigma Power 1000 (or some mesh of fixed diamond if 3v or m2).

Now the Sigma 1000 cuts well for a little bit, but gets a close sticky black coating, like a black glaze, after not many strokes, so that I have to refresh the surface often. I’ve been putting up with it, but wanted to try something different.

Also, I sat up and took notice of your recommendation of the Sigma 6K prior to Sigma 13K, rather than one of the Shaptons.

Thanks again, Wiley

Re: 1000g water stones

#27

Re: 1000g water stones

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

I have the Sigma 1000 - this was sent to me by Stu some years ago to test out. I found that it did not cut as quickly as the Shapton 1000.

If you are getting black marks, which is iron loading up, add a smidgeon of liquid soap to the water you spray (enough to keep the stone from loading up). It may change your view of the stone. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 1000g water stones

#28

A comment on steels.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, another point about the Sigmas: they cut most steels pretty well. My preference is similar to Bill, who advocates diamond paste - I prefer not to be fussing with a number of stones for different steels. I use several steels - such as O1 (and white steel), A2, M2, M4, D2, and PM-V11 - and for me, sharp is sharp. The esoterica of the ultimate match of steel and media is wasted these days. I am more interested in design and building. There is no getting away from the importance of a sharp edge, but at some point in the process it stops being relevant and becomes an obsession (zooming inwards forever).

The difference in the steels, in my experience, lies with how long they can hold a sharp edge (since the local West Oz woods do tend to test tool edges somewhat more than yours in the USA). All these steels can get sharp (the only exception I found was CPM 10V, and this was because I did not know how to get it sharp).

In my current project I have been enjoying using Blue Spruce dovetail chisels. The A2 steel may be considered unfashionable at this time, however they take a marvellous edge, and their thin blades are an absolute pleasure to use. The compromise is a slightly shorter user time.

We spend a lot of time delving into steels - which hold an edge longer? which take an edge better? - and I do believe that there is value in this. David's work here may turn out to be a classic. This thread may become remembered (on forums) for some ground breaking insights. However, it is not the first time these questions have been raised, and it will not be the last.

Incidentally, I will mention a piece I wrote several years ago as it does have similarities to the research method that David is using. This was comparing 6 different steels (pre-V11, sorry) and intended to look at wear in chisels when paring. It is, however, really not that different from planing ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselParing.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 1000g water stones

#29

That's the ticket

Jim Matthews

"Will experiment to find which steel likes which stone."

Right you are, there's NO substitute for experience.

I'm still surprised how well simpler solutions work.

There's a broad range that King 800 can achieve, particularly if you leave it a little "muddy" after flattering.

With a strop, it can be sufficient for all but the finest work.

Re: 1000g water stones

#30

disagree that chisels predict planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

intended to look at wear in chisels when paring. It is, however, really not that different from planing ...

While this well done study provided guidance on chisel selection for the tasks used, I don't think the results will predict the performance of these steels in a plane blade.

Steel has three fundamental properties- hardness, toughness and abrasion resistance. For a shaving lifter David's work is suggesting that abrasion resistance will be the primary factor that determines edge life. It took hundreds of feet of blade passing through wood to begin to separate the performance of the steels being tested.

Chisel edges fail at least an order of magnitude quicker when judged by inches of wood they pass through when chopped. Clearly a chisel edge is failing by a mechanism other then abrasion. The work I did suggests failure is by some combination of deformation and/or micro chipping which in turn suggest that selection of chisel steel becomes a balance of hardness and toughness, properties that unfortunately negatively correlate. It also suggests that technique will have a great bearing on chisel edge failure as Warren has stated.

This hypothesis is confirmed by the steels that have proven to make good chisels. PMV11, 3V and the Japanese steel you found superior all exhibit exceptional toughness at high hardness. Most agree that carbon steel makes a better chisel than A2 and the hardness/toughness values are consistent with this finding.

On the technique issue, Alan Batty provided information on how an English furniture factory made drawers in the early 1950's. The production quota was astonishing, 6 drawers a day, to someone that takes a day to make a drawer. They were chiseling oak drawer sides with chisel steel of that day. My notes are unclear whether they sharpened once a day or twice. Importantly(I think), the dovetails were pared, never chopped. Paring will stress the blade tip more like planing.

Re: 1000g water stones

#31

Re: disagree that chisels predict planing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

While this well done study provided guidance on chisel selection for the tasks used, I don't think the results will predict the performance of these steels in a plane blade.

That’s not what I said, Bill. I said that there was a similarity. The paring in my assessment was done with a plane (to simulate paring), but it was still planing and wear.

Regards from Perth

Derek