Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

Posts

Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#1

Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

E Phillip Smith

There's been good discussion recently around plane blade product development by Lee Valley via accelerated testing. I spent much of my career in R&D developing new products and we ALWAYS did accelerated testing. I just is not commercially viable to development new products otherwise. I've looked at the Lee Valley data set and it is impressive. See link below for their summary data. I liked the data so much that I've a set of the chisels and plane irons. The chisels hold and edge well, better at chopping than my CPM 3V chisels. Don't have data on plane irons yet.

Reason for this post is that I have many of the plane irons that they list in the summary data and in particular CPM high carbon M4. Other than Derick I'm likely the only forum user to have experience with M4. Bruce Norton and I made 4 M4 plane irons years ago when we working with Wiley and co. to make 3V plane irons. One of the irons lives in my Clifton no. 5 and the other lives in my LN 4.5.

From Crucibles web site M4's composition is 1.4% carbon; 4% Cr; 5.5% Tungsten; 5.25% Mo; 4% V for a total of 18.65% of Hard carbides. It's also hardens up to RC 64.

From Lee Valley's web site relative wear and ease of sharpening are:

Ease of sharpening O1 - 10; A2 - 6; V11 - 6.5; M4 - 1 From experience these all look good and if anything the 1 rating for M4 is a little generous. Even with diamond it is slow compared to the above steels and the CPM 3V that I've used. When Bruce and I made the M4 irons machining in the annealed state was no problem but once hardened this steel very wear resistant. If memory serves correctly the bill for surface grinding 4 irons after heat treating was $100.00, lots more that the bill for the 3V irons. Polishing the back even with diamond was much slower than any other steel I have used. Once the back is polished the plane iron takes and keeps a very good edge. As much as I like this iron I can't imagine anyone making a commercial iron. Manufacturing cost would be too high and customer relations would be terrible. Without experience with diamond honing this steel is impossible to sharpen.

Wear Rating O1 - 1; A2 - 1.5; V11 - 9; M4 - 9. From experience the O1, & A2 are where I would expect. Haven't gotten around to using the V11 and my CPM 3V is somewhat better than the A2. The M4 is in a different class than the other irons.

Now for some user data. Last year I finally got around to finishing a table top for my son. Top is walnut with lot of curl/figure. Top is: 34" wide and 64" long approximately 1" thick with 3/8" X 1.5" bevel on bottom of table. The table was larger than I was willing to try running bevel on table saw or shaper so I cut the bevel with a LN 4.5 hand plane with M4 plane iron. Iron was sharpened with 1 micron diamond on cast iron plate. It's the only effective way to sharpen these irons. Plane was set to take shaving of 0.002 to 0.003 inches so I assume average shaving of about 0.0025". At the center of the bevel the thickness of bevel is 5/16" and at edge it is 3/8" so with a shaving thickness of 0.0025 that works out to 125 to 150 passes per edge assuming you have perfect registry with is not likely. That works out to aroung 2000 to 2500 lineal feet of shaving by time I was finished. Plane was still cutting cleanly at finish. Pictures of table follow.

First is picture of planning end grain of table to clean up saw marks.


Next is picture of line for edge of bevel marked with gel ball point pen.


Edges were planed end grain, edge, end grain, edge.

End grain bevel.


Edge bevel.


Some pin knots at finish.



Table top was sanded to 220 grit sandpaper, stained with gel walnut stain, and finished with 2 coats of conversion varnish.

First is picture of table bottom to show some of the figure.


Next is picture of finished table.




Lee Valley Summary data

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#2

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data

David Weaver

I had a couple of chisels in M4, but no plane irons. The chisels were good, but they still needed to be resharpened every once in a while. I couldn't really say for sure that they would provide any productivity improvement over japanese carbon steel chisels - probably not, especially when sharpening time is factored in. They're laminated and soft iron or mild steel on diamonds in a cast or steel plate is a disaster - cast and mild plates are the domain for tools that are all hardened material.

I sharpened my chisels on crystolon followed by a fine india followed by a hard arkansas. To my surprise, the crystolon did a good job grinding the bevels (I worked the back with a diamond plate - they are hollow, so it wasn't too difficult). The bevel side (since it's laminated) on a chisel isn't that much hardened material to cut, which may be why the crystolon did OK with it. The fine india and arkansas stone can't cut all of the stuff that's in it so they probably didn't do much, but I got the edge to the point that it looked good under a scope, at least reasonably good, and was past easily shaving hair.

But something about them didn't resonate.

I sent one of them to Rob Streeper in texas who was doing some (potentially inaccurate in some cases) testing of chisels and the one he tested was the hardest of all of the chisels he tested. 66 or 66.x hardness. I trust they would do well if you wanted to shave a transition on something where brass meets wood.

As far as the plane irons go, there are commercially made irons of M2 and M4 in japan, but it's not like you can stick them in a western plane. I have no idea how well they go over in japan. Earlier HSS tools were intended for site work and were relatively crude, but some of the planes with the irons in them now (the m4 types) are over $400, so they're not really site tools. Someone must like them.

Those are also laminated, but glued together rather than forged together. The back of the blade on those tools is made without sides on the hollow so that the user only ever sharpens a small strip at the tip of the iron.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#3

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Are you saying that the plane performed so poorly that 220 grit sandpaper was needed on surface?

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#4

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data

E Phillip Smith

Not at all. I typically stain with a pigmented stain. To get even stain pickup I sand at 220 grit to get even color. Don't like the stain pickup on glossy surface.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#5

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data

David Weaver

Out of curiosity, I checked nj steel baron to see what the price of bar stock is, and it's about $40 per plane iron equivalent, add milling and grinding and heat treat, and they'd probably have to sell for at least $125.

It isn't the honing that bugs me with irons like that, it's how slow they grind. People who hone the entire bevel will find them pretty gross, though.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#6

Nice color on the wood..

david weaver

I have a soft spot for walnut, though I never use it. As a child, my parents drummed into me repeatedly that furniture should have dovetails and it should be made of cherry or walnut, but walnut to them is surely higher end.

They have nothing made of mahogany and aren't actually educated about furniture, so I'm not sure where they got their ideas. I know that they cannot tell the difference between a piece made entirely by hand and some of the early machine work where columns, etc, were littered with coves because someone had figured out how to quickly do things with a machine that used to take more skill by hand.

But walnut still appeals to me (all of their furniture is stained so that it stays dark).

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#7

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data

Charlie

Abrasives have been around for a long, long time:

https://journeymansjournel.wordpress.com/2016/10/10/sandpaper/

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#8

"Journeyman's journal"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I read the post you linked. "Journeyman" does not seem to know how to use a double iron plane.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#9

Re: "Journeyman's journal"

Charlie

I have no idea, but that has nothing to do with the history of abrasives he quite capably recapped.

I honestly don't know if you know how to use a double-iron plane other than your own assertions that you do.

I know how to do heart valve surgery. Prove me wrong.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#10

Civility, folks.  Civility

Let's remember that we can passionately argue about ideas without insulting each other.

I'm not sure where the author of the article Charlie linked was going - he started out with a little history of abrasives, then changed to a discussion of using hand tools for final smoothing, then seemed to return to "if necessary, sandpaper at the end." But his statements about early uses of abrasives were interesting. I don't know enough of the history in that area to be sure of their accuracy; I also don't have reason to doubt him.

But I believe Charlie meant well with his posting of the article, and I believe Warren meant well with his critique. There may be other comments and critiques of the content of that article, or other online (or offline but scanned) articles that will expand on the topic - but let's not step on each other's toes. Please.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#11

Re: "Journeyman's journal"

Charlie

I don't know if the people at the site below know how to use a double-iron plane either but I'll offer this regardless, since it matters not:

https://flintriflesmith.com/WritingandResearch/Research/sandpaper.htm

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#12

Re: "Journeyman's journal"

Charlie

And this, which has been posted as part of this debate before if memory serves:

https://anthonyhaycabinetmaker.wordpress.com/2012/02/26/yes-virginia-there-really-is-sandpaper-in-1775/

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#13

Re: Civility, folks.  Civility

Charlie

I will Bill.

I have a couple of mitral valve procedures to do this afternoon, but when I get back to the forum I promise I'll behave.

:-)

Have a great weekend.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#14

Somewhere....

david weaver

..a point is being missed here. I gather what Warren is saying - all of this care and expense to make an M4 iron, but the surface that's finished is sanded.

Sandpaper is quite often used in fine instruments, etc, because the surfaces are curved and the objective is to have a surface that shows no marks on something like a violin or archtop guitar. Most of the time, it's going to be varnished or lacquered, so no marks is a desirable thing.

No reason to get all stuffed up about it. I do wish people would actually show their own work, though: Charlie - that includes you. I give the OP credit here for talking about something and showing his own work.

You've mentioned before that I can't build my way out of a paper bag, but I'm glad to show mine, anyway. If someone thinks it weakens my points (which I suspect is the reason you don't post some of your average work, because it's paying work and not your best work), I'm not bothered by that.

I struggle to find some of warren's work sometimes, but there are bits and pieces of it out there (like this unsanded turning):

https://thechristiantoolcabinet.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/warren-samples.jpg

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#15

Re: Civility, folks.  Civility

david weaver

Keep the prolapsed valves and post some pictures. Somewhere, there must be a rule like there is in PA with mechanics where the customer is allowed to have the used parts so that they can see that they needed the work in the first place.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#16

Re: Somewhere....

Charlie

Sandpaper and other abrasives were apparently cost prohibitive, or at least that's the conjecture. If it hadn't been, who knows?

It was around.

Maybe the people who used it were hacks, or maybe only the best shops producing the finest furniture could even afford it. I don't know. If it really was cost prohibitive, then it's a fairly easy logical assumption that it was used in shops who could recover its cost in the products sold.

Food for thought perhaps.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#17

Re: Civility, folks.  Civility

Charlie

A lot of times truth is stranger than fiction David.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#18

Re: jumping to conclusions...

david weaver

..i would guess that there's a combination of things involved, but certainly cost is a huge factor. Maybe the "hugest". If it would've been cheaper to sand in 1775, then I think nearly all of the work would've been pretty heavily sanded.

I don't know that much about how old violins were made, but I'd be curious as to whether or not they were expensive enough to warrant shark skin or some of the other expensive work. If they were sending them to royalty, I would hope the tiny surfaces would warrant it. I mentioned top carving to george and it's his opinion that the inability to get a perfect top in raking light without sanding means sanding must be done on them. I will take his advice.

I sure have seen evidence of a lot of his work, though. Most of it is beyond what I'll ever do. Maybe all of it. http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson1.html#wilson7

The comments that he makes and then shows in pictures - I can see this lute, I can see that I couldn't design it and execute it, too, but it's clear both that he did the work and he did it by hand. He's described elsewhere why a lot of this work was done by hand instead of power tools (e.g., controlling the stroke of the saw so that a power saw with some eccentricity doesn't unintentionally sand the sides of the scrollwork).

Something sticks out to me that Ben Hogan said. When someone asked him his opinion on other golfers, he said he had great respect for all golfers who went out and competed. I think the interviewer expected him to sound off on all that was wrong with everyone who didn't do it his way. I'd prefer people talking about their work, and picturing their work first - unless they can't do what they're talking about (like above - if I had work the level of george's, I'd post his and not mine). I think we'd have a bit more respect for each other if we weren't falling back on someone else's work to protect ourselves from showing our own.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#19

tales from the selectively stingy

david weaver

One side comment about cost. I have no ability to claim cost efficiency in any way in my shop, but even now, i don't like paying for sandpaper.

It's not a matter of thinking it's morally objectionable or something, or punishing myself planing and scraping as much as can possibly be done, it's just the use of paper - and throwing it away without anything to show for it. Somewhere in the DSM, there's probably something to explain that.

The mrs. asked me to make a large base cabinet for the kitchen (pictures were here a few weeks ago). It involved SOS (same old) except that i sold the router table and stuff that I'd used to make the rest of my cabinets, so I made all of it by hand except for cutting the long areas of corian and a little bit of template routing.

I did not do a great job on it, but to be fair, someone will move into my house some day and just throw it in the trash, anyway.

When all was said and done, for a fraction of what it would've cost to buy the cabinet, I realized I used about $15 of sandpaper between the cabinet and the corian, and that really pisses me off. It literally felt like...sand a little bit, fit something, sand more. throw away sand paper....sand more....get another sheet, throw away paper.

Maybe i'm in the minority with that, but the more I can plane and scrape, the less I get annoyed. If I had employees and their labor + materials planing was more expensive than the same with sandpaper (or use of it allowed hiring of lower skilled labor at a lower rate) and the customer didn't care....they'd all be sanding.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#20

Re: jumping to conclusions...

Charlie

Even though he was one of the greatest to have played, Ben Hogan played in many many more tournaments than he ever won, so he was regularly beaten by guys who had completely different philosophies about the golf swing, though in reality everybody who can strike a golf ball reasonably well does a couple or three things almost identically and virtually all get to a position at impact that is effectively identical -- forward shaft lean (lag), a bit of loft taken off the face, a bit of a bowed leading wrist as the face is closes through impact.

George's work is top notch, but so is a lot of instrument makers' work. It's a field in which average doesn't really cut it, right? Who are other current practitioners of the art? Whose instruments are in the most demand? How do they work? Why is their violin worth $100,000, and their order book full, while somebody else's only $35,000 (still a damn fine instrument), but less than half the cost? Because they do or don't use abrasives? I don't know, but likely not. I guess those with the money to pay for it do, though.

All that said, there was still sandpaper in Britain and the Colonies. What to do with that? Anything you like I guess.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#21

Re: tales from the selectively stingy

Charlie

Nothing wrong with that. The time may come when the Mrs. wants something built with curves and turns and this or that and your philosophy might change. All I can say is be easy on yourself. You may be tilting at a 'no abrasive' windmill that never existed in the first place.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#22

Re: tales from the selectively stingy

Charlie

Perhaps a lousy analogy or whatever, but I assume you get the gist.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#23

Re: jumping to conclusions...

david weaver

If they're well made, there's no difference in a $20K violin vs. one that's $100k other than the ability of a builder to manage relationships with buyers. Even if you buy 400 year old wood to start, there just isn't that much cost in making them.

I talked to a couple of symphony players here (two married symphony players in this area get summers off and make about 3 bills together if they don't take on any additional work).

Not surprisingly, they have some expensive violins. I wanted to pick their brains about what made them good and they really don't have a clue. They just know they like them. I'm sure they have not touched sandpaper or studied anything about it in quite a long time. One of the two was enamored with one of the violins they got because it had a birdseye back.

Interestingly enough, baking wood has become very stylish with guitars because it moves the wood into a similar timbre vs. very old wood. While talking to the two, they mentioned a builder who had supplied wonderful violins to a few people they knew, but he was accused of baking tops, and figuratively run out of town as a seller to any of them going forward. They said the violins were wonderful sounding and open, but it wasn't appropriate to help the wood along in such a way.

??

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#24

Re: tales from the selectively stingy

david weaver

I'm not concerned about what's historically accurate. If I was, I'd read a lot more of the historical texts. I like planed finish better, but the mrs. wanted the cabinets to look commercial, so I sanded every single one of them after planing with 320 grit paper and a fesfool sander.

I think it was a waste of time. I did try progressive sanding early on (I've got a big dual action sander to use on floors in the house), and it turned out to take a lot longer than planing.

Whereas you might say that the difference in surface appearance between planing and sanding doesn't make a difference, I'd have to say on kitchen cabinets, the sanding isn't really necessary as if there is any more uniformity due to sanding (in absorbed finish or whatever), it's not really warranted. And it cost about 2 additional coats of shellac to get a decent base for lacquer.

I'll do it when I need to if the results look good, though.

Re: Product Dev. & Some User Data *LINK*

#25

Re: "Journeyman's journal"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In the Journeyman's Journal article that Charlie linked to the author talks about using high angle planing, if still torn, scraping, and then sanding as a last resort for difficult wood. That was October 2016.

Nine months later he writes that the double iron plane eliminates the need for a scraper. 7/18/17. So it appears that he did learn.

You can safely plane against the grain with no tearout, which eliminates the need for a scraper