Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

Posts

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#26

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Frank D. in Montreal

I made one chisel from a file that worked really well. Unfortunately I abandoned it when I got divorced... I've made a few chisels from bar stock (most cold, a few forged), but looking back if I had to make a chisel to use for woodworking (and not for practicing my metalworking skills) I'd definitely go the file route, it's a lot less involved than getting bar stock and grinding or forging and then quenching etc. I could post a few pics but there's absolutely nothing you'd learn from my chisels...they are a few leagues down in design and workmanship.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#27

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

david weaver

A few leagues down in make work, I'd think. I don't know about the rest.

I don't know that I'm getting anything really done with mine in all of the shaping and rehardening and tempering, i guess it feels like good control.

Bar stock would be a little easier in this case because there's a little scale or pickling, but I wouldn't have to grind that off smacking with a hammer.

I wouldn't be surprised to find that a good file just ground to shape would work just as well as the 4 hour wild goose chase that I went on with the first one.

when I started building planes, it was a factual chase. I wanted to make something that I knew why I was making it a certain way and why it was best. In this case, I'm working on superstition with a little control issue (about the hardness, the proportions, etc) sprinkled in.

It is more fun than I thought it would be. I'm still afraid that I'll waste time and make a tool that's less good than what I already have (which leads to shelving or discarding - I hate that. I threw a lot of early plane attempts away before sitting down and learning about what I was actually doing. It has the same feel as spending money on a bad dinner and crapping it out the next day. Nothing to show for the efforts except less money).

I'll do a chisel with this first one. It has more of a something for nothing feel that appeals to people on youtube. Not that it'll get more than 10,000 views in 10 years.....still not going to do video editing. A fast video with great production, and the implication that you could watch it and learn to do something that equates to getting something for nothing...that draws tons of views even though most of the people watching would never think of actually doing what's in the video.

That's the magic of Roy. We like Roy and watch his stuff, but I knew far more people (nominally) who watched his show and never did any woodworking. He made it look like they could, and it would be getting something for nothing (build it for yourself, don't pay for it) and it was attainable.