Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

Posts

First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#1

First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

David Weaver

Looks a little funny - needs a little bit more finish work, too.

The part that looks the most funny to me is the bolster since it was ground off of the chisel, drilled, heated and then stabbed onto the chisel tang. It went on a little far, but it's not going to move more at this point. I will file the sides back a little bit so that it's not quite so prominent.

Heat treat was uneventful (thankfully) and the result was as hard of a piece of steel as I've ever had. Tempered at 360 degrees F in the oven (not sure of the carbon composition) for an hour, and we'll see how it works once it's stuffed in a handle.

The next one will be a little better. 3 1/2mm at the business end and a little over 6 at the tang, just like the real thing (only smaller?...no, that's ertl).

Should've sourced ferrules earlier.

https://i.imgur.com/UhdLYmL.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/pyZBgJZ.jpg

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#2

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

bridger berdel

That thing looks a lot like a chisel....

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#3

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Rum

I agree with bridger, that does indeed look remarkably like a chisel :D

Did you shoulder the tang where the bolster seats at all? Hard to tell from the picture and I've seen it done both ways but haven't formed an opinion on whether or not its useful (pro: arguably stronger, con: harder to get a perfect seat ... tentative hypothesis that the con outweighs the pro except maybe framing chisels). I do like the bolster shape, has a nice crispness to it that should carry up well into the handle.

Be interesting to see how it cuts!

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#4

with temporary handle

David Weaver

https://ibb.co/w0tSGb5

Still need to sand off the marks from shaping. I expected the chisel to warp more in heat treatment, but the warp was almost nothing. The next one I make will be finish filed before it goes into the quench.

360 degrees for tempering isn't enough, it's still incredibly hard, but with that it has the wire edge habits that I like - nearly none off of a low-grade hard arkansas, which can just barely cut it, and only working just the edge. It's something above 62, and probably has a better chance at a long life (not breaking) if it's tempered a bit further.

Rum - the bolster was hammered on (bright orange) hot, and the tang has taper all the way up. It's possible that it could creep down (no shoulder), but that's OK. It probably won't move much, but if it does, I"ll make another chisel. Still considering ways I could do the bolster better. This is where an industrial die and giant hammer is nice - put the drill rod in the die, bang bang, and out comes a blank that's almost finished, has been heated only once and the bolster is integral. The bolster is O1- I don't have any iron handy. Because of the very high heats (several of them to open the hole after drilling at first), the carbon migrated to spots and there are very hard spots that can ruin a file, even though it wasn't quenched).

better to learn now.

The handle is rosewood, waiting for the magic mcmaster carr to bring me various pieces of brass tubing, and then I'll turn a handle. I wanted to try the burn in method on the handle, which I've never done before, and almost sunk it in two heats in an undersized drill hole, and then it was only just a little too much more to tap it home, and the handle gave way a little bit (you can see the crack). I'll get it closer to all the way next time. It's pretty solid otherwise.

Two weeks ago, I wasn't going to make chisels. My 1095 arrives this week, and I guess I'm going to make half a dozen or so of this type of chisel. :\

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#5

Re: with temporary handle

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That looks a lot like a chisel. Nice...

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#6

Re: with temporary handle

John in NM

I thought the bolster looked too close without the handle - with it the bolster looks better. Still close but not oddly so.

Take a trip to Tucson and I can probably convince a friend to let you use his drop hammer :D He makes jewelry tools but I bet he'd find your chisel experiments pretty cool. Don't know where you'd find a die though.

I use copper pipe for ferrules, easy to find. Might stretch too much but I've never had trouble that way.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#7

I always expect the first one...

David Weaver

... to be messed up. I cut out another O1 iron tonight watching my son (he likes to hijack my saw bench and clamp things to it to rasp, sand and drill through with a stanley 41Y. The hardness of the chisel in the picture is uncanny, i'm just not sure what it is.

When the bolster slipped past the mark that I had, not much I can do other than watch it - but since it's the first one, that's OK. I won't make the same mistake the next time (and it's not on one that I'm going to keep as a user - or at least matching others).

Worst thing in the shop is ego as opposed to curiosity (for me, at least). I picked up woodworking in the middle of a bunch of professional exams and thought I could just think my way out of making mistakes without experience.

Getting a little older and dropping that and being willing to fail on the first try has been a lot nicer. I may not have even tried some of the things I've tried 15 years ago because I wouldn't have had the patience to fail, and I"d have thrown the chisel across the shop when the bolster went on too far, and then come back later. Not sure what changed between then and now other than a lot of failures leading to something good, but I'm sure I threw at least one thing a week back then.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#8

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Steve Voigt

That's very impressive Dave. Two small suggestions:

- I would create a shoulder for the bolster, as Rum suggested. This could be done pretty easily on the belt grinder and cleaned up with a file.

- I think (will have to double check) that on most of my vintage chisels, the octagonal flats don't extend all the way to the tang. A small point, but it would put the cherry on top of an already very good look.

How did you make the bolster, if you don't mind me asking?

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#9

Re: I always expect the first one...

bridger berdel

Do you drive the bolster on hot, so a little expanded?

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#10

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

David Weaver

I'll admit I didn't look that close at how the bolsters were done on my old chisels because most of them are ground in situ, and I had no ability to do that. The older chisels that aren't too old look to be entirely ground with a radius left where the bolster meets the tang.

I have a couple of very old butcher chisels and they look like a combination of filing and radius, some of the crisp filing goes all the way to the tang and then filed into the tang a little (oops) on the older ones. Suggesting they weren't poking when they did it.

I will probably put a shoulder on at least one or two, though I"ve made a mark on this one where the bolster starts to see if it ever moves.

I made it by holding a piece of 1/4" O1 with a pair of cheap needle nose pliers and grinding the flats by eye with a 6" bench grinder and cheap brown wheel. My belt grinder is just the 1x42 kalamazoo, and it's not as fast as the bench grinder for such things. The brown wheel does great with unhardened steel. Something other than O1 would've been better, but I don't have any 1/4" iron or mild steel, and the chisel that I had on my bench at the time (a modern ward) looked like 3/16th wouldn't have done it to get the proportions right. That one is probably early 1900s and the bolster is very sloppy on it, but the whole chisel (for ward) is subpar - finish off of a grinding jig (no filing), etc. Still hard like a ward.

What I"m really chasing with this chisel is water hardening steel left hard - what can it do, still be addressed by natural stones and not break in abuse.

I just banged on this one for a while after tempering it a little more last night (380F - useless to know, because this is "portugal chisel steel" with no brand left on the chisel) and I'd guess it's now in the 63 hardness ballpark, but with very good toughness beating it into hard maple. I'll see how it does mortising a plane in the next couple of weeks. It looks a bit delicate for that, but it's got a mild taper in its width that you probably can't see, and I don't think it will suffer as much abuse as a straight sided chisel because it shouldn't get caught.

I may send it to Rob to test with his other chisels. It was a little chippy on the first temper, but it's now at the very lightest straw color, only just appearing and it is very hard and exhibits no bad behavior. It's the ideal i'm chasing if it manages to hold up. I hope 1095 turns out similar. If not, I guess I'll be smashing more files, but I will work on hiding the fit of the ferrule.

Total time to make this chisel (hold on to your seat), 4 hours.

I don't think I'll be able to get it under 2 with what I'm using, but it's enjoyable to make - much more so than I expected.

The other oddball thing is the burn in method with the tang gives it an uncanny hold into the handle. It was very hard to get off of chisel to give it another round of tempering (I put a newly made O1 stanley style plane iron in the oven last night at 380, so it was a good time to give it a little bit more).

Other details with the making of the bolster - cut out of plate square, drill a hole in the center, heat, bang a square cold chisel into the drilled hole to square up the tang, repeat then with a rectangular cold chisel (from a cheap set of HF cold chisels - ideal victims) and then one more high heat and bang onto the chisel. I am lucky that I have two holes in the anvil just the right size for the bolsters, bigger than the tang and rounded over at the top edges, so I could lay the heated bolster in them and hit them pretty hard, and then turn the cold chisel upside down, drop it in the hole and tap it out. A stroke of luck to have that stuff, but a little bigger on the initial hole, and maybe it could just be done right on the chisel tang. I did give the whole tang two more heats to drive the bolster further, but the thick side is less hot in that heat than the thin side, so I'm hoping the bolster cooled more than the tang. I notched the tang behind the bolster so that I can see if it moves over time, but a shoulder filed on quickly by hand would end any indecision.

slight sharpenability on oilstones and great edge holding so far with no desire to hold on to the wire edge, though..Just what I was looking for. I expected failure, but the chisel quality as a chisel is surprising. If I break it, I will make a slightly heavier one to mortise chisels (with the taper in width). Any store bought chisel could be given that treatment.

What I expect to find when I do find the chisel's weakness, if it doesn't just snap in half at some point, is that it may give up a corner mortising a plane. When japanese chisels are at the upper limits of hardness, that's what they do - just give up the very corner of the chisel while the rest of the edge is OK. That's a serious pain,of course.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#11

Re: I always expect the first one...

David Weaver

Yes, the hole was opened up first with cold chisels that have a similar cross section, and then driven onto the tang itself when hot. It could be that the tang would've been fine the entire time.

I heated the whole tang (this is before heat treat, of course) twice to drive it home, and got a little stiff with it the second time, thus it went on too far. The fat end of the tang was less hot than the bolster, so I'm hoping that it shrunk around it a little bit. I marked it to see if it moves. At this point, I'm going to see if the handle breaks in use, I guess, before replacing it (I'll put good handles with ferrules on better ones later).

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#12

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the info Dave. I've been wanting to do something like this for a long time--we've discussed it before--and it's going to stay on the back burner for me, but I'm glad to see you're doing it.

Using cold chisels or punches to square the hole in the bolster is a good idea. I was imagining filing the hole square, but your way is much more sensible.

Is your bolster the same size as the ferruled, bevel edged chisels that we both seemed to use? I ask because whenever I have to rehandle one of these, I discard the ferrule and make an octagonal handle that seats against the bolster. I prefer this, but the 18th c. and early 19th c. chisels that did this (like the ones in the Seaton book) have bigger bolsters. If I ever do get around to doing this, I think that's the route I'll go.

Any youtube videos planned for this? I'm sure a lot of people would love to see your process.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#13

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

david weaver

The bolster is a little bit big compared to most of the chisels that I have (most of those don't quite fill the area inside the ferrule on the wood).

I'm coming around to what you're thinking, though, which is leave the bolster a bit big and no ferrule. I kind of like this handle, but being rosewood makes it a little heavy. What have you made yours with...assuming beech? I have a lot of indian rosewood because it's a dual use wood (tools and guitar stuff), and use for one thing often leaves waste for another. Blanks sold for guitar aren't that expensive, and they tend to be really straight and make great handles.

At any rate, if I can get the making of the next one (which will be 1095) down to about 2 hours total and it turns out to be nearly identical, I'll make a video of another one after that. I whacked this one a lot more with the "temporary" handle and I'm just not sure that the handle would see improvement with a ferrule and the turned style (though that type would be a lot more economically feasible to product with a duplicator lathe).

heating metal and hammering it will probably bring out a whole new class of know-it-all goons in the comment section.

So far, though, the working properties of this chisel (hardness, lack of wire edge retention, how it deforms (or doesn't very quickly) in use, the fine edge it takes off of a mediocre oilstone. All propellerhead stuff, but great. I hope the 1095 is as good. #2 should erase some of the aesthetic that this one has, too.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#14

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Steve Voigt

Dave,

Yes I use beech, primarily for economics and laziness--there are always a ton of scraps lying around the shop. But rosewood would make a super nice handle. Darryl Gent makes a lot of his out of African blackwood.

The octagonal handles, sans ferrule, are my favorite, but not by a huge margin. The plain turned handles (usually ash or boxwood) that come on those early 20th c. bevel edged chisels are fine, and I don't replace them unless I have too.

For grins, I'm attaching a pic of a 1" chisel from the Seaton book. The bolster is a 7/8" octagon, much bigger than any of mine of comparable blade size. Also interesting is that the blade is thinner at the tip and thicker at the tang than any of my tang-style bevel edged chisels. Of course this is a firmer, not BE.

Re the handles, I have never tried burning in the handle. I normally file the tang a little so the arrises are sharp, drill a single hole, twist the handle onto the tang until it's about 1/4" from the bolster, then tap it down til it seats. Works very well.


Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#15

Burning in...and handle shape...

david weaver

I saw a couple of tutorials with that handle shape. I made sort of a pillow shape because I have another one like it, but I'm guessing there's on precedent for it. Only guessing, as I'm not much of a historical reader.

As far as burning in goes, I would probably be less cavalier about it if it was a "good" chisel and not just my own make. I'm not sure that I'd do it to anything else (e.g., old) as the follow-on would be doing something (polishing) to get rid of the tempering color line which would look awful on an old chisel, and i really don't know that much about what was done, anyway.

I saw some debate reading about burning in handles. Most of it being "I don't think anyone did that, I've never seen it in a chisel handle" or "it wasn't as common" variation on the same statement. As a non-historic reader, I have no clue how much it was done, but most of the chisels we have were factory made (I doubt anyone would've taken the time when the drilling was probably standardized and faster), and from my standpoint working with my house made junk - it's fun.

No clue on the safety aspect of this stuff. I work on the floor so that anything falling can't go far, bounce and skid onto me. I've gotten burned twice toolmaking, but both times, it was picking up a hot tool that was ground - less mentally aware of what's going on after a distraction. It's pretty easy to remember you just saw something orange colored when heating things.

Looking forward to figuring out a more aesthetic and proportional ferrule, though. If they didn't need to be heated to get onto the tang tightly, it would be easier to just file them. The layer of scale is pretty deep and I don't have a good way to grind them in situ.

If I post a video, I'm sure i'll get suggestions. I'd like the facets to match the tang, though, and not have any gaps anywhere.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#16

Re: Burning in...and handle shape...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Burning in a handle is a very clumsy method. If someone has seen a reference to this method for a chisel before 1800 I would like to see it. i cannot imagine wanting a chisel bedded in charcoal.

The reaming method has the great advantage that you can make adjustments to the alignment as you get close to the final fit, so the chisel is nicely aligned with the handle. One can get extremely good alignment even if the tang is slightly crooked. If you use an octagonal handle like was used in the 17th and 18th centuries, you can leave the handle a little fat and adjust the taper to coincide with the bolster also. Again very good alignment even if the bolster is somewhat crooked or asymmetrical.

I like beech for handles because it absorbs shock. Live woods like rosewood and blackwood transmit shock.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#17

Re: Burning in...and handle shape...

David Weaver

There was definitely a need to give the tang a final correction so that it was straight by eye laterally and vertically.

I drilled two holes with the larger one half depth. Not sure what's historically relevant, but this was so easy that I'll probably do them all this way.id bet most people who advocate the method probably haven't done it, though, because the tang and the drilling both have to be straight. It has incredible grip on the tang, though.

I had some concern about the liveliness of the rosewood but mostly use a urethane mallet. Even with Japanese chisels. Sharp noises irritate me after a while, even when I'm the one making them.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#18

Little that I can find on burning in..

david weaver

..most of what I see is like people in the bush burning handles in knives sans any drilling. I doubt there's much precedence for using it without drills around, but I won't do it that way, because as you say, it's sloppy and i don't want that much burned material inside the handle. Still curious about what caused such a strong grip on a heavily tapered tang (compressed charcoal in the little bit that I burned?). I also think nobody has a chance of creating a well shaped hole (without slop) if they burn from the start without drilling.

What I actually did was two stepped drill holes and some careful final work lining the tang up by eye, and it's quick to put the handle on. But even if there's bush precedence for burning in, I don't see any for drilling and then burning in. So, it's a "made up method", and it relies on straight drilling (which I don't have an issue with - I drill handles with a cordless drill and turn them as I'm drilling them to account for bit wander with grain. It works remarkably well).

I straightened the tang a couple of times through the process, especially after bolster seating and then again before seating the handle.The by eye work is kind of the fun part of it.

But this is all easy to talk about doing when I'm working with my own chisel - there's nothing really to ruin, and I'm controlling the tang shape and the straightness. A far different story with a fine older chisel or set of carving tools. Not advocating anyone else do it. It'll stink up a shop, too, for anyone working in a house. And I wouldn't do it to something I didn't make, I'm not controlling the variables and could ruin something.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#19

Re: Burning in...and handle shape...

Steve Voigt

I didn't see your handle until just now--missed it earlier in the thread.

There is plenty of historical precedent for that type of handle. Larry and Don like it, and Don wrote a nice article on making them which is unfortunately no longer online. I prefer the Seaton type, but both are comfortable. (Basically I like any of the simple, unornamented handles that were historically used on tang chisels. The London pattern handles and other poncy stuff I'm not so crazy about)

Warren, I think "charcoal" is a bit hyperbolic. Heating the tang up is only going to burn a tiny bit inside the handle, enough to mitigate the risk of splitting. I'm not a fan of the method--as I said, I prefer the reaming method, because it's easy to control precisely--but it's not a big deal.

The only historic reference I've seen on handling chisels is "The Joiner and Cabinetmaker," in which the author describes squaring and tapering the drilled hole with a chisel. That seems pretty unlikely to me. I'd love to see more sources, if anyone has them.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#20

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Paul in NJ

Hi David,

nice work on the chisel, it looks great. I made a small chisel a while back from a triangular saw file, I think it was a 6" slim taper.


This chisel is 1/8" wide and tapers slightly in length. I made it to do tiny dovetails for small drawers. I annealed the file, ground the shape, and added a bolster the same way you did. I did not do any forging but was sure to grind all the teeth away. I heat treated and tempered to a light straw in my toaster oven. I tempered the tang and the very back end to blue.



I am happy with it in use and sharpening. It holds an edge well enough for me. I have used files for tools before and I think it is a nice clean steel.

regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#21

Re: Burning in...and handle shape...

Paul in NJ

David,

I have been burning in the handles on chisels for quite a while. At least 3 or 4 dozen chisels have been done this way. I pre-drill a stepped pilot hole to keep the handle centered. The file is placed tang up with the bolster against the jaws of a metal working vise. When I plunge the handle to a hair above the bolster, I immediately remove it and cool the tang with a wet rag. I install the handle in the same orientation.

regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#22

Re: Little that I can find on burning in..

Rum

Still curious about what caused such a strong grip on a heavily tapered tang (compressed charcoal in the little bit that I burned?).

I'm pretty sure its the same mechanics as the behavior of a tapered tennon like the staked chair theory that is getting so much blah blah press lately or a Morse taper on a drill press. Tapers of less than about 7d are considered self locking, and the small imperfections in your tang likely increase the interference stresses substantially which would also increase the holding power. If you want math... try http://calqlata.com/productpages/00041-help.html and get back to me once you figure it out :D

A couple of minutes with a cold chisel would also make a self reaming broaching taper.. Not sure how that would work but it should fit at least as well and be similarily quick to apply (and not require heating the assembly to assemble). I think the main concern would be over broaching and thus removing (some of) the advantages of the friction fit.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#23

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

david weaver

Thanks for your two posts, paul. It's helpful to see what other people are doing and their experience with what they've gotten.

I think just grinding files is more sensible than what I'm doing, and the file that I used probably would've made a fine chisel without the hammering, etc. I'm chasing an ideal with it (which means most of the aesthetic stuff is a waste of time, and the hammering may be, too - as far as getting a good usable chisel. My grinding equipment is actually the slow end of things for me. If I had a good 2x72 belt grinder, it would be interesting to see if I could grind down a large file quickly and just shape a chisel to compare it to the ones I've hammered out).

There's some more freedom in using a tool like you made there - when you make it, you know you can make it again, and then there's no feeling of babying the tool in use to protect it. Same with burning the handles -I wouldn't have felt comfortable doing it with a good chisel, and who knows what the tang would've looked like on a good one, anyway - it may not have been straight, or it may have been blunt and rounded just with flats to prevent rotation.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#24

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

Bill White

OK David! Waiting on the chisel vid for sure.

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from file

#25

Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi

david weaver

You think I should do another one with a file? I have one more of the same file and wouldn't mind doing it again.

I also got a long stick of 1/4" thick 1095 a couple of days ago.

No clue what the average individual is more likely to do (buying stock is more prudent).

The wonderful combination of edge holding and hardness that the file provided, i'm almost afraid the 1095 won't do as well!!