Re: First file chisel, chisel file? chisel from fi
David Weaver
I'll admit I didn't look that close at how the bolsters were done on my old chisels because most of them are ground in situ, and I had no ability to do that. The older chisels that aren't too old look to be entirely ground with a radius left where the bolster meets the tang.
I have a couple of very old butcher chisels and they look like a combination of filing and radius, some of the crisp filing goes all the way to the tang and then filed into the tang a little (oops) on the older ones. Suggesting they weren't poking when they did it.
I will probably put a shoulder on at least one or two, though I"ve made a mark on this one where the bolster starts to see if it ever moves.
I made it by holding a piece of 1/4" O1 with a pair of cheap needle nose pliers and grinding the flats by eye with a 6" bench grinder and cheap brown wheel. My belt grinder is just the 1x42 kalamazoo, and it's not as fast as the bench grinder for such things. The brown wheel does great with unhardened steel. Something other than O1 would've been better, but I don't have any 1/4" iron or mild steel, and the chisel that I had on my bench at the time (a modern ward) looked like 3/16th wouldn't have done it to get the proportions right. That one is probably early 1900s and the bolster is very sloppy on it, but the whole chisel (for ward) is subpar - finish off of a grinding jig (no filing), etc. Still hard like a ward.
What I"m really chasing with this chisel is water hardening steel left hard - what can it do, still be addressed by natural stones and not break in abuse.
I just banged on this one for a while after tempering it a little more last night (380F - useless to know, because this is "portugal chisel steel" with no brand left on the chisel) and I'd guess it's now in the 63 hardness ballpark, but with very good toughness beating it into hard maple. I'll see how it does mortising a plane in the next couple of weeks. It looks a bit delicate for that, but it's got a mild taper in its width that you probably can't see, and I don't think it will suffer as much abuse as a straight sided chisel because it shouldn't get caught.
I may send it to Rob to test with his other chisels. It was a little chippy on the first temper, but it's now at the very lightest straw color, only just appearing and it is very hard and exhibits no bad behavior. It's the ideal i'm chasing if it manages to hold up. I hope 1095 turns out similar. If not, I guess I'll be smashing more files, but I will work on hiding the fit of the ferrule.
Total time to make this chisel (hold on to your seat), 4 hours.
I don't think I'll be able to get it under 2 with what I'm using, but it's enjoyable to make - much more so than I expected.
The other oddball thing is the burn in method with the tang gives it an uncanny hold into the handle. It was very hard to get off of chisel to give it another round of tempering (I put a newly made O1 stanley style plane iron in the oven last night at 380, so it was a good time to give it a little bit more).
Other details with the making of the bolster - cut out of plate square, drill a hole in the center, heat, bang a square cold chisel into the drilled hole to square up the tang, repeat then with a rectangular cold chisel (from a cheap set of HF cold chisels - ideal victims) and then one more high heat and bang onto the chisel. I am lucky that I have two holes in the anvil just the right size for the bolsters, bigger than the tang and rounded over at the top edges, so I could lay the heated bolster in them and hit them pretty hard, and then turn the cold chisel upside down, drop it in the hole and tap it out. A stroke of luck to have that stuff, but a little bigger on the initial hole, and maybe it could just be done right on the chisel tang. I did give the whole tang two more heats to drive the bolster further, but the thick side is less hot in that heat than the thin side, so I'm hoping the bolster cooled more than the tang. I notched the tang behind the bolster so that I can see if it moves over time, but a shoulder filed on quickly by hand would end any indecision.
slight sharpenability on oilstones and great edge holding so far with no desire to hold on to the wire edge, though..Just what I was looking for. I expected failure, but the chisel quality as a chisel is surprising. If I break it, I will make a slightly heavier one to mortise chisels (with the taper in width). Any store bought chisel could be given that treatment.
What I expect to find when I do find the chisel's weakness, if it doesn't just snap in half at some point, is that it may give up a corner mortising a plane. When japanese chisels are at the upper limits of hardness, that's what they do - just give up the very corner of the chisel while the rest of the edge is OK. That's a serious pain,of course.