Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Coping saw recommendation

Posts

Coping saw recommendation

#1

Coping saw recommendation

Jerry Gibbs

Looking for a coping saw that I can set adequate tension for removing dovetail waste in 3/4 hardwood. Don’t want to spend $125. Thanks, Jerry

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

jewelers saw *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

Any quality coping saw should work. I prefer a jewelers saw for cutting dovetail waste. It uses a narrower blade and is easier to get tight.


jewelers saw

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#3

Re: jewelers saw

Jerry Gibbs

I tried a jewelers saw and the blade quickly broke

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#4

Coping saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used the Eclipse saw for thirty some years. Pierced work, scroll work, tracery, dovetails, et cetera. I use it on both pull stroke and push, depending on the work. It costs about $20.

In general a 10$ saw is trash, but for double that you get something worthwhile.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#5

Re: Coping saw

Joe shelton

Doesn't the frame get in the way on wide stock?

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#6

Technique and a video

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I tried a jewelers saw and the blade quickly broke

Technique is involved. Most cases of broken blades come down to using too much force. Light pressure and let the blade do the work.

Here I demonstrate using the Knew Concepts fretsaw ..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6O4rY_0zQs

Incidentally Jerry, while you do not want to spend "$100", if you change your mind, the KC I recommend, is the $99 3" aluminium (red) version. This has a quick tensioner for the blade plus the ability to turn the blade 45 degrees for any length panel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#7

Re: Coping saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Does the frame get in the way for wide stock?

If you are talking about dovetails, we usually turn the blade at a slight angle, like 20 degrees, so the frame does not interfere.

If you are talking about pierced work, yes sometimes the frame gets in the way. Sometimes we use a larger saw; sometimes we put the frame in some opening within the piercing in order to saw the stuff that is far from the edge.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#8

Re: Coping saw

Jack Ervin

Olson is my coping saw brand, about same price as eclipse.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#9

I am so glad you're making videos now...

david weaver

..just think about how much easier it is to communicate all of those bits at one time in a video.

It's fun to type in a discussion, but the conversion rate from intended meaning to perceived meaning isn't nearly as good as it is with video.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#10

Re: I am so glad you're making videos now...

Jonathan Elliott

I second that Derek! another happy person.

Miss your videos David but glad they are all there as a resource, I realize all this stuff is very time consuming and don't know how you all have the time to share your experiences like you do so I'm just beyond grateful and hope you all know how appreciated you are! Glad you get enjoyment out of it too.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#11

Re: I am so glad you're making videos now...

david weaver

I think it's very time consuming to make good videos.

It doesn't take that much effort to make videos of the type that I made, though, and I wish folks who knew a lot about their area of expertise would be more willing for half an hour a week or so to turn on the camera and show what they're doing.

I understand why people don't want to do it (messing around with it in the middle of a project, getting criticized for not having a BA in video production and teleprompter reading, etc), but the whole woodworking community benefits when people showing work in process are people who do it rather than people selling something other than their work (e.g., product placement with tools, sponsored videos, people trying to maximize patreon and google ads).

I'm kind of out of unique ideas and haven't been making tools too much the last year and a half or so due to playing catch-up with some things my wife wanted to have made (and making several guitars - lots of good video content on that already).

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#12

Re: I am so glad you're making videos now...

bridger berdel

Can't say I have any particular expertise but here's a video I made planing a large panel:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KleQGHZ7eNI

If anything I'd appreciate technique feedback.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#14

Re: I am so glad you're making videos now...

david weaver

I can't say you should talk as much as I do in my videos - people criticize that a lot, but I'd add narration over that video to describe what you're doing and why. I think you could fill the 1:30 easily explaining the steps and why you're doing what you're doing, how you're holding the work, etc.

Most of the people watching videos like that are probably new and the concept of actually doing a large panel is quickly squashed when they try to do it and blow the back side off planing across the grain because "chris schwarz" showed a specific process.

Time lapse is a great idea on something large like that, though. As time goes on, the tolerance for videos with any dead space in them (as in real time) gets less and less.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#15

Thank you, Warren.


Re: Coping saw recommendation

#16

Clint Searl

Coincidentally...

Clint Searl

My current project includes six 3 x 1 insets into 1" thick walnut. Having no coping saw at hand, I slowly chiseled out the waste on the first two, but was getting frustrated on the third, that was all cross grain. So it was to HD for their $8.47 coping saw and $2.99 pack of blades. Used it to complete #3-6 in less time than for the first two. It makes me wonder what it is about a $100+ frame that would have made it any better than the one for 1/12th the price.

Re: Coping saw recommendation

#17

Re: Coincidentally...

Jim Matthews

Harmonic resonance attuned to the background note of the Universe?

Gotta wonder how many hunnert dolla saws have use the same Olson blade.