Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Gouge question

Posts

Gouge question

#1

Gouge question

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

Here is a photo of 5 gouges:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48105067488/in/album-72157708940252281/

The 3 middle ones are Stubai, an Austrian firm; the outside ones are Ashley Iles. All of the Stubai’s have noses, whereas the Ashley Iles and every other gouge I’ve seen have squared-up shoulders. In fact I’ve read that the shoulders are to be kept square and not rounded (easy to do whilst sharpening, trust me on this).

But the Stubai company either has a different style, or these particular Stubai’s have a different purpose. The other Germanic gouges I’m familiar with—Three Cherries and Dastra—all have square shoulders like the Ashley Iles.

Do the gouges with noses have a specific use, different from the square shouldered ones?

Wiley

Re: Gouge question

#2

Re: Gouge question

Rum

I've used round nosed gouges to finish the end of grove cut. Basically the curve on the end matches the bottom of a groove so you can match carve them. Wow I'm totally not explaining this well, hopefully that made sense.

For normal use of generic material removal the round nosed gouges don't work very well. The problem is that ideally for a gouge or V tool you want to cut the material from the top to the bottom. With a straight ended gouge this happens naturally because your approach angle causes the gouge to bit in at the top layer of material first and then progress into the cut. With a round ended gouge you are cutting near the bottom and then progressively closer to the top as the cut advances, this means that the material has to lift out of the way BEFORE its cut, which is both difficult and causes splintering at the sides.

Re: Gouge question

#3

Re: Gouge question

Wiley Horne

Hi Rum,

Thank you! That makes sense, even to this novice, or whatever comes before novice. More generally, as I read your description, it occurs to me that the nosed gouge could be flexible in fairing or detailing concave places that have already been carved with other gouges. Well, just a notion, and thanks again.

Wiley

Re: Gouge question

#4

Re: Gouge question

William Duffield

The simple answer, as in Rum's examples, is "Yes."

Mary May once mentioned, in a presentation, that the optimum gouge set includes a straight edge, a convex edge and even a concave edge gouge in each sweep. ;) But, even as many gouges as she has, she has not achieved this flexibility, so she grinds most of her gouges straight across, because that is the most useful shape, and when she has need for a different shaped edge, she grinds one specially for the purpose. This significantly decreases the number she has to carry to classes and demos and saves time searching for the right gouge, and saves space on the bench. Do I wish I had Mary's problem of too many gouges? That is a rhetorical question, and I don't have an answer. :D

Re: Gouge question

#6

You're only partly right...

Joe shelton

...in that it is a rhetorical question, but you do know the answer.

We all do. That's why we frequent these threads.

Re: Gouge question

#7

Re: Gouge question

Rum

Yeah you do have to be mildly careful about where the wood removal is happening and closely matching curves but sometimes a little pokey end on the chisel is just the ticket for getting into those tight spots.

I also use a small collection of straight and bend blade knives (no particular brands, just a bunch of things accumulated over the years) which can also work pretty well for such things. You have to use a bit move caution on your cut control but 3 or 4 knives can be super flexible in what you can carve with them.

Sadly I'm very much short anything resembling a full set of sweeps much less multiples in each sweep. That would be pretty cool though :)

Re: Gouge question

#8

Re: Gouge question

Rum

Re-reading Leonard Lees classic book on sharpening (the things you forget!!).

There was an interesting note that some carvers actually have two more gouges (hah) sharpened to a left and right skew gouge angle. This increases the effective cutting angle much like a skew(ed) plane (or a skew chisel or skewing the chisel or.. what have you). The thought came to me that by rolling one of the round nosed gouges you have here to the side you effectively have both a left and right skew gouge in one. How well that would work in practice I'm not entirely sure, but its an intriguing idea.

Re: Gouge question

#9

Re: Gouge question

William Duffield

There is also much overlap with what you can do with a fishtail gouge. The fishtail makes itself useful when you need to cut into corners in both directions, since you don't need to stop and change tools, but its disadvantage is it is expensive and it wears out rapidly.

I knew a wood turning teacher who used to provide a rhetorical answer to a common question, "What is the best tool to perform…(fill in the blank)? His answer was almost always "The tool you have in your hand." This is just as applicable to carving as to turning. If you can perform the next cut with the tool you are already using for the previous cut, even if it is perhaps not the "best" tool for that operation or the tool you are most comfortable with, it is more efficient to use it than to set the tool down and go find and pick up the specific tool you might be more skilled with. This strategy will most quickly result in increased skills with all your tools.