Gouge question
Wiley Horne
Hi all,
Here is a photo of 5 gouges:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48105067488/in/album-72157708940252281/
The 3 middle ones are Stubai, an Austrian firm; the outside ones are Ashley Iles. All of the Stubai’s have noses, whereas the Ashley Iles and every other gouge I’ve seen have squared-up shoulders. In fact I’ve read that the shoulders are to be kept square and not rounded (easy to do whilst sharpening, trust me on this).
But the Stubai company either has a different style, or these particular Stubai’s have a different purpose. The other Germanic gouges I’m familiar with—Three Cherries and Dastra—all have square shoulders like the Ashley Iles.
Do the gouges with noses have a specific use, different from the square shouldered ones?
Wiley
But, even as many gouges as she has, she has not achieved this flexibility, so she grinds most of her gouges straight across, because that is the most useful shape, and when she has need for a different shaped edge, she grinds one specially for the purpose. This significantly decreases the number she has to carry to classes and demos and saves time searching for the right gouge, and saves space on the bench. Do I wish I had Mary's problem of too many gouges? That is a rhetorical question, and I don't have an answer. 




