Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

Posts

Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#1

Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

david weaver

I've ordered a V11 stanley replacement iron and have a new LN A2 iron little used already (not my favorite kind of iron, but generally the best of the A2 irons available).

I also found a hock high carbon still in my piles (which I didn't think I had), and will test one of the $10 chinese high speed steel irons along with the group.

These are all stanley type irons. I want to, if possible, test all of the irons in the same plane and on the same wood. The procedure will be as follows:

* sharpen the irons initially after confirming in use that they are in good nick (as in, eliminate any poor performing anomalies before starting. If something is wrong with an iron, it's easy to tell when dimensioning and it's usually temporary). I will sharpen with a guide, which I never do, but just to control variables, and will sharpen on synthetic stones.

* take microscope photo of the edges (I may sharpen the various irons on other media just to see how the edges do to spot any issues. For example, A2 hates washitas. V11 grades them a little bit but takes a decent edge. I will probably not test anything other than the synthetically sharpened edges)

* take 100 strokes with each iron setting shaving thickness at .002". Swap irons after each 100 strokes and take a picture of each to get progressive dulling pictures. Will be rotated before dullness to limit the effect of wood variability

* the test wood will be hard maple. It's tempting to find something that is more abrasive like cocobolo to speed up the test, but the results may not be representative of how irons will wear in "normal wood".

The only subjective part of the test is that I will comment on the surface with each stage (it's hard to get pictures of small lines on wood because automatic cameras want to ignore that kind of thing - just as they like to cancel out reflections on a cleanly planed surface. I guess that is an outdoor glare reduction type function). I will plane until each no longer wants to stay in the cut under typical hand/arm weight (as in, until in actual use, you'd need to lean on a plane to get a continuous shaving).

I expect the V11 will fare best, and hope that it will also provide the best surface outside of O1 and simpler irons (and possibly better than the hock HCS iron at some point).

I have done a test like this comparing A2 irons in the past, and that and experience trying to get a finish off of the plane has shown the LN irons that I've had to be least likely to chip and leave lines if they're accommodated. I'd consider them the middle of the road standard in modern irons.

If I manage to do and document all of the above, I may run the test a second time just to confirm the results (this will take eons, thousands of shavings and I'm not going to do it all at once), and then do the same test either in a different wood or with a different shaving thickness.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#2

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nearly 6 years ago I compared the Veritas and LN #51 shooting planes. A large part of my interest was to compare the effect of BU vs BD planing on edge wear in a controlled situation. This was about as good as it gets ...

Both planes are guided along the same Stanley #52 shooting board.

There was A2 steel for both planes. In addition, the Veritas had PM-V11. Later, in a follow up test, the LN was also able to sport PM-V11. For interest, I added a Clifton hand hammered O1 iron.

The articles are here:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/LVShootingPlane.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/MoreAboutShootingPlanesandTheirBlades.html

The results of the first assessment were black and white: blade wear in a BU plane far away outclassed blade wear in a BD plane (shooting end grain). Keep in mind that the BU plane had a 12 degree bed and a 37 degree cutting angle (in other words, even when it used a more fragile 25 degree bevel). The BD plane had a 45 degree bed, for a higher cutting angle, but was still outclassed with a 30 degree bevel. Really, the results were chalk-and-cheese (using A2 vs A2 steel, and even more so with PM-V11 vs A2 steel).

The second test was completed because I wanted to compare PM-V11 in a BD plane (I had only the single PM blade for the Veritas plane up until that time). Rob Lee sent me a PM-V11 for the LN #51.

Results indicated that all BD planes need a 30 degree (minimum) bevel angle for edge longevity (25 degrees is far too low - even PM-V11 suffered at this angle). At 30 degrees, PM-V11 outlasted A2 by 50%.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#3

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

david weaver

It'll be interesting to see if the same holds true in long grain. I have a very hard 01 iron in my infill shooter, but it is unusually good. I could not distinguish a difference in its edge life vs. V11 in the little time that I had both the skew shooter and the infill shooter.

It's dangerous to compare different planes to each other, though, as I tried using a custom plane with a V11 iron it it vs. one of my woodies that I put a wonderful unusually hard butcher iron from Jim Andrews in. I think I bought that from Jim, but he could correct me if I'm wrong - he may have given it to me. Whatever it was, I paid less than market at the worst by a substantial amount.

That reference to hardness is only relevant because as Steve mentioned last week, many (especially if you don't buy parallel irons for infills or ward irons) of the irons are not what we'd call modern boutique hardness. I'd guess the butcher iron that I have to be 61 or so. I have no other butcher irons like it.

But, there is no way that it is more long lasting than a V11 iron - yet I can do a much greater volume of wood removal with the woody than I could with the LV custom plane. I just couldn't get more than about 4-5 thousandths of beech through the custom plane trying to use it like I would a try plane and the woody won. If I were new to this game and reported that the butcher iron lasts long, I think that's false with a 99.9% probability.

Thus the long grain test in wood alternating planes. It's the closest thing I can think of that actually seems like real woodworking. Beach's test is pretty good, but it looks like he hasn't done anything for more than a decade.

LV provided that plane to me to look at and provide feedback on about the time they came out, maybe slightly before. I didn't ultimately keep it because it broke my shop rule (it sat on a shelf and got some rust on it, and if that happens, it tells me I'm not using a tool and I couldn't bear to see it rot away so I sold it and donated the money to a community outreach service here. I think that's in the spirit of what LV would've done).

After reading the initial report, I expected that while I dearly love the ward type carbon steel, I would be replacing all of my bench plane irons with the V11.

it's possible that could still happen. I am testing durability to refine what I saw. I don't think I did the planemaking work before I provided my findings to LV (which were more about the plane than the iron), but I do remember sharpening the iron on media from diamonds to washita and finding out that it's possible to sharpen it on a washita, but it grades the stone (it's a little too much for it). I was generally pretty happy with it.

I'm on the fence about making a new O1 iron to use in this test, but I think I probably will not. I expect it will fare slightly worse than the V11 and it would look vain. If it did well (like the knight iron in beech's tests), It's not like posting it would give people the opportunity to buy one.

if someone doesn't like the findings of my tests, I hope they choose to do something similar. Testing things can teach you a lot, as long as it doesn't replace making (someone else may choose to do that. I'll do the testing when I don't feel like making anything but don't feel like sitting on the couch, either).

It filters back sort of to the comment you made below, and I agree with - more or less, it's more important that an iron is a reasonable spec and not defective than it is that it's some theoretical ideal.

I think we could probably tolerate the clifton irons here, even, but I've never used one that I can recall (they were ungodly expensive stand-alone retail here - something like $90). I'd refer to the irons that came in the primus planes as stripemasters - not long wearing, and never a clear surface, but lots of people like those OK (in that case, again, the manufacturer made claims about wear, but unlike LV, I don't think they did any testing, because those are some of the worst irons I've used).

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#4

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

1. Bevel angle. Derek said bevel angle was significant. Steve Elliott found the same thing, with differences of plus or minus a degree or two around 32 degrees affecting his results, and in more forgiving wood than hard maple:

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/bevel_angles.html

2. CPM 3V. Don’t have a Stanley-alike 3V, but if a 0.145”/2-3/8” one will do, I can send. Fits LN 4.5, 6, 7. Also have 3/16” thick at 2” and 2-1/4”. This may not be of much interest because they’re not commercially available.

Wiley

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#5

Re: 3v may not be commercially available

david weaver

...but I recall Bill saying that it was a pleasure to work with, presumably costly though.

If it tests better than everything else, I'm sure someone might take the results and run with them.

I think there's a lot of price sensitivity in the market, though. I was going to get a 2 3/8" V11 iron to use in a bigger plane than a stanley 4 or 5, but none are available online, and the act of buying the iron and not requesting it from somewhere is important to me for subjective purposes for the test.

I'd be happy to test a 3V iron, but if it's something you're using on a regular basis, it may take months for me to get all of this done and organized, and there may be something I want to test further. I don't want to tie up peoples' nice tools.

(I do have a plane of every size 2"+ for standard irons).

As far as angle, I was planning on 33 degrees final with a guide. The reason for that is simple - that's the angle that LN's A2 (and all that I've found out there) needs to be accommodated to so that there isn't premature chipping. Steve has already documented something like that (my 33 may have been his 32 or 34), and when Brian Holcombe first launched his planed finished goods business, I vaguely recall him asking the same question and finding the LN iron to work better there than 30.

I learned to freehand hone when I was still using A2, so about 33 is baked in when I hold plane irons - they all end up there unless I consciously do something different. Someone brought that up a couple of years ago (how inaccurate hand honing would be) and I didn't find any freehand honed iron on any of my planes that differed from 33 by more than +/- 1. I was overly proud of myself for that, but I think you get to feel very little changes very easily when you do something over and over. It would feel wrong to hone a plane iron at 38 or 30.

I guess that means everything that I do, and everything that I'll test here will be based on accommodating LN's A2. I also vaguely recall that other irons (especially if they're a little soft) appreciate that same extra bit over the 25-30 older texts seem to recommend. Job 1 for me sharpening irons freehand is to give adequate clearance as much as possible, but not to a point that an iron chips - the more sharpening is dictated by wear instead of damage, the better the experience is in a long session. You can also get away with finish planing then with an iron that's not freshly sharpened - the surface will still be bright without lines.

(too with that, when I tested A2 irons, I found that early chipping both reduced terminal durability by a lot, and also made split shavings and lines relatively early on, making plane use more frustrating).

I think these things don't get talked about that often because few people really try finishing right off of a plane. If everything is dialed in right, planing to a finish on the flat bits of work is definitely faster.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#6

I don't anticipate...

david weaver

...that this testing is going to generate too much interest on here. I'm looking more for a reference for all of the bits and pieces that I claim (once in a while, people ask about them).

Many other things that I'd like to look at, like quantifying my big/little smoothing theory, and how that negates even having the most durable iron in terms of feet planes - in favor of the iron that wears the most uniformly. (and it's much faster than dainty smoothing - a matter of practicality).

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#7

Reminds me to say...

david weaver

...thanks, by the way.

When I was thinking of building an infill skew shooting plane (something that I don't use much at this point, but it's been nice the times I've wanted to trim a board (a trim board without tenons on the end) to fit in something stick built.

Anyway, I had pondered not building one at all because I wanted to build bevel down and didn't think 40 degrees would provide clearance and durability. Your test gave me the initiative to build the plane at 40 degrees effective and the plane has been an absolute treat.

Even survived a fall to a concrete floor thanks to my constantly cleaning Mrs.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#8

I'll be interested in the results for

Chuck Nickerson

commercially available irons. I also enjoy the discussions of testing protocol. Apparently I want more science in my woodworking.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#9

If it makes you feel better...

david weaver

...I came to my preferences out of laziness more than science :\

I prefer straight razors to absolutely anything else now, too, even if I have shaky hands from lack of sleep. That's a discussion for a different time except to say that it's somewhat related to controlling the wear on the edge of a plane so that it seems to be mostly the same the whole time.

The angles that I found were just by feel. Plane, chip, slightly higher. Plane, chip, slightly higher. Plane, no chip...good. Never knew where the freehand angle ended up until someone prodded checking with a protractor.

(I did find the A2 angle by measurement with a guide years ago, but I used a guide back then).

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#10

W-1

Wiley Horne

David,

Will send anything you’re interested in, when the time is ripe. Just let me know.

I also have an LN iron that came stock in an LN4 back in the early 90’s (the ones with the heavy build of lacquer on the handles). People say it’s W-1. Which is likely so, because those irons most always came with hollow backs, and took plenty of elbow grease to get a 1” flat place above the edge. Thickness about 0.115”. I really like this iron, however it might test. Again though, I don’t imagine water-hardening steel is gonna make a comeback in plane irons. Funny, back in Badger Pond days, people would call LN and ask if they had any of the old irons left—and they did. Then.

Wiley

Wiley

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#11

Re: W-1

david weaver

Interesting on the LNs. At one point, George had some guys at CW go through more than an inch of an old LN iron (the water hardening) and found that LN didn't harden the irons up to the slot. They hardened as much as they could without too much warpage or cracking (my interpretation, not Lie Nielsen's).

At the time, george made all kinds of stuff out of steel and liked the stability of A2 (not surprising) and suggested that they use it. They said "no thanks!".

Not long after, they were using it.

I don't know if anyone will ever know who actually tripped them into using it. Karl H mentioned using it for quite some time before everyone else started to and he moved on in some cases to something more exotic (to the detriment of the fineness of the worn edge from most comments I've seen, and Brent Beach has a picture of such a problem).

I'll check in once I've got my ducks in a row. I'd suspect that the ability of LN's original irons to hang with anything more abrasion resistant will depend largely on the hardness they were able to achieve.

Beach tested the W1 irons and found them not to fare as well as O1 (the berg also looked a lot like O1, as did the thin punched out prelaminated blue steel irons tsunesaburo sold - or the smoothcut labeled irons found elsewhere. Same thing, I think).

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/LNW1test.html

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/Hocktest.html

I may wish to do the detailed tests on commercially available irons but post a result of a single test for some others just to see where they come out.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#12

Re: W-1

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You have to be a little careful about George's Williamsburg stories. Some of them probably happened more than 40 years ago. A lot of tradesmen have gone through in that time. Great blacksmiths that I have known have come and spent their careers and retired. I think I saw Wallace Gusler at Williamsburg 55 years ago, and he made the gunsmith video a few years later. If he did something clumsy in his twenties, we do not need to dwell on it.

When I first was going to Williamsburg many craftsmen were just putting on a show, like a play. Later they had a different spirit. They really wanted to put themselves in the position of the 18th century craftsmen and put their skills up against historic workers. Like one fellow said to me earlier this year, I am not pretending to be Thomas Jefferson; I am a blacksmith. In this mindset, A2 has no place.

Here is an old Williamsburg story: I taught George's wife how to sharpen a spokeshave. This might sound a little odd, but context is important here. She had just come to Williamsburg and might not have even known George at the time.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#13

Re: W-1

david weaver

Which one, his current wife? He's pretty precise, though once in a while he says something inaccurate.

in an era where people were on show there, he moved to the toolmaker shop because he didn't like that kind of stuff (at least that's what I gather from him). I think he probably turned off some of the folks there who didn't want to push that hard.

The A2 story is one that he actually mentioned shortly after retirement. He was playing with exotic steels for knives (which probably weren't half as exotic as most of the stuff now, or a tenth) and mentioned that he'd made some A2 irons and slipped them to the coopers, who were being forced to use what the blacksmiths could laminate (1070 or something of the sort) to wrought.

As far as spokeshaves go, I think I'd rather have someone else teach sharpening them to my wife, even though I've known her for 15 years. Not that she wants to learn, but she definitely doesn't like any advice from me!

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#14

Re: 3v MAY BE commercially available

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I suspect CPM3V IS commercially available. A knife making supply outfit near me has it in widths up to 4” in lengths from 12” to 36”.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#15

Re: I'll be interested in the results for

Jonathan Elliott

I'm interested too and follow these threads with great interest from those that have wanted the road ahead of me. I don't expect to not have to walk the road myself or to have the same exact experience as others but I greatly appreciate the sharing of experience and learn a lot.

I agree that the enthusiasm from 10-15 yrs ago is dying down and am sad to see the closing of many truly great (not all of them are) small business tool makers. I for one am very grateful for these forums since I learn a lot more than scrolling through some Instagram feed, which seems to be where most have gone.

Appreciative hand tool novice

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#16

Re: W-1 and A2; and preparing an edge.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Subjectively ...

I have two W1 LN blades. One is for a #4, and it has been trouble - it is difficult to even take an edge. I plan to re-heat treat it. The other is in a skew block plane, and it takes and holds an excellent edge. In this case, I do not see it as a BU vs BD issue.

The LN A2 blades I have are excellent. One is for a #3, and the other two are for a #4 1/2 and #51. I know the reputation of A2 for micro fracturing, but these blades have not shown up this way (or possibly I do not recognise this in the surfaces).

I have used LV A2 blades for many years as well. In recent years they have been replaced by PM-V11, mainly because I would rather hone the latter. A2 is more work to remove the wire. Nevertheless, the A2 blades have been really excellent on a shooting board, which is a pretty good test of durability. I have presented numerous examples (the Veritas Shooting Plane review being just one) where the irons are ground and honed at 25 degrees. In theory this should be a no-no for A2, yet it is not so in practice ... I can only put this down to the low bed angle. I am still getting my head around this. Perhaps a structural engineer here can say something: we assume that cutting angle is cutting angle, even when the bed angles are different. Do vector forces follow this as well? Is the low bed angle responsible for better edge life, or is this due to a lower cutting angle? Is it the same thing?

It makes logical sense to me that a lower cutting angle will wear better when shooting since there is less impact. It also makes logical sense to me that a progressively higher bevel angle will wear progressively faster since the edge moves increasingly away from the acute side and it has progressively less edge to hold onto. Logically, the higher the bevel angle, the tougher it is, but also the less leeway as well to retain sharp.

I'd welcome comments on the above since it seems to me that any discussion about steel type must include how the edge is prepared for optimal use.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#17

Double iron positioning?

Wiley Horne

David,

Have you thought about what to do about chipbreaker positioning—retracted vs. in-play? I ask this because a close setting changes the forces acting on the blade edge. Indeed, Prof. Kato was trying to find out, among other things, the extent to which a close chipbreaker had a self-sharpening effect, as it created a slight concavity just above the cutting edge. Forgot what he found out.

Wiley

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#18

Re: Double iron positioning?

David Weaver

Yes on the cap iron being set. I'll set it as I normally would with a smoother. I measured this at one point last year or the year before (after never really knowing how close I set it, I set it by eye). I think it was something like 6 thousandths.

I vaguely recall the self sharpening discussion and if I remember it correctly, the cap iron accelerates the wear on the top edge of the cut (the back of the iron) but I don't remember the conclusion about the effect of it doing that. I remember bill hoping that would be a beneficial effect in making for a longer lasting edge, but I think the action of keeping a shaving continuous and the plane in the cut is more beneficial in terms of being able to use an edge longer.

I guess there could be some debate about whether or not the cap iron should be in play, but I think the answer is yes in this case because that's how I'd use the plane (set to minimize tearout potential across smoother shavings that I'd use - up to 4 thousandths or so).

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#19

Re: 3v MAY BE commercially available

David Weaver

Yes on the stock, I've seen it sold at least in small bits for knife makers.

I probably should've specified what I meant. When Bill and Steve were making irons, someone else ended up selling 3V irons on ebay for a while. I don't remember precisely what their proportions were, and they were expensive.

So, the stock is available (and probably wouldn't be more available to a quantity purchaser), but nobody seems to be able to or want to make a go of turning relatively expensive stock into a profitable-to-make iron.

I'm supposing by saying that that the market is relatively price sensitive. It costs even for the V11 iron (with shipping), $58 to get a 2" iron. Sometimes LV has free shipping, and that would bring it down $10. Aside from the low volume irons that have been around, that's the most expensive I can think of (clifton hand forged were really expensive, but not for any good reason). i'm guessing that the cost of 3V stock eats too far into the final price of an iron (not sure about its workability at production speeds, but vaguely recall bill saying that it wasn't bad to work by hand).

(of course, A2 and O1 are relatively inexpensive - they fluctuate, but don't threaten the typical $40 cost level for irons).

I didn't go read the hardening schedule for 3V, but am assuming that any reputable hardening service can read the sheet and do it to whatever spec one would want.

One of the reasons I want to test the $11 green iron on ali-express is because I think it's pretty good. It's some kind of brazed on high speed steel, and it's about stock stanley thickness. I don't know just how good it is, but for some reason, a couple of the HSS items from china that I've gotten have been very fine to use.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#20

Re: W-1 and A2; and preparing an edge.

David Weaver

I think there is some validity to your supposition about angle and vectors. But I have no way to prove it, and I'm wary of saying much that I can't prove because of my first round foray into super steels and super stones, thinking I'd be able to prove that they were more economy of effort in woodworking. Charts about them would suggest so in all cases, but I was missing two factors (double iron and sharpening simplicity - both go together since uniformity becomes more important than initial sharpness with a double iron).

As far as surface quality on the A2 - my LN irons do not chip into the shaving splitting type of nicks, but rather in a way that leaves a surface looking a little bit more dull and still leaving behind some evidence of exactly where a plane traveled our strokes are never perfectly straight, and you can see them.

I didn't ever ask brian holcombe exactly why he switched from A2 to carbon steel in his LN smoother, but I suspect that last little bit (the tiny lines) drove him nuts. A good planed finish to me is one that after a burnish with shavings (or even without), has no telegraphing at all, but the little tiny lines left by A2 in raking light, I just cannot get rid of them with burnishing.

I've got another thing I'd like to test, I"ll post it in another thread - it has nothing to do with iron durability.

I would like to know a proven answer about bevel durability vs. bed angle, but I think one would have to do another "thousands of strokes" tests to see what they could prove, and it would require the use of two nearly identical planes to eliminate other variables. I'm supposing that the closer the iron gets to going straight into the wood (lower bevel angle), the less vibration there probably is at an edge - either that or just outright pushing force "pushing the edge off".

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#21

Heat Treatment of CPM 3V

Steve Elliott

The heat treatment recommended by Crucible Steel for 3V is intended to maximize its toughness. A knife maker named Jerry Hossum found that a different schedule that maximizes hardness gives a more suitable edge for knives. That's the way our batch of plane blades was treated.

At the time we made the blades Paul Bos would heat treat a single knife or plane blade for $30 and he was good at it. Our batch of plane blades went to him. He is retired now and sold his business, I believe, but I've heard the expertise left with Paul. No personal experience but I've heard of one customer who was disappointed.

Now that many good blades are available I don't see as much reason for trying new alloys. I still prefer my 3V blades but there was a learning curve to sharpening them.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#22

Re: Heat Treatment of CPM 3V

David Weaver

Thanks for the advice, Steve. I had a knife at one point that said "bos" on the side of the blade. I think it was 154 cm and plenty hard.

Almost across the board, my experience is that the specs used for knives are on the soft side to tolerate abuse and we never really push any toughness limits with woodworking. Edges that don't freely bend do better in planes.

Not surprised that someone else can't match bos when it comes to heat treating. There's still nuance just in things like you mention, and it's like cooking. You have to make the dish right every single time as well as knowing how to do it. $30 is beyond reasonable.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#23

forgot to mention..

david weaver

The main purpose of running this test is to get some actual quantifiable data for just how long V11 lasts in a typical wood (not MDF and not a torture test in wood that has shiny particles like the worst of cocobolo).

http://www.pm-v11.com/TestingWear.aspx

This page drives me bonkers. It provides relative numbers, but nothing really to know. The edge of the MDF abused irons, but there is nothing like it in the world of planing wood, unless you're planing paint.

if you remove the parts of the picture with the MDF edges, you see something that looks like it wears like A2, which is my finding.

I would prefer brent beach had done this as his page was a pretty good collection of accurately collected information (accurate in terms of matching my findings in real wood).

I think the real value in V11 is two things:

1) from LV's view, nobody else can market it

2) hoping to find that its edge fineness is an advantage over A2.

I'd guess wear in long grain that will be 100-125% of LN's A2 iron.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#24

Re: Double iron positioning?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

What I remember about the Kato wear study is that they put the cap iron extremely close and had a very thick shaving for that kind of setting. They also did an extreme amount of planing between sharpening sessions, which we also would not normally do with such a close setting. The whole thing was just far removed from the practical art of planing wood.

The planing was done by machine, which was alright, but a real person doing real work has an incentive to treat their body so as to be able to plane the next day or the next decade. So these considerations influence our settings and our sharpening regimen.

Re: Anything else to test? Testing iron durability

#25

Re: Double iron positioning?

david weaver

100% right. The setting that I generally use came about via laziness and not due to the K&K suggestions. I'd been on to the cap iron for a little bit before Bill sent me a link to the videos and noticed that slightly rounded caps seemed to work better.

When I saw the video, I attempted to create the 80 degree set (can't remember if the video used 90) on a japanese plane, hoping I'd just found the key to very crisp planing that a japanese plane provides as well as tearout prevention. While that setting worked really well in a video, it was very unforgiving. With a machine, you could set depth of cut and cap iron and just repeat over and over, but the nuance of hand planing didn't translate well.

If I have to think about it as rules, I'd say those would be:

* plane with the grain first, before considering anything else

* set the cap iron in the lazy man's setting with the lazy man's profile that I prefer (because it doesn't affect surface quality on very thin shavings if the cap iron is set back a little) and at the distance from the edge that you find straightens out briskly the thickest shaving you're likely to take. No disaster would occur, but the plane is easier to use and not harder (push pressure is close to the same as no cap iron, but no tendency to come out of a cut because of tearout - a net gain)

* set the cap iron 50-100% shorter than the lazy man's setting only if it's absolutely necessary. It rarely is. Quite often when it seems necessary, the wood being planed is "unplaneable" from a practical standpoint (quartered cocobolo is sometimes like this - the early wood is really fragile and fractures. It doesn't even scrape nicely).

lazy man's setting plays well with big/little smoothing, which also puts the least wear and tear on the person running the plane (first passes for smoothing are hefty smoother shavings, cap iron controls quality of the surface, last several passes are finishing). Big/little works great with machine planed wood, too. very fast, and predictable in terms of change in dimension.

I was a bit turned off when the video came out and a bunch of bloggers suggested people should put an 80 degree bevel on their cap iron. It just didn't work well on a hand plane and was very unforgiving, not eliminating tearout on thin shavings and being too hard to push on thicker shavings and leaving a resulting fuzzy-ish surface from smashing the shaving back down into the wood.