Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hardness Data for Chisels

Posts

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#26

Re: results have been repeated countless times

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I wonder if these are the same Lee Valley technicians who found no difference between a double iron plane and a single iron plane. Vic Tesolin claims they found 45 degrees is 45 degrees no matter how you slice it.

been discussed sufficient for bystanders to judge for themselves what data to believe.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#27

Re: results have been repeated countless times

David Weaver

If he put that in writing, he's an idiot. There was maybe a time that you could write something like that and get away with it, but it's passed now.

It's one thing not to know, but far worse for him to claim something wrong and be insistent about it. I'd imagine at this point, he's too invested in his own gimmick to care about whether or not he's actually right.

To use Bill's words, the results with the double iron have been repeated countless times.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#28

Re: results have been repeated countless times *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Check this out 24:00 to 26:00

I see now you already commented on this video.


Tesolin

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#29

Re: results have been repeated countless times

David Weaver

I vaguely recall when peter sefton posted that video on another forum.

I'm sure I couldn't stomach the whole video at the time and never saw that segment (the two minutes you linked), but to supposedly talk about that stuff professionally and actually believe that ....makes me wonder why bill is so excited about some guy in texas using a portable hardness tester.

Any experienced user of a stanley plane could make that presenter look like a fool in less than five minutes.

There are a lot of boasts that are just forum hot air, but that is simple fact. He should be embarrassed.