Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hardness Data for Chisels

Posts

Hardness Data for Chisels

#1

Hardness Data for Chisels

david weaver

(this is long, and if you're the type who boasts about minimal time thinking about tools, and maximum with tools in wood - it's not for you. Fair warning)

(Also, picture is at the bottom)

Attached is a summary of hardness data that I have copied over from Rob Streeper's efforts. I don't think you can view the pictures on the forum that he posted them on without registering, so I have put the picture here. I have a lot of opinions about how hard I think tools are due to switching over to using a washita stone on a regular (majority of the time) basis, and correlating how the chisels on that stone behave (from time to time looking at the edges under a microscope, but not often - it just confirms what I feel).

I was pleased that rob got a hold of some sets of chisels, and in some cases, single chisels, and tested them (none of the tests are single strikes).

These results are for individual chisels and not sets, but they generally correspond with what I've been able to gather from stones.

I purchased three sets of sorby chisels that I found for a steal (different styles) because I like the style so much, and they were just a touch soft (something you can work with, but disappointing) and I didn't know if they were 56 or 58 or what, and Rob has confirmed with multiples of them that they are about 57/58. I knew from a previous versitron test on a defective witherby that they were a lot harder than 53 - 53 is unusable.

This is the basis for my comment the other day about hardness.

I can't recall if Rob tested more than these chisels (I encouraged him to test some older chisels, but didn't want to be the donor as I don't have many that are in a condition that I'd just send them on a one-way trip - I have in the past, but have gotten rid of most of them, as well as two sets of the sorby chisels).

I see some interesting take aways from this data that I am afforded comparing only due to excessive buying and screwing around.

1) the softest japanese chisels to me, even when they are criticized (iyoroi mokume come to mind, I guessed them at 62 or so, maybe 63 - they were wonderful, but I sold them as I got a set of chisels that have geometry more to my liking) are harder than most western chisels, almost all. The off name chisels in this test (as someone who has ever had a lot of j-chisels go through their hands) show 63.5 hardness. You can easily feel this difference vs. a chisel that's 65 - it's stark if you have access to natural stones. 63 sharpens easily on a decent japanese natural stone, 65+ does not.

2) I would've pegged narex (the ones I've had, I have none now) around the same as sorby. That's about where they are. They feel like they have potential but they're two points shy of it. In my opinion, there are much better options for geometry, but they fit a price point. Sorby chisels on the other hand can be $225 for a set of five or six, as much or more than ashley iles.

3) the funmatsu chisel, I sent to Rob. I don't think he managed to flatten the back of it, but that doesn't really affect the hardness. I'd had the last 1/2 inch or so flat and sharp, which is not unusual with japanese chisels (a slightly convex back) but didn't convey that the entire back shouldn't be ground flat. The reason I sent it is because it's one of the super hard powder metal chisels that I'd gotten from stu in the past to try one. I think they would chisel a nail, but in the cycle of regular work, I preferred the less impressive iyorois mentioned above.

4) the comment at the bottom of the picture should've said "tasai". The tasai chisel had varying spots of hardness on it, thus the large SD. (I cut the comment out to save size of the picture after posting this, but the large SD is still there. I wonder if these chisels may actually be hand hardened in the open atmosphere by tasai)

It's interesting that all of the western chisels that we tend to view favorably are pretty much right at 60. Pfeil, Blue Spruce (twice), berg, ... I'm sure I could've provided a half dozen other chisels that were 60-61, and easily picked chisels that were on average 2 clicks less hard (many of the early-mid century american chisels like stanley 750s, witherbys, etc. chisels that were all the rage about a decade ago, but I never liked as much as other folks did - I think that was just a socket chisel craze that seems to have subsided because nobody is releasing new socket chisels right now and the stanley sweetheart type collectors that existed pre-internet don't really have much presence on woodworking forums).

Curious in this group is the PM V11. I would have guessed the V11 that I have is slightly less than 63 (which is the top of LV's spec, IIRC), but it has a lot of chromium in it, so it is a little less easy to tell with the washita test. I can sharpen it on a washita, but the chromium grades the stone a little bit. It was common in razors to back off hardness a little bit on stainless razors to make them more sharpenable. There's plenty of possibilities (maybe the data is incorrect here, maybe the step down in hardness is intentional for user benefit, whatever it may be). I'd love to see a couple more struck by calibrated testers (rob's using a portable tester, but it's got a calibration kit and he provides the data from the tests blocks at the beginning of each experiment that he does).

Separate and aside last comment - the marples chisel discussed is a chinese marples chisel. I was surprised to see it get some strikes around 60 and wondered if it might hold up well, but Rob did run some tests with these in soft and hard wood - paring. The tests were difficult to decipher because the chisels didn't all have the same bevel angle, so they didn't provide much information except the let down for the marples -which was that it seems to be subpar steel driven up in hardness (medium carbon? who knows), and it flaked out quickly once rob started paring hardwood.

I cannot recall the original point of the study - I think it had something to do with hardness and sharpness, but Rob is a tinkerer, and by the time he was done, there were about 140 different data summaries and he had spent huge amounts of time working various chisels full bevel in honing guides. I didn't want to bother him to try to make everything identical. The hardness data ended up being the most interesting. If I never knew it for sure, it wouldn't matter that much, but it's always nice to see numbers agreeing with your information.

I've got a huge amount of experience with older sets of chisels and plane irons and can make generalizations about those far enough to dispell the long-time myth that quality was bad and hardness was inconsistent. I can only guess that because certain makers uniformly made their chisels less hard that people with mixed sets of old chisels sometimes don't discern that if they sort them into makes, that within make, they are very consistent. I'd guess old bucks at 58/59, and old ward chisels at 61, perhaps 62 - some with some other makers like i. sorby. It sounds like a small difference, but they behave differently in use, and I've never had one from either make that crossed into the others' territory.

I can also conclude that if I were lucky enough to come up with a shop to make chisels with dies and a hydraulic press (which will never happen), I'd make them with the plainest steel I could find - 61 hardness for western chisels and two versions of japanese - 63 and 65 hardness.


Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#2

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

Neil Strong

Having tried to follow Rob's original thread, I can't say I'm any the wiser for having done so, but David's comments on hardness vs useability/sharpenability rings true to me.

An aside on his 3rd comment...

" the funmatsu chisel, I sent to Rob. I don't think he managed to flatten the back of it.... but didn't convey that the entire back shouldn't be ground flat."


Likewise, I failed to convey to Rob that the Tasai chisel I sent him for testing wouldn't need to/shouldn't have its ura (ie, the carefully constructed concave area on the back) flattened. Oh well, some people donate their bodies to science, others their best chisels!

In case you were wondering; No, I didn't pay full price for a new Tasai (currently about US$225 for the 18mm dovetail). I managed to buy it secondhand for a very good price. My opinion on Tasai chisels is that they are good, but you are paying a hefty premium for the name. There are much better value-for-money J-smiths.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#3

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

Wiley Horne

David,

Thank you for bringing this data. It’s fascinating stuff, and enough repetitions to make it credible.

I read through your anecdotes carefully, and what stood out was that the chisels you make sure are within reach, are ones picked on feel, handling, clean steel, amenable to Washita, and maybe certain intangibles (English look, f’rinstance :) ). Hardness doesn’t seem to figure very large. I wonder if those kind of practical matters are typical for most of us, as opposed to wanting a high-specification tool.

I was surprised the Tasai averaged 65+. They sharpen readily in my experience.

Got a Tasai fishtail coming in a month.

Thanks again for posting the data.

Wiley

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#4

Flattened Neil’s Tasai—-OUCH!


Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#5

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

RK near Boston

What do you think is Ashley Isles chisel hardness? Are they harder than Sorby?

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#6

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

David Weaver

Their spec is 61 and I think they're right at spec, at least my set is.

Really wonderful and much harder than sorby, but not overly hard.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#7

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

david weaver

Ahh, that was your chisel!

Rob is very determined. I think he had a method set that he was going to do and that was that.

It resulted in a less sharp chisel when he went after the M4 chisel that I sent, because he wore out before bringing the entire back into plane and scuffed up the short back that I'd polished, but I wasn't intending to get the chisel back - just confused when he said he got initial results but wasn't convinced that the chisel was as sharp as it should be (i sent it 85% of max sharpness, I'd say - beyond what someone would get on something like a King 8000 and free of any wire edge frizzies).

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#8

Re: Yes...

david weaver

..almost without question, the chisels I've bought (recently) end up falling into a narrow range. If I didn't have the luxury of trying so many (if I was one of the die hard "never buy a second set" types), I could live with the sorby chisels. But I'm glad to have gotten more and tried more.

There's one exception to my newly-realized typecast (of the English types). I do like a full hardness japanese chisel, but had been looking for a while for one that was a little less tubby in cross section. The love for the iyoroi set that I have was due to their ability to tolerate heavy mortising (no corners breaking), but I don't do as much of that, and I've found some older chisels that are equally good for it.

I'm otherwise a buyer of opportunity. If I can try something at a price that I know I can sell it for, I'll do that. It just means I'll have to take what comes along at that level rather than getting a jones for a certain maker. The unknown with that is fun, but I think I've settled (on the thinner uknown) chisels with what I like, and they don't sharpen on the washita - too hard - and that's OK. They sharpen well on japanese natural stones.

Until you mentioned that I like the English types, and until I measured chisel cross section earlier this week, I had no idea, though, that I was consistently buying almost identical chisels in proportion. If the wrought iyorois didn't have a thick cross section (something that I don't think you can avoid with wrought iron), I probably would've stuck with them. The thin chisels I found were ....well, purchases of opportunity, too, on a japanese proxy auction. Once makers aren't current, they don't seem to have any value over there, even with decent chisels....there are a few exceptions (ichichiro, shimamura, etc), but not many.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#9

If you haven’t already...

Wiley Horne

You might try a Tasai very-thin if you come across one. Push chisel. I bought a 5/8” years ago because I needed the thinness for some reason. But now, if there is just a random chisel task, I always reach for that one without thinking about it.

Wiley.......but don’t send it to the estimable Rob

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#10

Does anyone have any ability to verify numbers?

david weaver

I had access through a friend to a versitron, but he's retired and his access to hardness testing went with that.

I know that data like the data provided here gets posted, argued/discussed, never really verified independently and then disappears.

The few things that exist in this that I can corroborate are:

1) I can match experience in feel with a lot of the tools shown here (but that's perception)

2) this is the third hardness test that I've seen of lie nielsen's products. One that LN struck, one that a friend had struck, and now this one. They always come out about the same - within 1 c scale point. That and my experience with their exceptionally consistent irons makes me feel like it's pretty comfortable to assume that.

Is the blue spruce butt chisel really 65? I don't know. Is perhaps just that one 65? I don't know. What about the narex low at 55 for the mortise chisel - narex has a very tight spec. I had some parers when they first came out that were not really impressive. They were OK, but they - unfortunately - sent me quickly looking for "real" parers, which are really made any longer. Thankfully, the timing coincided with ebay opening up shipping from the UK, which brought a typical english parer down to about the cost of a narex parer.

I'm not surprised to see very tight ranges with japanese chisels. Nothing really ever beats them.

https://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

Remember this? I was reading woodnet at the time, and there was ranting and raving about a new 3V chisel that would never need to be sharpened again. I had the koyamaichi chisels that LV sold at the time and did a controlled test with one of them cutting leaves off of a maple stick, and with a couple of other chisels. It seemed to me that if you wanted to be gentle, you could pretty much make those chisels last many projects before any real sharpening. Or you could be more stiff handed and do little sharpening (my preference - cut a case of half blinds, touch up the chisel with a finish stone only without babying it and be no worse off at the end of the project).

I've gotten two email objections to the LV V11 number showing around 60 ("no way, that's an error" in nature - none from LV, of course). LV spec is 61-63. What's likely? I don't know. If someone else struck a result with a chisel in the wild, it might dispell that. I didn't sense 60 from the LV V11 tools that I had, but I also don't think they were 63. 60 would've sharpened easier - even though I'm guessing at what the steel is, it is undeniably close in feel on an oilstone or natural stone to friodur wares from decades ago. I don't know that henckels ever stated what their steel was, either, but I think it's cryogenically treated 440C. V11 is powder steel, 440C in henckels stuff is not. Henckels is a bit softer than carbon steel in their razors, but probably not be low 58/59 - the edge it takes off of a stone is very uniform given the era and the type of steel it is. Nothing else has ever felt similar to those two.

I don't think Sorby is O1 steel, we tend to lump all of the modern chisels into O1 or A2. I think it's not either, but I have no proof. I think Pfeil is not O1. I think Ashley iles *is* O1 (they say so themselves, but japan woodworker used to tell us that mujingfang tools are A2 - they are definitely not).

I'd love to see all kinds of things out of curiosity, but figured that posting this might be interesting to some folks and spark disagreement (public or otherwise - email only for me so far).

I can say this. Rob streeper is a tinkerer and toolmaker. He has honest intentions with everything that I've dealt with him on, though he's skeptical about some things, which can lead him into the groove of "i'm going to see if everyone is telling us the truth". He found a couple of soft saws from makers a few years ago and went on a serious bender that could've been more muted, but not ill intentioned. Point being, if any of these chisels were out of spec, as in if the narex mortise was really 55 - most of us would notice and say "I need to try another one". I think Rob, not being a life long hand tool woodworker will just play it as it lies.

I don't put that much stock in hardness quotes until I use a tool. It's a catalog spec to chase, but not always achieved. The Iyoroi mortise chisel that we tested that averaged 61 (that was done on a versitron, a LN chisel tested about the same with three strikes) was softer than stated, but it was a perfectly serviceable chisel. It's still the proof is in the using. I believe vintage buck chisels are almost the same hardness as sorby, but they're a little nicer to use, so the Rc number isn't the ultimate determinant. It's just a piece of data to compare to actual use.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#11

Re: If you haven’t already...

david weaver

I'll stuff that away in my money in suspense purchase list. I've always heard folks talk about the sharpenability of tasai's chisels. Rob's strikes showing less hard regions was sort of an "ah-ha! I see why!", but by no means conclusive.

...and i'm a guy who wouldn't care if parts of a chisel were 65 and parts were 63.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#12

A point about Narex

Wiley Horne

Narex’s website tells us they use austempering techniques:

http://www.narexchisels.com/Narex_Chisels/Narex_Bystrice.html

Classic austempering means that the final product is not tempered martensite (like all your other chisels)—it is bainite. They don’t quench to a low enough temperature fast enough to produce martensite. The prime characteristic of bainite is that, at a given Rc, it is tougher than martensite. But it can’t be gotten as hard as martensite. There are techniques where the quench temperature is controlled right at the borderline where martensite begins to form, and you get a bainite/martensite mix. Narex claims fine grain also.

So it may be that Narex is favoring toughness and fine grain over hardness. Do they advertise an Rc spec?

Wiley

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#13

Re: A point about Narex

david weaver

59 is generally what's printed. I remember the discussion about the process being that it allowed for minimal after-hardening finishing, and the point about the toughness, but that it had a limited top side for hardness.

The parers that I had were serviceable but had a really persistent wire edge at the hardness level and folded more than I would've expected in use.

They weren't "bad", but left me feeling like I was looking for something else. I think at the hardness level, I was expecting something more like a run of the mill vintage US socket chisel like a witherby or pexto or stanley, but they were a different feel.

the thickness of the profile and the lack of flex (which to my understanding is a matter of necessity for manufacturing processes) made them feel kind of like a long heavy chisel. They'll do the job, but the payoff wasn't there. I was looking for something almost like folks described of western parers without the very hefty price US tool dealers were charging for something like a pre-chrome marples parer, i. sorby, ward, whatever.

Hard to explain. I could see how people would like the bench chisels for the price, there was nothing really "bad" about them, and they're very reasonable, but I'm too far along to go that direction.

The persistent wire edge may have caused me to feel like my chisels were a little softer than they actually are. Just seemed like each time I pared, I'd have some edge damage that I didn't expect. Nothing major, but I crept the angle that they were set at up on the edge (and ground one of them back an eighth and then continued on) until the damage stopped and it was steeper than I wanted for a parer at that point. And, soon they were gone. Maybe the bar is a little higher with parers, too, because you can't just hit them a step harder if you have to add a few degrees to get them to hold up.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#14

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Moxon says that edge tools should be tempered to a "dark goldish colour", which I think would be about 60 Rc. (He predates the Rockwell scale by three centuries). He mentions that files and punches should be tempered to a "light goldish colour", which might be more like Rc 62.

There has certainly been a notion afloat that the harder the better for chisels and plane irons. For some tool makers, a high hardness number might be more of a marketing decision than a tool performance decision. As an example Hock plane irons are hardness 62. But when he says "The extra thickness of our blades offers superior stability, precise adjustment, and easier honing.", he seems to be playing to his customers prejudices rather than making a real performance decision. Does he really have experience using planes that informed his decision on hardness? I don't know.

All of my chisels seemed to outperform the "5 steels" mentioned above, for hickory, persimmon, and jarrah, but as you have noted, tester technique plays a big role in the outcome.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#15

Numbers are just one part of the equation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

Since you have linked to one of my articles, and Warren has commented on this as well, it seems relevant that I add my bit here.

Just in case others are not aware of the location of the original thread, and wish to read it (warning - it is long!):

http://www.woodworkforums.com/f279/chisel-hardness-study-step-216507

The thread was begun by Rob Streeper, who hails from San Antonio. His interest in woodworking to date has been building backsaws. The research on chisels was to guide his proposed venture into making chisels. That was 2 years ago. As far as I know, all has remained theoretical. Rob is a nice guy. I believe that his background is a PhD in medical technology (so he would be familiar with research methodology), but my memory may be faulty.

Early on (post #9), I asked:

Why is hardness relevant? Can you explain this?

Have you taken into account steel composition, and the manufacturers recommendation in this regard? Blue Spruce is A2, and some of the others variations of O1. I am not sure what Pfiel are?


Rob replied:

Hi Derek,

Why? Because it's there of course.

The purpose of this effort is to determine the hardness of the chisels that have gone before is relevant in that the results of my analyses will hopefully guide how I will make my chisels. My perception is that hardness is important, but how hard is best is unclear to me. Other processes will also be considered in due time.

Steel composition influences hardenability, toughness, and wear resistance, subjects I hope to address in the future insofar as they are relevant to woodworking tools. The openly available literature in this area is scant. I'm sure that the companies that make industrial tooling have done a lot of work to understand these factors but none of it is available to me.

Regards,

Rob

I did not consider this to be an adequate response (as the thread did not appear to be aiming to include these aspects), but by then any further response would have been seen as argumentative, so I left alone. My view remains that there is much more to steel in chisel (and plane) blades than hardness - which is the point that must be made for our own discussion. Chisels are struck (impact resistance) and used for paring (abrasion resistance). This is why I did separate test for each ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselParing.html

The results of the two tests were interesting in that they demonstrated that the wear in chopping and paring is so different with the same tool steels. Abrasion resistance and impact resistance place quite different demands on steel.

The thread in question has remained about hardness, and all the other ways of wearing steel have not been addressed. The same is happening in this thread, which presents hardness as a major player in steel wear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#16

Re: A factor, but not the factor

david weaver

...Probably long after most folks fell off of that thread, Rob rehardened or had rehardened four of the common yellow handled buck chisels sold at the orange borg here. Anyone who has picked them up knows that they're:

1) not a weight and geometry that we'd want to use for much cabinetmaking

2) they're a little soft, but uniform and reasonably good quality

Rob wanted to see what would happen they were stepped up into ranges and found that the chisels still didn't really measure up. We don't know what they're made of, but they gave up the ghost when they were driven too high.

That's hardly a surprise, but it's nice to see it confirmed.

The chinese marples chisels were another one. I suspect that if this test were run by 10 people, the chinese marples may still be in the 60 range, but the Blue Spruce butt chisel would not be 65 and the V11 chisel will be something between 61 and 63. Looking at that chart and relying on hardness, we'd assume that the marples and V11 might be similar, but buried in Rob's commentary was that the marples pretty much gave up in hardwoods and didn't live up to its hardness spec.

I don't expect that the data list is perfect, but few people offer to do anything like this. I also wasn't in on the early part and though Rob may have said it between my posts, I either forgot or don't remember reading his comments about hoping to make chisels. I think a lot of people hope to make chisels, but as our discussion went on the other side of this forum, to be a small maker and make chisels - especially if you think you'll make a bench chisel that is more of a classic form and covers all basis, is pretty much a mountain that won't be climbed by small makers for a reasonable level.

That aside, I expect that the measurements that look anomalous would tend toward something less so if 20 people did this test, it's different than a use-test, but it does show me something interesting. The measurements that don't appear to be suspect end up in a pretty narrow range for what we consider to be "good" western chisels and then the second band of measurements for japanese chisels.

(it could very well be, too, that there's some aspect to the tasai chisel that made striking it difficult, and maybe the 62-67 strikes that Rob got off of it really are just areas that are much more uniform - one never knows).

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#17

70s stanley irons...

david weaver

It wasn't until a couple of years ago that I managed to land a stanley plane made in the 1970s. It had an iron that I could tolerate if I had to, but one that would've been below the 58 guesstimate of lower limit tolerability to me. It is still the only stanley iron that I've ever gotten that would make me believe there is some credibility to claims from Hock, and I know David Charlesworth often talks about a 70s iron that he has.

But those irons are a poor indicator of standard bench plane irons, because they're the worst there was, and I get the sense that a lot of the praise of hock's irons comes from two things:

1) poorly set up or maintained irons in older planes

2) comparing a rounded top stanley iron to a new hock iron and determining the former to be representative of stanley irons

Moxon's point about colors agrees with what George used to say, he likes to temper irons to a darker straw so that they have no chippiness tendencies.

Ron Hock had made the comment in a blog or reply at one point that if you see tempering colors on an iron when grinding, it's already ruined. You know enough about something like that, just as i do, to realize that you (I know you don't use a power grinder) would just take a tool and use it if you saw something like that.

My own O1 irons, which are just made from good stock, hold up better than the hocks. I generally temper them to light straw, but they would be fine a little bit darker. I could just be lucky so far, but I think the issue isn't me (I'm not a magic maker with the midas touch) - I think it's the stock that I'm using, and I think light straw is the point where an iron will hold up longest without failing funny.

I came to all of those things by use, though - you're probably more aware of it than anyone because I used to argue with you about all kinds of stuff while I was satisfying my curiosity. And now I'm back to the "boring" viewpoint of:

1) there's not much magic out there to be found beyond what professional incremental improvement provided

2) if you want the holy grail of really hard steel in chisels and plane irons that will really hold up, skip all of the alloying and just get japanese tools

3) the context of use and the user will tell the quality of the tool. The result in this case is that regardless of data, people with lots of experience tend to settle into one of the things that resulted from incremental improvement. Be it western or Japanese, the established lanes are the most reliable.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#18

Age and failing memory...

david weaver

Now that I'm past the age of 40, all of the sudden, it seems like things trickle back instead of coming back (but after skimming parts of that 44 page thread, I can't afford the time to read it and see what I may have said back then...)

What vaguely trickles back, though is that I recall seeing if I could "con" rob into trying to make something the equal of vintage tools.

So my comment about not being aware of what his motives were may not be accurate - not intentionally inaccurate. In the fog is a combination spatial-ish feeling of:

1) telling him not to run a bunch of tests and stab a magic steel in a handle referring to his tests to prove it is best

2) pointing everyone toward the older tools and suggesting that many of the comments of their inconsistency within brand are really inaccurate.

I vaguely recall advocating for someone making vintage-ish chisels again, but that's not ever going to happen. Even making oil hardening chisels in the shape of a vintage chisel takes too much skilled labor, and not precise machine.

Which falls back toward Ashley Iles still being the best proportion, composition and execution of something similar.

Now, if someone ever developed an interest in diemaking and die-forging (or die-pressing like i understand Koyamaichi does) as a hobbyist, there might be a chance. But one that wouldn't last long.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#19

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

Neil Strong

Yes, David, and in the case of my Tasai that had been taken close to #20,000 on my best Nakayama natural stone before I sent it off. But, it may not have looked highly polished to anyone not familiar with Japanese chisels off natural stones, which leave a fine misty surface.

The ura also went up close to the cutting edge (as well maintained J-chisel should) and this perhaps was an issue for the testing method.

The variability in hardness with that chisel may have come from testing sites that were at different levels below the original treatment surface. I'm very familiar with that effect when using new turning gouges; I suspend judgement until I've ground away a bit off the end.

Anyway, I perhaps should not have assumed some knowledge of J-tools and their peculiar ways... :~}

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#20

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

David Weaver

My very first set had convex backs like that and I'll admit that I ground a good part of them flat.

I can't recall if yours came back to you. I told rob I didn't want the m4 chisel back. I keep at least one has chisel around to trim or scrape the junction of wood and metal when making infill, but any inexpensive hss chisel is fine for that.

Still, I appreciate rob's efforts, even though the thread got a bit disjointed and it would be nice to have someone else see if they could duplicate some of the results.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#21

results have been repeated countless times

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Still, I appreciate rob's efforts, even though the thread got a bit disjointed and it would be nice to have someone else see if they could duplicate some of the results. "

Narex and Lee Valley have measured the hardness of their product, likely thousands of times, and have published the result as a specification for their product. As clearly stated, LV has confirmed to me, and anyone else that doubts my report and chooses to contact them, their specification is met in every heat treat batch. I have no doubt whoever Blue Spruce uses for heat treat does replicate measurements on every heat treat batch , as this quality control is standard for the heat treaters I know about.

I believe the reliability of the data in the Table has been discussed sufficient for bystanders to judge for themselves what data to believe. 'Nuff said on this topic.......

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#22

From 30,000 feet

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

A fellow named Rob, advanced degrees in science/engineering, did some homebrew testing. Nothing amiss so far (except for erasing the hollow in Neil’s Tasai chisel). His results were published far away. Then David republished them here. Again, no harm, no foul.

So far, we have,

1. Amateur testing done for the usual reason (curiosity).

2. Results make circuitous route to Woodcentral Hand Tools.

Skies still blue. Then, 1 millisecond after the OP gets read,

3. Hand Tools’ mosh pit brand of talk begins. Excerpting from memory...Rob showed 3 orders of magnitude too much precision (plus some other calumny); LV chisel is out of spec, hell no it ain’t; who knew Narex chisels were so soft, no they ain’t either......etc etc, right up to the present.

Opinion: Bill’s right. The chances are vanishingly small that a random LV chisel found in the wild is off-spec. Rob never said it was—he just printed his method and his number.

So: Who will be the next brave soul to venture something? Seems to me, tinkering is a good thing, and data is a good thing provided only that we know the conditions of measurement, and man-named-Rob did not set out to unmask off-spec chisels.

Personally, I approve of the intrepid folk who do stuff, for whatever reason, and tell us about it. People who do metallurgy with cheap gear, people who measure planing forces with amateur set-ups, people who make chisels and plane blades from CPM-3V and catch hell for it. It’s all good!

Wiley

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#23

Re: results have been repeated countless times

David weaver

Bill, you're lost in thinking nobody else can reason or is allowed to have a different opinion.

You're free to disregard my posts. I'd prefer that over extrapolation.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#24

we're on the same flight!

David weaver

I'm hoping the destination is somewhere with English pattern chisels skillfully made of plain carbon steel ...

...and vending machines dispensing free Collings guitars.

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

#25

Re: Hardness Data for Chisels

TomD

I have some extremely high quality Japanese chisels, and some of them had to be ground until parts of the hollow were flat, just because that is what had to happen. It is not that unusual in my experience, though I have no idea what happened here. But just before we start more myths...