Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Kitchen cabinet molding

Posts

Kitchen cabinet molding

#1

Kitchen cabinet molding

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

I have a bank of kitchen cabinets, with doors needing replacing. Too many coats of chipped paint, and easier to remake than strip and detail the originals.

The job is actually easy. Flat panel doors. But I’m hung up on one detail: the moldings which set off the panels. It’s applied, not integral.

Here is a rough drawing of the mold:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48003578642/in/dateposted-public/

As you can see, it’s simple in concept. But I’m stumped on how to make it. And I don’t find this mold available for sale—I would buy it in a heartbeat.

This mold must have been standard millwork out here around 1900, when this house was built. Those were early days for this part of the world; lots of early settlers from Arkansas and thereabouts I’m told.

Two questions for you:

1. Is this mold or similar available for purchase?

2. If not, how would you make it, or approximate it? For example, I’m thinking of making the inside face an ogee.

Thanks for any thoughts, notions, suggestions......

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#2

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

Jim Matthews

This is a job for molding planes.

Once the stock is ripped, a card scraper could manage the shallow RH relief.

Follow with a broad hollow across the top and miter to fit.

If it's to be painted, relieve the RH profile with a large diameter dowel and sandpaper, glue on an appropriately wide rip from a round dowel.

http://musingsfrombigpink.blogspot.com/2018/12/making-another-picture-frame-with.html

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#3

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sometimes it is a bit awkward to reproduce machine moldings by hand and vice versa. I have sometimes been given a job making moldings for guys who own expensive molding machines and machines to make cutters, just because the design lent itself to hand work. In addition, for something like this I think making a stuck molding (as an integral part of the frame) would be easier.

A small ogee plane could make the right hand side of your molding. (I tried to see if the smaller ogee plane you show would be small enough.) And then a small hollow plane for the left hand side. Or you could make a rabbet on the right side and follow with small round plane and hollow plane.

Another method in hardwood would be to use a scratch stock, maybe with two different profiles.I think this would work well for an integral molding.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#4

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

david weaver

I have done far less of this than warren, but trying to find that profile online would cause me anxiety and anger. I've struck anything like that, but also agree with warren that making it part of the door rail would be easier because if you're doing it by hand, cutting it off of other stock and skimming the back of it with a plane upside down in a vise is just an extra step.

Whether the moulding is left on the edge of sticking and sawn off or done as part of a door part integrally, I'd do the following:

1) Plane a large facet off of the right side of the picture (over the cove) leaving only the hollow work to complete.

2) cut the bottom part of the curve (where it's tighter radius) with a short radius H&R

3) cut the remainder of the curve above with a wider radius H&R

It may be helpful to plow or scratch a small groove at the center of each cut.

That would leave some waste at the edges of the curves that I'd just plane off, inside the curve by scooting the larger radius H&R over for the final cuts, and on the outside curves any way you'd like.

The radius around the top/end of the moulding, you can do however it pleases you. I have better luck if I facet those areas first and then cut, then I can see the facets are even (and thus both ends of the moulding will match reasonably well) and do minimal work cleaning up the curve.

An alternative option is to make an open sided plane with that profile on the bottom and an iron to match. It would probably take an hour or two to make the plane and matching iron, but it would cut the cove in one pass.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#5

Re: Offer to make an open sided plane..

david weaver

Wiley -my next couple of weeks are busy, but if this is something that can wait a month, I'd be glad to build you a fenced open-sided plane that would cut the broad part of this profile.

It would be ugly, but you wouldn't be able to complain much about the price and it would kind of just cut the moulding for you without much thought, leaving only the rounded top, which could literally be done with a bench plane and sandpaper.

Warren's bringing up of open mortise purpose-made planes years ago sort of sprung me into making a whole bunch of ugly single purpose planes. they're usually made mid-process, really quick to make, cost nothing (they're scrap) and they work an absolute treat because they only do one thing.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#6

Re: Offer to make an open sided plane..

Wiley Horne

David,

That’s an over-the-top gracious offer. Let me work a little further...I have started with Warren’s thought of using an ogee to work the profile side. Proof of concept shown just below in separate post.

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#7

First stab or two

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

Thank you for the considered suggestions. I have started with Warren’s thought of using an ogee to do the profile side. I tried a little bitty one, marked 5/16”, and also the 1/2” that Warren spoke about.

Here’s the results in pine. Just trying to get proof of concept at this point. First photo is the drawing; second is the 5/16” ogee profile; third is the 1/2” ogee profile; last is the glass panel my sister is working on that will be surrounded by this mold—there’ll be two of them side by side:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157708940252281

The only dicey part of this is finding a registration point for the ogee. What I did was to start with a 1/4” bead to get the top (round profile) started. Then register the ovolo part of the ogee to that curve, and gradually sink the cove part of the ogee, rotating the plane to keep working the cove deeper and lower.

Judgment: I’m encouraged this will work. Will try it in oak next. And maybe look for a 5/16” bead for the top round profile. But I can live with the 1/2” ogee version right now, using the bead I’ve got. The glass will be the point of interest.

Will report back with the oak version (Borg doesn’t carry maple anymore).

Thanks again. Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#8

Re: First stab or two

david weaver

Looks pretty good. It's an interesting problem to get that a little taller and flatter (angle wise vs. the face of the board) and still get some registration.

The bead for registration could be set into the top of the board (with the board left a little bit thick) so that you have it at the bottom of the cut for the final passes, and then plane off the additional thickness (and bead) with it.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#9

Re: First stab or two

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

I hear ya about the angles. But I believe the fix will be to find a slightly wider bead—a 5/16” likely. Or some other plane with similar ovolo part. I can’t really get the profile side right without widening the top bead. Maybe that’s what you are saying!

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#10

Re: First stab or two

david weaver

Yes, though I may be understanding it differently than you're doing it. Flattening it out (widening it) and giving yourself as good of a reference as possible for ease is what I'd be aiming for.

Is some of the other moulding remaining in the kitchen to compare it to visually? Sorry if I missed that. My standards in my own space would become a lot more lax if there was nothing of the original around to compare to.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#11

Re: First stab or two

Wiley Horne

“is any other molding of the same type to remain?”

No, I’m replacing all of this type. So it doesn’t have to be a dead replica. I just need to be able to replicate my own hack, so it’ll all look alike.

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#12

Fewer iterations are preferred

Jim Matthews

Matt Bickford always recommended using the least number of planes, for consistency. If you can get close with multiple passes, in one plane - that's ideal.

Your sample molding looks clean, will it take paint?

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#13

Re: Fewer iterations are preferred

Wiley Horne

Jim,

That’s an interesting idea. I thought about whether the whole thing could be cut with one ogee, simply by starting the plane at about 2 o’clock, then progressively working it around counterclockwise to about 9:30. That would produce a profile, but not this one (it might be better!). An ogee that would make the ovolo right would have too long a cove section.

I hadn’t thought the thing very far through until you raised the question. What I am trying to do to make the mold reproducible is to focus on having a positive registration for the first plane, and then use the first plane to create registration for the second. If the registrations are not positive, then you get into a pattern of adjusting your adjustment, and trying to hold your mouth just right, and so forth.

As for paint, the only thing I see necessary is to run 220g sandpaper down that arris at the tail end of the cove. Just a couple of licks. In other words, make sure that arris is deburred.

A bigger challenge will be reproducing this in oak. Pine doesn’t put up much of a fight, but I am worried the initial passes of the ogee may skate a little in oak—that may be a problem to be solved.

But its looking doable. I ordered a 5/16 and 3/8 bead today—one of those two should help. Thanks to Warren for spotting that 1/2 ogee as a possible solution.

And thanks to all for the several good suggestions, any of which could be made to work.

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#14

Making moldings

Jim Matthews

In the classroom setting, only the straightest Poplar was used.

I missed if this will be painted or finished clear.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#15

Re: Making moldings

david weaver

That would be my choice for paint. It's not really a nice wood compared to good clear perfectly straight pine, but it sure is easier to find in straight pieces.

But, either will be soft. Our borg has never carried maple even though maple (other than western types) is common around here. Their poplar is often extremely light, too, but some of the local sawyers have poplar that is just below cherry in density and with better color.

Finding good wood to make mouldings (in general) is a challenge unless you have a lot to pick through or can get a slab to saw the blanks out of. Cutting these out of oak may be trouble.

My offer still stands for wiley - if oak is the choice, I could make an open mortise plane with a relatively heavy blade set at 60 degrees. But I must admit, I would want to do it myself with what I have as wiley is doing, it's more interesting, and the stimulation of trying things is ...well, stimulating.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#16

Re: Making moldings

Wiley Horne

Jim and David,

Yes, it will be painted. Thanks for the information on poplar, which my Home Depot has a huge pile of. I’ll try that.

And David, this is a chance for me to prove that having a drawerful of unused molding planes was actually a far-sighted and very wise investment :) . That’s my story and I’m sticking to it.

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#17

Dredging the canal of my memory

Jim Matthews

My memory isn't reliable.

I recall Matt Bickford saying that for beginning students, stock choice was easily as important as setting the plane properly. Buy half again more linear feet than you need to account for stock twisting, inclusions or accidental damage.

Shavings should make a sound like ripping cotton tee shirts in half.

It's NOT the same as a finish plane, and close to what a scrub plane sounds like.

I wish I could be more specific, but there's no substitute for experience.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#18

Re:zzzzzzzzzzzzzziiiipppp

David Weaver

That zip sound is the sound of a plane chattering through the cut. Common on moulding planes and wooden planes where the wedge isn't fit well.

a topic for another day is that I think that zip sound can be the same or less labor in a heavy cut in some cases, not all, but it doesn't yield a good surface.

I'd imagine that someone doing moulding work professionally, if any such thing would happen these days, would spend quite a bit of time finding straight nice working wood as it's always nice to strike long mouldings and then cut them. But they can only be done smoothly if the whole length of wood is clear and agreeable.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#19

Re: Dredging the canal of my memory

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For things like this we like to use one stick of molding for every door. That way if the molding varies slightly from end to end, three of the joints will be rather nice because they came from very near each other in the run, and you will have to doctor at most one joint. So for example if you are making four doors and each needs 60 inches of molding, make four pieces of molding 62 long or so. Don't make three 80 inch pieces or five 50 inch pieces and force yourself to mix.

It is nice to have near perfect stock for moldings, not that we cannot tolerate oddities in the grain so much as they take time and aggravation. And mark your stock with arrows to show which direction you want to plane each side and edge, then orient the stock so you are always planing in a favorable direction

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#20

Re:zzzzzzzzzzzzzziiiipppp

Jim Matthews

Finish quality on moldings -

I remember a quick sanding pass with 220 grit prior to shellac.

Too heavy cut and the shaving jammed.

A proper pass made a distinct zipping sound, ejecting a long curled shaving.

It's important to note that MB's approach does far more than half the cutting with a rabbet plane - hollows and rounds register on the flats a rabbet leaves.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#21

Re:zzzzzzzzzzzzzziiiipppp

Jim Matthews

Finish quality on moldings -

I remember a quick sanding pass with 220 grit prior to shellac.

Too heavy cut and the shaving jammed.

A proper pass made a distinct zipping sound, ejecting a long curled shaving.

It's important to note that MB's approach does far more than half the cutting with a rabbet plane - hollows and rounds register on the flats and ledges left by the rabbet.

I found the process tedious.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#22

Re: Dredging the canal of my memory

Wiley Horne

Warren, Jim, David, and all,

Thanks for the help—it’s very useful. I did go get some poplar and soft maple today; should work easier than red oak. I find the sound varies with the thickness of shaving, but at about a 2-thou shaving makes a singing sound like a wooden bench plane. If there is chatter due to wedge letting blade vibrate, or just too heavy a cut, it’s a lower gutteral sound—my experience anyway.

By the way, Warren, that was a great observation from Moxon—I had read right over that part without thinking what it meant.

Right now I’m going to start remaking two cabinet door frames. It’s a retrofit, so one of the door openings is square, and the other one is about 1/8” out of square—the face frame itself. The way I intend to deal with this is make the door frame a little oversized, and then plane the edges back to get a fit. That’s apparently what the original trim carpenter did 100+ years ago, because he made a dead fit, with out of square corners. You can track how the frame width tapers end to end, showing that he planed it to fit the opening. And the door is sturdy too—I thought about trying to strip it and save it, but it will be way harder to salvage than to remake.

All suggestions, stories, comments, jibes, and so forth—much appreciated.

Wiley

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#23

Re: Dredging the canal of my memory

david weaver

Yes on the shaving thickness - no stability issues or zzzzzzzziiippp at 2 thousandths.

I have gotten into it only cutting small trim mouldings for the house (meaning, in a hurry). Anything else, as Jim says, there's usually little left for the final plane to do and no real reason to rush a heavy cut.

The curiosity of the zipper sound and whether or not its detrimental for other planes in non show areas (like taking a heavy cut with a moving fillister...), maybe for another topic or not at all. When a bench plane does it, it can be a lot more obnoxious because while it may not be detrimental in a moderate cut (the iron never really comes out of the cut, it never is harder to push and it doesn't really leave any surface issues that aren't removed in subsequent planing), it is extremely loud sometimes.

When I'm fitting a bench plane, it's not uncommon for that zipper sound to be there, sometimes horribly loud, on the first go around - when the fitting is done, there should be none of it. A well-fitted wooden bench plane can stand you still in a heavy cut before it will do that, but I'm not sure it ever goes away in less supported planes in a heavy cut.

Not sure how common sanding mouldings is, if I use poor quality wood and just something for the house (poor for mouldings, not poor for anything else), I'm not afraid to sand and burnish those. Years ago, I made a bookcase out of low quality cherry being sold for a song at rockler, and sanded the mouldings (clear finish), though, without burnishing them after planing/scraping/burnishing the rest of the case and I could see the dullness of the mouldings >( On paint, it won't matter, and maybe sanding is better. It does solve some wood issues in that finding perfect wood is difficult, and just as I will pull pieces or slabs that will yield guitar necks, if I cut mouldings on a regular basis, I would be on constant lookout for pieces that would make nice mouldings and set them aside for it.

(it is so nice to not go looking for router bits or commercial moulding fits/approximations at this point, though)

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#24

Prepping for paint

Jim Matthews

We sanded the moldings to prep the surface for paint.

Straight off the iron, the surface saw often too smooth for paint to adhere properly on the sloping sections. It also knocked off corners that were sharp enough to cut us.

Re: Kitchen cabinet molding

#25

Real World

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have made thousands of moldings with molding planes over the last forty years. None have been sanded. Sharp moldings that were painted decades ago still look plenty sharp today.

With molding planes, short lengths of custom molding can be made for very little if the worker has experience. A six head molder is very nice if you're making 2000 feet of stuff, and I have friends and colleagues who do this kind of work. But for small runs the set up time is a deal breaker.