Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Heatless burrs for dremel?

Posts

Heatless burrs for dremel?

#1

Heatless burrs for dremel?

Wiley Horne

Hi all,

I seem to recall someone, maybe Larry Williams, talking about heatless grinding/polishing burrs for dremel, foredom, etc. To be used for grinding

or sharpening molding plane irons.

Did I dream that, or is there such a thing?

Wiley

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#2

There was a abrasive bit style

Chuck Nickerson

either Larry or Don preferred; I think it's called createx or similar.

It's been quite a while since I bought some because they're long-lasting for a hobbyist.

The abrasive particles are imbedded in a rubber matrix which is available in different hardnesses.

If it's important they can also be shaped.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#3

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

david weaver

In larry's video, IIRC, he uses the (conical) shaped stones on a foredom to grind hollow planes.

I don't remember if they were pink surface grinding type abrasive or if they were something else.

I have used the cheap versions of those from harbor freight and other places without issue in a drill press (freehand) at relatively low speed.

It's one of those things where you do it when you have to and that's it as even with that type of fixture, the stone can run away from you and round over the corner of an iron.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#4

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We use slip stones for sharpening moulding planes.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#5

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

david weaver

Yes on planes that are in shape, though it doesn't really hurt to use a conical to chase back a bevel that's gotten too steep.

I'm sure larry's preference has to do with manufacturing irons and needing to put the initial bevel on them.

My use of the conicals was related to refurbishing planes that were out of use and irons that either weren't in good shape or that may not have been for the plane they were in but were just stashed together by a dealer.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I haven't had to use a grinder on any planes since that initial work, but I wouldn't want to buy a set of auctioned planes and not use conicals or some kind of grinder. I would assume that 100 years ago, someone may have annealed the irons, filed them to the right size and rehardened them, but that's not always a great idea.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#6

The lens that we all view through...

david weaver

I recall Larry's insistence on single iron planes and when I was working through using the double iron (which to me was not intended to just be some planing, but a life change - learning something that would actually allow me to work mostly or completely by hand without just making it some little novelty where I make boxes or guitars - but articles like kitchen cabinets and doors if I want to do them by hand.

I just couldn't figure out how someone wouldn't get the whistling sh*ts of trying to dimension wood with single iron planes. It gets old in a hurry, and I had a selection of single iron planes that was pretty dandy.

I watched larry's excellent video on making side escapement planes since then. He skews a 55 degree smoother to get it to plane a plane blank. The plane blank is the key - you can tolerate that kind of faffing if you don't have a pile of a half dozen door parts and panels to work around, or you aren't planing around the corner on a door frame.

What larry does in the video isn't how he works day by day, his work is a lot more automated. I'm sure he has a process for grinding and setting the bevel on new irons. I'm not a customer of his, but imagine that planes show up practically ready to be used.

Once I start using any of my H&Rs, however much or little one will be used, I do as little as I can to grind anything. I don't know if they'll ever need to see anything other than slips for the hollows and other profile planes with inside profiles or bench stones for the rounds.

I'm glad that I didn't waste the money on a foredom system, because I wouldn't use it to carve (maybe it would be worth the money then), and the cones, I've used a little bit, but for the sake of not rolling past the edge of an iron, I'd prefer a file.

Nevertheless, someone who is buying (used) or making planes will probably feel at first like they're really in need of finding a fast way to grind plane irons, and use conicals. But after that, unless you're a glutton for punishment, you'll probably baby the planes and rarely grind them again unless there's an issue.

This lens is probably what causes half or more of the arguments on the internet, I'd guess. The other half being people who don't know what lens to even look through, but who want to be in the discussion, anyway.

The saw jointing debate brought up the same thing - I couldn't imagine jointing saws all the time, but if I had a business sharpening old saws or resharpening saws for rough users, maybe that's necessary. I'd hate to do that day to day. Most people would hate to use hand tools for more than just novelty things.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#7

Re: The lens that we all view through...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here are Roubo's stones for sharpening moulding planes.


These are water stone slips that are wedged into slots. There is a well in the center of the board for water. Roubo used water stones for coarse work, oil stones for polishing. Slips that are fixed to the bench like this are more efficient.

There are lots of instances like this, of people who have little experience with traditional work assuming that they know all about it. I read a fellow this morning who said cauls have been used on panel gluing for thousands of years. It did not occur to him that they used hot hide glue and would not have had time for the elaborate set up he imagined.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#8

Thanks for that image but I

Chuck Nickerson

can't enlarge it to get a better view. Do you have a plate # for it?

I have the book of Roubo plates by LAP.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#9

Re:duplicate post


Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#10

Re: Thanks for that image but I *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The slip stones are shown at the bottom of Plate 19. I wasn't able to load the best picture I have.

You can see the wedges quite clearly, but the stones less so. It appears the various stones might have different widths or different curvatures, or even a knife edge. The text says the well is two or three inches square.


Some Roubo plates

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#11

Re: I'm not sure if I'm being referred to ..

david weaver

... as the person who knows little about what I'm talking about, but if I am, so be it.

I settled onto slips as the way to sharpen mine, also - but out of laziness. they work without creating unnecessary additional work.

But I have made enough planes and refurbished enough to know that the conicals are useful for that, and worth the money if someone already has a machine to use them in.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#12

Re: I'm not sure if I'm being referred to ..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

No, I was not talking about you, David.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#13

Re: sometimes...

david weaver

sometimes, I'm that guy!!!

I still refer to what was done 250 years ago, though, when someone says they think they've "engineered" a better way to do something.

Just not very good at reading about it before needing to look it up because I'm sure that my way must be more difficult than someone figured out in the appropriate era.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#14

Re: The lens that we all view through...

Sgian Dubh

"I read a fellow this morning who said cauls have been used on panel gluing for thousands of years. It did not occur to him that they used hot hide glue and would not have had time for the elaborate set up he imagined.

That's interesting, Warren. I won't claim that cauls have been used for thousands of years, which I agree with you is probably no more than poorly informed speculation on whoever said that, but I do know that cauls have been used for veneering large surfaces with hide glue for at least two or three centuries. I used to work in a workshop in Edinburgh, in business since the first decade of the nineteenth century, where they had an old set up that at one time was used reasonably regularly for that purpose, i.e., very large open fireplace at either end of the workshop, and some original curved cauls, some dating back to the 1800s stored in the basement. There was a mass of stuff in that darned basement, including some massive four or five foot wide pieces of Cuban mahogany that had been in stock for more than 100 years. I've no idea why the company had never found a purpose for such material, but there it is.

As far as I recall the procedure as described to me by old timers that had worked there for decades (probably going back to the 1930s or 40s) was, briefly: heat the caul, ground and veneer in front of the fire(s) until all were warm, slap the glue on to the ground, lay the prepared veneer down on the ground, put some sort of barrier layer down (maybe greaseproof paper or similar[?]), put the hot caul over the top, and clamp it all tight with handscrews or alternative cramps, e.g., G clamps, sash cramps, or whatever was to hand.

I must admit I'd have really liked to see the job done for real, but it never occurred in my time working there. Sadly, that business closed down for ever in the early 2000s or perhaps the late 1990s - I can't recall for certain. Slainte.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#15

Re: The lens that we all view through...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, the use of cauls for gluing veneer and such does date at least 200 years. What does not make sense in historic times is cauls for gluing up panels.

I was just giving that as an example of someone whose "lens" was very much in the machine technology.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#16

Hah!

John in NM

Heatless? Might as well think there is perpetual motion :D

Best course for low heat is a friable burr, just like with a grinding wheel - high speed and friable.

If Cratex was recommended, I would bet its because they give an acceptable balance between cutting speed (fine though they are) and low heat due to their typical low speed use. They are an excellent product, though less aggressive than a typical hard stone bit. If your shape is formed and you just need to refine an edge, Cratex is a good thing to try. If you're going to shape a bevel, they will probably overheat it from having to linger too long to get the job done.

Disclaimer - I've mostly used Cratex wheels shaping and polishing non-ferrous metals like silver and brass. Just extending what I recall of their behavior to ferrous application.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#17

Re: Hah!

Wiley Horne

So right, John. Heat, time, and entropy all products of motion.

Thanks to you and Chuck for identifying Cratex, and to you for an evaluation. Folks here make even a dremel thread worthwhile—thinking about Warren’s Roubo reference on slips.

I feel like I need to apologize profusely and deliver a credible explanation of why I even own a dremel, let alone talk about it on a hand tool forum. Trouble is, the explanation is even more embarrassing than the dremel itself! So I’ll spare us. I will say that the dremel is a perfectly unsatifying tool, esp. the low-end one I bought. But it will grind away solder from leaded glass joints that sit too high. So there's that.

Now here’s a proper tool, that has been sitting in a drawer too long:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157678293590307

Marked ‘Hayes, Liverpool’, or maybe Mayes (first letter is dinged up). I’m calling it a cove-fillet-ovolo, and if anyone knows the right term, they can set me straight. Marked with a ‘6’. Plane is in sound shape, pretty crisp. But the cove-maker part sits too high relative to the ovolo-maker. Cannot be adjusted to cut evenly across the profile. Cove-maker needs to be ground down a 64th or maybe two 64ths, we’ll see. Haven’t scribed it yet. So I wuz thinkin maybe the dremel, plus a wheel that makes no heat. None. Well, the group advice so far is (a) no dremel, grind on a slip or file it, and (b) the cratex will heat it up by golly, if you try to grind! I guess I like filing plus polish with Dremel. So far.

But then here is another thing: How do you even use this plane? I like the profile, and have another similar that has a Jo. Fuller look but the marks are missing. But how do you orient the plane to the stick, when you go to make the profile? Can someone explain?

Wiley

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#18

Dremels

John in NM

I moved on to Foredom tools long ago, after burning up several Dremels with heavy use. While I find even the top end Dremel unsatisfying to use, they do certainly fill a niche - a relatively inexpensive means of spinning a burr or bit under occasional to rare use. If you only pull it out of a drawer 1-2 times a year, its probably the best choice to own.

To polish a molding blade filed down to the scribe, a Dremel and Cratex would be just the ticket. Slips are good too, and don't require safety glasses :D As with any job, there's a number of perfectly satisfactory ways of doing it.

Looks like a nice profile, I have a bolection a bit like that - looks like it cuts square on the edge instead of sprung?

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#19

Spring line

Wiley Horne

John and all,

Thanks for the further info on cratex.

I have added a couple more photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157678293590307/with/40910604613/

In the second photo you can see the spring line—there is a horizontal meeting line also, but not sure you can make that out.

The third photo adds some scale. The total width of profile is a bit over 1”, say, 1-1/16”. It’s pretty deep too. Which makes me think that the work might be pre-rebated with other planes before applying this one. If you did the roughing and final profile with this plane, you’d have to move a lot of wood, and have to sharpen before the final passes. How did they do it in the old days? Or even now?

Wiley

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#20

Re: Spring line

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The iron looks to be in very good shape; I would sharpen it with slip stones and a triangular or square slips for the fillet. I was going to ask if it had a spring to it because you can see the slope on the fillet is otherwise a bit crooked.

We usually rough out the moulding a bit with a moving fillister (maybe two settings) and then flatten the place where the cove is to be with a jack plane. Also round the bead somewhat with the jack plane. Sometimes we rough out the cove a little with a firmer gouge. This roughing out makes so that not only do you have less depth to plane, but it is less tiring because you are not planing the full width until near the end. Because of the spring you are not planing much more than 1/4 inch in depth.

This would make a nice moulding for the bottom of a chair rail or top of a base board or along the side of a stairs. I don't think there would be any problem planing a whole room's worth of moulding or more on one sharpening.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#21

Re: Spring line

Wiley Horne

Thanks Warren,

I did what you said using just a stick of pine. Roughing with a fillister and bench plane. Adjusted and sharpened the iron.

It really does make a beautiful profile. There’s one problem left—shavings pile up on the face of the cove section very quickly. Need to get in there with a float, and after that will show what the plane produces. Really is a handsome profile.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#22

Re: Roubo Plate 19, Figure 49 Slip Stones

William Duffield

Here is a better picture. It's the best I could do with the 100Kb limit.


I have a higher resolution image, 4.4 Mb, that I could email to anyone who wants to examine it.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#23

Re: Spring line

John in NM

It is a wonderful profile. The one I have is an un-sprung, craftsman made version that I continue to use in spite of it being a bit awkward to use. Lots of great uses for a profile like this one.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#24

Thanks to both of you!

Chuck Nickerson

I tried futzing one of my own design and didn't get it right.

The improved image shows the use of wedges, something I didn't think to try.

Re: Heatless burrs for dremel?

#25

Did what Warren said

Wiley Horne

Warren said (pretty much),

1. Rebate the work to the far side of where the fillet will be.

2. With bench plane. Shave away most of what will be wasted. Note: it turns out that holding the plane at 45degrees, you can waste from both cove and ovolo on the same stroke.

3. Put the final profile on with the molding plane—just a few passes needed.

I added 5 photos to the record to show these steps:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157678293590307

Wiley