Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

Posts

Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#1

Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

david weaver

I never bought those specific chisels, but fairly sure I had the same thing under another name. About $1.25 a chisel.

They remind me of some of the cheap guitars that I've gotten that were perfectly serviceable. I marveled at how good they were for the price, and then felt like "OK, now I'll go back to something 5 times as expensive and 25% better, because it's still 25% better".

I do like to grind little chisels like that - there's not much to lose if you need something for a purpose. If the mrs. has a use around the house that involves plaster or something abrasive, those are chisels she gets. I give them stiff treatment when she's done damaging them and they're back to usable.

But I wouldn't confuse them for the Iles chisels, or anything vintage. Not even close.

Sort of like narex. Narex chisels are good for the price. But their processes allow them to meet a price point and prevent them technically from getting one step further and being great. One with open eyes will sometimes find "great" chisels for the same price, even if they're not available every day on a "buy here - 88 in stock" link.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#2

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Aldi chisels are adequate for professional hand tool work. The are copies of the Two Cherries chisels. The steel has Chrome Vanadium printed on it, just like TC had printed maybe ten years ago. The TC chisels are heavily buffed to the point that they round over all the edges, an unfortunate situation which the Aldis have avoided. Aldis sharpen reasonably well, good edge good longevity.

Overall the chisels are about 11 inches, an ideal length. The are beech, which is one of the three common traditional handles for a chisel, and the handles are longer than LN or LV which are short. The TC handles are hornbeam and are more carefully machined and have more finish and a nice sticker.

The chisels are cheap because they are made in large quantities in large factories with good equipment. They take orders in the 1000 to 100,000 range. They don't do marketing, they don't put on exotic handles and they don't try to reinvent the chisel with goofy designs.

When you buy a LV or LN or BS chisel you are buying something for the dilettante market, but when you buy Aldis or the like (there are many brands of these Chinese chisels made in the same factory) you are buying a more serviceable chisel.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#3

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisel

david weaver

I'd imagine the lack of buffing is really a cost issue. They are stamped in dies, no clue how they're heat treated (but probably with a splash).

The harbor freight version from years ago (same proportion, same type of chisel - HF hasn't had that set for a decade that I can recall, though) is decent enough for use, but I'd rather have LV's offering given the choice. I shouldn't say that, I haven't used them. I'd rather have Ashley Iles given the choice - they're made to a spec I prefer - almost identical in hardness and balance to older chisels.

the finish level of the older chisels would fit into the dilettante market these days, though. If there is something better about the finish of modern chisels than an old ward, I haven't seen it. Actually, modern chisels are nicely finished in proportion due to the method, but the actual surface finish is less fine than an old ward.

But, as I mentioned in the long winded stuff below, it's relatively hard to find a chisel that you can't do work with if you're willing to work with the chisel and find what it likes. I found that out with a pexto or stanley chisel in cocobolo. I hadn't really written those types of chisels off for heavy work, but if you pick an angle and then demand the tool work at it, you can swing and miss. Two or three more degrees and I could mortise a cocobolo plane body, refresh with medium and fine stone, and do the same, working for a day on the same grind.

Two or three degrees two little, and the edge takes abuse and needs constant care.

Japanese chisels are the same way, except more painful to rehabilitate after they rebel.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#4

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisel

Joe shelton

My local Aldi hasn't stocked chisels when I've checked, but I may keep looking.

Breathed a sigh of relief when I recalled that I own neither LN or LV chisels; I'd rather not be a dilettante. Hope that label doesn't apply in the case of planes or saws.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#5

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisel

David Bassett

We don't have Aldi's here, but from all reports the chisels are seasonal, very limited, and usually offered just before Father's Day. If you're serious, start watching the weekly Aldi ads. (I'd guess in 3-4 weeks, if they do it at all this year.)

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#6

I tracked the set down on alibaba

david weaver

I became familiar with the tool side of alibaba years ago when woodcraft started buying stuff from china and marking it up, but you could actually see the items. They do more than just mark up (you never know what you're going to get ordering from alibaba or ali-express - I've ordered things other than tools from china and sometimes they are what the listing was, and other times, they're not, and the sellers will have a response along the lines of "it's not what you ordered, but you like it, anyway" :\ )

At any rate, the chisels that aldi is getting are either a dollar a chisel or a dollar to two dollars per set of four (with a large minimum order).

i'd imagine the seasonality of the tools has to do just with when they get a large lot and when their purchasers think they should go through the chain to retail.

FWIW, it's pretty rare for someone to buy a bulky low-value item that may be $4 with distribution costs and only mark it up to $7 or so at retail. They're doing buyers a favor.

I don't have the distaste for the chinese market that some have - I avoid buying copies and fakes, but I've had fairly good experience with other things. I did order two guitars from china last year, and one was to be a solid koa top electric guitar with a cocobolo neck and high output humbuckers. The guitar arrived with a veneer top (which is pretty much valueless), and a mahogany neck that was stained dark and then lacquered thickly to try to hide that it wasn't cocobolo. Any cocobolo trim in the sale picture was plastic on the guitar I got. The seller was dishonest about it and encouraged me to send it back (they know you won't, because it costs $130 to ship a guitar back to china, but their shipping is subsdized this way. I ultimately got a fair fraction of the price of the guitar out of the guy, cleaned it up and sold it at a slight loss)

The second guy I ordered from sold me a guitar where the high E string as just about over the neck because something got messed up in milling the neck. I took some things out of the guitar (it was cheap) and just threw it away. Any time I ask when he's providing the replacement that he promised, he always says "oh, you didn't get it yet?"

The first time I sent him a picture, he said "luthier say guitar OK - just push string toward middle of neck each time you play it".

BUT, I've gotten several high speed steel plane irons, a set of high speed steel chisels (which have superb fine steel that actually sharpens on natural stones and holds up as well as any chisel I've ever seen - the design just makes them mostly unusable) - just never chisels. All three irons are very good. They're tempered to a hardness that they're just soft enough to be easily sharpened and for high speed steel, the grain is very fine. I have confirmed that one is HSS by grinding it on an old wheel until it glowed and let it cool and it was fine. $10 each for those irons, more or less, and one style is thick enough for an LN plane (not an A2 fan) and one is the right thickness for stock stanley replacement.

I don't generally like stuff just cut out of M2, but whatever is being used for HSS over there, it's actually quite nice. The HSS chisels are a match for anything I've ever seen anywhere, including the best japanese chisels I have. But they're just stamped out of stock and their downfall is the connection from blade to handle.

I think ali's minimum order for the prices I mentioned above was 1000.

The reason I've never actually bought the aldi chisels (I like the aldi chain quite a bit, their leverage is needed here with a local monopolistic grocery player), well, I just don't need more chisels, and I've finally learned not to buy any just to satisfy curiosity.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#7

I have a set

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that I got at Aldi’s last fall. I took them home, honed the edge and tried it on some maple. The edge promptly folded. So, I let them sit there, unused, until today. After reading your post I went to look at the edge and found that the bevel is ground at about 22°. I re-honed at about 30° and found that it behaved quite well, didn’t fold or chip. The back needs all kinds of work, but they’re not bad at all. If nothing else, I’ll save them for the one neighbor I have that I wouldn’t trust with a dull cold chisel.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#8

This is them (or is it ‘they’) *LINK*

Wiley Horne

Think I’ll stick with what I got, but here’s a set. I can’t make the numbers add up on how 4 chisels got made in China, shipped to US distribution center, shipped to retailer, and sold at retail for $3 and change. Did anybody get paid?

Wiley

https://www.toolusa.com/products/tz02-17440


Aldi set at ToolsUSA

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#9

Cost of chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Back in 1790 a set of 16 chisels were worth less than a bushel of wheat. Handmade chisels with real bolsters and nice tangs and nicely tapered blades. A craftsman could buy a chisel for not much more than an hour's wages.

This week a bushel of wheat cost $4.37. What is shocking is not how low the Chinese chisels are but how high the price can be for chisels that aren't even forged.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#10

Re: Cost of chisels

david weaver

Warren, let's be fair. A bushel of wheat back then was probably equivalent to about 10 or 20 times that now.

Ag commodities across time aren't really comparable because of mechanization and agricultural practice (e.g., corn on typical land being a 175 bushel proven yield vs. a quarter of that 100 years ago).

The real question in terms of the chisels back then would've been tied more closely to how many man-days of labor would it have taken to get the stock and the chisels made and put in the hands of a merchant. No employee benefits, no real regulation, and taxes were probably limited to small local duties and tariffs.

Just looking back to 1960, the real cost of wheat vs. the average wage (a way to normalize to the average income to try to gauge productivity or man-time spent) is about five times what it is now. Farming was well mechanized (I'm sure you're aware), but more in a two cylinder tractor and probably 100 acres farmed on average. My grandfather was running 330 acres back then and trying to go to 550, and he was criticized for being a pig for wanting to do that.

I don't have data prior to 1960s, but the cost of wheat 230 years ago would've been astronomical. Probably several days' wages.

We can still buy chisels for less than an hour's wages. Even the iles chisels, which are better than chisels made in 1790 (not everything now is, but I can say in use of the iles chisel, I would pick them over old chisels except for perhaps ward/i.sorby, etc, made after chisels switched to all steel), are about one hour of the current hourly wage. They do, of course, come with handles, which few probably would've paid to have made for them in 1790.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#11

Re: This is them (or is it ‘they’)

david weaver

I think those are probably not the same chisels, but they do have similar handles. While the aldi chisels are homely, there are some chinese tools sold (have been on ebay, etc, for quite a while - as well as aliexpress and other similar sites) that don't necessarily have any of the aspects that you'd consider baseline entry requirements - like sides that are parallel when the design was intended to be, or large cuts out of the sides of a chisel that make it look like someone left them laying on the end of a belt grinder by accident.

https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Japanese-Hand-Tools-Heavy-Duty-Wood_60567997247.html?spm=a2700.7724838.2017115.46.2ac675ebVsgscf

These are probably similar to the ones harbor freight had, and that aldi sells now. There are hundreds of listings, and probably one specifically with a similar four piece set.

I don't think they've ever seen japanese territory!!

You're probably aware that a lot of the small things listed as coming from the US are actually drop shipped from China. There's a subsidy (partially paid for by the USPS, I believe) for first class shipping from china - it's a fraction of what it costs to ship things in the US, and I'd guess by the price of some small items that it's a dollar or less. So, our first class shipping fee paid of $8 ($4.50 or so shipping plus box plus handling) is probably $1 from china.

It still seems cheap. I'll post a separate post about the economics, it's unrelated to woodworking, but actual experience based.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#12

The economics of chinese goods...a string trimmer+

david weaver

My spouse decided that after the power company cut an L in one of our trees that I should go out and round over the entire tree. The tree in question is a japanese flowering cherry - which is not supposed to grow to be very old due to disease, and mine shows stress from age. It has for 15 years now. I'd have to guess that it's 60+ years old vs. the supposed life span of 25-40. Fortunately, they grow wide and flat.

Anyway, that means I need a maximum reach of about 20 feet. There is only one sensible way for me to get that, which is a pole pruner. I already have one of the nice scissor types (a professional one) that I paid just under $200 for years ago. But the mrs. wants the tree cut back harder, which means taking branches off that won't fit in it.

In looking for pole pruners, I found a chinese combo tool that has a steel spline drive and (not a mistype) a 52 cc powerhead. That is monstrous for a pole pruner bar and chain. The princely sum for it delivered (after the seller paid shipping and ebay costs) is $160.

I have no clue how they can manage to sell them for that. The cost to get the tree pruned would be several times that, which is why I'm not hiring it done.

I expected a tool that might be single use. It came two weeks ago. The tool itself is:

* 52cc powerhead

* three splined sections of shaft with rollerblade bearings in them and the driveshaft is steel - I didn't check its hardness with a file, I don't really care

* a string trimmer head and guard (the gear box at the power head is marked "japan" - that's usually a trouble point on cheap trimmers - I guess the chinese deferred)

* a commercial style hedge trimmer (which I happen to also have use for)

* a 12 or 14 inch bar and chain, lubed and all (and the oiler even works on it)

* a brush cutter head and four steel brush cutting blades of various styles

* a harness

* safety glasses

* a set of ear muffs

* a set of gloves

* a mixing container so that if you're not familiar with mixing fuel, you can refer to the manual

To my extreme surprise, I mixed fuel using their container (the ratio is different than my other western made stuff), fixed an assembly issue the tool had, and put the string trimmer part on. It started right away, and it's actually set properly (the carb is - I'm sure it wasn't run before, but still not something I expected). It is insanely strong running. I trimmed the yard just to test it running, it's a heavy trimmer, but is the equivalent of running around killing ants with a sledge hammer.

I took the trimmer attachment off, added an extension and then the bar and chain section and cut a couple of branches off of my tree before getting called out. The bar and chain is a little cheesy and cheap, but not something I'll wear out.

I have been buying and selling guitars (my next fix, if I ever build something, I always go bonkers buying a million things to look at - but carefully so that the net cost of having a look is zero or close to it). Their ship weight is less than the weight of this tool, and through a commercial account, I can ship one across the country ground for about $50. Ebay and paypal fees would've taken about $20 from this seller. He must be making something (the name on the box was in chinese), but I can't imagine he nets more than $100 after fees and shipping. Maybe he got 500 of them for $50 each, who knows? even in china, i don't see how they can make the stuff for that.

Mine was also not assembled properly where the powerhead is attached to the shaft - the shaft didn't turn at all. I spent about half an hour taking it apart and putting it back together. Most other people would return it and the seller will eat that if they do.

I just don't really get it, but it must be worthwhile to someone.

Many of the small things that I've purchase (a $9 lithium powered screwdriver for guitar making - with 50 *hardened* bits) look like they're listed in the US, but it's apparent that they're coming from china once they get here.

When there are $4 sets offered on ebay or through a website, I'm guessing they're just drop shipped from china. You can't ship them in the united states for $4. It costs me that much to ship a straight razor across the country, and they weigh about 5 ounces total *with the box*.

The average wage in china in the last 12 years has gone from $2k to $7,500. I'm guessing that it's not so much the wage for the person putting chisels in boxes, but the fact that china is developing a more modern economy and the jobs added are higher skilled.

(the manual on my combination machine is actually good, written in english, with pictures and even has diagrams for proper cutting of branches on trees to keep them from barber chairing. It must be 50 pages long. I'm over the moon with the thing and am dumping an expensive japanese string trimmer on craigslist. My wife is less happy about it. She wants a husband who has no things, builds nothing, and buys goods, throws them out as soon as we don't need them in the next week, and hires everything else done)

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#13

Wheat cost..

david weaver

..difficult to find for 1790, but I found published wheat prices as well as daily wages for various english occupations in 1761.

For a canal worker wielding a pick, it would take about one day's work to purchase a bushel of wheat. Assuming they could buy one at the posted price (not sure if that was controlled).

For a skilled working like a brick mason, it would take about 5/8ths of a day's wages to buy a bushel of wheat.

Non-commercial occupations (day laborer, etc) didn't fare as well as that. A head housemaid's wages would've purchased a bushel of wheat every two weeks, but presumably, room and board was included making that artificially low.

Not sure when England went to making most tools in a factory - guessing that was already going on in 1790.

( a follow up look at prices in the US shows a bushel of wheat to cost a little bit more for a bushel than a day's wage in 1775 - 78 cents for a bushel of wheat and 60 cents a day for a mason - less for apprentices )

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#14

Re: Wheat cost..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you are off here, David.

In 1790 a joiner made about 2 shillings 10 pence per day (34 pennies), a bushel of wheat was about 8 shillings (96 pennies), a chisel was about 5 pence. These figures all some variation but not into the ranges you suggest.

The blacksmith might have spent a half hour or less forging, grinding, filing and heat treating a chisel.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#15

Re: Wheat cost..

david weaver

That's actually worse than I expected.....3 day's wage for a joiner to get a single bushel of wheat.

If the chisels were factory made, I would've guessed half an hour at the most, and I don't know what hours practices were back then, but I doubt there were many 8 hours shifts (12+, I'd guess).

That would leave a joiner buying a 16 piece chisel set as you mentioned over the course of two days or a little more, vs. just under 3 for a bushel of wheat.

A bushel of wheat now is 1/6th of the average hourly earnings in the united states.

What i'm saying is that it's a bad comparison, because it doesn't give us an idea of what the sweat equity was in buying a set of chisels back then. It appears like we're saying a large set of chisels cost two days wages.

The boutique chisels are probably in line with that now. The job isn't the same, so it's hard to say, but the carpenters' union wage packages here are about $30 in cash compensation plus benefits.

Non-union skilled carpenters (which are often illegals out your way - I watched the tradesmen building in Myerstown where my FIL lived) are $20 something an hour, but the benefits are probably close to non-existent - providing the number only to say that if a union carpenter wage package is $55 an hour, I'm not saying that's representative of the whole market.

I'd stand pretty firm on my comment about the Iles chisels - they're made with a more modern process (probably started in a die forge - hard to know because the videos only should carving tools and turning tools). I would rather work with ashley iles chisels - as the edge is only slightly less good than something like a butcher iron from the early 1800s, but they're solid steel and far more refined. Similar weight.

If anyone can get a decent smaller set of chisels in a day's work, we're still in the ballpark, but now that has become a dilletante chisel, something I don't agree with. I think the reality is that the aldi chisels are cheap, made overseas with little refinement - they're functional. The fact that they might be the cost of two bushels of wheat doesn't really tell us much. Their relevant cost would probably been in *cups* of wheat historically.

I would still pay $175 for the iles chisels (my opinion) vs. the aldi chisels at $7 or whatever they may be. They are enough better that in the long term, I'm not willing to concede the difference in quality when a piece of case work has more cherry in it than the cost difference in the chisels. Each guitar I build has about $400 of materials in it. I just can't get on board with the sellers "golly ghee" stuff. It's useful to get a person started, but after that....

...it's like a professional orchestra player using a hard blowing bundy II clarinet.

No thanks.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#16

Re: Wheat cost..

John in NM

I agree with David, agricultural commodities are not the best comparison because mechanization has drastically reduced those costs.

I prefer comparing to metals prices, especially gold because it is comparatively useless in industry, so it is less affected by industrial demand compared to copper & other metals.

Using the gold sovereign as a starting point, I come up with 0.002354 oz/p (though the sovereign came into use ~30 years later than your date). That gives you a current comparison of $3 modern to on pence circa ~1800. So a 5p chisel would cost $15 today - although I bet modern manufacturing has reduced chisel costs along with wheat costs, that is right around the cost of an average size Narex.

This is just a rule of thumb kind of comparison of course, I'm sure there are lots of holes to be poked.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#17

Re: The economics of chinese goods...a string trim

TomD

The same economics apply in Canada, sometimes cheaper due to the way exchange is occasionally handled, and the way shipping works. Yet our post internally is many times higher than US, virtually no free shipping, and US to Canada is crazy expensive.

Chinese get huge subsidies and rebates for selling to the US and Canada, and I don't know what their long game is, but they have a large trade surplus. At some point someone has to cover those dollars into US goods and services. Consumers sorta win, at least in the short run, but it certainly plows under US producers.

I bought a Fender tele rip off, that was very playable in the right hands, and it cost me about 67 dollars US. Free shipping, and that went through Amazon! I think the most obvious long term problem would be a broken truss rod, since you can't see it or easily repair it. But since I can replace any part of it, I am not overly concerned.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#18

Re: The economics of chinese goods...a string trim

David Weaver

The Ebay listing that i purchased from said California, but I went and checked the user listing and the dude lives in China. His items claim ship locations all over the us, but they're probably not in any of them. He sold 375 of the trimmer/pruner/brushcutters (!) Out of that one listing.

Apparently, someone in the UK is trying to rebrand them and create a permanent item.

As far as the guitars go, I got one of the strat kits. The necks are available for $34 separately complete. It wouldn't pay to even repair one. Surprisingly, after a fret level, it plays perfectly fine. Soft frets, but at that price, who cares? The rosewood fingerboard is laminated like a bamboo floor or bowling alley. First I've ever seen that, but linseed oil and light sanding made the whole thing uniformly dark.

There's no foul in either case with those two purchases with me because I wouldn't have bought the branded item of either. Comparable shindaiwa multitool would've been $900 and half the power. Both purchases required more correction than the average consumer could've done.

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#19

Re: The economics of chinese goods...a string trim

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The Ebay listing that i purchased from said California, but I went and checked the user listing and the dude lives in China.

This is likely happening around the world.

A few months ago I purchased a replacement battery for a cordless drill. The seller stated the company was in Australia. The address on the website was in Australia. I specifically wanted to purchase from within Australia.

The wrong battery was sent, and so I tried to get this rectified. PayPal were involved, and intervened on my behalf. It turned out that the business was based in China and that the battery would have to be returned to China, at my expense, before it was checked and replaced. The cost of shipping was as much as the cost of the battery (one reason I wanted to purchase in Oz in the first place).

Since this was not going to happen - I could not get either the business nor Paypal to understand the issue here - I wrote up the experience on the Australian woodwork forum. All of a sudden the business were jumping up and down and paying attention. They ended up sending me another battery.

The problem is not that the goods originate from China. The problem is the absence of backup service.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Warren - what did you think of the aldi chisels?

#20

Not that it's particularly important,  but I used

David Weaver

Not that it's important, but I used the Chinese contraption to trim an entire tree yesterday, end to end and top to bottom. If I'd have stuck my neck out and bought a 4 figure commercial combo machine, it wouldn't have worked any better.