Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The best hand tool dust collection

Posts

The best hand tool dust collection

#1

The best hand tool dust collection

David Weaver

Making doors for cabinets today with the associated filth that comes off the jack plane and other planes, and in the last couple of weeks, I've rediscovered the absolute best dust collection for hand toolers....

...one that won't pass muster with the dust collection nazis because it does suspend a little dust (but not as much as sanding something in front of your face)...

...The plug in large nozzle leaf vacuum with a nylon impeller. I used to pick up shavings, try to smash them down and then vacuum the dust, but this thing is far better. It grinds up the shavings like leaves and I can pretty much do a full day's work and get them in the firepit (vs. several trips before with several bags full) and light them up.

$50 for the one that I've got (a black and decker leaf hog).

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#2

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

Howard Pollack

Good idea. I use a broom...

-Howard

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#3

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

david weaver

Broom and dust pan is definitely fine. I have too much stuff in my work area and am not neat enough to keep stuff out of my way when cleaning, and the leaf mulchers are definitely fast and get the sawdust up (I don't generally have any sanding dust) all in one shot.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#4

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

Jim Matthews

Undoubtedly cheaper, too.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#5

Re: $45

david weaver

$45 was the cost of a leaf shredding electric version.

I have a sunken driveway and the real purpose was to run up and down the sides and clean up leaves every week or two in the fall and spring (last fall's leaves seem to blow into about april or may here).

I was sure at the outset (undecided on gas or electric) that the "plastic" impeller would be shredded by the stones that roll down the driveway, but it's nylon and other than making a lot of noise, nothing breaks it.

The cheapness side of things here is that I never had the interest to install a "real" dust vacuum system - seems like sunk costs and a huge waste of current.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#6

Re: $45

Jim Matthews

Considering the plume that emanates from my Reliant, with a "finer" bag - your solution makes more sense. It appears to me that most dust collection systems concentrate dust rather than remove it.

A cheapo electric leaf vac as shaving collector?

That's clever.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#7

Re: $45

Joe shelton

I was so impressed that I went yesterday and got one!

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#8

Re: $45

david weaver

I'd be curious how you find it in use. Only because I already had this thing and used it by chance out of laziness. Some of them have different designs and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that one type works well and another one doesn't.

Still, for me, it's purely a matter of laziness. It will suck up thick jack shavings and crunch them to bits to make the garbage compact (which makes it much easier for me to handle and burn without anything getting away), and it will suck in the long thicker try plane shavings that a shop vac won't touch.

I was going to buy one of the smaller dust collectors that are 110 and can hang on the wall, but all of them have protection in front of their impeller to block anything large. Not sure they'd be easier to use, and I don't use power tools often enough to warrant anything more than just cleaning the dust up (rather than collecting it at the source).

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#9

Re: $45

Joe shelton

I'm pleased so far. Most of what I picked up was shavings off a smoother (this was a brief session). But I did collect some small chunks I'd chiseled out of 1/2" poplar in cutting dovetails. They rattled for a moment, then stopped, and when I emptied the bag I didn't find any whole chunks. And, it got all the finer stuff, too. But it can't get under benches or into tight spots.

Thanks for the tip.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#10

Sloppy

david weaver

I'm an occupant of the "sloppy shop" I don't consciously want to be filthy, but am out of laziness and lack of focus for that kind of stuff, I guess. About once a month, I lose something under the bottom shelf on my bench and am forced to pull a push broom through it.

It always drove me nuts vacuuming under the bench or bending all the way down to get a push broom under it. The vacuum always clogged, and I have mild arthritis (which is OK with general hand tool work other than sore hands, but getting all the way up and down is painful).

I'm sure that I'm not the first person to use a leaf blower to vacuum shop shavings. Once in a while, I open the garage door and blow everything out, too, after I've vacuumed the big stuff. It's like a colon cleanse for the shop.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#11

Re: Sloppy

Joe shelton

When James Krenov wrote, a number of years ago, that "Nothing so polishes a shop floor like sweeping up a pile of planed shavings," he wasn't talking about my concrete floor.

I take consolation in that, and assume it wasn't intended for me.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#12

Re: Sloppy

Jim Matthews

You think JK was pushing the broom with a room full of earnest devotees?

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#13

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

William Duffield

No electrons died in the collection of this dust. Totally organic. Effective on power tool and hand tool dust and shavings. Multi-function. :D


Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#14

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

david weaver

I like that model!

I am very messy. My spouse is over the top clean (if you're walking in the park, then there's an extra pair of shoes in the car to put on when your done, and the ones you're wearing go in a plastic bag, etc).

Kids track through the shop and if they bring wood shavings at all into the house, she goes bonkers.

We don't have a dog. Sometimes she tells me that we should get one (Because her friends have one), but one that doesn't make any dirt (or bring any from anywhere) or mark hardwood floors with toenails...

......uh, yeah, OK.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#15

We used to have one of those, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A slightly different model - the Newfoundland/malamute hybrid model - but very effective at collecting dust. We'd sometimes have to sweep or vacuum the living room floor/rug where she'd been sleeping.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#16

Available at gift and tourist shops near you!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Your wife might like this kind:


img

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#17

Re: Available at gift and tourist shops near you!

david weaver

I like that kind, too. Cheaper and no kennel fees.

Grew up rural and live in the burbs now. In the summer, if you want to pet a dog, all you have to do is walk outside. My neighborhood is a "tweener". We're not well off enough that people have large properties and don't talk to each other because they're too competitive.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#18

Re: Available at gift and tourist shops near you!

William Duffield

Do you know that you can get a real shop dog that looks just like that one? They're called Golden Doodles, and are a cross between a standard poodle and a golden retriever, sometimes crossed back on a poodle. A significant advantage is that they don't shed. (The Blackdawg in the previous picture was at least part poodle, and he didn't shed either.) If I wasn't so committed to greyhounds right now, I would seriously consider getting one.

Re: The best hand tool dust collection

#19

Re: Sloppy

Joe shelton

No, I don't. I think that he was inculcating me with the notion that I oughta pick up a broom.

And I think that, if he'd still been around when I dropped by, the shop would have been neater.

Still enjoyed the visit, though.