Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

What is "gummy" steel?

Posts

What is "gummy" steel?

#1

What is "gummy" steel?

Joe shelton

If I have a blade that is "gummy", how will i recognize it? Will it be obvious in use?

Seems hard to imagine steel that is gummy, so is this jargon that refers to some specific trait?

Appreciate any insight.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#2

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

Jim Matthews

I'll take a stab at this: if the sharpening medium rapidly "loads" with swarf and stops cutting - the steel is soft or "gummy".

I liken it to the difference between drawing with charcoal, chalk or crayon.

Too hard, and the steel will fracture suddenly.

Too soft and the steel never forms a wire edge.

It's important to note that ANY steel can be sharpened with the proper handling, but balance must be struck in cost, time and fiddle factor.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#3

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been using the term gummy for steels with chromium for quite some time. High chrome stainless steels like pm v11 and 440A and semi stainless like A2 and D2 are they worst. Since the tools are abrasion resistant they don't really grab the stone, acting like the stone is loaded or glazed.

Steels without chromium feel much crisper on the stone. They sort of grab the stone in a positive way, making sharpening much easier. Even if they are extremely hard they abrade easily. Examples of steel without chromium are 19th century cast steel, Japanese white steel, and 1095.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#4

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have called A2 gummy quite frequently in the past. It creates a wire edge that is tenacious, likely owing to the large grain stricture of the steel. It feels a little "dead" (subjectively) when pushing it around a stone.

I would not call O1 or White Steel gummy, and neither would I call PM-V11 gummy. Their wire edges are similar - all these steels are fine grain - and they all feel more "alive" on a stone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#5

Depends on the stone...

David Weaver

I found V11 to sharpen OK on an oilstone progression as long as you allow the grinder or a crystolon stone do most of the work and then just work the edge.

But it fanned out a very tough wire edge off of an oilstone. A more aggressive stone leaves less wire edge.

i also thought that it seemed less hard (based on how the stones communicated with it, and then how it wore) than spec, and later saw that Rob (saw guy from texas, can't remember his name) found that his sample was about 60 hardness. I think that's a concession to sharpenability vs. the stated spec, and something like that is not usually by accident (the same thing occurs on razors from friodur - they're OK as stainless, which is unusual for razors, but they are softer than they say they are as a concession to make them work on more sharpening mediums).

There'd be less wire edge on a V11 iron at 63 hardness than there is at 60.

I found in hardwoods that good O1 at high hardness (mine is probably still 64 or so - the oilstones tell me that it's above 62 by a fair amount, or they'd cut it better) holds up better than the V11 that I had in the LV skew shooter. The latter might hold up better shooting something punishing, though. My O1 iron didn't tolerate heavy shooting in really dense purpleheart.

I don't have a firm conclusion on V11 because it seems to be one thing some ways and another in other ways. I'd bet it's a great smoother iron, but it doesn't outlast good carbon steel in a try plane and a heavier cut. I don't know why.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#6

"filing"

David Weaver

I would use the term "filing" on a good dry feeling carbon steel. Until it gets into the super hard range, it feels like the stones are filing it off rather than rubbing it off. AT high hardness, it transitions to more burnishing and skidding, but that's above 62 on good oilstones.

I've had so many stones and so many different irons that I could probably go on at length with each one, but suffice it to say that there isn't a good way to describe stones on each type unless one has used them.

Just one example, the irons that come in mujingfang planes clog shaptons. Hard carbon steel doesn't. Muji irons don't clog some japanese barber oilstones that I got, nor a washita (but they will grade and slow the washita). One person using shaptons will talk about the stone clogging, and the next person using another stone will accuse them of not telling the truth. My conclusion is that they're just a bad match for the shaptons unless you want to constantly abrade the surface of the stone (I don't).

I prefer the dry feeling steels across the board.

Hardness is another big gummy feeling factor, though. Anything 55/56 hardness will raise a big wire edge (even 1095) on any kind of stone. The worst one will probably find in terms of wire edges is initial cleanup of a cap iron that's unhardened. I work those with a polish stone and then leather with compound on them to get the wire edge off. Even when they're made of annealed O1, they have a wire edge that will flop back and forth and tear off.

Still like oilstones the best of all that I've tried, but not settled on the finish stone as natural or not (the japanese have a big white hard poreless synthetic oilstone that says "barber oilstone" on it that works just as well as a trans ark and settles in to polishing - it's a little more consistent regardless of steel hardness. Difficult to find, but really cheap if one pops up).

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#7

Re: "filing"

Wiley Horne

David,

I really enjoy and appreciate your analysis of steel and stones.

With that in mind, could you comment on this proposal: a gummy steel is an alloyed steel, usually with substantial chromium, that is being sharpened on the wrong medium.

Wiley

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#8

Re: "filing"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sharpening on a different medium will not change the quality of the steel.

It is true that our high quality steels were developed with specific sharpening methods in mind. I think Japanese chisels work best with Japanese stones because that is what they were designed for. And our traditional European tools were designed for oil stones like Turkey stones or Arkansas stones. If one sharpens either on different media they will not be shown in the best light.

The modern chrome chisels do not have the history of development, long interaction of high quality smiths and woodworkers, that makes for a great tool.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#9

Re: "filing"

david weaver

I'd say that's fair. You can sharpen those stones on diamond and finish with compound on a hard buff and have no perceptible wire edge.

Hardness is a big factor in how gummy something is, though, too.

I had a 1095 ka bar that must've been in the low 50s. It would sharpen fine but raise a big wire edge and not have a fine edge on an arkansas stone. When a trans or black arkansas stone raises a big wire edge, you know the steel is soft and the wire edge will be tough to get off.

Strangely enough, on the grinding side, I've never found a better grind stone than a new crystolon in an oil bath - no matter how hard the steel and no matter how alloyed it is.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#10

Grit size and friable medium

Jim Matthews

In machining steel, it's my understanding that BOTH the steel and grinding medium eject debris at the point of cutting. If that happens at a low enough temperature, a clean surface results. If the medium isn't hard enough, or coarse enough to eject a "chip" I suspect the steel will be drawn out until it yields.

Continuous chips might be what the OP described.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#11

Re: "filing"

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

Interesting observation that soft steels tend to be gummy, whether simple high-carbon or high-alloy. And that a high-chrome or high-alloy steel will be less gummy if higher in RC hardness. As a steel is hardened, it loses ductility, until at quench hardness it can be brittle as glass. And conversely, as the hardened steel is tempered back, it gains ductility, becomes less brittle. This increasing ductility would account for the lower-RC steel having a tenacious wire edge, whereas the more brittle high-RC steel will readily shed its wire edge, and will not even form a large wire edge.

Warren’s vintage high-carbon steel, if grain-refined by multiple heats and hot work, would also shed the wire-edge readily. The dislocations created during hammer forging would make the steel harder and less ductile. Same with hammer-forged traditional Japanese steel.

I had to look up crystolon. It’s silicon carbide, which will cut any alloy as you say. You mentioned ‘new’ crystolon—silicon carbide breaks down quickly into dust (gets finer and finer cutting), is this why ‘new’ is important for grinding?

Warren’s observations bring to mind how good the steel is in vintage molding planes, even real old ones. Tremendous edge life in these, even the Jo. Fuller 1790-1800 ones—I think at that time the cutting steel was largely being imported from England. Would love to know more about English steel-making from that era.

Wiley

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#12

Re: "filing"

david weaver

Yes on the crystolon being new, but the only reasons I can say that's important for sure (and it should be used in an oilbath, too, so you can just roll it over through the oil to get the surface unloaded - anything else will be messy unless not much grinding is done).

* important because the new stones have a good balance of hardness - they let particles go, but they don't let them go too quickly.

* some of the older stones are hard. I don't know if they are hard when they were made, but a friable abrasive in a hard matrix where the matrix will clog just ends up being a graded surface. Not desirable at all in hand grinding

Certainly a lot of the old carborundum stones were friable, but some were very very messy and the little bits of fragmented stones are very contaminating to say the least.

I've never had an older silicon carbide stone that works as well as a current production norton medium crystolon. They're probably still unpopular for two reasons:

* they don't really come into their own outside of an oilbath, at least not without some mess. There's negligible mess in an IM 313

* they are not a stone that automatically stays flat.

One of the biggest wastes of time in stones is chasing a coarse stone to lap flat things. It's pointless because the abrasive is too large, they'll load and you have to faff with them. a skilled user can grind on a medium crystolon about as fast as you can grind (most things) on a bench grinder. Fresh PSA sandpaper roll is better than any stone at any price for that kind of work.

For knives, the crystolon is practically magic. When I was struggling to find something that would give a truly good edge on the SGPS fallknaven knives you referred me to, I ground the edge back with the crystolon stone and was shocked at how fast it wasted the steel off. Not just the outside layer (which is just probably mild steel), but the SGPS core wasted away quickly after it pretty much thumbed its nose at other stones - either skidding across, or allowing big chunks to come out and ruin the edge.

I was very surprised, because, as you mention - it's just "plain silicon carbide" more or less. Just an example of how the combination of the right binder and right medium to carry away swarf makes it really good.

When I get neighborhood knives to sharpen as a favor, they always need a grind. I resent grinding them on a belt grinder unless they're really horrible because it doesn't leave the same geometry as the natural scything motion does (which allows you to go from one stone to the next quickly).

There may be some 64 hardness S30V or something that sharpens better on a diamond, but not with the same feel, and I wouldn't use that, anyway. The crystolon for the same level of fineness is much faster and more uniform than any diamond hone I've used.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#13

Re: "filing"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used silicon carbide stones since 1961. The Carborundom company used that name; Norton used Crystolon. Now both are owned by the same company. I am on my fifth stone, having worn out the others.

There is some difference in these stones in how easily they expose fresh grit, both between the two companies and between different eras from the same company. For a given stone and a given tool there is an optimum pressure for quick cutting.

I now use a water stone for coarse work on tools that are wide and flat. The silicon carbide stone is used for grinding turning gouges, narrow chisels and the like. Things that would mess up the water stone.

Re: What is "gummy" steel?

#14

Re: "filing"

david weaver

If I sharpened full bevel, I would choose a different stone, too, as IIRC, you're using a king stone to do the bevel work.

The crystolon is pretty abusive to an edge when it gets all the way there.

AT one point, I reprofiled a kiyotada chisel that wiley gave me. It is an old one and it is ice hard, the hardest I've seen. It probably should be retempered a little, but I'm not going to retemper a kiyotada chisel - that would be like putting modern exhaust pipes and mag wheels on a duesenberg.

At any rate, chisels like that will not sharpen well on most natural stones, and they grind especially slow on most stones.

Except the crystolon. I was very pleased with the rate of work setting up the bevel on the chisel, but a little concerned about the roughness of the work. As I progressed through my waterstones, the entire edge fell apart. It wouldn't tolerate the abuse of such a harsh stone, but it didn't show it until later in the sharpening process. I took the time to reprofile the bevel with a gentler stone (which was considerable), and it made it through the sharpening process without any issues.

This is an issue that's common in hard tempered razors, too. I set up and sold a huge number of razors over the last three years, as well as three digits in japanese natural stones (no other way to actually get a look at so many things without being out of pocket - both being a good late night play thing after the kids are asleep because there's no noise). It is extremely uncommon for me to use any synthetic stone on a straight razor, because it just isn't necessary and it's risky. The edges are very transient on synthetic stones and it takes a lot longer for the linen to bring them back in use than natural stones because of the way the edge crumbles in blunt little voids.

I was never able to see the actual evidence of this until I got a metallurgical microscope (which is something very useful to have if you're selling razors that are sharpened - it's easy to sharpen a razor well from prior setup about 80% of the time without being able to see the edge. Something much more particular than refreshing a razor in use - which is far more enjoyable than setting up razors anew. At any rate, with a microscope, it's probably more like 90-95%, with the remainder of razors being defective and not able to hold an edge properly).