Re: "filing"
david weaver
Yes on the crystolon being new, but the only reasons I can say that's important for sure (and it should be used in an oilbath, too, so you can just roll it over through the oil to get the surface unloaded - anything else will be messy unless not much grinding is done).
* important because the new stones have a good balance of hardness - they let particles go, but they don't let them go too quickly.
* some of the older stones are hard. I don't know if they are hard when they were made, but a friable abrasive in a hard matrix where the matrix will clog just ends up being a graded surface. Not desirable at all in hand grinding
Certainly a lot of the old carborundum stones were friable, but some were very very messy and the little bits of fragmented stones are very contaminating to say the least.
I've never had an older silicon carbide stone that works as well as a current production norton medium crystolon. They're probably still unpopular for two reasons:
* they don't really come into their own outside of an oilbath, at least not without some mess. There's negligible mess in an IM 313
* they are not a stone that automatically stays flat.
One of the biggest wastes of time in stones is chasing a coarse stone to lap flat things. It's pointless because the abrasive is too large, they'll load and you have to faff with them. a skilled user can grind on a medium crystolon about as fast as you can grind (most things) on a bench grinder. Fresh PSA sandpaper roll is better than any stone at any price for that kind of work.
For knives, the crystolon is practically magic. When I was struggling to find something that would give a truly good edge on the SGPS fallknaven knives you referred me to, I ground the edge back with the crystolon stone and was shocked at how fast it wasted the steel off. Not just the outside layer (which is just probably mild steel), but the SGPS core wasted away quickly after it pretty much thumbed its nose at other stones - either skidding across, or allowing big chunks to come out and ruin the edge.
I was very surprised, because, as you mention - it's just "plain silicon carbide" more or less. Just an example of how the combination of the right binder and right medium to carry away swarf makes it really good.
When I get neighborhood knives to sharpen as a favor, they always need a grind. I resent grinding them on a belt grinder unless they're really horrible because it doesn't leave the same geometry as the natural scything motion does (which allows you to go from one stone to the next quickly).
There may be some 64 hardness S30V or something that sharpens better on a diamond, but not with the same feel, and I wouldn't use that, anyway. The crystolon for the same level of fineness is much faster and more uniform than any diamond hone I've used.