Just bought some 5/4 Curly Maple for our dinning room table table top. It has been planed but there is some tearout and just a bit of twist in one board.
So I would appreciate a suggestion for what plane would be appropriate. I am thinking my regular bench planes,bevel down, might not be up to the task.
I don't think just buying the right hand plane will do it. You will also need to learn how to set it properly. I would first get garrett wades handplane book and read up on it . Then you will have the knowledge to decide which plane you need. Scrapers are a good way of taming rough grain. Also sanding can get you a decent surface on difficult grain if done correctly.
What is the actual thickness of the planed 5/4? And what is the intended final thickness of the finished table top? I ask to get at how much leeway you have to do further stock prep. This gets at questions like whether to glue up first, before final flattening and grain-taming. And whether to try to work with that twisted board, or whether to rip it in two to minimize the planing loss, or buy a new straight board, etc.
And whether to sand the surface to deal with the tearout, as has been mentioned already. This is heretical of course, but if you don’t have much leeway, might be the practical thing to do. And become a planing expert on waste wood.
1. Some curly maple exhibits terrible tearout. Some doesn't. If the power planer didn't take big chunks out of your board you may be in luck.
2. Wetting the wood slightly will reduce tearout. Water works fine, but you have to dry your plane afterwards to avoid rust. I like using low odour paint thinner - just enough to wet the surface while working on it. It makes the fibres softer and less prone to tearout. Commercial formulations like Supersoft also help, but I wouldn't buy it unless you need it for veneer softening or other uses.
3. The right plane is the sharpest plane. I use a 4-1/2 with a high angle frog (Lie-Nielsen). The high angle does help a bit. I'll also skew the plane across the direction of travel.
3a. Keep the mouth opening as low as possible, take very light shavings.
4. Pay careful attention to grain direction. The grain direction may be different on different parts of the board.
5. Don't get too carried away with obtaining a perfect surface from the plane. You may want to sand the board before finishing in order to get more even finish or dye absorption. The grain may raise when applying your first coat of finish and you need to use sandpaper then anyway.
Gosh, it's like 7 years of history have been erased.
I know nobody likes to hear it said like this sometimes, but ...'curly maple is not a difficult wood to plane', especially compared to curly cherry or some quartered woods.
In fact, if you are going to plane more than a little bit off of it, all of the other methods available are markedly inferior to a bevel down "cheap" plane like a stanley plane.
The original poster would be doing himself a disservice at this point to go any other route, not necessarily even from a cost perspective, but from a practical perspective in terms of planing wood and doing more than smoothing.
Sharpness, mouth size, angle, etc...all of those are fine, but a stanley plane with the cap iron set even with a mediocre effort will plane curly maple without tearout and without much in the way of sharpness. It'll literally do it all the way up until the point that it doesn't cut. If the plane is set just OK, you won't be able to generate tearout, even if you try. In fact, if you keep ratcheting up the shaving thickness, the ability to create any tearout at all will get further and further away.
I'm assuming scrapers were popular for veneer work, but never cycled around in the same volume as planes otherwise because they just aren't as good for much (I've had a bunch - the LN version, the veritas version, the stanley version, the LN small version..I don't have any of them at this point, but I do have a stanley 80 and a pull type scraper for floors - that's kind of nice, takes less damage on a hidden staple than does a plane).
You might consider the following for your dining room table:
1. Replace the twisted board with a straight one planed to the same thickness.
2. Glue up first, rather than working the boards individually first—this will save thickness in the final product. Maintain alignment in the glue-up by using splines or biscuits. Shoot for zero variation across the seams.
3. If you can, get the grain all in the same direction prior to glue-up.
4. To flatten, use a long plane, like a No. 7. As others have said, sharp is the ballgame, rather than having a new super-duper plane. Use the double-iron technique suggested by David, if you want to pick up a new skill in this project. Suggest work at an angle across the boards, then work at an angle from the other side, so as not to plane a tilt into the table top. Use two milled edge levels, 4-ft or 6 foot to keep track of flatness and wind.
5. If any whole ‘peppercorns’ of curl are torn out, fill the holes using a Behlen master burn-in kit, or equal. A good alternative, less expensive, is to make up a slurry with liquid hide glue and project dust/shavings to fill large curl tear-out (if any).
6. Sand in boiled linseed oil: progress through 100, 220, 320. At each stage, flood with oil and sand it in using as much paper is required until no more oil will absorb. Then go to the next finer grit. This process will yield a wonderful surface to the touch, and a filled surface. I believe minor remaining tear-out will not be seen.
7. Finish with blonde dewaxed shellac; numerous thin coats. At say, 1/2 lb cut.
8. Rub out with OOO (or so) steel wool dipped in wax.
The burn in technique is something that I don't see a lot of outside of instruments (I used to see it working in a cabinet factory to fix issues with new cabinets).
I wish I'd have gotten a burn in knife sooner, and for folks with old shellac flakes lying around, they work fine with a burn in knife, so don't throw them away for fear that they won't dissolve.
If spending on the commercial knives is undesirable, heating a piece of steel and using shellac flakes will achieve the same result as the commercial irons and the more handy sticks.
"Sharpness, mouth size, angle, etc...all of those are fine, but a stanley plane with the cap iron set even with a mediocre effort will plane curly maple without tearout and without much in the way of sharpness. "
What is this "cap iron" thing that you speak of? From your post, I assume that it was invented seven years ago, but has since been forgotten, is that correct?
I vaguely recall discussion from that and some slightly later discussion (what I don't vaguely recall is that I came to the wrong conclusion early on), but there was little in terms of usable information for people to go try with their planes.
Of course, once the video came out (vs. screen shots only), everyone said "the video says 80% angle and set the projection at .008", that's the best".
I tried it and found that to not be the case.
revisionists showed up afterwards and found every reference to the cap iron (but none of them that I can recall provided any reason to believe they could use the cap, and they certainly provided no evidence that they ever mentioned any such thing in a prior discussion. That was predictable).
This same topic came up on another forum, same conclusion (need to build a plane with a 60 degree bevel), as did other plane design items that should be defunct, but larry popularlized (the whole myth that a double iron plane can't take a full width shaving. A crappy one might not be able to, but every properly fitted plane I've made or tried takes one without clogging problems).
Fairly sure that I'm wasting my time talking about any of it. Someone who dimensions wood by hand will come to it unless they're lacking curiosity or intelligence. Someone who uses a machine planer and jointer only may not ever notice a difference when they're just taking off machine planer marks and sanding to finish.
Interestingly, on p.309 of "The Wooden Plane," Whelan describes a "chip plane," which is used to produce thin strips of wood for hat making. He says the plane actually makes several strips simultaneously. No picture, unfortunately.
That was a good tip on using a feeler gauge to get the chipbreaker setback, especially for the ahem older eyesight-challenged folks. Steve’s music composition is a great commendation to this Bach-nut.