Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

Posts

This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#1

This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

Charlie belden

A $296 Bridge City Chop Sticks Making System?


Chop stick making sytem

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#2

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool

john sayles

It is absolutely NOT a prank.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#3

Seriously?


Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#4

Bridge city

Jack Guzman

Bridge City is known for high quality,very expensive specialty tools. You get the idea when you look at their webpage. This is a real kitchen tool.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#5

Yep...

John in NM

And also true to BCTW's usual offerings, there is typically a much cheaper option available, in this case a couple maple planing forms would do the same and could be made in the shop.

But BCTW isn't selling utility, they never have. They sell pretty stuff that is also useful if you can bear to get wear marks on it!

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#6

One man's tool is another man's folly......

roger lance

you can buy beaucoup chopsticks for this much yen......

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#7

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool

David Weaver

I don't think that's a tool for woodworkers. Think two attorneys or google software engineers with no woodworking experience and who perhaps have other things like a set of shigefusa knives.

Chopsticks would be pretty easy to batch by hand.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#8

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool

Mark Nowicki

You should see how much it is in Canadian $'s (add 15% of Federal and Provincial penalties)

Just a slight correction, not Steel City, but Harvey Industries, so Made in China.

More like "Jump the Shark" than "April Fool"

https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=jump-the-shark

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#9

Re: grain direction

david weaver

If you watch the video on the product page, you may gather from it that it appears a lot of people will be learning about grain direction and warpage very quickly.

I eat Chinese food with a fork, so I'm unfamiliar with the making of these, but in supposing what a "normal" woodworker would do rather than buying $300 of imported aluminium contraption, I figured you'd split a billet so as to get grain direction without much runout and then plane it into a longer board and then saw the result into a gaggle of chopsticks

(think taking a cedar shake and cutting the thin part off of the end and then sawing the result into a bunch of roughed chopsticks - except use something harder than shakes).

All that said, BCTW stuff probably has a pretty low utilization percentage, so maybe it won't matter.

(there's a large chinese grocer at the edge of my neighborhood - the other issue is that they probably have superb quality decorative riven and finish sticks for a couple of bucks).

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#10

Re: grain direction

AlanWS

It is certainly true this is not designed for woodworkers. If I recall correctly, the first one was made for some kind of show to highlight his block plane, and it wound up attracting flocks of people to try it because planing is fun. And you wind up with something.

We are not the target audience, but it exists.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#11

Re: grain direction

david weaver

I can imagine that it will delight some, too. And that's good.

Those of us offended by the proposition aren't the buyer, and those buying aren't offended. I've certainly wasted money on more.

Your story about how the device came about reminds me of Gallagher (the prop comic). He said Chevy Chase was ripping on him about the props, and he said something like "you know, when people like something, you tend to do it".

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#12

That is a good point....

John in NM

Planing is fun, ending up with something is fun, and neat if over-engineered tools can be fun too. So much fun, who are we to mock it?

I remember loving that block plane's looks when it first came out. Some of the other over-engineering struck me as silly even then, but I have to admit it was a handsome design. That and their combo squares.... probably would never buy one, but they were handsome tools.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#13

Re: That is a good point....

Barry Irby

China's problem is that with 1.3 billion people, they need a LOT of chopsticks.

I doubt this is the answer, but it might help.

Actually I have heard they are encouraging people to use "western" style silverware to reduce the demand for sticks.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#14

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool

TomD

The thing about the original story is that the chopstick maker itself is better made than the plane, which is not so great. I bought one for the kids, and for my wife to use with her students, if the school would let her. But the plane is poorly made for a 200 dollar plane. In some ways a non-adjustable (accidentally) Japanese plane would be a lot better, and cost around 20 bucks to make. I might give it a go if they sold the parts separately. As is it is, it is going back.

I do support the idea though. You will get really nice sticks out of it, and it had the potential to attract a lot of people to some form of hand work, or woodworking itself. Kids go through their whole 20 year educations without ever making anything to a high standard, or anything useful. Of course this will rather suggest you can make nice things for nearly zero effort.

It is basically the same process used to make bamboo fly rods, and I have made all the tools and parts for that craft including re-inventing my own planes, forms and binders. So it isn't as though I couldn't make something for chopsticks myself, but this looks luxurious, which probably appeals to a lot of people who would think a lot of wood shops were pretty taudry.

As far as needing to bring in an alternative to sticks, like flatware, the problem with sticks is not that they are sticks, but the billions of disposable ones. Of course with all the climate concern out there, you could just burn the sticks thereby upping your zero emissions energy credits.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#15

Re: grain direction

TomD

"(there's a large chinese grocer at the edge of my neighborhood - the other issue is that they probably have superb quality decorative riven and finish sticks for a couple of bucks)."

Well you can say that about anything we make. Maybe custom fitted prosthetics or something are useful and unique, though probably pretty automated at this point. But all the crap people love to make like guitars, or ladder back chairs. It isn't for lack of cheaper alternatives.

BCT does have a high angle cutting alternative. Sorry, no breaker insight is in the kit.

One place that should get one is like a maker space. Our local libraries have all gone super into makerism, which is hilarious because of course the purpose of makerism is to de-skill all making, and the folks using the space are about as creative as the kid fishing a prize out of a cracker jack box. So this would fit in pretty well. Those places are putting out tons of money to buy all kinds of stuff for making things. the 350 this thing costs up here would be a bargain.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#16

Re: grain direction

david weaver

That's sort of a strange comparison. (guitars and whatever else to chopsticks).

There is one parallel here to guitars. No matter what you say on a guitar forum, there's always someone to disagree with you there, too.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#17

Re: grain direction

TomD

I'm not sure that was a comparison of guitars to chopsticks, though there is a comparison, guitars are largely not made by woodworkers, and they are almost 100% jigged. The Spanish tradition is like woodworking, they can cut a fret slot freehand with a handsaw, kind of thing. I'm torn cause I love Charlie Fox just as much as I do Tores.

The comparison was just that you could get good ones for less than you can make them for. I bought my daughter a Fender accoustic guitar for 100 dollars Canadian, that was 100% playable, properly compensated, well set up, nice action height, sounds good, etc... One could absolutely perform professionally with it, if it had the right electronics package. I can't remembed if the top was solid wood, I assume it was all ply, but that isn't even a disadvantage in a guitar that will be gigged. Depends on the style of play, but it was startling progress in the low end of the field.

The Guitars I make needed to sell for 4K. Daughter 1 is a careless thug (great A student though), giving her an expensive guitar would not pan out. I was shocked at how good the Fender was. When I took up guitar in the early 70s. The guitar I had was horrendous in every category. Whoever built that Fender had looked very carefully at a custom level guitar.

I gave up on Guitar forums: 1) nobody knows what they are talking about, in the sense that woodworking stuff is easy/low level, so who cares what they think, and the kind of stuff say Somogyi was trying to get to, last I heard had not being cracked, though maybe the glitter guys got there. 2) My experience is that forums that combine amateurs and professionals as guitar making has to, end up unfriendly.

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#18

Chris Scholz

Have not seen that happening

Chris Scholz

Have not seen that happening. You certainly can get for knife and in tourist restaurants they might give you fork and knife when they see a Westerner coming.

Disposable chopsticks have been banned in China a few years ago. Traveling through little known (to us) places during the last few days (spending a few days in Wuyishan right now), I have not seen any disposable chopsticks anywhere (fancy sit down restaurants with table cloth to food carts on the street corner, not a single disposable set of chopsticks).

Re: This has got to be a LV April Fools Tool *LINK*

#19

Chris Scholz

correction

Chris Scholz

Saw a few forks in a ‘4 star’ hotel today. This was at the ‘western section’ of the breakfast buffet.