Re: Follow up comments after talking to george
david weaver
I called George yesterday afternoon, or rather he called me (he met a local guy who wants to vacuum kiln beech), but I hijacked the conversation with varnish talk.
The more significant part of the S-W and other varnish issue was that the varnish went from having a very favorable color for violins to having a purplish hue. I don't know what the problem was (I think maybe a change in resins, but who knows?).
He did, of course, have some stories of instruments that didn't harden, but I was incorrect, it wasn't the S-W. I asked him about alcohol varnishes (behlen has an alcohol-based product that they call violin varnish) and he suggested no - no good prior experiences with alcohol-based violin varnishes (the reviews on amazon are mixed, anyway), extremely slow drying.
If you're wondering why he didn't cook his own varnish for violins, he did sometimes, but it's a time soak. I'm still thinking about doing that instead, though - thanks to youtube, it is easy to see someone's process and visually what tests they use.
If anyone who has made guitars is wondering why he'd entertain discussing varnish on guitars, he doesn't - he suggested nitrocellulose with an epoxy pore fill below the nitro and dewax shellac (no surprise). I would have to spray nitro outside - and that leads to bugs and pollen here (no area without trees on my small property).
Thanks for your thoughts, guys. I did go and look up pre-made varnish again from violin makers (lots from eastern europe on etsy). 20-40 euros plus shipping for 100ml. Ouch.
Automotive two part finishes are also an option on the other end of the spectrum. I repainted my car hood (car's only 5 years old, but I guess the paint is extra environmentally friendly) and used "USC Spray Max 2k High Gloss Clearcoat Aerosol". Two cans of it on a hood. It is incredibly hard.
One other aside, I did ask about tru-oil, because it has a really nice lustre on gunstocks, and George had also used that on a violin. he said it took forever to harden, and then once he set a bridge, it literally slowly sunk through the finish over a short period of time (weeks?) and went all the way to the violin, so that's also out (i'm sure it would accumulate sweat and hand oils on a guitar neck and get filthy).