Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Where to find "real" varnish

Posts

Where to find "real" varnish

#1

Where to find "real" varnish

david weaver

Does anyone sell real varnish any longer (without spending a huge amount for 8 ounces from a violin maker, etc)?

I'd like some to finish guitars, and I recall George Wilson saying that about 20 years ago, all of the true varnishes (even basic Sherwin Williams standard varnish was excellent for instruments prior to that) changed due to either supply or environmental rules, and nothing now is like old varnish without cooking your own.

Behlen "rock hard" varnish, and other such things are out. They're not similar to old varnish, and rock hard is a naming trade mark (they are no such thing).

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#2

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

Bill Tindall wrote a number of posts on this very subject several years ago. And he named the one he liked best. If you can figure out to search the archives, you could likely find the info. Alternatively, just ask Bill...

Wiley

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#3

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

Don Stephan

A few years ago I read all I could find on the Internet and in books by Jeff Jewitt, Bob Flexner and a third journalist finisher whose name escapes me. The consensus seemed to be that alkyd varnish dried clearest, and I think I saw a recommendation for Pratt & Lambert 38 gloss (alkyd) varnish. I've been buying it quarts for 4 or 5 years now and about 8 months ago found Stop Loss bags, which keep the unused varnish from gelling. Perhaps I am very lucky, but a local paint store here in Cincinnati keeps it in stock.

I am using it thinned 50-50 with a good quality mineral spirits as a wiping varnish on wooden bowls and the outside of turned lidded boxes. Another Stop Loss bag keeps the thinned varnish from gelling.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#4

What characteristics separate 'real'

Chuck Nickerson

varnish from what's commercially available? Also please share whatever you learn from Bill Tindall.

I've got Sheperd's book on finishes which have several old formulas for varnish.

Perhaps I need to get cooking.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#5

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

John in NM

Try Sutherland Welles.

Not cheap, but I think some of their products are about as real as varnish gets.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#6

Re: What characteristics separate 'real'

david weaver

"real", IIRC, had to do with drying to a reasonable hardness that rubs out well.

A friend who always avoids trying to spray finishes is the one who tried behlen rock hard, and IIRC, their response was that the name doesn't really have anything to do with implying that it actually gets hard. There's some story behind using that name, but I don't remember what it was.

In terms of how sherwin williams went from "real" to "not real", George described it as them changing the formula, stating that they didn't, and then later admitting that they did. At the time, he stated that the original was suitable for varnishing violins that sold at CW for what would be equivalent to five figures today.

I'll check out the pratt and lambert.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#7

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

david weaver

Thanks, John. I'll look them up.

if it doesn't work out, purchasing the components and making varnish is always an option, but it's not exactly cheap, and it would be sort of a distraction.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#8

Re: I read a little bit further...

david weaver

..the guitar tutorials online have been written with modern alkyd varnish in mind. They basically say "no rubbing out, and the finish will be very soft and prone to scratches for a long time", but make for a more resonant guitar (there's a lot of superstition in guitars - I'll leave alone whether I think it makes much if a difference to have varnish on an acoustic guitar vs. a reasonable coat of nitrocellulose . There is an upcharge in some cases of $1200 to $1500 if you buy a guitar and want it to have varnish.

I'm just going for the look, as I purchased a chinese les paul by eastman and I like the look of the varnish. Some of their guitars are still made "by hand" and are a bit crude by factory guitar standards, but perhaps the kind of crude we like. Evidence the work was done by hand, but skillfully and not sloppy. The street price of their varnish les paul is about the same cost as the upcharge for a varnished US-made guitar.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#9

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

david weaver

I called George yesterday afternoon, or rather he called me (he met a local guy who wants to vacuum kiln beech), but I hijacked the conversation with varnish talk.

The more significant part of the S-W and other varnish issue was that the varnish went from having a very favorable color for violins to having a purplish hue. I don't know what the problem was (I think maybe a change in resins, but who knows?).

He did, of course, have some stories of instruments that didn't harden, but I was incorrect, it wasn't the S-W. I asked him about alcohol varnishes (behlen has an alcohol-based product that they call violin varnish) and he suggested no - no good prior experiences with alcohol-based violin varnishes (the reviews on amazon are mixed, anyway), extremely slow drying.

If you're wondering why he didn't cook his own varnish for violins, he did sometimes, but it's a time soak. I'm still thinking about doing that instead, though - thanks to youtube, it is easy to see someone's process and visually what tests they use.

If anyone who has made guitars is wondering why he'd entertain discussing varnish on guitars, he doesn't - he suggested nitrocellulose with an epoxy pore fill below the nitro and dewax shellac (no surprise). I would have to spray nitro outside - and that leads to bugs and pollen here (no area without trees on my small property).

Thanks for your thoughts, guys. I did go and look up pre-made varnish again from violin makers (lots from eastern europe on etsy). 20-40 euros plus shipping for 100ml. Ouch.

Automotive two part finishes are also an option on the other end of the spectrum. I repainted my car hood (car's only 5 years old, but I guess the paint is extra environmentally friendly) and used "USC Spray Max 2k High Gloss Clearcoat Aerosol". Two cans of it on a hood. It is incredibly hard.

One other aside, I did ask about tru-oil, because it has a really nice lustre on gunstocks, and George had also used that on a violin. he said it took forever to harden, and then once he set a bridge, it literally slowly sunk through the finish over a short period of time (weeks?) and went all the way to the violin, so that's also out (i'm sure it would accumulate sweat and hand oils on a guitar neck and get filthy).

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#10

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

John in NM

I really don't understand what it is you are looking for. It kind of sounds like you want a hard, fast cure product... go with nitrocellulose lacquer or an automotive clear coat.

You won't get hard or fast out of a "real" varnish (a boiled oil basically). Some resins tend to be harder than others (Tru-oil is indeed a soft product), but my impression that what really makes the difference is time - you won't find any traditional oil varnish that achieves full hardness overnight.

I think speed is much of the reason you don't see "real" varnishes for sale much. The market wants speed + ease of use over color.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#11

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

William Duffield

Although their characteristics are quite different, both the P&L 38

http://www.prattandlambert.com/product-selector/homeowner/stains_clears/38_clear_varnish

and Waterlox Original are true varnishes. Note that some of the other Waterlox products have been modified to conform to California and other states' air quality standards, and you may not be able to find the Waterlox with it's original label in all states.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#12

Clint Searl

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

Clint Searl

Give Martin Guitar in Nazareth, PA a call. Maybe their finish guy can give some enlightenment.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#13

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

david weaver

Speed means something that hardens near fully in weeks or months. Vs. never hardening.

I'm looking for a warm amber varnish that looks like a vintage violin varnish without finding out that it won't harden fully or it will harden with a funny color cast. And without UV additives that make it keep a funny color but resist oxidation from sunlight (something irrelevant on a guitar).

I think such a thing is difficult to find, as most of the commercial supply seems to be aimed at boats, or exterior furniture.

I figured if there was a restoration type product available, someone would know here. It looks like there really isn't, most of what's out there is compromises, and given the world of a million uses, a million solvents and a million resins, it's probably not surprising that most of the things commercially labeled as "violin varnish" really don't resemble what a violin maker would make.

the reason I'm not defaulting to lacquer yet is that I've already sprayed a lot of lacquer, not on instruments, but on furniture. I've sprayed instrument lacquer on furniture, even, and it works well. But it doens't look like varnish, and that's what I'm looking for - something that

*looks like a vintage varnish without funny colors

*where the comment/review section isn't full of "never could figure out a way to get good results applying this", or "dried fast and didn't flow out, but never fully hardened"

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#14

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

david weaver

That's an excellent idea. Collings applies varnish still, too - I will ask them if they don't publish what they use.

Thanks.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#15

Final preliminary findings from ...

david weaver

lunch and evening searches...

I thought there were a lot of varnishes on etsy. They're actually all from one seller.

There are other kits sold to make varnish (resins and colorants - you buy the oil and lime separately, and burn maple to get maple ash), at a cost of about $50-$75 to make about a pint or a little more.

Pratt and Lambert #38, as mentioned above, is the only varnish discussed on the various guitar forums where nobody has a gripe. Behlen's violin varnish matches the amazon reviews - tacks quickly, but never really seems to be fully dried until years after, except for a few lucky "lottery winners" who are satisfied with it.

Many of the other products with "varnish" on the labels are drying oils with no resins.

Thanks for the help folks. I am dwelling on this topic, but only because when I do something like this (guitar, etc) I like to spend a day or two finding out what I can and then go with it rather than intermittent incomplete here and there type wondering, then giving up, then wondering, then giving up.

I like the idea of making varnish, but it looks like a two hour or so process with heating of oils up to 300 degrees, so it's an outdoor only project (I have an excellent open burner on a propane grill that never gets used), and the kind of thing my wife won't tolerate. It's potentially something to do if she takes the kids to the inlaws. I recall george saying that fire is a possibility when cooking it if anything goes wrong.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#16

Re: Final preliminary findings from ...

GolfSteve in Calgary

I tried buying P&L 38 in Canada back in 2013 without luck. I found one company that would ship by ground from USA to Canada, but decided to use Mohawk Instrument Lacquer purchased locally instead. I cannot find the name of the company in my files.

If I recall correctly, John Boganovich sprays P&L 38 on his guitars, only two coats or something minimal like that, whereas I sprayed about 15 coats of shellac and nitro for my guitar.

I would have suggested trying to get "Paint Direct" in Calgary (off blackfoot trail) to order P&L for you, but it appears they may be out of business?

Check out George Heinel in Toronto. I've only purchased hide glues from him, but he also sells violin varnishes (at $45/100 mL).

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#17

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

John in NM

Ok, that is a bit more clear, with a single exception.

I would try either Pratt & Lambert spar varnish or Waterlox original. P&L says their resin is phenolic, but being a spar varnish might have UV inhibitors and a color you don't like. I've been told Waterlox uses phenolic also (they don't say on the website, but might tell you on the phone if you ask). I've used Waterlox almost exclusively for 20 years and like it a lot. My impression is that phenolic resin gives you a harder varnish.

I still want to try Sutherland Welles (their site actually tells you the resin they use in each product) but the "hard" varnishes they list (added resin rather than just boiled oil) all use urethane and alkyd resin and may end up looking more like poly than traditional oil. Worth a call though, they're a top end product and will probably be happy to talk to you about what you need.

Now to the exception - "never hardening" - its not clear whether you mean that it cures and is dry to the touch but is still a relatively soft finish, or you mean it literally never gets beyond tacky. If the former, then its just a matter of formulation and you do need to search for the right product. If its the latter, then its either homemade (incorrectly) or misused (like adding dye and acetone).

If you do want to try cooking your own, keep a cookie sheet handy. If you get a fire, the only way to put it out is to smother it.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#18

Re: Final preliminary findings from ...

david weaver

Thanks for the tip on George Feinel - I may go that route.

I haven't yet ordered p&l 38, only because it's like the model T as far as colors went. You can have your P&L in gallons here in the states, and if you don't like gallons, you can also select....gallons. (No quarts or Pints).

The other option that folks seem to like is Epifanes, which is $25 for 500ml.

I think an easy start at this (unless my wife says she's leaving with the kids for three days) would be to get 500ml of Epifanes and try 100ML of violin varnish from the fellow you mentioned and see if I can see much difference on a test board of mahogany and a test board of maple. If I can't, then Epifanes it is. If I can...well, it'll be purchase or make.

Thanks again - even though the discussions often get off track (or in my case, lots of unnecessary details as I type out loud), I always come to a better conclusion on a new topic like this than if I just do a little bit of googling and then stab at it.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#19

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

david weaver

Thanks for the tip on the look (due to the UV).

I am right now making two cherry telecasters. I don't intend to expend that much effort on them unless I have varnish in hand by the time the second body is complete, and I might trial it there. One of the draws to using cherry is the lovely caramel/amber color that it turns into over time, and though not many folks probably stain cherry with a brown pigment stain (vs. mahogany), I think when it's toned with a darker brown, it looks fabulous.

Thanks for the tip on the cookie sheet, too. I'd have ended up shoveling dirt or sand on it.

Yes on the waterlox, I found folks with positive opinions about that (due to its quicker cure and high hardness), as well as P&L and Epifanes. These discussions were more well developed on classical guitar forums where the traditional finish is still varnish.

And I also learned that the ever shifting "Rock Hard" tabletop varnish has gone from a long-chain varnish to a short chain varnish (the switch that my friend didn't like) and in 2012 or 2013, it left the realm of true varnishes entirely - it's now a urethane. Who knows what it will be in five years - acrylic with crosslinker? It wasn't on the radar, anyway.

I'll check into the other name you mentioned - it looked to be very heavily aimed at the marine industry, but maybe all of these are.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#20

Re: Final preliminary findings from ...

GolfSteve in Calgary

Sorry, David, I thought you were in Canada.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#21

Re: Final preliminary findings from ...

david weaver

No problem - it looks like Heinl doesn't ship to the united states, but I sent them an email to make sure, just in case.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#22

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

John in NM

Honestly, I don't know that the funny hue of a lot of modern varnishes is due to UV inhibitors, it could well be the resin used.

I can send you a little jar of Waterlox if you'd like to try it. I store it in variously sized jars so that I'm only using a small jar at a time. It jells quickly, and I use it fairly slowly, so I like to keep the waste to a minimum. It will keep for years when stored in a jar full to the top.

I like experimenting with varnishes when I get the chance, but I always end up sticking with Waterlox.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#23

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

david weaver

No need yet. I may order a can. Do you know what the shelf life of it is?

Yes on the resins, sorry to imply that it might have to do with UVs. George thought it was a matter of changing resins that gave it a purple hue, due to something becoming unavailable.

The UV protectant is just another complicating factor, because I'd like the instruments to look old as they get old, and the cherry bodied guitars, I'd like to look like aged cherry from UV exposure.

So far, I ordered epifanes gloss varnish, and I broke down and ordered all of the components to cook a varnish recipe that I found published on youtube by a violin maker. Part dammar, part pine resin. We'll see how it goes.

I like the look of the varnish that Steve linked me to, but the web form from the supplier only allows canadian province addresses, so I'm assuming they won't ship to the US. If they do, I may try theirs, too.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#24

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

John in NM

Waterlox shelf life is short once opened - depends on how full the jar/can is and how often its been opened to use a little. I've had half a 10 oz jar last a couple months (stored upside down) if it hasn't been used a lot - like that initial 5 oz was used in just a couple applications. If you open the jar a lot and use just a little it will turn in a couple weeks.

Since everything I make these days seems to be so small, I've thought of buying a bunch of 1 oz jars, or 2.5 oz maybe - that little I could easily use up before it turned. The 10 oz I have a lot of due to my wife liking a jam that comes in them. When I made a lot of furniture they were the perfect size for an average project.

When I buy a gallon I tend to pour most of it into larger jars and then fill small ones from those. I've had those large ones last more than 10 years when I was building a house instead of furniture. Key is to minimize the oxygen exposure.

Shows you how much I like the stuff that I'll go to all this trouble!

Try aging some cherry with a little ammonia or lye, then buff with steel wool and finish. You might have to dilute a little to not overdo the effect.

Re: Where to find "real" varnish

#25

Re: Follow up comments after talking to george

david weaver

Thanks for the tip (being able to split the finish and not have it oxidize right away if if the small split apart containers aren't opened and used subsequently), that's exactly the kind of thing I'd like to know without experimenting myself.

In the world of being picky costing money, so far to make varnish, the ingredients are about $75 :\ Add the cost of epifanes (which appears to be spar varnish and not urethane - at least from what I can tell - but the MSDS sheets don't always tell you what you want to know because the manufacturers like to hide the resins as "trade secret").

I was surprised George would go so far afield in some cases, applying tru oil to a violin, etc, that would be a price equivalent of $10K now, but I suppose everyone likes to experiment. The last thing I ever want to spend time doing is stripping a finished project to refinish it, for something like a guitar, it's just a good opportunity to ding up or get an unexpected result, but in each case he mentioned something that didn't work like he wanted (behlen's spirit varnish, the purple S-W varnish, the tru-oil,...he said he ultimately stripped the violins and refinished them).

re: the hue, from the violin forums, it looks like a lot of the hobby builders and lower-aiming professional builders and instrument repair folks just accept it. I saw comments like "P&L has the purplish gray hue from the resins, but the results are good". I may be led astray a little bit based on george's pickiness about color (I'll never make an instrument that anyone would buy for more than the cost of materials), but might as well try to do it right.

I'll ultimately try waterlox at some point, though. It sounds like the kind of thing I'd like to put on furniture. Right now I always rub shellac and wax it, or for something more permanent, shellac under WB crosslinked lacquer, but I'd like to get away from spraying in general. It's fast, but I don't enjoy it.

I can say as a separate comment to all of this, if anyone ever wants a hard clear finish that pretty much goes over anything solvent, the two part cans of 2k finish are really fantastic - but since they're two part (there's a separate cell inside the can that you burst by pushing a plug on the bottom of the can through the cell), you have a short window to use the entire can (something like a day). This is interesting to me because fender intentionally used automotive paints on their guitars, and while I generally don't like that kind of look, it's good on a stratocaster.