Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dovetails

Posts

Dovetails

#1

Dovetails

Tony - Memphis

I've made a few dovetails over the years, but I'm not that great at them. My current project includes a small drawer that begged to be dovetailed. I'm using mahogany. My 'warm up' attempt was awful! I mean really bad. I made a few observations:

I discovered that my vise cheeks were nowhere close to being square to the bench top. Fixed that. (never noticed it before!)

Using an xacto to mark the pins (tails first here) did not work well for me. The tip seems to crawl under the tail a bit. I ended up using a knife I have that is flat on one side (Murphy knife - really too clunky for this, but it works - I double beveled the blade on it).

I needed to pay more attention to the saw being perpendicular to the board rather than following that angle. Also, saw perp to the board, not the vice cheek - the board could be a little angled to the vice face.

The blue tape method looked interesting. I tried it and I think I like it.

After all of this, my dovetails still aren't that great (I'll man up and post a pic later!), but I learned a few things. Derek's site was a big help -thanks Derek!

Oh, and I also sharpened my saw. Not a full blown sharpen, I just kissed the teeth (LN early DT saw). That really helped too.

I've had better luck than this, honest. I've cut a few that I am proud of. My first real DT heavy project was a low boy and I cut all the drawer half blinds by hand. But...those were pine into walnut,so cutting them a bit snug helped and also only one side was visible.

Anyway, I would like to practice and get better so that it was not such an ordeal to knock out a drawer, box, etc. I made a small wall cabinet for my wife a couple of years ago with half blinds and those things looked awful! They were good and tight, but they looked terrible. I was so ashamed. The good thing is, they are all hidden away behind molding...thank goodness.

One thing I think is important is to stick with a method. I understand, as with many things, that you correct to whatever method you use (marking knife, pencil, etc.) so stick with it.

Ok, I'm done. Thanks for listening. And for those that are still where I am, keep trying. Get the magnifier out and study your results and try and figure out what happened. It really isn't that hard of a concept! Thank goodness for 1.25 and 2.25 glasses! I think that may have been a factor last time I tried this! Light is good too.

Tony

Re: Dovetails

#2

Re: Dovetails

roger lance

Tony.....there are a lot of tools and aids out there to help a person make acceptable dovetails.....saws, chisels, marking knives, layout gauges, moxon vises, special goose neck lights, magnetic saw blade jigs, etc., etc.

But, the best aid of all is practice. Like anything else repetition.....repetition.....will equal better results. Think of the number of dovetails a Frank Klausz must have made in his career. Its really not all that amazing that he can cut dovetails as easily as he does.....and with such great results.

Keep practicing.

Re: Dovetails

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Dovetails

Jack Guzman from Maine

You said it best "stick to a method". Once you have that just practice. I learned from reading a booklet by Ian Kirby. In it he stresses repetition. Practice your saw cuts. often. Rob Cosman,another dovetailing "expert" states that he practices cutting dovetails often. It is a simple joint and easy to master. You just have to practice to get consistent results. When I was learning I dovetailed everything I built. Even birdhouses. Just for the practice.---Jack

Re: Dovetails

#4

Re: Dovetails

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony and all,

Great post! Practice one method is fine advice.

I’ll add one note. One would frequently hear the phrase ‘saw to the line’, and with that in mind I would get my nose down in the cut, trying to avoid that first little straying from the line.

Then one day, John McDonald who years ago would post on Badger Pond gave me the opposite advice. He said to stand back so that you can see the whole picture, the horizontal planes spreading out on either side of the saw cut, the plane the saw is making relative to the right angles of the work, and the marks on the work. In other words, look and think in planes, and get a comfortable distance back so you can see the planes.

Made a lot of difference!

Thanks for your post.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails

#5

Clint Searl

Re: Dovetails

Clint Searl

Countersunk trim head screws are a lot neater and quicker.

Re: Dovetails

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Dovetails

Jack Guzman from Maine

Yea but alot less fun

Re: Dovetails

#7

Re: Dovetails

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Tony, there are two factors I emphasise when sawing, whether it be dovetails or tenons, and all else ...

1. You have to see the lines clearly. That is why I use blue tape when transferring dovetails. If you have not tried this, then do so. There are articles on my website. Here is one: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/HalfBlindDovetailswithBlueTape.html

2. Saw against the line. A fine knife line, that is. The ideal is to just see the edge of the line remaining.

I'll add two more ..

3. When sawing, saw to two adjacent lines. That will keep you tracking straight. I have never practiced sawing. I just saw to the lines.

4. Go for it. Don't be conservative and saw away from the line. The more to tune, the greater to chances of creating an off-square wall.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails

#8

Re: Dovetails

William Duffield

When you say "two adjacent lines," it would be clearer, or at least more precise, if you said "two coplanar, perpendicular lines." (We usually find one of those lines on the face of the board and the other on the end of the board.)

Re: Dovetails

#10

Re: Dovetails

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is more efficient to cut straight across the top and establish a nice edge, then worry about following a line on the face of the board. The tooth line of the saw is always horizontal.

Re: Dovetails

#11

Re: Dovetails

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, cutting across the top is the first saw cut. I agree. But only enough to establish the kerf. Then angle the saw and work across the intersecting line. Works for me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails

#12

Re: Dovetails - Krenov Kludge

TomD

Not that I am advocating bad work, but if you finish your end grain with a file as Krenov showed in his book, something I did to be Uber finicky and perfect. Turns out it will hide many gaps that would otherwise take a playing card. Sometimes you get a set that you know are strong as the gates of Hell, yet a few gaps. filing the overhang will sort them out. it isn't mater of filling the gaps with glue and sawdust. It sorta peens the ends over.

Re: Dovetails

#13

Re: Dovetails - Krenov Kludge

Chris C

Hi Tom,

I've not tried a file, but do occasionally peen pins prior to leveling to achieve the same effect. Thanks for the file suggestion--I may try it, particularly for pins without much 'meat' to peen.

Best,

Chris

Re: Dovetails

#14

Re: Dovetails - Krenov Kludge

TomD

Cool.

He used a mill bastard file from the look of it. And he put a turn of tape on the end so one can bear down on the end and not gouge the wood. An MB file is slow in wood, so don't over do the projections, and half mm is all you need.

If you look at his details there are often very sensitive radii on edges, barely broken, but polished. These were also filed to blend with the plane work. Today, and back then with auto paper, you could sand these contours to the finish required but it would take even longer than files.