Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A carver's mallet......

Posts

A carver's mallet......

#1

A carver's mallet......

roger lance

Now, I know this is mundane......real basic.....but, there's not much going on here so to inject a little life, I just turned some scrap into a mallet.....






Just wanted a wood faced mallet sized between the other two. Love that scrap bin.....

Re: A carver's mallet......

#2

Re: A carver's mallet......

Mark Nowicki

Nice mallet, neat shop.

Need an "agent provocateur" to ask a sharpening question to liven up this place.....

Re: A carver's mallet......

#3

Re: A carver's mallet......

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a chunk of northern ironwood (which, I’m told, is a hornbeam) that is destined for the same fate.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#4

Sweet

Kevin French

Very nice mallets Roger.

I have a grove of Ironwood/Hornbeam

Time to get the saw out.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#5

Re: A carver's mallet......

Don Orr

Nice work on the mallet-good to have several sizes.

No offense but there were quite a few electrons sacrificed for a hand tool forum. ;) :D

Re: A carver's mallet......

#6

Re: A carver's mallet......

roger lance

No electrons were harmed in the making of this hand tool.

I'm a proud member of The Blended Woodworkers of America.....an organization that represents the vast majority of woodworkers as most woodworkers use both power and hand tools.....and we will not be silenced by those ridiculing our lack of purity in our woodworking efforts.

I'm part Norm.....and part Roy......and proud.....proud I say.

Besides, all of the power tools I own are getting old.....just like me.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#7

Re: A carver's mallet......

Kevin French

I make my own electrons.

10.03 Megawatts last year

Re: A carver's mallet......

#8

Re: A carver's mallet......

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Kevin,

We made around 18 MW per year for several years now with our photovoltaic system. Offsets ~80% of our electricity use. Yes, that's a lot of electricity for a home and shop, but it powers our geothermal heating and cooling system. Quite efficient during the air conditioning season, less so in the heating season. Our solar hot water heater also offsets the electricity usage.

John

Re: A carver's mallet......

#9

Re: A carver's mallet......

Kevin French

Nice system John, we have 24 panels on a tracker that produces 150% of what we use. We're going with Mini-splits for heating and cooling this year.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#10

Mini-splits

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Digressing a bit, Kevin: are you doing the installation yourself on those mini-splits? I've heard opinions that a competent civilian can do the installation and that no way should anyone but a professional do it. My bride's talking the need for one - we normally have a heat wave of three or four days every summer, but last summer we had four, longer than usual and with records being broken, so are considering air conditioning for the first time here, and a mini-split seems like the way to go.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#11

Questions, questions ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That is a very nice bit of work, Roger. I am very impressed with your turning. I have made a few of these carver-style mallets over the years, and for a time I used them. In the end I purchased Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce model, which is indestructible (resin-infused) ...


I used it for mortising ...


Here are two questions that lead from this ...

Firstly, this is a nice, hard head. There is no give at all. Can you tell the difference between the two types you have, and which do you prefer?

Secondly, Have you used a more traditional joiner's mallet? If so, which do you prefer, and why?

I moved from the carver type to a joiner type. I have two I use all the time, one most of the time. This is a modified Veritas cabinetmaker's hammer (I changed the handle and modified the head with UHMW ... but it is still a Veritas! :) ) ...


I find that I prefer the directness of the hammer blow compared with the carver mallet. They weigh much the same, so it has to do with the focussed energy from the smaller head.

The other mallet I made and use, when mortising into especially hard wood only (otherwise it is just too must effort - the mallet weighs 38 oz!) is this brass-infilled joiner's mallet. Heavy it is, but the handle design makes it very controllable. This is designed to be held at the end or choked up ...



Last question: do you consider the handle design when you make a mallet, and if so, what do you look for?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A carver's mallet......

#12

Re: A carver's mallet......

Don Orr

I was just goofing on you a little as I am also a blended woodworker. Nothing wrong with utilizing electrons bouncing back and forth through the grid. What ever gets the job done. I look at old hand tools as the original cordless tools, but have no problem employing the mysterious magic of electricity.

And again, very nice job on the mallet.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#13

Re: A carver's mallet......

roger lance

Don.....I was just goofin' back.....I'm told I'm getting crankier as I get older.....but, no evidence of that as far as I know..... :(

Re: A carver's mallet......

#14

Re: Mini-splits

Kevin French

I've heard you can self-install them, but that's what low-interest energy loans are for. Let the Pros do it.

We have the same 2 or 3 hot days a year, most likely 2 or 3 days after you do and we don't have a central heating system. My wife took out the oil furnace during the 1st Gulf War and we heat only with a Pellet Stove and a Wood Stove. So the M-S is prefect for us and on the really cold nights we'll still have the wood stove.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#15

Re: Mini-splits

david weaver

If you have four or five hours of time, a distance of less than 25 feet and only one head, you should do the installation yourself if you can follow directions.

The literature that comes with the split systems is clear, and I found that I would've followed it more closely than the installers did in my instance.

Here's the aspects of my situation:

* Bought a Mitsubishi mini split through my contractor when having an exterior patio made permanent (stripped to posts and then turned into a real room with insulation, etc.). Cost for the split from the plumbing supply place (including lines) $2125. 15K btu, 21 SEER (it's been superb for the last four years so far).

* Contractor's HVAC guy said "I'll install anything that you get for $750", so I let them do it

* Electrician cost to run a 220 line to my split system location and install a whip disconnect was about $225.

total cost, including electrical work was $3100.

I also got a quote from an authorized mitsubishi dealer, and it was just shy of $6000. Highway robbery.

This should strike anyone as an odd thing - that's bordering on the cost of furnace and whole house air conditioner in my area (that's probably 8K).

Authorized installer also insisted on another $400 of plastic to cover the line in the interior (I boxed that in with pine and stain matched it to the flooring in the room). The installer's line when I questioned the price was "we have a lot of overhead".

If it's to be done again (if this unit poops out), I will order a unit off of the internet and install it myself. The only challenge with the units after you choose location is basic drilling and following instructions. If the paper instructions don't come with your unit, they are available via PDF online, no problem. I mentioned 25 feet, because most units come precharged (maybe all do), but mine stated in the instructions that it would require additional coolant if the lines to the interior unit were longer than 25 feet. You can probably plan around that in most cases to avoid going over 25 feet.

The lowest prices you see online are probably what the units will cost at a local plumbing supply place, so when you get quotes and the salesman is evasive about the actual costs of the unit, you'll know why. there's probably little that a mechanical service contractor can do that's easier money than installing these.

(no part of my 15k btu unit is heavy enough that you can't just lift it, either - they're really a dandy technology - and in my opinion, there's no good reason to give someone else $3500 for four hours of work. The terms of my unit give me a warranty regardless of who installs it. The "authorized installer" adds on 2 more years of parts warranty for the extra charge, but not labor. I'd hate to see what their labor charge would be on "warranty" service of a 6 year-old machine. I'll just replace mine if i'm that unlucky).

Re: A carver's mallet......

#16

Re: Questions, questions ..

roger lance

Derek.....I want to thank you for complementing my wood turning.....it gave me a good laugh.....the lathe and I are only occasionally able to get something made.

Dave Jeske's mallets are works of art.....truly beautiful.....but, there's something inside most all of us that compels an attempt at making our own.....and I had the right pieces of scrap.....so.....

I'm actually a novice at this mallet business.....I've never used a traditional jointer's mallet.....basically, I've had two mallets that I've used for my wood working.....


I've used the wood one for chisels.....dovetailing, etc.....and on other tools that should not be struck with a metal hammer like lathe dead centers. The other mallet is for case assembly as it will not dent (not so far) a furniture part that needs some perswasion to fit.

Of the two types of carver's mallets I have, I recently came to own the mallets from Wood Is Good on the advise that the 'rubberized' head made less noise when striking a tool (those guys must be spending a lot of time in their shops).....and secondly, off-center mallet strikes still have some griping of the tool being hit with that rubber coating. I just made the wood mallet and have yet to use it. I do like the Wood Is Good mallets.....but, we're talking about very short strikes of a tool.....very controlled.....they feel good in my hand.....balanced.

When it came time to make the handle for my mallet, I thought of you and the lesson you gave about tool ergonomics.....that tools should fit the human hand as well as they can to let the hand move in its most natural position.


Years ago, you helped me evolve the fence of my cutting gauge from something crude into a fence resembling one made by a Japanese master that was very comfortable to hold and control. After sampling various handles in my shop, I decided to replicate the Wood Is Good handle. I found that those two narrow portions of that handle were functional.....if I choke-up on the handle, my thumb and forefinger curl around that narrow area near the tool head giving a great grip and control.....and, if I move my hand to the end of the handle, my pinky finger curls into that narrow for a better grip. Ergonomics 101....but, at least, you got me in class.....

Re: A carver's mallet......

#17

Re: Mini-splits

Kevin French

We're looking at 4 heads on 3 floors, one of which will push the 25' limit.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#18

Re: Mini-splits

David Weaver

If it gets complicated and routing the lines is an issue, then you might need to have someone else do it. If you're just installing a head or two close to a unit, then there's not much to the installation.

Also, the coolant is some kind of low volume high pressure setup, so it requires different gadgetry than an older style a/c. Thus the comment about 25 feet being a hurdle, since no extra coolant charge is needed below that.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#19

Re: Questions, questions ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

It's been so quiet here. My reply to your post was - like yours - an attempt to drum up some discussion. I thought some might respond to discussing design, ergonomics and preferred mallet types. mmmm ... no response.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A carver's mallet......

#20

Re: OK, Some Comments:

William Duffield

I like Roger's design, for several reasons:

Compared to using a single block of wood to turn the whole mallet (like I usually do), this wastes a lot less of the thick stock.

Two different species can be chosen to optimize the mallet's performance. For example, ash or hickory can be used for the handle, for the same reasons they are used for hammer, axe and shovel handles. Lignum vitae can be chosen for the head, for its density. Alternately, hornbeam can be used for the head, for it's ability to take blows on the face grain without chipping or splintering. A different species, for example hophornbeam, would be optimal for a joiner's mallet, which needs to take blows on the end grain.

Roger's design makes it easy to add additional mass to the head. Simply drill the handle hole deeper and drop in an iron bar or lead shot before gluing the handle in place.

I always turn the end of the head flat or slightly concave so I can stand it on end on the bench. It makes it easy to pick up and set back down without it rolling off the bench. To minimize chipping of the outside top corners, I bevel them before flattening the rest of the top. This is the same principle used to shape the bottoms of chair legs.

I turned these from dogwood, Cornus florida, and cocobolo, Dalbergia retusa.


The ring between the handle and the head is very useful to locate the thumb and one finger to choke up on the mallet a controlled distance, depending on which finger you choose, for controlling small precise taps. I also like the make the knob on the end of the handle a little larger diameter than the end of the grip, so it gives me a tactile indication that the mallet is sliding out of my hand, and I can reflexively grip it tighter before I lose it onto the floor. The handle diameters of these two are designed for different size hands, to maximize the effectiveness of the grip. Your hand should not quite close completely around the handle when you grip it as tightly as possible. Making the diameter either much larger or much smaller requires a tighter grip and is therefore more tiring.

Re: A carver's mallet......

#21

Re: OK, Some Comments:

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks William. Your mallets are beautiful.

What tasks do you use your carver's mallet for? Across the board, or selective tasks? And have you compared these to a cabinetmaker/joiner-type mallet? If so, what are your observations?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A carver's mallet......

#22

Re: More mallets, and Answers

William Duffield

Another cocobolo mallet


A bloodwood mallet


A collection of several different mallets I use for different purposes:


On top is a black locust maul or beetle I use with a froe for riving. Hornbeam, Carpinus carolinensis, would be a much better choice for this purpose, if you can find a 2' long 4x4.

From left to right:

1) Rubber shot filled dead blow hammer. For setting and releasing Gramercy holdfasts. For test fitting joinery, including Dominos. It leaves black marks, so I don't use it for final assembly of joinery.

2) Hophornbeam carver's mallet: This is my favorite. I use it for chopping mortises and dovetails, striking carving gouges, assembling joinery, setting holdfasts, etc.

3) Chester Toolworks plane hammer: for adjusting wooden planes and setting Dominos.

4) Hard Maple carving mallet. I made this one over 20 years ago from Shop Notes plans, don't use it much anymore because it is a little too large and heavy. It still works well for persuading pig stickers.

5) Red oak joiner's mallet. This is the first thing I ever turned, also from Shop Notes plans. I used to use it for joinery, but now mostly use it for setting lathe spur centers.

6) Purpleheart carving mallet: I use this one at SAPFM outreach events, for the same functions as my Ostrya virginiana mallet, and let other people use it, becasue I'm not afraid of damaging or losing it.