Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Counter Stool prototype completed

Posts

Counter Stool prototype completed

#1

Counter Stool prototype completed

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The seat went through at least 4 re-builds. It looks like Swiss cheese (with the holes plugged) as the rake and splay were modified a few times. In the end I preferred 11 degrees rake front-and back with 10 degrees of splay on the front legs.



To answer the question which leg preference my wife had, it was the 3-legged stool. The 4-legged was "too much like a stool". :\

The other question was whether 3 legs would be stable. The short answer is I could dance on this stool and it will not tip over. Solid.

All the legs were tied together with stretchers that had wedged through mortice-and-tenons. The leg-into-seat were tapered at 7 degrees. The stretchers-into-stretchers were straight. All tenons ended at 5/8".


I spent some time comparing the 7 degree reamer and tenon rounder (taperer) I made versus the 12 degree versions from Veritas. I shall post pictures at another time. What I can say is that - in my short experience! - is that the Veritas tools worked amazingly well. Mine worked well too - slower, which is a good thing when you are needing to be careful. Nevertheless, I ended up using my tools as I found the 12 degree taper was not as secure as the 7 degree taper. It would be great is Lee Valley offered these tools in 6 degrees (my tools aimed at 6 degrees but I managed 7 degrees).

The prototype ended like this ...




In the end, my wife decided that this design was "ho-hum" ... just not in keeping enough with the more modern designs I build. :O

So back to the drawing board!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#2

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

roger lance

"(this stool is so stable)....I could dance on it and it would not tip over. Solid."

Now, that would make a YouTube video worth watching!

It's a great looking prototype. I'm looking forward to seeing how you'll top it.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#3

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don’t see anything “ho hum” about it. Very nice work. I like the profile of the seat’s edge a lot.

Thomas Moser makes a nice three-legged stool, too.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#4

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Jim Matthews

It's difficult to reduce a form like this, any farther.

I wonder if Mdme. Cohen would accept the current shaping in a different species? Something where the legs blended into the "bar" by color match would make the seat pan appear to float above the floor.

I wish to achieve results half so fine as your cast offs.

Kudos

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#5

Clint Searl

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Clint Searl

The faceting on the seat is most appealing. Would that the legs&stretchers also display subtle faceting in the "production" models.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#10

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

david weaver

Hi Derek - how about something a little bit more progressive for the stretchers, such as this style, but still with the trim turned-style stretchers that you have.

http://www.ana-white.com/2015/04/free_plans/vintage-style-three-legged-stool

I see that the type of stretcher that you installed is quite common, but it interrupts the center of the legs visually without being interesting where it interrupts. I think something that's intentionally there, or perhaps three stretchers going around the legs, but not meeting at the same points, would be more visually interesting.

To be more clear about the second suggestion, it would result in stretchers that were on a slant, like 10 degrees or so. Each would attach at a spot on the leg, and perhaps the next stretcher on the other side would be 1 1/2 inches or so below and incline up to the same spot on the next leg over.

Or all three could just be at different levels on the leg - not sloppily so, but just a little bit different (I went to google image and eshrick had a stool like this - it looks quite nice).

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#11

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

david weaver

The comment about "intentionally there" probably isn't clear. By that, I mean making what's happening in the stretcher area a point of visual interest, one where you draw attention to something interesting (like the three stretchers that tie in one leg and then into the center of the next stretcher)

Also, I think the leg taper would be more attractive if the bulge was right in the middle or slightly closer to the top or bottom with no abrupt tapering on an end and no bulge too close to one end or another. Might not have been an option with pine, but should be fine with maple.

Not that there's anything wrong with the stool, but I know you and the mrs are hoping for something that stands out a little bit, but in a tasteful way.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#12

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

50+ years of married bliss inform me that, when she says ‘the problem with that stool is that it looks too much like a stool’, it means she wants it to look more like a chair, like with some kind of back or even arm rests :) .

Caveat: No guarantees express or implied; not responsible for consequential damages; invalid outside the US; cannot be combined with other offers, yadda yadda etc etc. Please continue.

Wiley

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#14

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the ideas, David.

The stretcher design is complicated because the stool needs a footrest. The prototype is really comfortable for me. It is the ideal height for me as I can rest my feet on the ground. However my wife needs the footrest to feel secure ..... otherwise I had ideas of raising the stretchers to a position about a quarter below the seat, and using three rather than two sections.

I am actually secretly (well, not so secretly now :) ) relieved as this gives me an opportunity to come up with something different. I like that challenge. I learned a great deal in a short space of time doing this stool. For example, getting the stretchers in position with through mortice and tenons needed the development of a new technique. Learning about resultant angles for the legs took some time to get my head around. And then there were the tools I built. I'm having lots of fun.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#15

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

david weaver

I think eshrick's design looks nice (the stretchers at three different levels) if you still need one in the front for a foot rest (which I also prefer, too, and is sometimes missing on stools). The 10 degrees off idea that I proposed wouldn't be that nice for a foot rest since both feet would be at different levels.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#16

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Brian Holcombe

Derek, as a point of reference I have Barstools that have the rear legs attached without stretchers. I don’t know the particulars of how the legs are attached beyond the fact that they are Mortise and Tenon.

The stools are strong and do not splay to a noticeable degree when they are sat upon.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#17

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Charlie

I like it. What about the Jacobean-looking piece it's sitting in front of?

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#18

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

AlanWS

It looks good to me, particularly with regard to function. The front stretcher looks like a footrest, which I like if it is. I interpret the comment about looking like a stool as looking too ordinary, not that an armchair is needed.

One thing that might dress it up and that might fit your aesthetic would be to subtly curve the legs. I am thinking a gentle curve that makes them meet the floor closer to square might be interesting. The inside surface of the leg could become almost straight. I might make the the leg taper a bit more gentle as well -- continuous over its entire length so you don't see as abrupt a transition below the stretcher.

If she doesn't like the seat, I have no suggestion. I like it.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#19

Drilling the mortices

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here is the drilling of the mortices ...

The stretcher is placed in a set of holders (the jig is Pete Galbert's work) which are held in a vice ...



Not the blue tape with the "line". That is the orientation for the mortice. I arrived at this by using a spirit level, and simply marked a line along it.

Next is to orientate the stretcher so that the line is vertical ...


A square guides the brace and bit ...


I am using Owl bits here (purchased from Lee Valley, made in Japan). There have three cutting edges rather than the two of the Jennings I usually use.


They create very clean holes ...


As always, drill until the lead screw pokes out from the other side, then turn it over and complete the mortice from the rear.

A tip using braces and bits in hard wood. Drill a pilot hole (1/16" dril bit) through the work. That will not only guide the bit, but enable the lead screw to bite into the wood.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#20

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What about the Jacobean-looking piece it's sitting in front of?

Thanks Charles.

The "Jacobean-looking piece" is a dropfront desk that belonged to my grandfather.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#21

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The front stretcher looks like a footrest, which I like if it is. I interpret the comment about looking like a stool as looking too ordinary, not that an armchair is needed.

Thanks for the comments Alan.

The front stretcher was indeed placed there to act as a footrest. All counter stools must have a footrest as they are otherwise too high for comfortable sitting for most.

One thing that might dress it up and that might fit your aesthetic would be to subtly curve the legs. I am thinking a gentle curve that makes them meet the floor closer to square might be interesting. The inside surface of the leg could become almost straight. I might make the the leg taper a bit more gentle as well -- continuous over its entire length so you don't see as abrupt a transition below the stretcher.

The next version will have the legs 1" longer and the taper with be slightly slimmer. I will give some attention to the transitions. In this one I was taking a cue from similar versions I have seen by Pete Galbert. I was not too fussed about small details as I just wanted to establish a basic design to work with.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#22

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Charlie

I'd love to hear more about it.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#23

Desk

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

Not much to say. This was my owned by my mother's parents, and has many memories attached to it. It used to live in their study room.

It's a nice Jacobean desk, well made .. if the dovetailed drawers are anything to go by :)

I took these with my iPhone. Not great photos ...



(you may spy a Paul Hamler plough plane on top :) )

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#24

Re: Desk

Charlie

I love it. Thanks for the pics. Very charming piece.

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

#25

Clint Searl

Re: Counter Stool prototype completed

Clint Searl

Shucks. Also, the visual texture of the pine argues for it's use in the "productions."