Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

Posts

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#26

Clearance

Patrick Chase

You're right that a BD plane with a 20 deg bed is impractical, and that was certainly a typo on David's part. He's far too knowledgeable to actually think that.

With that said, you don't need anything like 12 deg of clearance for most woods. Hardwoods can go down into the low/mid single digits, and many softwoods can as well.

A bit of food for thought: Bevel-up spokeshaves typically have only a few degrees of clearance (difference between angle of the toe and the back of the iron) and yet they work quite well on most species.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#27

Re: you asked -- sorry, but you're wrong

david weaver

I meant a 20 degree bed bevel up like the LN 9. Sorry for the confusion.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#28

Re: sorry, but you're wrong- you don't need 12 deg

TomD

One of my most successful planes was a 30 degree bevel set at 35 degrees. Worked really well. The idea you need 12 degrees of clearance angle is one of those things one has to wonder how many people really tried.

Despite building this plane around 1982, I mostly do the 25 degrees at 45 degrees thing. But when you think about is a stouter bevel is more supported, and runs out to a finer scratch pattern at the edge of the tool. Old habits die hard.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#29

Zero

Mark Hennebury

Trust no one, Question everything, Experiment, Observe, Analyze, Verify.

Zero relief angle, blade was honed in the plane by lapping the sole, tight throat, cuts fine. I am not saying that it is the way to set your plane, just showing that there is no mystical perfect number for a relief angle.





Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#30

Re: Zero

Brian Holcombe

That’s awesome!

Relief angle gets pretty narrow for me on some Kanna I’ve cut with low angles. Definetly under 10 degrees, but probably no less that 6-7 degrees. They don’t cut forever though, they run out of clearance with moderate wear.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#31

Re: Zero

Mark Hennebury

Hi Brian,

i should have said zero-ish as technically it changes as you adjust the shaving thickness, and will still cut at negative clearance. which it would be if you lap it in the plane then tap the blade down. if you push down on the front of the plane when starting the cut it would be zero, but as the plane progresses over the cut area and you apply pressure to the back handle, technically the plane would tilt back the thickness of the shaving making the clearance a negative angle. So a very small honed edge would be best. And of course as you say the as the edge degraded it would not cut well for long. With the Japanese planes are a little different as the soles are not flat

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#32

Re: Zero

Brian Holcombe

That’s amazing that it does work especially when you consider the minor tilting effect.. Also true wrt Japanese planes which are all infeed table and no outfeed. :D And with a hollow I’m sure they flex throughout the cut in all but the lightest cuts.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#33

Re: sorry, but you're wrong- you don't need 12 deg

david weaver

12 degrees is probably something someone came up with in regard to a cycle of work before sharpening. Either that, or they took common pitch and subtracted the lowest angle where an iron fails only by wear (which is somewhere around 33 degrees for most irons).

I've had less, but as Brian said, frequent sharpening is necessary, unless you want to lean on the plane.

In this plane, I'm going to shoot for 30 degrees bevel and 10 clearance, but I sharpen freehand, so that just equates to "a little less" steep than I normally sharpen bevel down. Or who knows what....I'll just do whatever works well assuming the plane ends up being a plane that works.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#34

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

david weaver

The shell for starters:

about 14 1/2 inches long, 2 7/8" wide (external) - I stepped up the iron width to somewhere between 2 3/8 and 2 7/16".

Due to a measuring error, the sides will be about 2.7" all or a hundredth or two less (oops). I had intended for the thing to be closer to square but mis-marked the baseline for the tails by a sixteenth.


I bought one of those portable metal bandsaws from HF, and it works surprisingly well, but the blade only made it a little more than halfway through this shell (and I have no spares), so back to the hacksaw. I like the hand work enough that I don't know if I have a preference either way, but the cheap bandsaw saves some time. If you've seen one of those and you're wondering how you can use it, if you have a decent machinist vise with soft jaws, you just clamp the thing into the vise and put a quick release clamp on the trigger to keep it going. they have a tiny stamped table.

This picture is before filing secondary angles in the pins and tails. I've got a couple of gaps bigger than I'd like, but that always seems to happen. We'll see if it all comes out in the wash peining - hopefully, I can get them all closed.

The mouth is located (marked from the inside) about 1/3rd of the way from the front. I'd like to make it more interesting than a brick, but I think that's probably the most sensible given that it'll be a little used plane. I'd like to round the infill that goes in it, at least, we'll see. That might interfere with a track, and for simplicity, it may be easier to just give in and make it a brick. The skew should at least make it look a little bit more interesting.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#35

bevel up  -- thanks for the clarification


Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#36

That's what I do in 40 deg planes

Patrick Chase

FWIW I also use 30 deg cutting edges in my BD planes with 40 deg beds.

I have two smoothers, a 4 and a 4-1/2, configured with 40 deg frogs. I don't see much trouble with accelerated wear when using them on hardwoods, but I also use a notably abrasion-resistant steel (PM-V11).

On a related note, when I've used O1 irons in these same planes I've found that I prefer 28 deg edges. O1 is more prone to wear bevel formation but also more tolerant of low edge angles, and those two considerations may shift the optimum a bit (or I may just be imagining things. It's not like I did a double-blind trial).

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#37

Yes, but for how long?

Patrick Chase

As David alludes in a separate reply, you can initially get away with very low clearance angles. As I pointed out in yet another reply low-angle shaves are invariably operating with a couple degrees of clearance, and as you found you can go lower still.

The catch is that eventually a wear bevel will form and further reduce effective clearance. How quickly that happens depends on both the wood and the steel, specifically the latter's balance of abrasion resistance vs other attributes, which determines whether a wear bevel is likely to become objectionable before other failures modes like chipping or outright dulling. It also depends on how willing you are to press a recalcitrant plane into the cut.

So as usual, my opinion is that there is no single right answer. It depends.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#38

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

david weaver

Not that anyone is looking at this (I can tell, the posts where you talk about making something don't get much press - but that's sort of understandable given that they're more statements than anything else), but in case someone wonders why there's a stub pin on one side of the plane and not the other, here's why:

The sole of an infill plane needs to end with pins on both ends. The mouth area also needs to have pins on each end of the mouth. Normally, you'd take a straight-ironed plane and lay out the pins and tails on both sides and mark them at the same time. If this plane had brass sides, it would look funny (but the stub pin side is the side that will be down on the shooting board), but brass is sticky feeling compared to steel, so I didn't use it. It is a bit easier to work with using only hand tools (cuts really easily, you can literally cut it with a coping saw).

Anyway, on a skew-mouthed plane, you can't lay the pins and tails out identically. you have to lay out the pins at the sides of the mouth and then work from there. For me (laziness), this becomes a situation where I stop and go back up to my computer and lay out the pins and tails precisely by taking the remaining measurements between the three must-be-pins at the ends of the plane and at the mouth and doing a neat job dividing up the space, or ....more realistically, I just lay them out by eye, flip the plane over and if I end up with a pygmy pin or tail, that's just the end of it. I don't intend for the dovetails to show after draw filing and finishing the metal, so they should be invisible. I have a lot of planes on my rack.

The more important thing is that the pins and tails fit the files that I have on hand. Pen and paper and calculator (or spreadsheet) would've been required if the sides were brass. I'm not using a mill, so the pins don't all have the same angle, either. I cut them square and then file the tail taper on them by eye (pins first).

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#39

Track clearance

Patrick Chase

Not sure what you're planning to use for a track, but the near-ubiquitous LV ones have a 1/4" high adjustable backstop that registers to the top edge of the plane body. When I've made my own in the past I've used 1/4 ply or 1/8 hardboard for the same purpose. Either of those would prevent you from extending the infill in an "overstuffed" manner, if that's what you were alluding to.

As I'm sure you know you can use a shooting track without a backstop, and I sometimes do. You just need to be careful to keep the entire length of the plane biased to the front edge of the track, just as you would with a bench hook.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#40

Re: Track clearance

David weaver

I'll probably make a 1/8th track of some sort. I don't like using purchased goods for something like this, and may make a beech chute board if the plane is nice. That's many hours away at this point, though.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#41

Re: (skew shooting infill) - little bit more

david weaver

Still haven't gotten the Veritas plane out of the box (and want to, just haven't done it), but there's no great reason that I'd have needed it thus far due to the infill building.

https://s13.postimg.org/pdy9qr4fr/02112018_169.jpg

I've got the mouth opened, still need to work back a little bit to remove my error of haste in overcutting the back ramp on the mouth, but I have plenty of room.

I cut and tapered an iron (yes, you read that right) from quarter inch O1, and beveled the sides so that it will fit in the plane without looking garish. Also tapered in its width. Not exactly machinist accuracy, but reasonable hand accuracy, tapered about a 16th in width to the top of the plane body, and about a 16th in thickness.

The mock pine infill is just laid in the plane to assist with laying out where the brass cross strap (for the wedge) will go. I'm sure it's possible to measure those things and mark them, but just miles safer to make quick wooden patterns for the parts and lay out from reference.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#42

Re: The LV Shooting Plane

david weaver

I finally got the LV shooting plane out of the box last night and tried it (no reason to get it out if you're just building another plane).

It's spectacular. Quite possibly the best working plane of any type that I've ever gotten.

Not sure why I'm trying to build an infill shooting plane at this point. If I can't match it, I'll resent the infill a little bit, and if I do match it, then I'll have to unload the LV plane (but I like how well it works and don't really want to!).

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#43

Re: (skew shooting infill) - little bit more

Steve Voigt

Dave, how'd you taper the iron without a mill? Grinder?

It looks like you have two layers of steel underneath the "infill." Did you rivet a a piece on top of the sole to support the blade?

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#44

Re: (skew shooting infill) - little bit more

david weaver

The tapering is done using the drum on a belt sander and a coarse belt - with a bucket of water nearby. It takes about an hour (higher belt speed and more powerful belt sander, and it could be much faster), so it's not exactly good policy for more than a couple of blades.

I consolidated the work of the belt sander with a bowed-out vixen file on a wooden handle. Bowed so as to create a slight hollow across the width (if anything) as well as along the length. The iron is 0.26 at the business end, 0.2 at the far end, and between 0.22 and 0.23 about 40% of the way up from the edge.

Any error in hand grinding the taper will be taken care of in bedding the iron (since we have that option, and since this isn't an iron that is going to wear quickly). If there is an error, it'll be measurable on a diagonal as a few thousandths. Poor for a machine tool, but better than many vintage irons.

Yes on the sole plate - It's peined in place with 3 rivets made of 3/16th steel. If the sole was 1/4" thick, it wouldn't have been needed, but at 3/16ths, it might be iffy. it should still work at that if clearance on the primary is only 15 degrees, but more is better, and that kind of bedding seems to be common.

I can't remember what I calculated the mouth opening to be, but it doesn't really matter - I'll pattern that instead to be sure, and then open it once the plane is assembled to control it at about 6 thousandths or so (hopefully). that's always the last step. It's easier to hit a zero mouth than it is with a wooden plane, because everything happens more slowly.

I should've been more careful roughing the sole (where the hollow spot is), but that work is so physical that you sometimes get lost in the effort while you're doing it, and the urge to stop and check isn't strong enough.

If one made a couple of these and had...say...a shaper, they could be made profitably. I say a shaper because it would be nice to bias the bottom side a little bit thick at the top vs. where the dovetails are so that you'd end up with a favorable situation before squaring (you can do the metal removal up away from the tails, which eliminates the risk of finding pinholes in the dovetail fit, which requires careful closing and then removal of a little bit more, hoping at the same time that removal of the light peining marks doesn't make a pinhole show up elsewhere.

In a completely tooled up machinist type setup, you could control the precision of the dovetail fit a lot better and not have any of that, but my last plane is pinhole free with completely invisible dovetails.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#45

Re: The LV Shooting Plane

Patrick Chase

I was very curious to see how you'd respond to that plane.

I like mine quite a lot, and I think that they absolutely nailed the functionality and ergonomics. At the same time it's an "aggressively nontraditional" design, and those can be quite polarizing.

FWIW I have a second iron for that plane that's back-beveled by a few degrees, reducing clearance immediately behind the edge to 9-10 deg. I did that to beef up the edge a little while preserving the plane's end-grain cutting performance. The only catch with doing that is that you have to refresh the back-bevel every so often to prevent loss of clearance from wear bevel.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#46

Re: The LV Shooting Plane

david weaver

I can't repeat the phrase my old guitar teacher would've used for it, but it's fantastic. For the price, I don't care about the aesthetics, but I think they like their aesthetic, so that's up to them. It's not like they're sloppy about manufacturing or anything.

I'm not shocked that the plane works well, but once you use it, it's just like "man, I have to start referring to my wooden shooter as a man's plane, because you have to put your man pants on to be able to use it and get a square edge."

The LV plane, you could talk to your broker (if you're not as cheap as me and actually use a broker) and be completely distracted and just slip it through the wood.

I got the V11 iron, only because I figured if I was going to come up with an O1 iron (or rikizai), I'll make it myself and temper it really hard and see how it works out.

I prepped the V11 iron on a new-to-me ohira suita that cost a multiple of the plane (that's an indulgence, of course), and for some reason, it shredded the V11 very easily and brought it to a bright polish with no semblance of a wire edge. There's a strange mark on the back of my iron that I'll have to sharpen a few times to see if it might be a crack, or if I just somehow managed to run it over something and scratch it deeply. The iron itself is one that would be very easy to make by hand. Short slot and two drill holes.

Great plane, though. Fantastic. I have little chance of matching it with a bevel down wedged plane, but I'm not giving up yet.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#47

Re: The LV Shooting Plane

Gary B.

This plane is on my wish list. I find all of your comments regarding it very amusing. I've never told the below story until now... :D

At IWF in 2016, I was tired from a long day of walking the show floor and came upon the Lee Valley booth. It was the first time I saw that plane, and one of the booth attendants had a freshly sharpened iron in it. They had a piece of 3/4" stock (can't remember the species) on the shooting board. I probably stood there for who knows how long, peeling shaving after shaving of end grain. It felt like Nirvana. It was a bit embarrassing regaining consciousness and becoming aware of the crowd surrounding me.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#48

Re: The LV Shooting Plane

david weaver

That pretty much describes the feel. If I were them, I'd try to use mahogany for the demos. Lots of heavy very capable planes sell really well when you put them on compliant wood!

Most of the infill demonstrations that I've seen are planing down grain on a stick less wide than the iron itself (though letting the general public try to keep a board flat and take overlapping strokes would probably be a mistake).