Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

Posts

Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#1

Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

david weaver

..looking more for advice from people who have built or designed a few tools.

I'm thinking of attempting to make a 20 degree bed bevel down skewed infill shooting plane. I do not have machine tools and I don't lay out plans ahead of time other than generalities (it's easier to "fit things" as you go along).

I have a big wooden shooting plane that excels if the shavings are a few thousandths each, but it's a bit of a trick to get it to cut dead square thinner than that.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSusq2iW14o

Style of the infill would just be square body like this (but smaller), and I would need to make the iron (which isn't a problem). It would also give me a chance to try a tongue and groove bottom and a bridged wedge, both things I haven't done yet.

I think a skewed version of the plane above would work well, but the only thing I don't love about the setup is that the end grain really erodes the sole near the mouth (which probably doesn't help the fine work).

The other option is to build a bevel down skew infill (brese builds a straight cutting infill for a princely sum and people seem to love it), but I'm fairly sure that the bevel up orientation is superior for shooting in terms of what's going on with the iron when it's in the cut. It may be that a quarter inch thick iron negates some of the oscillation that occurs in the cut, don't know.

Thoughts?

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#2

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

A while back, I put the Veritas Shooting plane and the Lie Nielsen #51 head-to-head. Both planes run on the Stanley #52 shooting board, and both planes are skewed at 20 degrees. The only difference is the Veritas is BU (12 degree bed) and the LN is BD (45 degree bed).

A number of different blades were used: A2 from each manufacturer (and at both 25- and 30 degrees in the LN), PM-V11 (used in both planes), and a few others.

The long and short of it was that the Veritas BU plane left the LN BD plane for dead in terms of edge longevity when shooting hardwood end grain. The article is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/LVShootingPlane.html


It was my conclusion that a low bed angle does less damage to the blade edge than a high(er) bed angle. If you are going to build a shooting plane, build one with a low bed.

The next question is whether the low bed can be BD, rather than BU?

The answer is yes. I built a strike block plane with a 38 degree bed. With a 25 degree bevel, there is 13 degrees of clearance. More than enough. Might even get away with a 30 degree bevel ... however my experience with the Veritas BU planes (LA Jack and Shooting Plane), which both use a 25 degree bevel, demonstrates that the 25 degree bevel (even with A2) is safe as a bank. I have over 10 years of using A2 at 25 degrees in a LA Jack without any chipping. In short, a 25 degree bevel is a safe bet, as long at the bed angle is low.


The other plane I have used for shooting is a Veritas Custom #7 with a 40 degree frog. The bevel was 30 degrees (PM-V11), and this was equally a good combination.

Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#3

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

david weaver

Derek - do you think that the low bed negates the difference in wear entirely between BU and BD? I'm guessing that in end grain cuts, there is more iron oscillation on BD vs. BU, but that's all I'm doing saying that - guessing.

In the end, you can use a 50 degree bedded vintage iron and if you're good at sharpening, the edge retention doesn't really matter.

However, I am applying a bit higher of a standard if I am going to spend 50 hours making a plane (potentially more) - it should incorporate anything I'm aware of.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#4

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

do you think that the low bed negates the difference in wear entirely between BU and BD? I'm guessing that in end grain cuts, there is more iron oscillation on BD vs. BU, but that's all I'm doing saying that - guessing.

David, Veritas A2 with a 25 degree bevel (in the BU plane) easily managed 60 shavings, while LN A2 with a 30 degree bevel - an advantage over 25 degrees (in the BD plane) barely made 30 shavings ... about half the longevity. The results were the same with PM-V11 in both planes.

That says to me that the low bed was responsible for the difference.

In the end, you can use a 50 degree bedded vintage iron and if you're good at sharpening, the edge retention doesn't really matter.

I used to use a HNT Gordon Trying Plane for shooting. This has a 60 degree bed. One can shoot with a plane like this, but the edge does not last as long as a 12 degree bed LA Jack. A sharp edge can do wonders for any plane. What you want is a plane that does wonder with an average edge.

One more point: in a shooting plane, mass is relevant. More mass is better (within reason). A LV LA Jack will outshoot a LN #9 mitre plane: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#5

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

david weaver

Thanks, Derek. I'm still curious as to whether or not the bed type itself may be responsible for some of the difference in edge longevity, but I'm not going to build two planes to experiment. I think I'll build bevel up just for the challenge.

Yes on the mass. My wooden plane is extraordinarily heavy. The first end grain shaving that I measured was something like 5 thousandths, and I was shocked. Because of it's two-bed design, I can't really go shallower on the angle on it, and want to go skew on the next one, anyway, so as not to have to give it a horseplay type thump to get it started on a cut like that.

But, infill first, and two birds with one stone - or maybe three (a wedged infill with a strap, skew and bevel up). It will have to be something more like 20 degrees bedded (for practicality hand filing and scraping the metal bits around the mouth) and I would suppose total weight will end up being in the 8 to 10 pound category. Not because I want a ten pound plane, but in the size that I'm going to make, that's just what it will be.

(I could chicken out at the last second on any of this and make it bevel down, though - it wouldn't be a deal breaker, and layout issues with such a long iron protruding from an infill wouldn't need working around - as in, the plane could be taller in side/cheek height...

....Now I'm starting to revise to thinking 40 degree skew bevel down might be the way to go, or perhaps 42 - I'll have to make a mock up, as it will change bevel clearance to turn it askew).

A smart labor-saving idea would just be to buy LV's skew plane, I doubt I can make one that performs better than that one, but sometimes I'm just looking for weird instead. Or, I could do both.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#6

LV skew shooter

david weaver

I just ordered the LV skew shooter. That'll give me a decent target to aim for (no shooting pun implied!) in terms of performance.

I'm sure that if I come up with something I prefer (most likely preference being due to "i made it" bias), then it won't cost much to have rented it temporarily.

If I come up with a dog, I'll sell it on ebay disclosing that it's a handsome plane that doesn't perform as well as LV's (it may sound like I'm kidding, but I've found that saying something like that doesn't impede some buyers).

I think I've settled on a plane about 15 inches long with a (yet to be decided) wide blade and without absurd metal thickness - 1/4th on the sides and 3/16ths on the bottom.

I think I'll do bevel down 42 degrees with a 15 degree skew to experiment, and put the mouth around the same location that it would be on a 14 inch panel plane (in distance from the front) with a stub handle similar to the wooden plane that I made tapped into the metal and wood. I found the wood plane handle a bit too tall and see why the original that I copied has a shorter one.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#7

Re: LV skew shooter

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Why 42 degrees, David? That suggests a compromise to achieve clearance. But it is not necessary, and in fact the higher bed will affect the edge life.

My recommendation is either 38 degrees, if you are feeling in a radical mood, or 40 degrees, if more conservative. I mentioned earlier that the strike block plane I built is 38 degrees. This is a single bevel plane - built expressely for end grain. However my Veritas Custom #7 jointer has a 40 degree bed, and this plane is fantastic both with end grain, because it has a low cutting angle, and face grain, because it is set up with a chipbreaker. I wonder how a 38 degree bed would go with a chipbreaker?!

A bed with 38 degrees will leave 8 degrees of clearance on a 30 degree bevel. That is approaching as low as it gets. However, it is not as if you are going to be using this plane to cover miles and miles of shavings as you expect from a bench plane. I want a shooting plane that can be used on sides as well as edges, and this is the weaker area of a single iron BU plane (when planing wood that is interlocked).

42 degrees is going to compromise both ease of shooting end grain as well as edge life. I think that you will end up disappointed. Yes, I know that higher bedded planes, such as a #5 1/2 or #7, may be used to shoot end grain - I mentioned before that I used to use a 60 degree bed HNT Gordon Trying Plane. However the surface quality off the higher beds is not as good as the low cutting angle plane, and the edge life will be poorer, as I have been emphasising.

I am pretty certain that what you build will end up working well, regardless. What you are striving for is something excellent, something different ... otherwise why go to the trouble?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#8

Re: LV skew shooter

david weaver

I think at 42 degrees, it'll cut around 40 effective. Since I'll be rolling the iron rather than turning the whole bed (to get the skew), I'll be giving up a couple of degrees of clearance - probably only one or two, i'm not inclined to figure it out at this point, just to know that I'm giving up one or two.

So I'm guessing a little bit, but I think a 15 or 20 degree skew will have me around 40 degrees effective pitch meeting the wood and clearance will suffer a little bit of the same fate.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#9

Re: LV skew shooter

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, does the skew actually lower the cutting angle, or does it act like it was cutting at a lower angle?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#10

Re: LV skew shooter

David Weaver

If you rotate the frog like lv and in, it doesn't change the clearance. I think it does if you get skew by rotating the iron along its length, but not much. I'll have to think a little more.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#11

Re: LV skew shooter

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

Skew does lower the cutting angle. I posted the formula once here, and Leonard Lee either gives the formula or a tabulation in his book on sharpening.

The way to visualize the effect is that the shaving is moving up the bevel on the slant, much as a roadway is cut into a mountain on the slant rather than going straight up—it lowers the grade.

Nevertheless, I agree with your argument above about bedding angle.

Wiley

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#12

Formula

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Somebody please check my back of the envelope solid geom:

Sin(effective cutting angle) =

Sin(bedding angle) x cos(skew angle)

Wiley

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#13

Re: Formula

Larry Barrett

That is what Whelan says in his 'The Wooden Plane' book, on page 387.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#14

Correct


Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#15

Re: LV skew shooter

Patrick Chase

Derek asked:

> David, does the skew actually lower the cutting angle, or does it act like it

> was cutting at a lower angle?

This is a tricky question because it depends on the material being cut.

If you assume that the medium being cut is perfectly rigid in the direction of skew (i.e. no neighbor/adjacency effects) then a skewed iron does cut at a lower angle.

If the medium being cut is compressible then individual elements (wood fibers or whatever you care to think about) may not meet the edge in exactly the direction of motion, and the cutting angle is higher than the equation Wiley posted would predict.

As a practical matter end grain seems to always benefit.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#16

Some retracting to do..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The formula I posted is theoretically correct for skews achieved by ‘rotating’ the whole plane throat, in the same horizontal plane. But on re-reading the thread, I see David’s current thinking is to tilt the iron to get the skew, which creates a set of different angles. These angles do not fit the formula, and make Derek’s question very interesting. Can’t say more without knowing whether David is going to tilt-only or use some combination of tilt-rotate. For example, if David goes tilt-only to get the skew, then a full-width shaving will run straight up the 42-degree bedding, and there will be no reduction in cutting angle. Further, if the plane is BD, then the skew would reduce the included angle, and would seem to increase the clearance a little, while leaving the attack angle at 42 degrees. On the other hand, if the plane were BU (and obviously at lower bedding), the tilt-only approach would reduce the attack angle, because the shaving would be moving slantwise to the grind on the blade.

All the above truly does get us into the realm of angels dancing on the head of a pin. But it seems to me that BU versus BD may be a big deal affecting thin shavings, due to the long cantilever of the BD iron beyond its bedding support. The lower the bedding angle, the thicker the iron, and the thicker the sole—all combine to increase the cantilever. Perhaps a chipbreaker would stabilize the blade tip against vibration, but the BU configuration would start with the advantage of having bedding support closer to the blade edge.

That is all. Over and out.

Wiley

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#17

Re: Some retracting to do..

david weaver

Wiley, that's what I was saying when I said "I'm not sure". Yes, this plane will be only rotation of the iron and no turning of the bed itself. (in airplane terms, all aileron and no rudder).

I think the lines up the bed of the plane will all be the bed pitch, and so, too, will the relief.

I can sharpen the relief into the direction of travel (which will be askew from the actual edge. No matter what, it will work fine, if there were any difference, it'd only be a degree or two. I have so many irons in the fire right now that I'm resisting the desire to draw a diagram and get out my trigonometry textbook from 25 years ago.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#18

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill

david weaver

Basic Proportions - This plane is going to be a square block more or less, but I am going to let it have some protruding toe sole and heel sole (like a panel plane).

I have a piece of scrap 3/16 x 3 mild steel that is 14 1/2 inches long, so that's that for the length (length is a real measure of indifference on a plane that's only going to be used to shoot ends).

For now, it's going to be 15 degrees skew, with the skew done by rotation (think barrel roll) of the iron rather than rotation of the bed itself (think stanley 51).

The iron will be a hand tapered 01 iron 1/4th inch thick, and the effective width after skew will be 2.25 inches. I could easily work out what the iron width needs to be for that, but that's a waste of time. It's a lot easier to draw a diagram and take measurements (maybe not easier, but it's more reliable - no calculator button punch errors. Reliable is important).

S the infill will be square for now, which means 2.25 inches of width plus a 16th for lateral adjustment, so total plane width will be roughly 2.25 + 1/16 plus 2*(1/8th) = 2 9/16ths. Height will then be a 16th less.

Bedding by peined block (wouldn't be necessary if the sole was thicker, but no planes of note historically had a 1/4th inch sole - not that I've bought. Modern planes do so that the sides can be riveted instead of dovetails - that kind of thing is a safe bet for people with machinist tools, but it's easier for the average joe to just dovetail than it is to drill and tap holes and then pein special screws.

The wedge will be retained by a brass cross strap and scroll wedge. I like the look of wedged infills. The wedge is what drives the need for taper on the iron. You can wedge a parallel iron just like you can wear work jeans to a funeral. I don't do it.

This will be my 6th infill, which doesn't sound like many, but they take a long time compared to wooden planes. I'd like to keep this one to about 50 hours, because I have too many things pulling at my time right now. I would love to have a solid work of week off and make this all at once, but if I did, my wife would think that taking the whole week to myself would be about as tasteless as wearing work jeans to a funeral.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#19

Cutting edge skew is all that matters

Patrick Chase

What matters here is the angle by which the cutting edge deviates from perpendicularity to the axis of motion, measured in the plane of the surface being cut.

How you conceptualize or talk about the way you think you got there - "rotating", "tilting", "shimmying", "swinging", or whatever - is thoroughly irrelevant.

The equation that you gave is correct, period, provided that the skew angle is as defined above and the bevel is measured perpendicular to the cutting edge.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#20

Re: Cutting edge skew is all that matters

david weaver

I figured out an easy way to think of it. I only care about the ability to get 10 degrees of clearance on a 30 degree bevel, and while I don't mind breaking out textbooks, I'd rather size this stuff up by spatial understanding and layout - there's less risk there.

Each slice of the iron is indifferent about skew (like riemann sum type slice approaching zero for its thickness), where the slice considered is from the iron on a rotated bed with the axis of rotation along the center of the iron, and not vertically like rotating a frog. The slice travels along the length of the plane and not perpendicular to the edge in this case. My plane bed is 40 degrees front to back (or will be). Each slice has the same geometry as a plane with no skew, and so too will be the entire iron. However, measuring the angle perpendicular to the cutting edge instead of along the length of the plane will result in something greater than 40 degrees.

That's exactly what I'm looking for.

Everything in a plane like this is setting up an initial mark (in this case, on the sole) and then fitting everything to the mark progressively.

Just by sight, more or less, I've changed the skew to 20 degrees. 15 didn't look like enough.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#22

Minutiae—do not read

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Patrick,

David gives a very good description of his plane’s geometry above. And clearly he is in good command of the process.

In our own discussion, the formula works as stated for the LN or LV configuration. For David’s configuration, we don’t need to use the formula because the effective cutting angle will simply be the plane’s bedding angle.

Your statement is absolutely correct, provided one substitutes (in David’s configuration),

Sin(cutting angle perpendicular to the grind) in place of

Sin(bedding angle).

However this substitution will yield the trivial result that the effective cutting angle is simply the bedding angle (in David’s case).

Apologies to those who got this far.

Wiley

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#23

Re: Minutiae—do not read

david weaver

No need to discount your contributions and put a do not read warning!!

I notice that I majored in mathematics, and I see warren talking about trigonometry, patrick, you....did anyone else major in math? I'm the only one who doesn't remember much of trigonemtry - I'd have to refresh for trigonometric substitution, too (since none of that is remotely related to my job).

I'd still rely on spatial skills in the shop to figure this out, though, because of the safety factor. I'd estimate at this point that this plane is going to take about 80 hours to make, so I don't want to re-do parts.

At any rate, this is a discussion about actually making something. It won't satisfy the furniture mongers, but a friend of mine has something to say about people who want you to make what they want to see you make.

Re: Tell me where I'm wrong..(skew shooting infill)

#24

you asked -- sorry, but you're wrong

Ian Neuhaus

..looking more for advice from people who have built or designed a few tools.

I'm thinking of attempting to make a 20 degree bed bevel down skewed infill shooting plane. I do not have machine tools and I don't lay out plans ahead of time other than generalities (it's easier to "fit things" as you go along).

snip

The other option is to build a bevel down skew infill (bresse builds a straight cutting infill for a princely sum and people seem to love it), but I'm fairly sure that the bevel up orientation is superior for shooting in terms of what's going on with the iron when it's in the cut. It may be that a quarter inch thick iron negates some of the oscillation that occurs in the cut, don't know.

Thoughts?

I may have missed this in another reply, but a low angle bevel down plane will cause you no end of grief.

The plane's cutting edge need's about 12 degrees of clearance, so for a 20 degree bedding angle, the blade will need a bevel angle of about 8 degrees -- meaning that the edge will be incredibly fragile with no support till well back from the cutting edge.

Planes with low bedding angles are bevel-up to avoid this problem.